Loading...
20200444 446 Broadway Window Replacement SSPF 8-5-20 Preserti�zltion Foundatioil Au�ust 5, 2020 F t��` l/r/�,r.c' [�i�F S E[tv,a-l�t�7 � Ms.Tamie Etiinger, Cliair Dcsign Review Commission �. � City Hall �` 474 Broadway 5aratoga Springs, NY 12866 � RE: 446 Braat�wav—Window Keplacement Dear Tamie: f3vard of Directors The Saratoga Sprin�s Preservation F�undatio►�has reviewed t��e applic�t�on for tf�e ,���`n N.�a"r° window replace project at 446 Broad�vay. Pmsic�ent �d���5 G�,�� Tlle Italianate style cammerci�i builtiin�, c. 1860's, contributes to td�e National Register v"`'�r`�'d"'` of FIistorie Places �isted I3roadw�y Histaric District. The nver�an�in�eat-•es with p�iret! �.�naa t��r�ey-op�r�;k hrackets and the simp[e 6/b windows are contributing features to t�iis architectur�al style. Secretary d,,,;tr;y Y�„no�ay��, �T11e Foundation is pleased to see tliat the origina! 6/b windows will l�e retained on the T�����u�er third floor. The Founc�ation appreciates ttie historic rese�rci�that was d�ne to reveal thc ori�inal fenestration on th�second loor and understands that tl�e existiit� 1�I12 wind�ws Jaime Bu[]cr-Binley c�r�i�r,�c�ra�ne at this location were added aft�er the doors were removed. Giovanna�7'Orazin sc���n ooctds 1,�r]»le the secc�nd stor-��windqws were not origi��a) to the building they still re�lect an Brenn�n D�nkc sa�,dr�FoX evofution of the liistoric buildin�. F3ased on the inf��rniation provided in the app�ication, John Hallcr the windowS do not appear to l�e beyond repair. If noise consideration is an issue there Liz[s��ae1 Samnntha Kcrcull �r�01t1�C WBVS CO iTlltl�ate 110[5� SLlC}7 &S lI1tel'lO7'OC eXte1'lOr STOI'17't t�'1riC�UWS. T}leI'efOl'e, ���u�.i�3s K«T th�Foundation recomrnends that these w�i�:dc�ws he a-epaired Richard King Stephesi IC}'ne w�n�3,»M�ca�ny The Standards outiined in the Histori� Review Ordii�ance or ti�e Historic District Design ao�ntny r:�,eeT�-B�>>;� Guidetines adopted by the City c�f 5arato�;a Springs intent is to preserve as �nuch�f t�e cindy sp���e historic fabric of our communit �5 histaric resources as �ssible. The Stn«dards state: Nlatthew viitcn y� p r"�. Preserve rather than remave Ja�t�es FtiettEewell . �,�„��.«115 Dist�n�;uishing original features of a strueture or s�te are essential ta the liistor�c quality and character of that site. Distinguishing original qualities or character of a structure, site and�or its environment sE�all be preser�ed and pratected to the Executive Dircctor san�ancna��>Ssf���M �naximum extent possilale. L3estruction or alteration of any histaric material ar distinctive architectural features sho�a�d be avoided. IW'[cmbership& Progrxms Director �;�o�e�ab�e $. Repair rather than replace � Distinetive arcEiitectural features that cl�aracterize a struckure or site shall he repaired rather than replaced rinc�;never possible. If replacement is necessary, the rep�acement materials should match the original in compositian, des�gn, texture and other�isual qua�ities. � ti�,�„�: 5���,�_ ���;<< ���_ S.ir.it�i�.i SF,renu+. ;�'y I_'�ht� I' �I�-iti'-iu{n The Fou�}datit�n appreciates the significant investment that the owner is making to preserve their lxistar�c building. Thank you in advance for yc�ur tho�ghtful eoz�sideration. Sincerely, , , r .I /�'� � ._ 4 �.:���.�.�. ;���.� Adan� N. Favro � Samantha Bosshart Presiderft Executive Director Cc: Melissa Paquet, Owner Bradley Bir�e, Administrator of the Office of Pla��ning and Economic Development ,��.r'1 r'� ;.� � � .4�r � � � � },�y�'�p, �„ �a �' .4'��� �. �`�, +� �+ e .;�' J� s er( � �,e . ���,q� �� .'S`� � I,e . i('�Pr�.'"",�t �� 7 q.: r�-�a�P�s�..nii � ,� ���T �z '� '`�'�� `! �" '��" ,:a *' �°� � '��'� „ � `-�y _ t yk . , �' a�� � �.� ��r sv,w � .+�s' 'e�'g � L ,� Qx . r . °�,� ,, �. . �} � y, ?aw�,r i � `� 5 ��.� i��'�w^"�vr,+'� Y . .., . } r �� `� ..�"'� � 1 �1 � � �r � s 8 �� J� �� . � �Y �� �t� ���... �yY,. ry y�'. ''�� , � . '� .. V• yy/��m1�^�Yw.' " +yj' ._� ! R,�? _ F ,x ;"! TL j1 I W �.�� A `�rF ,� ° ap', ,� � ;� � � �,� x ,.�,�, :a � .�rw� � � ,���,h=� �� ,, �� a _i�� �„ �„�.�' � � �� v ; � ,� � �;: _ �' i _ ,��� ; �; ° � �, 4 y.N �� I�-1i�� .' � � � ��,7 s X'a:� � � , ; � � . t �{- �� �� . �� \t�' u �:. '��"i�4"'�r; �; ' V� a '�w " ° "' , , , ,�, i1�� �T g0 , �:'� T � �,Y' ��� +K. T � � { ��.- I�� �Y :1 �r '�:,� � �.� � 3''° � .y��,•� �� � ' _,. _ ^"" , � �� �. ,ub �.. � �� : �� ' �'S �' � _ ; � � . � e x �P c �C' �A „ �'�a � i�.ry.'�' 1 � y �d� f � � J� i. �,s _r-� ,! I ._ � I � ,�, '�d ql°� �¢ Yy� , ' , . ��� � �� M �. a��y�F K,-- i� � w � . . �' sa q '"« y.. e „ T � � �"� f r 7: �; . � �� - � � �. �,� "> b.�+?: � r Y '4'��� . � � ,,d�_ ,� k� � =My�� a ( ` d.' � G �"�z ��`� - I�✓ I� . ,y . . � � c�> : 9 T�, , � a. . � :.t,`� -�-�.... P- � �"-r �.r' �� �,g;���'` �i � i r � , �if `a�' �.�'.:�'�. +�'`a,�„` �.� '�°. ..F s i � §4�°+�'F -.� � "t�'�n ��� y �_.�{ F' +�y �� `�,,r i� r�"� �ry 4 F �rp� � ��'a.�'�- �"'� , �'�' �:� 4d . � � ��> 31. �,; -T^^35 :t � ! af � . t � N � �� � �, t� t s � � � � �� ��a � � ,� ''� � ,. � > . .'�; �3.s r,.Y R�-��' {1°d.t�, ., a ��6�ix � � � � ��.�.,�..»,::�y �� . : �' 3 i t'��� ��'��. �; t , � - �s��- v' �,� � � . _� _� „ ,;.. � � t i E r � � f" �'`� rr"�'�L� �" .= E � .�?' f �.:'�`��.'.' . �5 e � �. �sF �� _ d L s'x°� �.-hJ"'� �'�"y"t�=n,"^�''+�,�-�+?� - � �^. � � � 4 � . -. _ r�4 :�..�..� '� � "�+�� � _ — � . t �'�3 .. �4� �&k� � s �,;; r�. ��"' a �ti- ��f� �c.,,°� . y� z�,,r x� {� ��. F .G / qYj3„'' }�"+"�"aLw 3'! .. � 3C F 1 ., P' '� 5 —'� �,a- �q�� F a` � � �n t k� � - y � ��. < .: `� ° aT�.�- - ��.��j � �-a �' �; 4 � 'c�� i'.' � � i.; p' A. r.lu.r�-� �:h � �� ^ � ,_ Y,� , x t , � '� s Ya, � . i i ""„�. �_.�� ' ti `'�'� ' �t ,,?.:F� 3' i ��fsf� 4 V,.. �;���` x5 ' �E�4" :3' ` � 4 � '„�" r���� s �� _�- �� ..-�'�., .; 1,� .. � €" ' ��'��r:I a �.� i ����a�SS�� � ..�k$a ����. �F _ �,. . �. t, ��.y ��. :' "!�'y� �4�1 ",.��, . ;� . ,� �.yt�= '"' . �.�_v .1'"� �-- ,�F f'�,v��S� .;: ' , � � �" � ���r � i � �,. _..�� w-.. � � .., : .. �, , �'�_ � ,�, _ - v� � s �� t . . -: ti9 ` k :W f � 'w.. �' �� Y .� �.�+ ,- A� �' � _ 1S. �', I _uR , . r � p ,.:� i j,. � , y ? ��� 3'- J l i.+• �W�� � � 4' 1 u.y� � �§ •.,� �� .i�'" :;;� L � �S ��� ���1.. � i ��e� ,,� f ��' � ` '- � � l,`.... + f� �'� �"'` . � � �rc „ ��•{� � _�p,� �� �� � 5 - a4.�!' � t . ., �tr"� � Nu i ��, .�� �e - ^.. y S � ..r ��,.^�. �d`X ,.`, � � �W .3i k f`�� ..+� �� . t7 ..rl � ..,,k'�i wP � .ti _� " 1��. �' i '1 ,y� �e � � �� � �.� ^4. \r� � .' <'�` "� ' . �$ ��� y �� �Y���� �� � � ����� .. . ,�� �' � , , _' ��: .^ , ' .. },��' � .... _c�,_, .� . . ._...... . �,�""�.� ! _ . C � � ; i _ _ _ N, ' �... . . . . F{n., ., - � ._ • , .,. , t,� � '�., .. �...GwA'lrem,.._ . .. " , . ' . . � ...�M , � _ � — .