The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About20260639 40 Fifth Ave. Demolition & Construction NOD Page 1 of 1 Tamie Ehinger, Chair Rob DuBoff, Vice Chair Karen Cavotta Karen D’Andrea Leslie DiCarlo Jeff Pfeil Geoff Wood Alison Dockum, Alternate Christina Abele, Alternate CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS D ESIGN R EVIEW B OARD ❖ City Hall - 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 Tel: 518-587-3550 x.2517 www.saratoga-springs.org NOTICE OF DECISION In the matter of the application #20260639 40 Fifth Ave Demo & Construction - Construction 40 Fifth Ave. Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 involving historic review of exterior modifications and construction of a side porch within the Urban Residential -1 (UR- 1) District, tax parcel #166.62-2-10, within the City of Saratoga Springs. In accordance with 6 NYCRR Part 617, the Design Review Board classifies this request as a SEQR:  Type II – exempt from further SEQR review And, in accordance with the objectives, standards and guidelines contained in the Unified Development Ordinance Article 240-13.9 Historic Review Applicability and Approval Standards, the Design Review Board issues the following decision on September 9, 2026:  Approve the plans with the following conditions: Applicant to install appropriately sized shutters that will cover the window when shut; shutters are to be installed with proper hardware such that they are operable. Applicant to install the miaratec smooth side out. Record of vote: motion to approve made by G Wood, seconded by K D’Andrea passed 6-0 In favor: T Ehinger, K D’Andrea, L DiCarlo, R DuBoff, J Pfeil, G Wood Opposed: Note: this approval shall expire 18 months from the issuance date unless any necessary building permit has been issued and actual work begun. As a result of this decision, the applicant:  may proceed with the proposed project as approved Please contact the Building Department to verify permit requirements. Chair Received by Accounts cc: Building Department Accounts Dept. Applicant/Agent PROPOSED SCOPE OF WORK Reconstruction of Side Porch Remove existing open air side porch down to existing slab / foundation as it is in poor condition. Construct a new open air side porch on existing foundations to generally include the following: New PT wood columns, beams, rafters, ceiling joists, etc Wrap columns and beams in composite wood and paint. Any profiled decorative trim to be wood, painted. (crown, shoe, base, etc) New picketed railing similar to existing shall be wood, painted. Ceiling to be natural wood beadboard. Roofing to standing seam metal, brown. Flooring to be stone pavers set in bead of mortar. Chimney Repairs (2) Remove the top portion of the existing stone chimney due to deterioration. Lower approximately 24” and ensure 10’ horizontal from adjacent roof. Reuse existing stone cap and maintain existing aesthetic. Repoint existing brick chimney where joints are in poor condition. Roof Replacement Replace existing asphalt shingle roof with new. Gutters / Downspouts Replace existing aluminum gutter and downspout on the front of the house with a copper gutter and downspout matching the rest of the house Home Exterior Provide new custom wood shutters, painted, at two windows on the front elevation. Replace exterior wall sconces on rear elevation. Paint exterior siding and trim on the entire house. kpb Architecture gar eve eve eve vfgar epep clkf wdfg eve eve eve ww ww ww ww ww ww ww ww estone estonewdfend wdfcor eve gar@wfend vfap EPDRASPH EPDRASPH EPDRASPH hse hse pchpch pch wdfgwdfgwdf eve eve evegar gargarcncpad cncpad cncpad bbqareabbqarea bbqarea ew chimLhse hse spatio spatio spatiospatio spatiospatio spatiospatio spatio spatio spatio spatio spatiospatio spatiospatio eveL edw edw edw up eveL eveL eveL eveL eveL brickwlkbrickwlk epdw epdw ecncdw ecncdwbwlk@epdw bwlkchange@epdw ecncdw fc fc up fc fc fc fc fwlk@fc bwlk bwlk step ebswlk ebswlk ebswlk ebswlk ebswlk ebswlkebswlk ebswlk gm landing landing landing ohhse hse firepitfirepit spatio ew chim ww ww ww em ccncpad ccncpad ccncpad pch pch pch pch wdfend edw edw gar gar eveeve clkf up ep ep wdfcor 334 333 332 331 330329 327326 325 323 318 317 316 315 314 313 312 311 309 308 307 306 305304 303 302 301 300 296 295 294 293 292 291290 289 286285284 283 282 281280 279278277 275 274 273272 270 269268267 266 265 264 263262 261260 259258 257 256 255 254 253252 251250 249 248 247 246 244 243 242 241 240 238 237236 234 233 232 231230 229 227 226 224 222 221 220 219 218 217 216 215 213 212 211210 209 208 207206 205 204 203 202 200 198197 196 194193 192 189 188 186 185 184 183 179 178 176 175 174 173 172 171 165 164 163 162 161160 159 158 157 156 154 Area= 11, 250 s. f. or 0. 258 ac. GARAGE GARAGE ASPHALT ASPHALT DRIVEWAY CO N C S I D E W A L K BR I C K S I D E W A L K PO R C H DRIVEWAY CO N C ST E P R e c o r d N o r t h p e r I n s t . 2 0 1 9 0 2 0 3 9 7 Lot 11 Lot 12 CONCRETE EAVES ( TYP.) GARAGE CONC. WALK CONC.WALK STEPS CONC. DRIVEWAY GATEGATE STONEPATIO FIREPIT BBQAREACONC.PAD WINDOW WELLTYP.) A/ C UNIT ON CONC. PAD HEATPUMPWINDOW WELLCHIMNEYEGRESSWELL ELEC. METER WINDOWWELL OVERHANGEAVES CURB Fi fth Avenue Tipton Alley 10. 0' 15. 0' 21.3' 14.0' 0. 7' 0. 6' 8. 7' 0. 8' 8. 7' 14. 3' N02°45'00"E 150.00' N8 7 1 5 0 0 W 7 5 0 0 S02°45'00"W 150.00' S8 7 1 5 0 0 E 7 5 0 0 n/f Kenneth W. and Cheryl J. Grey Bk1311 P107 n/f Bruce D. Steves Inst. #2019020397 2 STORY HOUSE PROPOSED SIDE PORCH ON EXISTING 10'-0" x 20'-0" FOUNDATION SCALE 1" = 20' -0" 15 0 15 0 30' - 0"30' - 0" SITE STATISTICS ZONING = UR-1 (URBAN RESIDENTIAL 1) ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW DISTRICT = APPLICABLE HISTORIC OVERLAY DISTRICT = APPLICABLE LOT AREA = 11,250 SF EXISTING BUILDINGS TO REMAIN NEW SIDE PORCH ON EXISTING 10'X20' FOUNDATION Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCESITEDIAGRAM 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY T.O. SUBFLOOR -FIRST FLOOR 0' -0" T.O. FOUNDATION 1' -1 1/2" T/ FIRST FIRST FLOOR PLATE 9' -1 1/8" T.O. SUBFLOOR -SECOND FLOOR 10' -1 1/8"2" 12" EXISTING STONE CHIMNEY REMOVE THE TOP 24" FROM THE DAMAGED EXISTING CHIMNEY. RE-USE EXISTING STONE CHIMNEY CAP AND REBUILD 'NEW' TOP TO REPLICATE EXISTING TOP NEW ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOFING. B.O.D.: OWENS CORNING - TRU DEFINITION, DURATION, COLOR: DRIFTWOOD EXISTING METAL ROOF EDGE TO REMAIN REMOVE EXISTING GUTTER AND REPLACE w/ NEW COPPER GUTTER/DOWNSPOUT TO MATCH GUTTERS ON REAR OF THE HOUSE PAINT EXISTING SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY NEW CUSTOM WOOD SHUTTERS, TYP. COLOR: SW 2838 - POLISHED MAHOGANY PAINT EXISTING TRIM, TYP. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN EXISTING WINDOW TO REMAIN, TYP. EXISTING STONE, TYP. PAINT EXISTING ENTRY DOOR COLOR: SW 2838 - POLISHED MAHOGANY PAINT EXISTING SIDELITE/TRIM COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF COLOR: DARK BRONZE WOOD CROWN TRIM COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN WOOD SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY COOMPOSITE WOOD COLUMN WRAP COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN COMPOSITE WOOD BEAM WRAP COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN WOOD RAILING 30" A.F.F. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN STONE FLOOR ON EXISTING CONCRETE SLAB/FOUNDATION - GREY SANDSTONE EXISTING CONCRETE FOUNDATION WOOD BEADBOARD CEILING COLOR: SIKKENS PROLUX 009 - DARK OAK REMOVE EXISTING FLOWER BOX EXISTING STEEL RAILING, TYP. REMOVE EXISTING LIGHT FIXTURE Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCENORTHELEVATION 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY T.O. SUBFLOOR -FIRST FLOOR 0' -0" T.O. FOUNDATION 1' -1 1/2" T/ FIRST FIRST FLOOR PLATE 9' -1 1/8" T.O. SUBFLOOR -SECOND FLOOR 10' -1 1/8" EXISTING GUTTER/DOWNSPOUT, TYP. REMOVE THE TOP 24" FROM THE DAMAGED EXISTING CHIMNEY. RE-USE EXISTING STONE CHIMNEY CAP AND REBUILD 'NEW' TOP TO REPLICATE EXISTING TOP NEW ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOFING. B.O.D.: OWENS CORNING - TRU DEFINITION, DURATION, COLOR: DRIFTWOOD PAINT EXISTING TRIM, TYP. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN EXISTING WINDOW TO REMAIN, TYP. PAINT EXISTING SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY PAINT EXISTING LAP SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY WOOD RAILING 30" A.F.F. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN STONE FLOOR ON EXISTING CONCRETE SLAB/FOUNDATION - GREY SANDSTONE EXISTING CONCRETE FOUNDATION EXISTING DOOR, TYP. STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF COLOR: DARK BRONZE WOOD CROWN TRIM COLOR: SW 0053 -PORCELAIN PAINT EXISTING SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY COMPOSITE WOOD COLUMN WRAP COLOR: SW 0053 -PORCELAIN COMPOSITE WOOD BEAM WRAP COLOR: SW 0053 -PORCELAIN WOOD BEADBOARD CEILING COLOR: SIKKENS PROLUX 009 -DARK OAK REMOVE EXISTING GUTTER AND REPLACE w/ NEW COPPER GUTTER/DOWNSPOUT TO MATCH GUTTERS ON REAR OF THE HOUSE PAINT EXISTING TRIM, TYP. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN EXISTING WINDOW TO REMAIN, TYP. Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCEEASTELEVATION 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY T.O. SUBFLOOR -FIRST FLOOR 0' -0" T.O. FOUNDATION 1' -1 1/2" T/ FIRST FIRST FLOOR PLATE 9' -1 1/8" T.O. SUBFLOOR -SECOND FLOOR 10' -1 1/8" PAINT EXISTING SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY REMOVE EXISTING GUTTER AND REPLACE w/ NEW COPPER GUTTER/DOWNSPOUT TO MATCH GUTTERS ON REAR OF THE HOUSE PAINT EXISTING TRIM, TYP. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN PAINT EXISTING TRIM, TYP. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN EXISTING WINDOW TO REMAIN, TYP. PAINT EXISTING LAP SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY EXISTING STONE, TYP. EXISTING GUTTER/ DOWNSPOUT, TYP. EXISTING WINDOW, TYP. PAINT EXISTING LAP SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY PAINT EXISTING TRIM, TYP. COLOR: SW 0053 -PORCELAIN NEW ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOFING. B.O.D.: OWENS CORNING - TRU DEFINITION, DURATION, COLOR: DRIFTWOOD PAINT EXISTING COLUMN COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN EXISTING METAL ROOF, TYP. RE-WORK EXISTING GUTTER/DOWNSPOUT RE-WORK AND EXTEND EXISTING ROOF RETURN/TRIM DETAIL BACK TO WALL. EXTEND EXISTING GUTTER BACK TO WALL AND SPLICE DOWNSPOUT INTO EXISTING DOWNSPOUT. PAINT EXISTING SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCEWESTELEVATION 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY T.O. SUBFLOOR -FIRST FLOOR 0' -0" T.O. FOUNDATION 1' -1 1/2" T/ FIRST FIRST FLOOR PLATE 9' -1 1/8" T.O. SUBFLOOR -SECOND FLOOR 10' -1 1/8" RE-WORK AND EXTEND EXISTING ROOF RETURN/TRIM DETAIL BACK TO WALL. EXTEND EXISTING GUTTER BACK TO WALL AND SPLICE DOWNSPOUT INTO EXISTING DOWNSPOUT. EXISTING GUTTER/ DOWNSPOUT, TYP. NEW ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOFING. B.O.D.: OWENS CORNING - TRU DEFINITION, DURATION, COLOR: DRIFTWOOD PAINT EXISTING ENTRY DOOR COLOR: SW 2838 - POLISHED MAHOGANY PAINT EXISTING COLUMN COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN PAINT EXISTING LAP SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF COLOR: DARK BRONZE WOOD CROWN TRIM COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN WOOD SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY COMPOSITE WOOD COLUMN WRAP COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN COMPOSITE WOOD BEAM WRAP COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN WOOD RAILING 30" A.F.F. COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN STONE FLOOR ON EXISTING CONCRETE SLAB/FOUNDATION - GREY SANDSTONE EXISTING CONCRETE FOUNDATION WOOD BEADBOARD CEILING COLOR: SIKKENS PROLUX 009 - DARK OAK REMOVE THE TOP 24" FROM THE DAMAGED EXISTING CHIMNEY. RE-USE EXISTING STONE CHIMNEY CAP AND REBUILD 'NEW' TOP TO REPLICATE EXISTING TOP EXISTING STONE CHIMNEY EXISTING GUTTER/ DOWNSPOUT, TYP. EXISTING WINDOW TO REMAIN, TYP. PAINT EXISTING LAP SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY PAINT EXISTING SHINGLE SIDING COLOR: SW 0037 - MORRIS ROOM GREY NEW ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOFING. B.O.D.: OWENS CORNING - TRU DEFINITION, DURATION, COLOR: DRIFTWOOD REMOVE (4) EXISTING EXTERIOR WALL MOUNTED LIGHTING FIXTURES AND REPLACE w/ OAKMOUNT EXTRA SMALL WALL LANTERN EXTERIOR SCONCES PATINA BRONZE) Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCESOUTHELEVATION 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY 20 0 E X I S T I N G F O U N D A T I O N 2' 3 10' - 0" (EXST. FOUNDATION) 1" 6" 6' 4 6' 4 6' 4 6" 1" 1" 6"9' - 6" 0'-0"-0'-5" EXISTINGHOUSECOVEREDPORCH STONE FLOOR ON EXISTING CONCRETE SLAB/FOUNDATION - GREY SANDSTONE EXISTING DOOR EXISTING DOOR WOOD RAILING 30" A.F.F., PTD. 6x6 P.T. WD. COLUMN, TYP. LINE OF ROOF OVERHANG 8x8 COMPOSITE WOOD COLUMN WRAP, PTD. EXISTING EXTERIOR WALL LINE OF EXISTING FOUNDATION LANDSCAPE STONES 2" / 12" 7" 1 2 7" 1 2 STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF COLOR: DARK BRONZE REMOVE EXISTING GUTTER AND REPLACE w/ NEW COPPER GUTTER/DOWNSPOUT TO MATCH GUTTERS ON REAR OF THE HOUSE NEW ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOFING. B.O.D.: OWENS CORNING - TRU DEFINITION, DURATION, COLOR: DRIFTWOOD OUTLINE OF BEAM BELOW TWO MAVERICK 52" LED CEILING FANS (DARK WALNUT) WOOD CROWN TRIM COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN COMPOSITE WOOD BEAM WRAP COLOR: SW 0053 - PORCELAIN WOOD BEADBOARD CEILING COLOR: SIKKENS PROLUX 009 -DARK OAK Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCEPLANVIEWS 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY 1/4" = 1'-0" 1 FIRST FLOOR PLAN 1/4" = 1'-0" 2 ROOF PLAN 1/4" = 1'-0" 3 FIRST FLOOR REFLECTED CEILING PLAN ASPHALT ROOF SHINGLES OWENS CORNING - TRU DEFINITION - DURATION COLOR: DRIFTWOOD DIMENSIONAL STONE FLOORING SOLSTICE DIMENSIONAL SW COLOR: GREY SANDSTONE EXTERIOR LIGHTING OAKMONT EXTRA SMALL WALL LANTERN (OL13100PTBZ) WATTAGE: 60W COLOR: PATINA BRONZE CEILING FAN MAVERICK 52" LED CEILING FAN (3MAVR52BKD) WATTAGE: 18W COLOR: MATTE BLACK HOUSING w/ DARK WALNUT BLADES STANDING SEAM METAL ROOFING EVERLAST ROOFING INC. - EVERSEAM COLOR: DARK BRONZE (2716) EXTERIOR SIDING PAINT SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOR: MORRIS ROOM GREY (0037) EXTERIOR TRIM PAINT SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOR: PORCELAIN (0053) EXTERIOR DOOR/SHUTTER PAINT SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOR: POLISHED MAHOGANY (2838) Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCEPRODUCTSANDCOLOR 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY MIRATEC WD. COMPOSITE TRIM 1x4 TRIM, MITER CORNERS, TYP. MIRATEC WD. COMPOSITE 5/4x TRIM TO WRAP COLUMN, MITER CORNERS, TYP. BROSCO WD. COVE TRIM (8026), MITER CORNERS, TYP. MIRATEC WD. COMPOSITE 5/4x BEAM WRAP TRIM, TYP. BROSCO WD. SCOTIA TRIM (8052), MITER CORNERS, TYP. MIRATEC WD. COMPOSITE 1x8 TRIM, TYP. COLUMN TRIM WRAP SECTION COLOR: PAINTED PORCELAIN (0053) MIRATEC WD. COMPOSITE 1x4 TRIM, TYP. MIRATEC WD. COMPOSITE 5/4x4 TRIM, TYP. BROSCO WD. CROWN TRIM (8004), TYP. 6" 36 ROUNDED CHAMFER, TYP. ALL CORNERS AL I G N COMPOSITE WOOD TRIM TO BE USED FOR ALL FLAT STOCK TRIM WORK WOOD TRIM TO BE USED FOR ALL PROFILED TRIM WORK Architecturekpb BERGERONRESIDENCEPORCHCONSTRUCTION 07.29.2026 40 5th AVE., SARATOGA, NY