Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20190117 Eberlein Subdivision Correspondance (4) To: City of Saratoga Springs Planning Board Department of Public Works Office of the City Engineer CC: Mayor's Office City Attorney From: The Raga Family Trust, 50 Ruggles Rd., S toga Springs, NY 12866 Re: 20190117 EBERLEIN SUBDIVISION 42 Ruggles Rd. Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Subdivision of a 2-lot conservation subdivision Date December 11, 2019 20190117 EBERLEIN SUBDIVISION The Raga Family Trust at 50 Ruggles Rd. is submitting comments in opposition to the 20190117 Eberlein Subdivision. The Raga Family Trust has submitted comments in opposition to the 2019117 Eberlein Subdivision: • at the May 16, 2019 written and oral comments were provided at the City of Saratoga Springs Planning Board meeting, • on June 3, 2019 additional comments in opposition were submitted to the City of Saratoga Springs Planning Board, the Department of Public Works, Office of the City Engineer, Mayor's Office and City Attorney, and • on June 12, 2019 comments were provided to representatives of the Department of Public Works on site at 47 Ruggles Rd., Saratoga Springs, NY. I would like to start by saying that the Planning Board and city officials have known since May and June 2019 that there are neighbors in opposition to this application. The timing of this application process is patently unfair to those opposed to this application. At the May 16, 2019 Planning Board meeting the application was tabled pending an engineering review. An engineering review was conducted by The Chazen Companies and the response to the Chazen review was posted on December 9, 2019. It has been less than 72 hours since the posting of the applicants' response to the Chazen review. I have no knowledge if The Chazen Companies has even seen the applicants' response to the Chazen review. Also, this 72 hour time frame does not give neighbors in opposition to the application time to seek independent engineering and/or legal advice. This time frame is patently unfair. The comments in this memo and the comments to be presented at the December 12, 2019 City of Saratoga Springs Planning Board are in opposition to the subdivision. 1 The 20190117 Eberlein Subdivision is out of compliance with the: • City of Saratoga Springs Subdivision Regulations • Zoning Districts Intents— Rural Residential • Conservation Area and No Cut Buffer Planning Board Policy The Chazen Companies review 1st submittal dated November 7, 2019 Attachment 1 The Chazen Companies November 7, 2019 review of the 20190117 Eberlein Subdivision proposal has found 16 areas that required submission, revision, amendment and/or review. These items included but are not limited to: the Short Environmental Assessment Form (EAF), Site Plans including several questions regarding compliance with the NYS Dept of Health's requirements for Residential Septic and Wastewater Treatment, and the Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP). The Chazen review specifically referenced that the Eberlein project would impact the Raga Family Trust property at 50 Ruggles Rd. The applicant's response to the Chazen review did not adequately address the issues. On the Short Environmental Assessment Form (EAF) the response to question 13b was that the project would not affect existing wetlands. I believe that the project may affect existing wetlands, possibly wetlands at 47 Ruggles Rd. The response to question 17b on the EAF pertaining to stormwater discharge is not consistent with the Chazen review that the post development system may not meet requirements. The Chazen review identified 2 stormwater drainage points. On the applicant's 12/9/19 revised Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) the applicant's representative answered NO to question 15. 15. Does the site runoff enter a separate storm sewer system (including roadside drains, swales, ditches, culverts, etc.)? There are 2 culverts: 50 Ruggles Rd. and 42 Ruggles Rd. Attachments 7,8,9 document the drainage course and the culvert at 50 Ruggles Rd. The applicant's response to the Chazen review did not adequately address the issues. City of Saratoga Springs Subdivision Regulations CHAPTER 241 OF THE CITY CODE OF THE CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS, NEW YORK SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS Adopted by the City Council June 17, 2003; amended September 4, 2012 2 The proposed subdivision should be classified as Class B type land in accordance with the definition of Usable land in the City of Saratoga Springs Subdivision Regulations, Article 1, Section 4, Definitions, page 12. USABLE LAND: Class A Type refers to developable land generally devoid of wetlands, drainage courses, steep slopes, etc. Class B Type refers to land not suitable generally for development except for passive open space. By any definition, including a legal definition, "devoid of means entirely lacking or free from. Attachment 4 Steep Slopes — Drainage Courses —Wetlands The proposed subdivision includes documented steep slopes and drainage courses with wetlands identified in and around Ruggles Rd. The areas of steep slopes, drainage courses and wetlands have been identified and documented since the beginning of this application. The slope functions as a watershed for drainage in the area. Wetlands are also identified in the area and across the road at 47 Ruggles Rd. The proposed area can be described as a steep slope and a drainage area and there are properties within 250 ft. of the project that are also considered wetlands. The 20190117 Eberlein Subdivision is proposing a driveway on the north side of the subdivision which will abut the south side of the 50 Ruggles Rd. property line. At Ruggles Rd. the driveway is being placed approximately 15 ft. from the 50 Ruggles Rd. property. The driveway which will be approximately 250-300 hundred feet long will progress directly through the drainage course and steep slope. The areas on Attachments 3 and 3a shows the significant areas of steep slope. The driveway is placed in the steep slope and drainage area. The 20190117 EBERLEIN SUBDIVISION does not meet the definition of Usable Land in the City of Saratoga Springs Subdivision Regulations, Article 1, Section 4, Definitions, page 12. Attachment 1. The subdivision should be Class B Type land not suitable generally for development except for passive open space. Attachments 2-9 Zoning Districts and District Intents Zoning District Intent Rural Residential To provide low density residential and agricultural uses in order to preserve open space and a rural character. Limiting topography, soil condition, slopes and lack of public infrastructure also warrant the low densities. Attachment 10 The destruction of steep slopes, watershed drainage course and extensive removal of trees that would result from the subdivision is not in keeping with the intent of the Rural Residential zoning because of limiting topography, soil conditions, slopes and lack of public infrastructure. https://www.saratoga-springs.org/DocumentCenter/View/243/2o-Base-Zoning-Districts-PDF Conservation Area and No Cut Buffer Planning Board Policy 3 "Designated conservation areas serve an important role within the City as a means for natural resource protection, preservation of open space, wildlife habitat, stormwater management, ensuring consistent natural community character, aesthetic beautification as well as buffering among properties and land uses within the City. The City's Urban Forestry Master Plan (2013) notes the benefits of trees, in particular improved air quality, stormwater benefits, and aesthetic/ commercial value, equating each tree with a notable assessed value of benefits per year." Attachment 11 The subdivision will significantly impact stormwater management. The subdivision's destructive impact on steep slopes, drainage areas, stormwater management and wetlands is not consistent with the Conservation Area Policy Standard. The proposed subdivision has steep slopes and drainage courses. The subdivision will require extensive tree removal, extensive excavation and extensive fill. The proposed subdivision will negatively impact the slope and drainage area and negatively impact the 50 Ruggles Rd. property. https://www.saratoga-springs.org/DocumentCenter/View/8525/Conservation-Area-and- No-Cut-Buffer-Policy-adopted-071918?bidld= The 20190117 Eberlein Subdivision is out of compliance with the: • City of Saratoga Springs Subdivision Regulations • Zoning Districts Intents— Rural Residential • Conservation Area and No Cut Buffer Planning Board Policy The timing of this application process is patently unfair to those opposed to this application. The Raga Family Trust, 50 Ruggles Rd., Saratoga Springs, NY OPPOSES the 20190117 EBERLEIN SUBDIVISION. 4 it/f/W-c:-A iMeA4 THE CAPITAL DISTRICT OFFICE Chaen Civil Engineers Land Surveyors 547 River Street — Planners Troy, NY 12180 COM PA N I ES Environmental&Safety Professionals P:518.273.0055 or 888.539.9073 Landscape Architects Proud to be Fmpioyee Owned Transportation Planners&Engineers www.chazencompanies.com Mr. Michael B.Veitch, Business Manager City of Saratoga Springs Dept.of Public Works 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 November 7, 2019 Delivered via email:michael.veitchPsaratoga-sorinl s.org Re: City Designated Engineer Services for Subdivision Application and SWPPP Review—15`Submittal Eberlein Subdivision-2 Lot Subdivision 42 Ruggles Road,City of Saratoga Springs,Saratoga County, New York City Project No. PB#2019.117 Chazen Project No.31904.05 Dear Michael: The Chazen Companies(Chazen)have completed our review of the following materials received: • Subdivision application package containing: o Application for Subdivision Approval, prepared by Ingalls&Associates,dated February 7,2019. o Subdivision Approval Submittal Checklist, prepared by the Ingalls&Associates,dated April 19, 2019. o Application for Conservation Subdivision Plat Completeness Checklist, prepared by applicant, undated. o New Water Service Connection Agreement & Application Form, undated, signed by representative of the applicant. o SEQRA Short Environmental Assessment Form, prepared by David Ingalls, dated February 7, 2019. • Letter addressed to Chazen prepared by David Ingalls,dated October 18,2019. • City of Saratoga Springs Public Hearing Notification Letter sent to Ingalls & Associates from Jen Merriman, Land Use Board Coordinator,dated May 8,2019. • Correspondence from Raga Family Trust at 50 Ruggles Road, Saratoga Springs, NY dated May 16, 2019 and May 18,2019. • Draft Subdivision Conservation Easement, unsigned, undated. • Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan, prepared by Ingalls&Associates,dated October 18,2019. • Site drawings entitled "Ruggles Road Conservation Subdivision", dated January 18, 2019, and revised October 18, 2019, prepared by Ingalls&Associates, unless noted otherwise,consisting of the following 5 sheets: o 1-Cover Sheet o 2-Conservation Analysis o 3-Subdivision Plat o 4-Grading and Erosion&Sediment Control Plan o 5-Details New York: Hudson Valley•Capital District• North Country•Westchester Tennessee: Nashville•Chattanooga Oregon: Portland Chazen Engineering,Land Surveying&Landscape Architecture Co. DPC(NY)•Chazen Engineering Consultants, LLC(TN/OR) Eberlein Subdivision-P1342019.117—1"Submittal Review November 7,2019 Page 2 of 4 Please note that An Engineers report for water and sanitary sewer,the Complete Streets Checklist or Project Cost Estimate were not received for this project. Following are our observations/comments: General: 1. The City's project number of 19.117 should be added to all site plan application and construction documents. Short Environmental Assessment Form(EAF): 2. Please respond to item 13b. 3. Item 17a is marked"No".This should be changed to"Yes"as the project will create storm water discharge in the form of non-point source runoff from new impervious areas. Site Pans 4. The original signed and sealed survey referenced to NGVD 1929 datum must be submitted. 5. Please indicate the location,size and material of the existing water main to which the project will connect in Ruggles Road. 6. Please identify the inverts of the existing 15"culvert under Ruggles Road. 7. A drainage easement is shown on the Conservation Analysis upstream of the project site,ending at the east boundary. Please confirm that the easement does not extend through the project site and restrict the proposed development. 8. The Conservation Analysis needs to identify the required 30'buffer areas as defined in Chapter 241 of the City of Saratoga Springs Code. 9. In accordance with City Code Chapter 241,Article IV,Section 1, Paragraph C.3,the Subdivision Plat shall identify the location,use,ownership,management,methods of preservation,and rights of the owners and the public to the open space land subject to the deed restriction.Please add appropriate notations. 10. The Subdivision Plat should be updated to note the area of each proposed lot,as well as the area of deed-restricted open space on each lot. Also,the plat must be prepared and signed/sealed by a licensed land surveyor. We assume that since Van Dusen &Steves prepared the boundary survey that they prepared the subdivision plat—please confirm. 11. In accordance with City Code Chapter 241,Appendix H,Section 2, Paragraph R,the owner of a proposed subdivision shall offer to the City"Class A Type Usable Land"equal in size to at least ten percent(10%)of the owner's subdivided tract.There are alternatives presented in the Code. Please identify how this requirement will be met. Eberlein Subdivision-P8112019.117—1"Submittal Review November 7,2019 Page 3of4 12. Silt fence is shown on the Grading and Erosion&Sediment Control Plan as perpendicular to contours. Please revise. 13. Insufficient information and detail is provided for the proposed septic tank and onsite disposal system to verify compliance with NYSDOH requirements presented in"Residential Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems Design Handbook".Specifically,please provide the following: a. Proposed invert elevations of all system components along with top of concrete and the finished grades over each component. b. Proposed concrete strength and reinforcing requirements for the septic tank and distribution box. c. Identification post details for buried septic tank and distribution box covers,if applicable. d. Additional septic tank dimensions,including:offset between baffles and top of tank,depth of baffles below inlet and outlet,wall thickness,tank width, minimum and maximum liquid level, inlet and outlet inverts,and offsets between baffles and inlet/outlet. e. Additional distribution box dimensions, including: inlet and outlet inverts,offset between outlet and bottom of distribution box,width,length,and height. f. Certification and tightness testing requirements. 14. The septic and onsite disposal system notes reference the Town of Charlton inspection requirements. Please revise. SWPPP 15. The SWPPP identifies two drainage areas and two analysis points in the Existing Drainage map. However, it appears that the northern portion of the site drains to the north and discharges onto the property of Gary and Leeanne Raga under current conditions rather than to the 15"culvert under Ruggles Road as analyzed. As modeled, this overstates the peak rates realized under existing conditions at Ruggles Road.Since the post development analysis shows they are just maintaining the rates at Ruggles Road,the system as designed may not actually meet detention requirements. The Existing and Proposed drainage maps and runoff analyses should be updated to reflect this additional drainage area and analysis point. 16. The post-development runoff analysis accounts for storage and exfiltration (10 inches/hour)in a proposed onsite depression area. Deep tests and falling head permeability testing must be completed within footprint of this practice to verify the exfiltration rate used in the stormwater model and that the infiltration system meets industry separation requirements to seasonal high ground water. In order to expedite and simplify the review of revised materials we would appreciate if the next submission be accompanied by a response letter that describes the revised materials and how our comments were/were not integrated. Eberlein Subdivision-PB112019.117—1St Submittal Review November 7,2019 Poge4of4 If you have any comments, questions or need additional information, please do not hesitate to contact this office at 518-273-0055. Sincerely, e� 4a944v.r^, Jennifer Nechamen, P.E. Project Engineer cc: James J.Connors, P.E.Chazen File t:\pro{ects\31900-31999\31904.XX_Saratoga Springs\31904.05-Eberlein Subdivision PUA2019.117\submittals\Submttal-1\sent\31904.05-Eberlein Subdivision PB19.117_1st-sub 201911D7.dacs 20190117 EBERLEIN SUBDIVISION Attachment 2 LEGEND EBERLEIN SUBDIVISION LEGEND — — PROPOSED PROPERTY LINE WETLAND AREA 47551171 . Int 213M2:121 DEED RESTRICTED f' AREA �a:s'11114, ,'di"t. i ice!tS. DEED RESTRICTED AREA SIGN LOCATION STEEP SLOPES ( > 20%) EXISTING TREE LINE • PROPOSED TREE LINE EXISTING CONTOUR I0 0 PROPOSED CONTOUR LOD PROPOSED LIMITS OF DISTURBANCE SF PROPOSED SILT FENCE WSL - PROPOSED WATER SERVICE T -? TEST PIT LOCATION I .Z st .. 'per_\ < 15 n .2 �.9peaply ill! Ncc y N . , , - , ''' •4.-,_ , ___ 7.�__� \ aL �U� tSa f RI J M\ 1 ,. �1 e : :-----,- -.-e' Ti / .615 o • pis. °d5` a c 1J \C ?, :------ s . ..rd.,"-""'?"61'.' ''.-L-1 / ', .:1-,-)/ .- Jr __, ,.. . ki,' -.., ,, \ ......., ki - - I': <7 'P n n 8'.^ p'�///J .1w I / L a .moi oti J 4 ;. ^-'7 . _ _ / rc �o -V\1=,' I �• i _ _r-- ;.we ano,ne/, ! - _"At' .. ro+/ y ar�7:F'..Yr* f/ r !! f.; t ' r• �� \ i® odd faia1i b w, r rs U 17.% t. Obbtsi^ Q 3.9L.U.19N i i r. V N i3: -K r� E Iii I la. N p c� ! r. fi ... a ; ,n, [ b 1 „.... l. , ,, , A / A : i }Y I t e A v 191 t `s Q L ` 9 b 4q.yap.I J igtyy g� a i it�g li i?i. t{i d br �. v: S r :” i tia t ii _• Q . 5 ll• -. 2'g °1 j r..1.110 x> ! t t ;v 1 4• aa' 7b a6 • ilt I°ai : u€ as Ra' '€ ! S d IA S [ z Y r Yi[ b w t'3c7 t {" 3 5 yrt Y- 0 ; y'aa :1 nYr6 I a a / - 9 :Slap q 1YLc 9 a A;, t- 9' 3 . ii l� 1 �y4 ;PO!if: orda T 1 3b 4 r 9: f ei Ii' e s t 1- p.g h S''t •_ : a E K� a• 8 Yte r. £ifar is-"a F ‘..,.',1 ',.'',-,' .. r„_ a !:� [ I i °@ z" 3 as ; n a ;:l p sa i ' a 3Y : iiet �{r� [` i , T T W M P a p iY:. - 8 ��3e[ [ ISE T;il,•3 t.wil r . Qi D 4'a ; Q C E ,P 15811"" A A. - 's;.3 t 1 • • 1 -l Y f gY '- 3„ i d =asI v li4 1..1, { t Y �. uQ � '} y63 �s 'a R as Pgea a 1 'OW �r•SQ Ti1, r 1 . 1`. ,[ g„Z 7;;4y1 !e O AI S I Y� :T@ • .Ye YtrY��7 I ddE� .g'r!;illnsr �� .. .� �= s Ya`^ ::[9yt' •.6�i4 = .E 1c ! aw3- ,1 ej !9: 3 . t ` . D '! A Y•c �n„ ig �� lig: id! -e:;'piii 1I In F d 't. ? t a !' a ba t a°1sialFs �,f4§ .I . e� a 7f -� w I ag 1 i§3.k erYf-;e. 10 4i 'ei 4�gg d1 :"r G Y_g i` dagdas p1l°ai i .. 'xg 8 v} ; COI W I if :18 9 7211litlff :& a t'a 4 I = 1 ��"[ y3ir1Y w ^his Iw-pwwl 9r a;lip a>S3Eg " a—tt - Ii kc hil§ sa ro i i Y Yr • 1 ,It -.. - _ .... [ i i 8• t f 7 !g i<:] AI.,A, § I i. d a i P 6 ;rs a 1C= . `s a i li !i�17 ;11;P 9 s 3 ae Q 4 ; i I Y-x t( 's°r 13 ,i g..e- 11 i=f ;e a e is a 3 r ;a, 3 g 4.- 31;: 3::e Y 4 ? ' _ : Ln A. Fi;sy i1.J IP : „ 3 ke a a i e Ig! 9e°t 9 FIA .. e4 yt a P1 r g:I- Is ri xiv , o a o I ! sgi9�a 1i9 i5 5€ 1 1 , Ii i !!!h N;;: ;S t4 i b- a 6 5€ Fe�R; i 1 i r v}y' Y "�y 4 r S �oa 4 y � -'3. 2 5” I "-g a 3,;! Y +{ ;[ a[• 1111 a ',!'s pAIti d .; )i ;;t;4 Y4"v I g } gig cd''' -Ill 4Y • a r_xig PIYI 17t!d t ° t °a "- N �. loab 3[S(4v Y[ _ I} 4'Y,°r a I;, °e e+ §"j I c a f}f� � a t- Y: -- O " fr.' 11411. 1 [ s ,}1i 4 g7: 'i„f i'iI 'fa;P 90 a➢ Y Yp fv=� a .F i -ti .:?¢4 ••4.j'1� g dG[Q •3 'E'.Y +�a ! a e g PI ,ie'1 91 •Y• Iler if/' a: 2 F4 9 v 1 [ 4 s.. .. S. 2.1A[! Y a: 2 i 1.- a!4 ` r I IL 4 r F:2 ?If.;p s t V ? S - 1j : } r . S v -Y¢ [P0�' &41: a I ;el r r Y�Y ;:e t. Y - :01 1 nx 3Y,r 1 }ga - 4F 13 V O t - - y 3 •€,.. lg ,4 sal 1 Y s ei 3 ISA Y"s z} a d tI g_ -, b.:F." a: e# z ' 9 f i Ca Qyyp 4 ..:r$ �. r [ li •• _ •t I i P - F P P P v7 Sir (i°tp logo" YF f t y s YE'' at 5 a x 1 y li;Fg 3T id F:4d ? ve j a= Iy ig W = _ _ �s t2/II.' a,i §§a,i..' a i-1 i E� 3 ;i ;Xi 4=a xi J i'i`% -, a ab •6 6a iSSi ::" a J inn t 1 I I I ' .-':al r 16eg4 a 3 1� Y i1 ! 4 i�Y i ; .1;�{ .! SIi. 1 °IP ! —: »S u 1 I Q x�+ ,,8'.4 -:giY-8 ;fide # [ 11 q .;- �Q� x 1 Y a1� J.3 Y r3 � x � Z i �-� s-y Iai_ ;fid a 1 1. I Y;" 4 1 Yui Y 1■ 777 A g9;r Ag q 9:t .`iea g a; $i Y5(„S o I U''i{{ _ I I �Yi ( ' S � E re l a Y Y4 i 33 W Y� ��i:• U PI°1!!!! 41it1s6°TiT 1T1 iyiy!Y st <a!;i1easli earx' -' o: .'J3 t'd1f3114:1.g 9e i [ � 6 er5 Ig,g b 1 IV %%3aE•:f�8 i ayepa ; . •Qya % [ala to 9g pa :aT ggr. 3 [.ai i[Ye @ v5 E g fav gk§a r 4-rL� a "d -�`� q!F9€r ;e,• Y1e[1ii1r Ir(Y-t� ft fggt i °i4'.i76 g!; € :'.fig :Mg .2flaiiR. .Y.-E".i:al ar a[to=- . 4:C: " f ,,, r Y7f,J a 9.1 a�••� )J fit; ! $ r a• � 9r a �S " " ? / / f � � �.. '[4"1: �'* // 1 ,JTZ ../1y, .--1 ] 10 _"' •.��.-�•[L�/� �' F"� y'Rp � 'm YET Nn , "a-4Z / ��Od '' E . \- '' ' ' 0,D ,,,---,...-..-..--,,, ',,, ' -,-- ..,..... . k , . f N -)3 11 4,. $,\ , , ,,,,,,.,, .. ! � j vittELL N 1115 i!;!: ''''! t.,:,.„...;;., v ,,,,,,,,,,, .:i.L.,..; ..,„ .. t.„... „,,,....,,,,:: a. .. 'yyp '�y?�1 , '`‘+''''' r., ti. T 3 li,.„4:„ p��t zr. a ._ mm it }+� /' t �# '.1 i— \4 t �^ "S �'ktt-\ � YnRAGA � 1. , ,,..i.,„::,,,,,,t. ";:i'lt;74;itill7,,i4.iti1.4:``,Ip„./..,,,..,,, i,'''' ''..1.1::::,,:::'-`;''',,,::-.„1:::*'",:;174'-'6,,....rof,,,,,,\.\\:„ ,-\\/, \ „I„. ,,,;,t,.:.,1_,,,,,,„1.,'";;;::'',"3.:.;.1.}..t. i. . ;>. • ;?- ' :' -' �� ' r5 . ) I Il 1 i \\N\ / '' .::••,, \ '.N../ \ \ '''' ' ., :"1.;\ °S :::.\.,'\..1,1 uRttT OF � \-,, ,, ,Ny .,4":2,, 'i'i _ \ i t • - inti w �, — / / ,, ��' Oat ' v �. cc*Li 2UCTi{k J 11 / . G� E1�TRANC£ �fi • a ' > ai.a�<garr�, h - 1 \ . . f� , ,,, N . rya �h : '.i�4' �� w jeer a '� Attachment 4 20190117 EBERLEIN SUBDIVISION CHAPTER 241 OF THE CITY CODE OF THE CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS, NEW YORK SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS Adopted by the City Council June 17, 2003; amended September 4, 2012 Page 12 USABLE LAND: Class A Type refers to developable land generally devoid of wetlands, drainage courses, steep slopes, etc. Class B Type refers to land not suitable generally for development except for passive open space. https://www.saratoga-springs.org/DocumentCenter/View/2613/Su bdivision-Regu lations-PDF?bid Id= Burton's Legal Thesaurus definition of devoid: bare, barren, bereft of, blank, bleak, deficient, denuded of, deprived of, deserted, desolate, dessitute of, empty, empty of, found wanting, ill-furnished, ill-stored, impotent, in default of, in the absence of, in want of, incomplete, insufficient, lacking, missing, out of, poor, revacuus, scant of, short, short of, sparing, stinted, tenantless, unacquired, uninhabited, unoccupied, unofficered, unpeopled, unpossessed of, unprovided, unstaffed, unsupplied, untenanted, vacant, vacuous, void of, wanting, without, without content, without resources :R..,....,,.i.`w., *'Cb Ji«' i `�T'' • i4. '-.-1›...''�N. Qin!—Cita— t d• t �,"F • } t .. ro � l� r '..,,,,,,--0.;,-...**:‘,‘„�, M 1i4p',-;,,-,.. �yi)'y�.,. / , r7 < 1 i t ;.€» ` ,,\ . t' . +,a } r eh; max. E i S,, I ,4 �]) ifx , 4 A A`A t R d } �r sr r.�r..'� + ,per +./� s eu�w '�'y'y� pt ''..',-,,.:a.;77-• 7r� ' "'(\R\1ry. +'T.jyx 0. a- , • (ri .e*w.s'i'q•`_,. ,+X 3 .'3; L F " • ' i,t i � s k Vit,,..„, - iaMi�. -,-",144.N.' ''t1 '.5•,,b��.art hi.' 3•d ,.,( .• 4.1•.`':''.:C.,4 4 '. L ';• y >� ..','-"7x'°,� -°'C n v-Je9fr yr' i wN.'':Vlr ^r IT-7z4"-'.- w'. ' a i:- } i•y ' - ) }' a • Sr yy� . =A x•�•Yte "` --•a- "�.+., _i� ' �< r >i livii ,- ..„.:-..:„ ..,....:,;p. .., ...,...,,,, ..11,...,, ,;,..1...,..,,,...,,. .,..... ,?,..„.„,,if. ?le lqi7,...„7.,,,-:,)1, i„,;=,,,,,,,.'-: i,A;.7..::4), f ' .. - ,. ' � t' i ' �1 - ▪-a., ,....,',4.26a,-4,414-4 ,.....e.,...,.... ��`- Ss ▪ �^ ,1'..I4,41_,.` ., ` 1' ' > 4. i 1 '- f i.• YS e • _ .. . , } S rF� ; 4,7 .2,,,••.,;". �r' iS�: 7,�"A w _ FaY -tc _ fi ,It -sem' 6e "" • S,, `"7"-. - dew #r ,+4*Y ,R* ;,,e t�s+� ' y" 1 N "s. > . gy- r` c �" '- a a r1 . a▪ r �4- � * m )`� '"z� n . r ax��k.-t i ^: ; f ., •, ,-?$t L . y i �{yo3 v • • x \ ,x, "� " y'r+ t 77-7:!-- n = r fir' � ' • .� .« • 5. ' ''.!,,c... h• 4.-') ' 1"'i� j` t � / •_-i� w_ ho¢.. °':�+ k t `lylas w ' . �� 1. m • oftet M.^.-.-,_. r. - -{ Cs a .w. �£> :dam- .: _ Y P, f ,.t •+ • Wiltr iip,i .. �, a i . 44,..„.7.71;', _elf,}` 4F>,' **e-ss': ya 1 9..c,Y 1 l : er a .'{ -:,..i..- 'U,i-,,i , 3..w�w !-'i d.:. { • -)4''',-,..T.`:; 1;-.,,. 1 S, { . • �tn • Niyowiti ® s�a,,.'.1'„ t� '1 ' , ... def it', irr r _",,,4-,--f--..-7...---:1. � r-11•.' �1.k7" '3 ° x :ti t `- rheb ..),--;:',4.---- t - 1865 ."t d : E i L?=': „ x1:S}4 • • § 7 KSS .. _ - p'a."t,•i".!" -4r _ •. +.: s�5r- 5 `*afi .i4""- ; .}� ""Z,':-.?, T' �. ::"''''-al- r e!•_s,. = *,t. �t {▪ r r y' • -` '*�.3;1 •) ''{-., ;'--- t -• y • ; 't • a+ • _�s.r n z-4•La•z ''( '.""". `�+.. :,••,,,,.,: j � j r•°�▪o; t :144.."*/- fid. - ,AwA..' P ,. -k.— f .� "n '''',41*,`"":" • i �7. "` � fi '1� 7s • ,f ,/ ,10-' i T'il 1, • - k /\ t Mµw : • ° " v �.i ' -'• �4` r = aw ' + +C'- Wa3y _tr6 .x•; ,�f > Y•"• xx• ♦ ., ,'r " , ,, wt � a int [ 1 # u 4 PA' � is' d 3 )Cs , ` .: - sw,i '',-.1 , '�r ' ' 5",,.� m .Y ' yc 1 ;VC ~ rr f�" J _. Y. ( i-2-70 a9s.ir : as 8 i6t .. "ar � rr & -." Y"' :r'T, a t d : fiR4fq„ ar� a 'a !• ,C- { u� t'�Y� r _ [,w ,pk " +" a7 • : !Y } 14tpvXf7 '''‘‘':',‘, .;,.\\., ?, 't - 4 � x .i x ! ', , ".-Se 'ks ` "!,,,,,,:4..%'.) ,,,,,,),,I,...,:,1'1'.7wp�x* a\t p ' : ... ivyy ! ci 4 r I ,y }. ..,,',4.',,-....:•r4ir ,b , 1,:,,:"--,',:t"."77., 1 .r ?• . ' r4 , "., r '''::;'...-",w,-,,,,,..„....,.1,/ 7` �' x k ?_ .`'"w.®M�N 1.h �.."..,.a:'.�v'�(- -•uil„ac.:�.'�8`,,Y l i,j—p.►n+7.�61(▪ rw-.• . Y"- 'rl-+l rb-1..:'..,x o }CM!.,'�:b.,�?°✓t " 1 i a!I}P71�,`.4 .'v.z ; ';r b ., ` • ,.:p''- .., ',„".., ', . ' - i : aw_� � - is,, . ♦ . t t4'c -� eye- r,,, 4'`w-m . t1. 'y'1 •. [ x F5fr • YS*":j �}rere1 ,.%:•,',..,,',,,c,+ ! 4 a ,„ x . )cei xf x l ¢ „t. • ,.,y? , ' b�'6 991�t„417P. ` 1. ,,, t'e , �'e++4 6,•i 4�.1lJ' .,� v4-,t :-7)1 .i. , 1 , r- ...';1•414„,(}at tio j '?' #, 1., Lrisl12., ° a " fs� y„,,,,.;..e:-?,(,,,.,., r] •w. +R..'1i, 9r� 4 -,,i,4- .•u H i � r t , • x3 ',a •;'•4`',.,0•'„r; i' • :. e ? ,z,...';.., t. ., . 'f. i ,:i 1'd . • r;rv `,y ,:,.!.'',1•4:: : ', . a : ,am '. k,„t 411; • N �a [ba` gsr Sj � ' vj Y 'l ` s ( a _,i?!"1�44jx;,'_,;..'''''i'. n F jr ; 1x''''.:•.•Y ' a � }.NY. "' r�F a-- ;, tit \' y` r;5: rlyrsy + o ,.'c. tYTS + np ` "'i Qd * w ra P � . ` '--7-:.t.,?!..,.-L: r "tteS' f'y 3Yldkdli';*g, c ; • ,..�t , ? ;..,: " -�M: ,rr, :4-=.1..:,'4i::'..'7.'.4. TS. 7B'" sk r ir � t? 4 ''''.:!:i”; 7-S • , ..„..... ,.._ , • • • • .iiii • ,W';kW.f 7 / .1j6iMWy�. n- � ++a• '.aM9L'= rf . ( -. � ° ( Yds� ; :f i:i� ” x° • > t �[ i St• b ��^ v7. 1JY �� .' � -, �#� - d'i� �R .:+ 4t,3y .i.1 � . F: 7ae; :ya -C,txR«. w< '',It . *�'«� .��.4 . =0.'",1 c r •.i.1,-. 6 ,y � � Z-"Jk` .�� nrr: .iii..,?. . d 'T ,',,i7:‘:;.;' yC r f ' r d '',::-.10.4.',',„!--.',.v..,9',•4.,,„" ' t' V,'..,-,..!..;;:.• =;- t L S , t ' ' 1`w. -.-c t z tis. ; , *r'� �t, r --,xyt ?4. , . ' ey" c +r ,..,.,,i,',-,: .4.,....,,,,,,:;:,? t» a „711i $'ur t•�' .SJch , .i!'''f.-,:,:::4 fis. � N� ?, a s r vif ; ;.•.j,r_7i.,2,,',.;,:‘,.4„-.0. r' 't ' • ;;, „,,,,,:,,,..4,.-:-,,.-..",..', �y, , a ma,$'�'�+`r`t x ' r� .t .",'•.,,,.,k4 < i -k yf, k . t t!.-.,..-11, ,,' '�'r: , t', ' • , :t7. 'T• . - x9"'� 'r `-'4...1,';',.. 4.t9Y:1`4,:,:',",r., .f '- pa R ,„ ,� , 1^ty+1�e3 1!ti ` ' 1 , ",-,1,,',...1.•v ''t . -.....•.„,„.-..,....,-,0- Akt+,, . *.. ,w' ' Mlh.�i#..� t „,:...-t 7,‘.... "'r' .J f t' ,y.� .... ,,,,',,.'.1.!!;41.. ,�,,'`rik , ° .k' l� t � a``'`aa"^. �'-• 1�; -"1,,,,,I•-....•-+ 4,,,,./4-44y f t a. 1� dv+ �� 4''s�' � ,,,,,,:i".. 'irr a‘'- --.,,,!...4 -1,-..,4;1_,,-4-1,..'31104.04):•,,,,.,, :'! ►?+1 'd��y.� 1pl�'�'\^-', '1- p" •'� i . . > - rli j �,, '� g.,...g.,...,,.4'. � Yta' s , .. f d t ° ,4,� �" . t” ,r . ri''''',\;---ij� f �li �t � IF w, as6£: k..., . i,' •- .�C^ 3' t r ,i. � r rf ' 5i t.r ?„.i.- t es' » 4' .'z .tLs,. •' �' 1 ,,. 7 '4:44',":',,,,'4.r."./4‘.''t f xz: ? °ir. t .1';,.:',.,,.. fi °” ` d'-*4;','...,.",''''-''''I''':' ",. +r. bx. , �Y • ' �t'-, �t .„�.�r� ��� ” 4 "a 1 , { ,. *X ' � , ' f ,,. ' : ?:rt�-/� iA':�AS �I7�? t 4?- 1Y 7it ": '1 ',� T-�Yjofi� •,441yYqS 5'111.41",1V,..-:0,1 r ,V]..7:,,' ��ftPs�� , �,:.!'" - r;'''''''' T,; 5ei "4/ 6 ' . u4, s.; - 1 '1.`'t'''. '4 '''...!,',7'...., „Ia.. a i ' iy f ` ;.-1,. "ga «.i xPfy " Stxr 1 r $ r - ---7'T''''. 'T''. - s'''':'r � i1 � ' k a°� .Iti,7 '.4+,,I,4';;47..'0:7:77. rtl ' f ;,,4,;.",.,;.'p ! 4tb i."-,-„, a‘ i;:.'7';7,,..;.„'4•:,,s� , ;,..e • • It It a fa+ ;, - £ `-•s�,yi'....d'•''.•:1•'-vi �, C vJ i v r$ -.-...,-x;',—,, - '-4"r " a��M” . } ;',*•:',,,'`4.;.a ? ry r , ? ,..p v+��'�A . 4 waT � � x lye ` fi„".. ,y��-14,3r`�lW��1�1► .� , t u� �•S? t 1;4';',447.,...1� t �.�� ra; " ''-" b f E 4 41 1 dst } a-w� O4•.,�^" G«� . Ixxr C,ir t♦ ? i 9 t ✓ kr� i' 1 �SP^ xt c f ' ..., - 1.•• l-.�..'1 r - 4 5..a ) Y ppF'tt tysi j 4 S•.� V4 Y §r�'�".fa�, f.i + � ''''..':4., 14, • 17.7; d" e' fi• I*` r {•' M r �1,+ l R ' .4C',..1.,'4'.' f�' k �'� mA;;q, % C`zt '7S:awx i ' , �1 ' i i �. a s 14.4:<"...,.:("%", r . .u, r qx.1}} y Vi0y� 4- 4 4+I •� 1 . $ zi. .,.1.,;,„1:1(4.0.- 1.b! J� e RF,, ,," , '.: 4- � � `� - 1.. ,'1•' c«.,. 4:' ..4, :Yi " `gri"si+^4-•p t ','n n a' ''''" ; " lit ;: ?> y.sr ,r' J 1y4i , ., ' : y Ay. , Jb. • i �a"'''.4"' y $ *wr lt'r ✓r •tL _.�. � t y v 4,� ,''''', 4470. a 7 Y � .1,,:'+;',E " ii " y, , 'S> ,w¢ rx li et .� ,�:„1 :'r(r .-.� + 3 `t" 'a yir i ' ' A. r .... ..11 ? � - • 7,7:-.J.,:•-•:",,;,,* Pr.7+ar*.,'� 3' i"t ht ° t 7? :•?,-",,'1...,;:,,e 1;°z-!. j ; c�0 trr/ .r:n/F f�'dJ_ 9gp1+ : r., - r+ �- ? 4..-','",,-;.-.. .....'.:T.'4,''',-, y "�.,.t-e,�..--wfi'"°`'.r r'"i.tq\ :1,4-2,,, f' �Pi , .,.,•. .,•;,..., .,,...„1„. tx&('. r r4g,P,t. ''.1''';':,' o-. r %'�kti�S (2' ,,-,:::.,:.,.,,.,,,,d4, ! ..1,4', t �t T - di r ' ' a7a�+ ,;',7-,:;.,;;;);in'. ,,:;;?;;',;',::' P (k{rtiIkt, .� q i„x •; }Iy ; , :rj ' hn ?F. +� S f.r:'fie , 'c` . ' ti4 4". £ A ," f(rrrx '}1-'' „ :. i • J•„,....4,..,...:-,,,'-,,....c, ..E r gi"*PI' g. " � ",,,�� A� r • 1 $ t 8sta 's`,:-.....•,\,:-1:.Q.•:!..'.,' .rYy r 4"� " • r" ' , . t .„4„, t k � _A } 4Aw � • • e. }W ,'W.- " T :471, ,J1a. : -' ` , 1 vr m r,Y''Wvta . a? ` -,, g�c4m, %` sl ,,t ' 'vl . • • • pg. iii, '""'L.� .. '" .-,`IL 11 J t ' ',. :,....t,„,..,..4 r 1 i ,a N ;'::,',''''.\.`'A tA5J , . �l W , - 5 s �.2"-, ' g :.r , ra .,Yt ! 1t, t i' ?..-4- sp ez ," 4417-!,▪ ", am! ,i!„,... -" 11i, . y , ,a ��; sat& `� s' ,' 't bN 1t., .....i7" 96h A, ir+ll c rr `(; i " , , f 2.- f g a .1 rAdoK' .� e ' 3x K t.,,, eF' j.l .+. � £r ti6: x : r j �. , .„,,,1'.;,:. ,„7,0.,,,I.,',„.1,:,.,, �'s +, Ywla,'F alt,: Ra ,.x I ', rk � } ...=',..� �htm�wx o�r `s '1 - .4.1...?,, u V� � tt ) Jray �t �% t it ?ce .� .77--;;,7,-';;;;,,,,,,7„,,j:,'t 1,.',' ris4 At ^ �,t i :,$':::::',',.'''-.:.-.,',7,,T,'' F' f �ii 7 -,,..t,..;')..-„„! :" ., tr tqr , ?' : ryY3 " . ,--;;;..4., ;? Y >t • • 14 kiit ": r yl , •,hy^ ,+ i k d' r rR♦ ada '. "44):',: 4 ."' ..G' C'.',,,/ ;�, � ( i ,r .t (!. . p�ay �" 1-0-,,-: ti .v r rrr t. • l : 4 wS r�i 41't 712 9'. 1 x ;a -,,w . � - Wt— i„......-• y 1.1:,,,z4,-?...,"'.-;' ♦ 7: 7i tj. 9 _- _— L,✓r tw " .WYE 44T• :of : • '47"; R `a.R: d }.rz C ^5.g **4',40 „'''r ,1 #t iFC� trg > x .4,4J':',/1C„e` ',5.e.' ‘ii.'” .,. ..,'!' - ' ,,,7 . ' . -”,.- '74.4 ,,„S',), ` r L' ,r R ! , g ,` , ; ic w, Ni.' .' li J! �; .•-r •.N of y� . 'y, ; '- A-'�"" ^-M fie• Y ,. ' g 7. ,�,�, •i ", w , .,.t R f •i, r 2 i '4 , r x� .- , 4' F r i r , , rt k IA.rij'w4 1 �Y. �1''�,�"..6, a T - • .• w t,iy't . w+«;, ,..1.0‘ • ��........, ..i.„,,_ ▪ r y- �;ti. � r .e�'a 1a +}•r����,� t 4 r�� yr r yji ,��,E ,}$ �� rY �: � �y. ; ,.;�"�-� :44.,_,----..;�`-.- • '" wii. 41 1 ygy'�r1,j • l'S f �f�'�'�¢`i } A -t�'.�yr , r ..,! .VIF'In 'x ..4-1,.......,„:.. � w:tio4 i;.4-fi'r i •, 4,,.0• %r7 ��jl • 4 � ,V-,r , ts_+Fii ';:^, ,�tla 1-, a �'R .y tr[#i09 ' S1 4, t 4`.•d ' " t� �,..",1'.1,,,)",rw J p •.;,, � ..;,,,4▪ ` '°" --v. , x.�-v ��* __ 4"",,. . ,y„n'1KiX1 Ef'/ � 'e'''''.r"1 + `k Y ?„a.•..j� rr • q ti r ),. ,,,, /.,,,„ „, . r, �r - y �•'� ` 1'Ria 2 rad f "1 � y y�r',t.',fr� /:.4"ZAr1Y 'r.';1^1''`•-£-,r ,� +✓ j :f r `ti ;, 6W y$�f• _ t w i "�. , y's yt h. 'r•1} .. ..rvc �`, fits ,i -1`,.-::'---:'`-...--. ?”" �w t "V '`�-'� _ ,F�� ��'±��� F +��, �6n z t y�, '''�• yr^1�,ry'w w,•�r j�w�r y� c � *�� t Y t,, ,� t V � !�l 77 * >y - d - hn �r(tiir�r•" � '"''"r'� « !+r ,# ° i ': T �'l �'w▪ na.",w.«.... --;,,i,-*,,,..,- °' 'C,,,.., . ° 'C.....4.1-T_ r-rL it 'i jt a '� '1&kp f r ' r,,( ""'r"gs"''g� g '. t . k,.,, . s ,. ' ..,_ .; �Y t' �' .r "t.,� iy Yt �• .?.'ya y �l 0 ��r, T w,a` F ',-.::::,••:',, l ,'r7' � 2 �* nr. ',..7t."...0,......„ //1 kf'j ka ..'1,A,,{ 'e' I r 4• 4.1▪.1/7 d ,•4, '�' r�1. "^:`-g. . . =� .raw !ii� ':,'' ,k,-'',- k i;#`'t'` s.�.yf.'4. a ir�!' ..,L,.,.',,,.!':lir q.Y 7 ,M„i 7 +' :•"s^ a .1 y 71, 'c,, Y ;< � ,,,,4Y.\;f:,Q(kx4g7 r s rrT F ig • • :,t. ,a. ,Jim ' '.44 •' 'L(• _ {, �'t ,' ,e".ti v1/4.▪ 45,'1,';4',&,S,'# .# rf 444 r. r z f kr �- ifit M R,#,,, w, .4:„. '� 3 ,{ . z 4 ,'' • '� A'.r • .t x '-'Pi r�' '. .#$,r,<1 R3;F Sy �f• .A x f �yia�' �::..yy;IiIi*" p - - «a s _'Tk `&x 4-, r Y5 i''1 '-' ,. �,y'ly, sx_lr ,f _ ^-y % ',.0 i,'� tS,.•y�w ',e1 i yJ' j ' 1. ',`w�". =,+�taMr"•�. yr . 'f.... ',,��'�'R f�=«ypQy fi4 4Y!.44.''''''. 'RF� � j'&.'f" � #j +�l # y, l.e� � w» a T++w�, r�r L. ay,J • i, ' aa. r r. i f ^, ,•'-'---.'''....„ •' ,,p, „ir f`• }'�r�.r.ALCrr < W"�y�[y } �jle'1"/*,"4 �?a r ' At ' t P } X "-" ` �`a Ai „;4161 .. •`„ ,�" ' '..) 4J' s't1l - #-•-- , h`� r x,� r &, 1 ,. ; r,; te __ --�°"4,.� `,,-- ..,lcs, fi T ,y s,feY "wSSS �p „ t , ' "tk yA.nT. 7 L:, � G t” � #F? ,y •=�, t f -c- �f^.n t> w _.*._,.44.4 7'. - .F• �J N,y , 5 Tri,.}[, n t r 1 "C� s} c I N.. �'�.,� , � i; 1 ;*0414.„,,...0,-;f,,,,., ,w ",ya ° rf;T -..,, r; <d4Siy.i,,C'45 �; , ''*,r3+ i t' ':/�7y ,,-, 4 $^`y ,, ..._,."; 2� e1� • ' t ±;q ,++^':. t, > '4; ate "'7r$ { ”'=:v ° yx S r t-;,- Fa'``' -'°-:•-':.0,0".,`:,,,L'',.; "ii„;',,'g' wv^v"rp ,., 14.1„ .•1"1 41^. • • ,Lf1`' ru's .._ }. t. • ,w �,"7-tti_.., YP' s ,rvw{s l ; . yrs .•.' l!'. Y ! .r'y" f 1'3 , ,f .:t �Th3, wJ -,..---7-=1,-2*' .., } y :.7j: "• „""t..e� {"!'r ff.. t• r' a •6.. r, kN 7 •(."r•• 1 Si,_. :i'.!'Fi . ''� �� /' y ., t"t„.. r °+ iF ..1. 0,,,f1; x " -Xw" lis r�y zz:•.FR 2k';,}rr{v"'r'i4E�'G .,�:'.:1;!,,i;',./.",?-: ',./. r'' r `R{' r {F. a b� , } ... %-44...t„.. ."'4,. .. .yam ; 4,4 a....?r� w ,--J,, ..• r'> $k • # Tf . , }' ',Al.g ' r :a a k -- t tr rp ,"t.Ni J 3V• i,'L • ,� S, .4 i' ���� � 'F+,yy a 1({ �� :'k�:.41�k '0,4, �°'� � '... �'�y'}-. .e t�.� q."-.-4--2.,— - �. ,r;,p;, ....441-....,..., ,,, � b:. c ... 7z fir_ r� rs .. �...,,, ,: ..,...„,,,,._i_,!_,, r r l`r ,.,1•,1 , il' w zS .,,..g t-v.o.�,,., °r>rt ,•,„ „.f.....„,.• > ;-f r t/t,�/`)+;1lk -'4 Yt•• .` r y "''.,./ ,..-L... 5 y - '. ,:i,,,........ a..~ � ...?C r •'I?r E i„.s,.5, ,, :„.. C i`y r., ▪ t,r �”.w. .,.i.}1V'.1'} 7,,' .,r 'a,,;. ''.',,.i,, 1 "^ ""m ,, v r-" +ItwT a t.r l t r _. gym,. .-=.,e . �.,y�..q 3!`iyq� •s •..,,,,,......$......t�7�'a ' # -��1.'a`r�vr.'�..� ' qi� ° 7 �.r i�� r "d" � --.14.. ...4,.. .....`� r r. S d ki, 1 s rk 't APO.i C ti_' J ! Ck 5"� ;.I. r.'' ' 7- `1 t�.t• ,' I r• ispmtii• gir`.f y J ti .`1, ..` # ,,-4-2,-,,r.‘. y--40,.... .,,,,,'w t ' '�C' •v X '04" i r J �a'`♦ i•y "; f, ''-t 't :- ?„i •J x' ,F•-`. ��� _ ,i 7, i ai. r ' t1 ,� dp 17;;•,,,c.,1,/ 7;; (, 1 -Li: 1 r i .r v Ftt,_,,,,..„'� • ,_.'µ. A ,!k w • e--,- ' ' YiK ti ` ,...Y.: ,. ..7�r li �I' 1 } 9�.., ) j _j ▪ • -;.:.—i-..= -�•:.',.., e. . , v.. i -z i! r . 1- s •{. + ,4 S -3. 1 i!t .,a ;>•, - • • 0 '. it • .1 ,i'.+v'�. .,,,.-a , ! T 1,!Jit'.,% "t$.;''...19,;;;.':,;4,:;;',10i ' „I,,,;,,y'v l ° -,,tri • „ • .r t” 1,'µ,i ''t,'`2" ci' ..... - .. -. , . it r" �+Y• .r : `!1471 r ],"'56,,;‘;,',.'1'''.., 9�r�Z • : .L'S'1` ya 4r"'1f y•L , 11 .� + k i� "� � rt t vr d a'fi�a5 e �a,' r lairr ,Filtr�f41L X5•4 '...! t �g Jae,# i Vf µ -• ^ �E",r,rw '';',\:.Yr ,�{� i ''''',A t :t A (y '-;• +3t. '. P,r}s''i`•.�i�)r e s -, , •'1. #', y'.... i44 s ' y�'. ,s. ' •ry,,„e c,'`� {y ' ;-, , e" • '.,,' �i Y ' ,i/x!... �,,.( '?.0 r9 yr y. ,S r1 •1 •G ��,/pJ^� rR W i1Pr .r y '� 45 r ,� � F1'1 � � 'r r 4 '�* 4 .�p y �} .4-#... tilt d ea•�c } �� �'7b° `I �� 4 .,.�,^ - .1 . °'� r 2:;''''''' '°!r '; 1' t T' - ` 4 d..ii- 6R ti +r r.,Y'y.-' '°`o e ,„r.---.' 1”j. - 1~'1 .y 'J of. vyy ,� �i�, Ji. • - . • �. M r '11.;;;"•""1"1{ r",-.',,-.:)/'1;' , 4 t g t7'. }v'C?y yj '�„ ' 1 :4:,.. w'r q�' , # '',,,,sq,3 a` ,nr i;,a , � -IN.y�ah5 .,, 1 w ti4 .t t+- P V•C b , ry 't 1'” -'" ', 14 's�. ., ° r •��'�, ti <� +T� `� '� •.�' • �s� dd' �i��' 7��y�a i. �p r�" r2s �r � '�_, ,r.� '� ,� *�, '' .,. ..jam .,-4,,.:-.,-,7.'-,..,- . L t4 „+c t i i c '4 k , .e •,, •' ,' ` % �' ...,..0.,...:,,,,,,,.. .,..7.„-,,,,,:.,„..,,,,,_.:.7..,...7, ,,,...„,:,.....,:::___......._.,,,,,,,.:77., C , r .t >5 j� y,M# ,; # 7� ani_ 'v• � ;t.L I 'ya of•4� Nttt -- -.qq�� • ,vt�yg .� ..,,..,,,...11,..,,,,,,..:.,.4.,..,,..,,,„:,,,,..,:, "'P,r ds-5, r`?,...,:,;,,,,,,,...„..;,,it,,,,:,,,,,,,., ' ! ,� ` `'� cy� . r .k'.....,,,,,..,,,,..4:;;,-.;,",.",',-..4,-, •▪y,�Y'`. k� a. -S ."�' -.„..- ▪i .. .°. Ar �4}�,hy, '1•1.114, ,�,°.,..i..,,,,,... a,..,. r,• + �z ,��5. L' S `.. �i . f, y ® 1 � ,,, :k,„...0.. , '" ,...i '1.r.:::„.M, ,....c�-+i1t4M . i i ',r1ir. r'' ' � f >• .411v�, t4 A t •' y ,.' 44•• "*ya."•• 14` ,> ..'' ``y<,L',-- ' T` {r .siT ,4 c vl •, • .♦v qyq, • 1, :", '" m;w-� ff'..,- -7'+.�;44,...‘:"t,71.,„, , ▪• i .1^11', ,..-.-.14 ,p•-• t ?.I„ 14•lo, f. ,j�, 14'..1 r 1, ' '' , 1. • `5*' { `t„�. .�v7 y�• • *Ala ,,i - 't J,- • x., ',n..- ,,, { ' �tw+ • , .,• 1, ,-i! {� 3 r!;: * , 's� ▪ klt as x -'.,e.,14-. .,,, `'„ ; 4 F l f, , * ry '• s, ' `I '� f ii-'.1 4,, l ,, ,, !i.i.. we .gyp, ,I{ Y 'i.` J -4 1,,, ff�' '+ i # i7 ,- - xh +, 4 Va r �i r ,rR' r ! i- u Xf ri i'fii S• � a .441..-.4,!„ � �Y•3w ,.v.y r � ',l � �• y P ,E�� * �' r �4 .'!° t � 4 ' �r ' 3-, � Y• N� 1 . .k y• ' • .. Y��r ,i' �,. �,y,� r I r rr ,r� y k L)�� 44}}}l{�{ ��' � � „44.,. .,,,.,, �. •,� �, i r• It_I J ice r # f ` 4"),...,'",'-,, , #; �,,-.:.�t. t -, i r ! t .4 ilk...) a s rte'' ,r T Y yi C` 4r ,i w' ,, y -. ,� , s Ar +i. 4� s 1 r ti a ,t CO y� r F ,yS qp ,.r { 'ti '.M itk T �� .. !•K� '� ▪1 ' -rt l `Tl' ,C• r f flr Tt..`. ,r d•• ,-'"'..T fir' �,•i� d, i'4Ar 1,. A*rla �' dx t t • s r' '� _'� 5 �i .�i9i'•:' !) R r � r�i w ° ��` eS * � ��▪'J 1 h • t, LI' y H .yyg, w ' c,-nr - ,g a V.'1 ” i ,,„,-:"S dr, Si+�; ''t'L4 ''It p I �y .t+ .ir , ."‘it.” „,\r, lT....r�'�"'A�r� •! k �� ,L S �j �?#;[ ro ( �' lair t f3��i T �i L k,- I 1. ., ,,.,. • �ry y4� y y vy; . '!•iv: 3rYl,.it r,.�,;'. 4';. -.4”• I ;V )r --"-',,shy {�.., I' j� ti �,py .h'rl '.`�wi' t?�tY v.• �f `�• tii I71 {�. rfy*S $. � T r v F. w�,� `-«. �'• �'( -.410111111,111,�6 t Yk ye r- .+ r • V, q` � �jj ; :.,4p- [�' 4ar`3s;r1 71 '4,4k, ♦y', i rt y 'P q _ lyi �l 1l w .� 1 0 x�"'•. ,'"'"-c °s .-4 I'•� � e[ �R ,. �'f 'h "I•yi�,... •f. -"i y'k ) 4i f '�F.� .,„ -1114 4 .. +r rr .' ,c.6;..'-<.::‘,,„„77 \ ir• V a., a'e4' •I'"t � '{"" I ! [ �. � .. .'� .n.. w '\ rid r t a , ,' rr..� • • • " .. ,aA „•-•4.. �7 w-��., .e"+ i^+c^'� • tt. k .. d !j) jM:'s ,f "1 •; ,eE':.* • • .,, 7 ,y t• AW 1• #4 ! ,r ew (" ��.11�• ;•...., ilW�,• •yw�" - x . • A w +,.�,tr A:t tom, 7 ^1a t��, .'`'% �� .., .' A ,� ',.k t 3 k"6 i'="4 c./.340;'--.; '•• t* ,..,4„,„..- . . • . 'T • rte -' - ti +* s ;a fir, rG w' ,*ti+ ,� ; + • t _. - �� 4- ...tom, t`+`-'*� �s 7 X i; T z t -t. ,� '� A- /:' "^, „a r. . x+" n it l s , '' _� ' y 4".„,t. y{ tr .,._, ...i7,..itzi,-.,, ,,,...;.,, ,i - , - ,, ..,. i t "+-..M1,, •-y-,�. .Y` i .'. _;........,.,4*,4.7„,,,:,,,,,.,„,,-. = :� �� [� [" • �� y`.T'� 1. 4„..._,,. Y ,........___.. .,._,..,5 ....i ,..,.,i .,,, . 21, ... ,,.,....„.....,.. ..,. -,..:,....•_;:-.."!=....*.T.if.'_'",i,..77*:1"*"'"*ii•vi."•. ...--..,-.;-,.•; -:....1*„,,.':., ,ti w � fiti „t.i., • t� a :�.. � ;�� fix, , , �r{�y. �; � �. . .._.. ,:„,..,..:;:., .,,:.., .„.4e.1......„.....:,......„:......„„,,,,,,,,...,..tils..,,r -',. •'1„:,2,.„,. / %„, , i'V' � a„ M ;--''1M sit..P-; P s` ,;r �. '1 __z '„.„"h' ,-,raw..... rt . -�r{ � x�.1 .., yam.. , rr.....� ti " "3"-. .. .� -"."7',,,7":'',•)•,`).-" )•Ito' �{ )" A " i41.. "`' '.S*,. r ,- . 1• k. -fit' ti°" ""a.«-. ' 1 :'r .Yd p`7 ;d' '° • �' Sys s a dG: fi. y... �° ', 1?:::'.'*'' a q,R `;t , i { �•, k �` a ,� 74:.4 �. .ro a r a{}a �+r�"e" *r ,7;:;,.''....._,.".,,,*. ' c�F + k� p , ._; ��e r '':� " fir' . Y '^A (r "trt t� z.`* t., �.* rdN ✓ �°� 1"� -,'.'(ie.,:: .''' 'A.e. n: • 1� i _� a '-�_ ' '�.r t ° �.I.A ' 4 g? ,^�?/j�� — • _w r/ �iO�iC hri `� �. i A.; ♦ 2 - "� ...I* � �. i kr ,��"` `$F '''11: -� � F '„!1......'.�` 7.7-2,7.7;.!:=••.'"_,40: � V ♦ e ,;:,'• �' :.,;e2•'� • 'L�, �e J r rr r" „ •`ey ."ce'.. w � .[ .R, • '',B� iF ,� " e . .""'.n" i ' - ,,p },° r '' F 4 MK T L ,.,- r<- .r�,••l` d . 1 1:: , tii r .s.�.-. ".Y ..*4 V ^JMd,y*,S� !.'S k �,..` y a. �•A vyy4 y y a • t �l " - a } • r /.} - v t ' iw k7 t t.7117P,' � '� SI:.r'..2,'A!:r'''' .''SO:.*::t.."7(''444;,94:iq'''' 1� ....• '' �#�-`J,,. -,�.. � �?W'Y` ‘1'411 F iJi l��"�, ,+�.,P"^p+t, � � ��"�tt�� �. y�am,,,__ !at f�cy � 'y�, ,.. .1�a� ad WL ° A .. z.r\ .'1 Y.;i:. .„,,,,., :�. +>., d> R ,, ,-..,,t,:,,,,,,;,' .:„ , y "�' , T � -i a G" tG �.: i. f 4 r��r f * �" 11 *'^4 Yi41 N, y ' a y \\,...,_ i` � f1! mow. t+� p ���' !7 ., Y �� "'� � F • .fin p i __ r 1. 'f' •'i; ;cI., • , '+'-+.� J.. : aa�4� aL;. Pok Nu •#\" AiI '.F. 1 i,l•• I � P. ! .1....-f • ; i1.' yl-.• 14 j F A�: • .11 \L‘4, -�...... ,,,::...„� ��\t--,..:,,,,..w ..,,,,,_,..--z,,,,� '� : ,i�� �`! • � .1.....f.,,:„-•:;.. .._:.r...."3,-.,,k.„-,z7-4. ...,,..";.t. ,_...., � �+ir 7 '. � '�".- .^, ate^, >-a�-`.`sx� = i'',." •-# T �.. �9 'ti" `'°'t .. �,7 k° : .A. a' '1.‘,',...,:'"5 3,., '�+ i ." .„4.-:rJ ear �'C`> a t..,. ,,/ .0 • .,,.,,,.,....,„-:,,,,.... ...*,:i..,...„ „7..... __ ... `►, 3+ Ccy, '�- 1 4 e-,� ti, ' env .r' , � _.....„...:z :r �r "�} Y`.� '6 h« @t,- ,...,...i;,. ♦ , �...• ,c,.:..,,,,,,...,,,,...,....,,,,,,..„, er, � -`r -�Jy�77:- : „,',-2....7:-..!...-,,,,-.r �^-°r,Y t +J-' ��. �' � -` t `4: i ">• ,- x t.. ri *,:i5.4 R` #sn'. let, k ,- ?, -w ,i'ir' l't,fiF '',';'� , t+R`' ,,,.,.. .-....,-'sC.'{w,r .?-71.4 ---.,..,;•,-.1.1, 71. , , ♦5%-.,7,8,.:::N.-,,,4,,t, r � ^ . ""#IT i FA -;:.;'`.`-r .---In ti+Aiti '2,,", ,,«,_-''N �S y'- t `-- s;r....«*. ' * 'S. ` ? 4 , A i� ” .� h?i d!{` �. Z t„ v,L. , mac., - yl a ,° .'a 7' 9 ''i' C`i- .x �,° y ,",{a,�,iA . Y.,. 4- ..:. {.+..,r L4...' ' x F l ° ,. .. .. _ - .. �" y' fy„w,. u' M:..' la .i 1,..,. ./i., V 1 '.}6.N� �i. _ 1-. t F . *ice '.k \ y �Y moi+. s'a « "-. /`� `_,.J °�`.I� .Vis �.� .''„,1,7-'7'i4.4" W.. �8y�A� �� � Y k1.T.7.' �L I'�$-y�! �`! F �`.�• i '....-,,,T.'.'..!.4.: .-.„ •�„ �?40 �' -� 'j7 '4.':r°f � " w E \ m) ,.S �' ♦ 9i p4,.y w "L A 'F !.4 'yy,-$. as �E }!y,1. #�y Y `.7 `41#. . L 4"#'.•'� �. ` a� .'',� ��r,� �' .n;' ,..� '1b���� 4. 41,t,-'4';' -,'' "- � � ;.$"i.1.1 � �'� ff a � ��1 mob' +� ,tip } r � • � .., p .,. ', y;. . w ° 1y, • y '%� y 6tl �`a s- ' '' r . of p ,[ r II y, y� >r":y yet# " h}t "M' rpt"Aj '"'T7 44 r �. f r ` +,)6 .. ftJ .: 'r , ',1 • �, a °" i ! "+{,.,. +,. ,.. .:',::„,7:7:!,-,;;'L_ °13<e ,. -i" "� .i• «4 � em Ssr .:�ti`.. ^+,ham a f ,...,. . w,. �. ; ki:,„" >~ ,.,;4.,,, ,,,tit44.4:4',.,:,,,Z$4k 14"fr,',:t ,,,,,,,,0.:,„:,,'' '''....dtto..7,.';'10,4:4;5.,.-,; ' '''''''' '!1'..'''I'L.':::;'::•-•!*;'''''',.'•::,, 1% - r 1.'4KII*k`''':''.,#.1" ww ti � w 04..-.'7.:'7,-..,.:',I, ._ *,a .•. ta. a', '„ fin'", � .1yf� ...1,.•.,•-_,,,.. i.t d. � C: „„�,. •.`41.110.:A.,:,--• rep -,1-;11f.,...,,';. '4.,'•,,; 'Tv yKaR 4 11 R„4.174,,,„1.4.43,,,'10411- 14.',..i,477,7,. ?Vz s u. ',. s.""' � a � .`, :1tty ,7 . 1:',..4,r,- { ba%. ' _ 's ` `� '4' `� �r d .a'J ' " f A1.: �R 11457:,...." " rfiyas. ...;? . s .,., - a� t} 1‘;:P1,4%;.. . p. '>. 1 44:'.r F�`ri�� � r 4 41.b ,teds "^, .,t 4's#1e.r 6-rw."C .i1:440.* , sw+ „, ”. M .t a ,:am, Iftf-177 . " r tl> � _ . s.Cll'" ,. „.. r ._/, ' . • ao 9° a h CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS ZONING ORDINANCE / D 2.0 BASE ZONING DISTRICTS 2.1 INTENT To fulfill the intent and purpose of this Chapter, the following tables identify zoning districts and district intents (Table 1), districts use schedule (Table 2), and districts area and bulk schedule (Table 3). TABLE 1: ZONING DISTRICTS AND DISTRICT INTENTS RESIDENTIAL ZONING DISTRICTS DISTRICT INTENT To provide low density residential and agricultural uses in order to preserve Rural Residential (RR) open space and a rural character. Limiting topography, soil condition, slopes and lack of public infrastructure also warrant the low densities. Suburban Residential - 1 (SR-1) To provide low to medium density single family residential uses reflecting the Suburban Residential-2 (SR-2) availability of public infrastructure. Urban Residential- 1 (UR-1) To provide medium density single family residential uses where public Urban Residential --2 (UR-2) infrastructure is available. Urban Residential - 3 (UR-3) To conserve, maintain and encourage single family and two-family residential uses. Urban Residential -4 (UR 4) To accommodate a mix of-single, two-family and multi-family residential uses. Urban Residential -4A (UR-4A) Urban Residential -5 (UR 5) To accommodate multi-family residential development at moderately high densities and to encourage a mixture of housing types. Urban Residential-6 (UR-6) To accommodate the development of mobile home parks. Urban Residential -7 (UR 7) To accommodate the development of affordable housing units in two-family residential dwellings. NEIGHBORHOOD COMPLEMENTARY USE-1 (NCUD-1) To accommodate primarily single family and two family residential NEIGHBORHOOD COMPLEMENTARY USE-2 development with some select and limited non-residential uses where (NCUD-2) appropriate. Non-residential uses are intended to provide sales and services NEIGHBORHOOD COMPLEMENTARY USE-3 within walking distance of surrounding residential areas. (NCUD-3) To accommodate development of neo-traditional neighborhoods with primarily TRANSECT-4 URBAN NEIGHBORHOOD(T-4) residential uses incorporating a mix of unit types and small-scale commercial uses where appropriate. vi.0 2.0: Base Zoning Districts - Page 1 ao q O /1 #1/nelimeAif II • • f 3 CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS MARK TORPEY,Chair PLANNING BOARD JAMIN TOTING.Vice-Chair it �•` '° f. CLIFFORD VAN WAGNER 1 e. k i ❑ ROBERT F. BRISTOL : ' + ' • City Hall -474 Broadway JANET CASEY '4.o 9,y Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 RUTH HORTON RPORd1LD ` Tel: 518-587-3550 fax: 518-580-9480 TODD FABOZZI www.saratoga-springs.org AMY RYAN,Alternate City of Saratoga Springs Conservation Area and No Cut Buffer Planning Board Policy Adopted by the City of Saratoga Springs Planning Board on July 19, 2018 The City of Saratoga Springs places a strong prioritization on the balance of development with protection of the City's open spaces and natural areas. Designated conservation areas serve an important role within the City as a means for natural resource protection, preservation of open space,wildlife habitat,stormwater management, ensuring consistent natural community character,aesthetic beautification as well as buffering among properties and land uses within the City.The City's Urban Forestry Master Plan (2013) notes the benefits of trees, in particular improved air quality,stormwater benefits,and aesthetic/commercial value, equating each tree with a notable assessed value of benefits per year. The City's Comprehensive Plan (2015) notes a primary goal is "to encourage quality development that can be clearly balanced with the preservation, protection, and enhancement of open space. In fact, economic growth and open spaces are interdependent and there is compelling evidence that the presence of ample and accessible public open space increases community property values and contributes to economic growth." The Planning Board provides strong support for the roles that wetlands,waterways, and designated protective buffers play in terms of natural resource protection, stormwater management, flood prevention, and community environmental health and aesthetics. The Board strongly discourages physical alteration, temporary disturbance, or permanent structures being constructed within such identified areas that may include ACOE or DEC jurisdictional wetlands, DEC wetland 100 foot buffer areas, City-designated watercourse and other special protection or preservation districts.