Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20250896 116 East Ave Area Varaince Supplemental Information and ComparablesA B C D EF G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ADDRESS LOT SIZE FOOTPRINT % 116 EAST AVE 5,000 SF (.114 AC)1,098 SF 21.96% A. 41 PINEWOOD AVE 4,791 SF (.11 AC)980 SF +/-20.45% +/- B. 36 PINEWOOD AVE 7,404 SF (.17 AC)1,428 SF +/-19.28% +/- C. 16 LEFFERTS ST 5,227 SF (.12 AC)1,416 SF +/-27.09% +/- D. 18 PINEWOOD AVE 6,098 SF (.14 AC)1,644 SF +/-26.95% +/- E. 7 PINEWOOD AVE 4,791 SF (.11 AC)1,306 SF +/-27.25% +/- F. 39 PINEWOOD AVE 4,791 SF (.11 AC)1,076 SF +/-22.45% +/- G. 161 EAST AVE 4,791 SF (.11 AC)1,064 SF +/-22.20% +/- FOOTPRINT COMPARISON TABLE (UR-2) ADDRESS SIDE SETBACK (8' -0" min.)CORNER SIDE SETBACK (10' -0" min.) 116 EAST AVE 4' -10"6' -2" 1. 132 EAST AVE 8' -0" +/-7' -10" +/- 2. 134 EAST AVE 4' -0" +/-9' -0" +/- 3. 150 EAST AVE 3' -0" +/-1' -0" +/- 4. 152 EAST AVE 6' -0" +/-8' -0" +/- 5. 45 PINEWOOD AVE 5' -0" +/-N/A 6. 41 PINEWOOD AVE 3' -0" +/-N/A 7. 36 PINEWOOD AVE 6' -0" +/-7' -0" +/- SETBACK COMPARISON TABLE (UR-2) Scale Project number Date Drawn by Checked by Halfmoon, New York Phone: 518.429.8093 email: kbuff@kpbarchitecture.com Client: Project: NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION As indicated 11 / 4 / 2 0 2 5 1 : 0 9 : 2 7 P M Z-102 FOOTPRINT COMPARISON DIAGRAM 2025.27 116 EAST AVE. SARATOGA SPRINGS 09.10.2025 KPB KPB MASSIE RESIDENCE No. Description Date 1" = 60'-0"1 NEIGHBORHOOD DIAGRAM 116 ZBA Zoning Appeals The neighborhood is composed of single family homes, largely built in the 1920s, 30s, and 40s. The neighborhood is primarily a UR 2 zone. Houses are on undersized lots that cause rear, interior, and corner side setback requirements. I aim to illustrate that the variances we are requesting are in accordance with the majority of properties in the neighborhood. Map 1 - Property Line Overview of Neighborhood Map 2 - Address and Property Lines of Neighborhood Key Points ● Table 1: 62 of 69 lots (90%) in the neighborhood do not conform to UR-2 zoning minimum lot width requirements ● Table 2: 38 of 69 houses (55%) in the neighborhood have a setback violation (rear, interior, or corner side). ● Table 3: 11 of 16 corner lot houses (69%) in the neighborhood have a corner side setback violation. On average these corner properties have a setback of 6.36’ instead of 10’ zoning requirement ● Table 4: 16 of 16 corner lot houses (100%) in the neighborhood have a setback violation (rear, interior, and/or corner side). Table 1 - UR 2 Lot Requirements Analysis Street Address Frontage Violation? (60') 116 East Ave YES - 50 118 East Ave YES - 50 120 East Ave YES- 50 122 East Ave YES- 50 124 East Ave YES- 50 126 East Ave YES- 50 128 East Ave YES- 50 130 East Ave YES- 50 132 East Ave YES- 50 134 East Ave YES- 52 136 East Ave YES- 52 138 East Ave YES- 52 140 East Ave YES- 52 142 East Ave YES- 52 144 East Ave YES- 52 146 East Ave YES- 52 148 East Ave YES- 52 150 East Ave YES- 52 152 East Ave YES- 49.5 154 East Ave YES- 53 156 East Ave YES- 53 158 East Ave YES- 53 160 East Ave YES- 53 162 East Ave YES- 53 164 East Ave NO- 79.50 47 Pinewood YES- 50 45 Pinewood YES- 50 43 Pinewood YES- 50 41 Pinewood YES- 50 39 Pinewood YES- 50 37 Pinewood YES- 50 35 Pinewood NO - 75 15 Lefferts NO - 60 16 Lefferts YES- 52 29 Pinewood YES- 52 27 Pinewood YES- 52 25 Pinewood YES- 52 23 Pinewood YES- 52 21 Pinewood YES- 52 19 Pinewood YES- 52 17 Pinewood YES- 52 15 Pinewood YES- 52 13 Pinewood YES- 50 11 Pinewood YES- 50 9 Pinewood YES- 50 7 Pinewood YES- 50 5 Pinewood YES- 50 3 Pinewood YES- 50 1 Pinewood YES- 50 52 Pinewood YES- 50 50 Pinewood YES- 50 48 Pinewood YES- 50 46 Pinewood YES- 50 44 Pinewood YES- 50 42 Pinewood YES- 50 40 Pinewood YES- 50 38 Pinewood YES- 50 36 Pinewood YES- 50 34 Pinewood YES- 52 32 Pinewood YES- 52 28 Pinewood NO- 104 24 Pinewood YES- 52 22 Pinewood YES- 52 20 Pinewood NO- 94 18 Pinewood NO- 62 12 Pinewood NO- 90 8 Pinewood YES- 50 6 Pinewood YES- 50 2 Pinewood YES- 50 TOTAL UR-2 LOT VIOLATIONS 62 TOTAL HOUSES 69 90% Table 2 - Neighborhood houses with setback violation (interior, rear, corner side) Street Address Interior Setback Violation (8')? Corner Side Setback Violation (10')? Rear Setback Violation (25')? 116 East Ave YES 128 East Ave YES 130 East Ave YES 132 East Ave YES 134 East Ave YES YES 138 East Ave YES 142 East Ave YES 148 East Ave YES 150 East Ave YES YES 152 East Ave YES YES 164 East Ave YES 47 Pinewood YES 45 Pinewood YES 43 Pinewood YES 41 Pinewood YES 15 Lefferts YES YES 16 Lefferts YES YES 29 Pinewood YES 27 Pinewood YES 23 Pinewood YES 21 Pinewood YES 19 Pinewood YES 15 Pinewood YES YES 13 Pinewood YES 9 Pinewood YES 7 Pinewood YES 52 Pinewood YES YES 50 Pinewood YES 48 Pinewood YES 46 Pinewood YES 44 Pinewood YES 42 Pinewood YES 36 Pinewood YES 34 Pinewood YES YES 18 Pinewood YES 8 Pinewood YES 6 Pinewood YES YES 2 Pinewood YES TOTAL SETBACK VIOLATIONS 38 TOTAL HOUSES 69 55% of houses have setback violations Table 3 - Neighborhood corner lots with corner side setback violations Street Address Corner Side Setback Violation (10')? Corner Lots Distance from Sidewalk (10')? Corner Side Setback Violation 132 East Ave YES 8' 2' 134 East Ave YES 9' 1' 150 East Ave YES 1' 9' 152 East Ave YES 8' 2' 47 Pinewood YES 7' 6" 2' 6" 16 Lefferts YES 6' 4' 15 Pinewood YES 8' 2' 52 Pinewood YES 6' 4' 36 Pinewood YES 7' 3' 18 Pinewood YES 7' 6" 2' 6" 6 Pinewood YES 2' 8' Total feet 70' 40' Total Corner Side Setback Violations 11 Total Corner Lots 16 69% of corner lots have corner sideback violations Average corner side violation per properties 3.63' Average distance from house to sidewalk per property 6.36' instead of 10' zoning requirement Table 4 - Neighborhood corner lots with a setback violation (interior, rear, or corner side) Street Address Interior Setback Violation (8')? Corner Side Setback Violation and Distance from Sidewalk (10')? Corner Side Setback Violation Rear Setback Violation (25')? 132 East Ave YES - 8' 2' 134 East Ave YES YES - 9' 1' 150 East Ave YES YES - 1' 9' 152 East Ave YES YES - 8' 2' 47 Pinewood YES - 7' 6" 2' 6" 15 Lefferts YES 16 Lefferts YES - 6' 4' YES 15 Pinewood YES YES - 8' 2' 13 Pinewood YES 52 Pinewood YES YES - 6' 4' 36 Pinewood YES - 7' 3' 34 Pinewood YES 18 Pinewood YES - 7' 6" 2' 6" 12 Pinewood YES 8 Pinewood YES 6 Pinewood YES YES - 2' 8' TOTAL CORNER VIOLATIONS 16 TOTAL CORNER LOTS 16 100% of corner lots have some setback violations Table 5 - Visual Evidence 132 East Ave ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 8’ to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform to 10’ zoning requirement 134 East Ave ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 9” to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform to 10’ zoning requirement 150 East Ave ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 1” to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform 10’ zoning requirement 152 East Ave ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 8” to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform 10’ zoning requirement ● Note: My neighbor ran off yelling at a delivery van for running a stop sign and didn’t take a picture of me measuring 36 Pinewood ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 7” to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform to 10’ zoning requirement 16 Lefferts ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 6’ to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform 10’ zoning requirement 15 Pinewood ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 8’ to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform 10’ zoning requirement 18 Pinewood ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 7’ 6” to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform 10’ zoning requirement 2 Pinewood ● Corner side setback violation ● The structure measures 2’ to the sidewalk. Doesn’t conform 10’ zoning requirement 41 Pinewood ● Interior setback violation ● The structure measures 3’ to the property line. Doesn’t conform 8’ zoning requirement ● Currently adding on in rear - no ZBA hearing required 45 Pinewood ● Interior setback violation ● The structure measures 5’ to the property line. Doesn’t conform 8’ zoning requirement ● Owners went through ZBA process to add on rear living space that’s visible in second photo Table 6 - Interior setback violations Note: I did not go and measure for privacy concerns but are all under the 8’ minimum required by zoning regulations Address Interior Setback Issue Visual Evidence 128 East 130 East 7 and 9 Pinewood Ave 21 Pinewood Note - Driveway on left of house is on 19 Pinewood property 23 Pinewood Note - Driveway on left of house is on 21 Pinewood property 27 Pinewood