HomeMy WebLinkAbout20230378 Washington Land Disturbance Public Comment (50)Outlook
Fw: Concerns Regarding Land Disturbance Behind 27 Outlook
From Susan Barden <Susan.Barden@saratoga-springs.org>
Date Wed 1/8/2025 3:27 PM
To Julia Destino <Julia.Destino@saratoga-springs.org>
From: Eliza Bianco <eliza.whipple@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, January 8, 2025 10:02 AM
To: Susan Barden <Susan.Barden@saratoga-springs.org>
Subject: Concerns Regarding Land Disturbance Behind 27 Outlook
CAUTION: This email originated outside of the City network. Please contact IT Support if you need assistance
determining if it's a threat before opening attachments or clicking any links.
Dear Susan,
I sent a letter via the online form but it doesn't allow for a large enough word count so I'm sending you
the full letter here.
I am writing to express my concerns regarding the Washington Street Land Disturbance Activity,
specifically as it relates to the proposed swale and its potential impact on the large oak tree located on
my property line. I appreciate the opportunity to provide input on this project and would like to
emphasize the importance of thoughtful consideration for the existing natural landscape.
My primary concern is the survival of the oak tree on my property, which is in close proximity to the
massive pine tree currently marked to be saved. Based on information provided by an arborist who
recently visited the property, no earth-moving or deep digging should occur within 12 feet of the tree's
canopy. Given these parameters, I struggle to see how both trees can survive long-term with a swale
dug between them. The proximity of such earth disturbance to these significant trees poses a serious
threat to their health and longevity.
To address this issue, I respectfully request that the city provide a certified arborist to evaluate the
situation and offer guidance on preserving the health of both trees. Additionally, I would like to
understand what specific plans or safeguards are in place to ensure these trees' well-being. Without
proper assurances and protective measures, the risk to the oak tree is unacceptably high.
Beyond the immediate concern for the trees, I have also reviewed the proposed tree buffer plan and
have reservations. While I appreciate the effort to replant and restore some of the natural barrier, I am
concerned about the reduced density and the visual impact. It is unfortunate that this project is taking
place during the winter, as the full extent of the buffer's current effectiveness is not evident. During the
spring, summer, and fall, the woods provide a dense, natural screen that significantly blocks the view
of the unsightly buildings on West Avenue. Replacing this density with a thinner buffer, regardless of
tree variety, will inevitably alter the landscape and diminish the current level of visual privacy and
aesthetic.
Additionally, I am curious about the strategy behind selecting different tree varieties for the buffer
behind each house. Was this choice made for ecological reasons, aesthetic diversity, or another
1/9/25, 2:42 PM Mail - Julia Destino - Outlook
https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADI5NDIzZGRiLTQwNjEtNGM1MS05ZmQxLTUyZTNkMzFiZDJiZQAQAA03Q%2BWf2Q1Mswn0vhz3…1/2
purpose? Understanding the rationale might help residents like myself better appreciate the long-term
vision for this plan.
In summary, I urge the city to:
1. Provide a certified arborist to evaluate the proposed swale's impact on my oak tree and
the adjacent pine tree.
2. Clearly outline the measures in place to ensure the health and survival of these trees
during and after construction.
3. Clearly outline the swale location, size and location relative to my property line.
4. Reassess the tree buffer plan to address concerns about density and visual impact, and
provide further insight into the strategy behind the tree selection.
Thank you for your time and consideration. I trust that the Planning Department will take these
concerns seriously and will continue to work with residents to find solutions that balance development
needs with the preservation of our natural environment. I look forward to your response.
Sincerely,
Eliza Bianco
27 Outlook Ave.
--
Eliza Whipple Bianco
518-339-6698
eliza.whipple@gmail.com
@whipradish
1/9/25, 2:42 PM Mail - Julia Destino - Outlook
https://outlook.office365.com/mail/inbox/id/AAQkADI5NDIzZGRiLTQwNjEtNGM1MS05ZmQxLTUyZTNkMzFiZDJiZQAQAA03Q%2BWf2Q1Mswn0vhz3…2/2