Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
20230378 Washington St. and West Ave. Land Disturbance Activity Permi Tree Survey Memo
December 3, 2024 Tree Survey and Clearing Analysis W M Memorial, Inc. 239 Washington Avenue City of Saratoga Springs, Saratoga County, New York LaBella Project No. 2230803 LaBella Associates, D.P.C. (LaBella), on behalf of W M Memorial, Inc (aka Mr. David Mohr) conducted a tree survey and subsequent clearing analysis for the property at 239 Washington Avenue. The tree survey was conducted in those areas north of the existing Mohr Service Center on October 14 and October 15, 2024 by LaBella Wetland/Environmental Scientists. Data was collected using sub-meter units including tree location, identifier, common name, tree size (diameter at breast height (dbh) in inches), and notes. Attached with this submission are the following figures: 1. Figure 1: Showing screen shot of tree survey from November 14, 2024 meeting 2. Figure 2: Amended tree survey map is provided as Figure 2 3. Figure 3: two maps (Figure 3 whole site and Figure 3A focused on area of disturbance) of significant deciduous and coniferous trees as required bythe UDO.To assist in understanding screening concerns, it also shows coniferous trees equal to or larger than 12 inches dbh. At the November 14, 2024 Planning Board meeting, LaBella provided the Figure 1 map from the October 14-15, 2024 tree survey to the City Planner that showed all trees on the site, not just those the UDO determines are significant. As discussed at the last Planning Board meeting, the tree survey for the site needed to more clearly show the categories of trees based on the requirements of the UDO rather than all trees. The amended tree survey and accompanying table now uses the UDO categories to demonstrate the "significant" trees on site. Based on the UDO, "significant" trees consist of deciduous trees with a 12" dbh or greater, and coniferous trees with a 24" dbh or greater. The changes between the maps that are provided (Figures 2 and 3)with this submission versus Figure 1 (previously provided) are due to differences in categories used to group trees by dbh. Per the Land Disturbance Activity Permit (Section 13.7(C)(2)), the removal of trees over 4"in diameter are not reviewed, thus the amended map now shows trees over 4" dbh (i.e., not including 4" dbh or less). In addition, deciduous trees equal to or greater than 12 inches dbh and coniferous trees equal to or greater than 24 inches dbh are considered significant trees and are differentiated this way. Figure 3 focuses on larger trees, and so includes the significant deciduous, the significant coniferous, and the coniferous trees equal to or larger than 12 inches dbh. The requested information pertaining to clearing and tree cutting for trees equal or larger than 12 inches dbh is shown on both the Civil Site Plan and the Figure 3 maps. This includes a) "significant" deciduous trees (greater than or equal to 12 inches dbh); b)significant coniferous trees (greater than or equal to 24 inches dbh) and c) coniferous trees equal to or larger than 12 inches dbh (herein referred to as "large conifers"). The large conifers were included to address concerns about visual screening. In response to the Board's suggestion to limit the initial area of disturbance to only the area necessary to fill the wetlands, we are proposing to divide the land disturbance activity into two phases. Phase 1 will involve tree clearing and disturbance to that area necessary to fill the wetlands and grading related to stormwater drainage, leaving many of the significant trees intact for visual screening. Phase 2 encompasses soil disturbance and tree cutting at the time there is a plan for future development. Civil 1 Site Plan Figures C140 and C141 show phase 1 and phase 2 areas. These same areas are shown in Figu re 3 of th is su bm itta I, with phase 2 shown with a I ight ora nge hatch. Of the 213 "significant" trees onsite (186 deciduous, 27 coniferous) 66 are located within the Limits of Disturbance ("LOD") and 147 are located outside the LOD. There are also 16 large conifers inside the LOD and 57 outside of the LOD. In 2024 as part of the proposed phase 1 work, a total of 22 "significant" trees (1 significant conifer>_24 dbh and 21 significant deciduous trees >_12 inches dbh) are proposed to be cut inside the LOD. In addition 3 large conifers greater or equal to 12 inches dbh but less than 24 inches dbh will be cut. However, 57 trees equal or greater than 12 inches dbh in the phase 2 areas (or protected within the LOD) will be retained within the LOD (4 significant conifers, 40 significant deciduous and 13 large conifers). Figure 3, C140 and C141 all depict the location of the cut and retained significant trees and other conifers greater than or equal to 12 inches dbh. Outside of the LOD, 147 significant trees (22 conifers and 125 deciduous) and 57 large conifers (204 total matu re trees) wi I I be reta i n ed. In summary, within the LOD, this phase of the project proposes to retain 57 trees (or 68%) of the 82 trees that are equal to or larger than 12 inches dbh. On the whole site, phase 1 of the project proposes to retain 261 trees (or 91%) of the 286 trees equal or larger than 12 inches dbh. To address concerns of the Planning Board and neighbors about the removal of trees, the Applicant and LaBella looked for groups of large trees along the edge of the eastern and western property boundaries that could be retained in 2024 to screen the property while still addressing the Applicant's proposal to: a) fill the 0.45 acre isolated Wetland 1; b) provide a drainage swale to convey flow to the outlet at Outlook Avenue; and c) maintain the center portion of the property until a site plan was developed. The grading contours were developed and used to identify those trees within the 2024 Clearing Disturbance Limit. Areas in the northeast and southwest corner of the Limits of Disturbance will be retained in 2024 to provide screening until a there is a future development plan. Finally, the engineering plans illustrate an area of arborvitae tree planting buffer (see Plan C140), which will provide additional screening for the neighbors on the eastern border. Trees closer to observers have a better a bi I ity to screen views that those trees i n the d ista nce, given the a ngle of the I i ne of sight of the viewer from the ground. Sincerely, LaBella Associates i Barbara Beall, PWS, LEED�AP Sr. Professional Wetland�cientist 2 00 - � , . , t a mNotes: . �, ��� , f •�- � f �• 'w � r 'A"'�,� '� ` .5 � � ' `t, ! .1�`• l��1 � 1.Tree Surve conducted b LaBella on October 14& � �.` _� '�;`�_ �`��` � ' .* �" � � � v y � ��'`� ,..�. , �,�,,. . "*�. , :. . ��►��� "*'=` , -�. �. �> 15,2024. -- -�• � . . y� . � � � � � �• . i w 0 ,� �.'t` r ,, r, �����+T•�� ...� w *���r �_.`l � t�� r^ � .� : . '� i ' � '�` - '`, � . � . J -'_�� „�. ��� . � �� , �� �.i. ��A. �� � ti � �� � � y,r� .� ` � .� � . . � , . �. . � . _ .� . .� -� ��. . - �, r r��I � � - h � t ���T `w�L . �1:'��'�� ,a,�, , �'� . �ir� .-� . _ � � , _ � �f- .� + 1 ,�,� � ��• „ � , �' � •� �r � �'�" _ � � .- 4. � i r . . � . • � �. . � a . . , ��� _ o : _�� �a, . ..�,,,�,�' �" . � �- .,� ,i�- �� � n.�- . � � � '� '- '�' � . r . A _. •� �� � J� ' � � �` � F �; �f,�'. � r� ., _ .. �- :, �1.M� p �� : � r� : . � - , � �, . ,� David Moh r � { �� i R M f ������,•�. .;�. �� � .e R 't' ' � . R , _ � 11��� ' • �. � +�i� { � *-�� 9 �+��� ��'�'' � ' �' �/�� � � .�•{i is[ � 'y.�_ . _. �, ' . � . 1.i . � ��� � L�'' QR{ i� � '� � � � . , , '� ,' • • � ` • � / + � � �� �'�.1_�..� ��� �• r, f � �'� �. ��_� � �• , .� �« r/ j ��� � �� a � � � � ����• � .L . �� - , � � -- 1 �{►., �'-.'� tt�� .� •� -t'� � ' i ,; -s � � ��� � � �� � � �� �,.� � ����=s� .� �,; �R � . .,� � �;. .�: � � � ,�� ; . �. � � - .�. .� �; �: � _ �..� - Tree Su rvey r *� 4• �.rl._3� .` �r=�.�E F_,•'+r�'��i�. ,��� �'� s. 3� t.'' (� 'r`, . i � , ;�n �,* .,y 1 `� f► �`. �y _° �� r , ! , � �.�� �� ��_ -- � - . Y �.. •T �y J .. . � .�,� -� �y � �. � � i . 4 . ` , , '+rP-�'"�Y'��#` r . y� �� i r . . ,���t �. � .�_ .. ��-'�; ; , _- , �` ���*;� , �•�p . t � _ �, s_�-� ,, , ,,I�.�+'�, ` ;, ; ��•,. ` � °• � 'c„�+ : ,. ' � ' ' - . • � � -=�` � - �'^.4 � _ _ ��,+� � �- '` �' ,� '� _�e" �, - �••i 4 '� . � �,� r, � - -"0 7" f- �3+ k .� �., , Y.. , -• _j w �� � • ��.-,,. #�_ + ,��' y , �. � ,� l � ,, � �� , .7 � r ���! � •� - 239 Wash i n gto n Ave �*�•• ��'�~�' �f'.•�'•��►�.• - � • = 4 � ► . � 1 � � ` /' �r- ��•,�,5 � - �-. � f��� ' � ���� ��_ _' � � ' # T �� �r ; a �,, �� • �' � � `i� _: ���``' �� ,�R+" ,I ,�t��.�� - .$ 'l � ■ �- � . . _ � --�� � � ` - ' �.:'��° •� � Sa rato a S ri n s. NY Station►-n , �. � . � �;, � �� ,�-_ � �, . g p g _�- .. . - , '� i�,. �j .��,� '�I _�. r , `+�,5 i � � -y' '/'��i"� �' � • '�a ^ �� � 1�■ . � •�� � �r, � `.'�� '�` ,���• `���""s ,� , �r � ��" `� � �1 ' � + � �_ '� �' � _ f ;�--r� � j' ` r+�►� .� +�i� � �+; �. �k„ N w�, •�;+' � "�. "�`� ' � , � f; �� _ . - ; .�• -� ��'I:, ,�� � .' 1� � ' , � .- � � �-' , , � � ' --- • ' - ��" � ° �� � O ' -, �. - �- �� N � � . � �w '. �: •• ►. � � U =� � ��{ �� .. .�,_�s� " ' ' t:�_ : � � ,,. ' �, -� ci � -�''•' (p ��> O � . � � �� ,•! ' }•= � � � �� • ,�'t - . .'�' . - • '.. .. : �`�-' z�-'```- = i{ � ��.S r� � e x,. � r , 1 _ '.� . �` �`� •'� � r ��-'� ♦ ��"r';� .�. i � ' � � � � T - 1 �.. ��� T�.-r � i � M1 , '���� � -` . �`��\e����~� ��� � � � � - `� •� O � � r , ��� - O II .�- _� �{� . .. . ' i � ! � �� t ��� �' ,I�.�'' O � - �� � � � Y_ Ms �Y• � ! ► ��� 1i (� �_�� ( �•� ���'t p ,-q�,,'�. .y '�, i�, . , �,'�`t: • , - _ _1/�1 " �� ���{� `� � � �� : � - � `- __.._� rw � � )" �-'��' ' "+ , { � I �• /�� ,,���-/\ �_J �J � � �r �� � � "� � (v C� �'\�_J� �M � � , � ��� �"�t�,yt��`_� �� �i.... -a� *���'���:• �J� � �V\ � � � O� -� '` �' y p �� � �� �_ - 1 ` ��>_ � ��,��•: ;f' ���= j .f .;: ',. '� �M ��x r i� � C�``lJ �(�l � _, � � . `� ` t ���� 0 100 200 Feet J ��- �`4 �, a. � . F Z ' � • �� \-/ C� }1 .+ .� � ' � � ��� .i . �F' (� � � � '�' � -_ "� ' � �` , � � • ' � � O_ J � ' - . ' � � , .� � � � = J ti ;� � 1��',,� 1 y . • ��tl� � � . •�'�-� '',: . c . ;�� '1���� ���� ���' �C���� -� : '_ `" , �,� �� * . ���'� �,�"- � .� • - 1 i nc h=200 feet � . ; � �• . �� " ' � '� � - . �---- -. �f"�' ., � ��. ,,'� � . . �'�!` C� ;'�',;�, �� � Z . . ., , . . , R �� �t �-i �.� t ' .�. y � ..,.� , � �"� :,�� -, �p , . ` t ,. • ` . , . • � �Y- ' � . � � -� T �' s' ,.'' : >�� � :.x� � . ;,. :.��.�:.�� �. ::, �-_ �- . . . n st '� . >, t� � s :• . � > � � p '„ � �� '� �"� ` .. W �� . � _ ` �VIS�� � `"` � �� ,- ,+_ � . .,. , .�� p ��-� � � � . �� � o . Le end (� ��'�. �,, '. � ' "'�_ �'� '� "��.�' � �"=� � �'� �""'� � � � � � - • � ' ;. Y � � 'M _�� �- •� -•• , �. =�r �� :�a.'� �� �,��� ;•:���=, � � u 1 ��> > ,, , :, Stud`/Area � �,'�"�, �.• : ,�.r�' �• � � . " C��� �J�' �_ ,- - 4 - � �' < , �� � � J' ~ TT � � ", -� r' � � O • . • � � � ,�,.. s i �� �. 'ir'�' � � � '� 4. O 0 �{ �„ . �. ~ , .��-�#�`���-��: ��• �. � ��t�� o � � �� �" -� � ---� � ��� �` Limits of Disturbance � .� ,. ,� t � ,,,� . �. � : .- . _�A� � , _� o -��r i - f � f+j,i.. , y� � ti � k� � s t �-.` �. �j�"� �r,` ���{��b - ��, � -- � '` � . � _ . '� ' - �. i'� �� ... `�!� i��'.�t'� ! •• � �- r �O ��� r,. � .'�� r„ ,r•.. rw O �� �� � t Tree D B H 4 to 8 � -i „,,. • #1 ., .� .�, ;�• �r 1 t� • , � - --� � � � , �„ � , . _ . � �', � . ;,4 �� .. 1'�,. �,���,,r �,�� ,J�,� r � .�- � • � � � � •, '`� . �1 // ,R .r i� .� �'�.1�' � i +z_7�,' f�� 'y�. � t _ �� O � !��'Y�rt1� r�� _ ' .. � . #. � �, �` �.�� , � ,.� -, �, � � ` < , - ..�- =f � . A � o Tree DBH >8" to 12„ z � t'�� , ' �r;� �` � � � � .-- . �, �r � �� .� �� - ..s�" �� � + � � 1� � r,�� " ��# ., I � � �� � �'. ", f" .+lh,�� • 1 '-� • ''• � �` ` � ° ��� � " '`� ' � " � � � Tree D B H >12" ~ � •������ .� � `'�e° � "� �.�' _� f w ,7i �3��- . r��aF" � 9�,r�,,�S' s � � �ti�.� ,, `�� � � �� � .. ' � - ���r� �_ � �• � � r F ♦, ,. . .��1" � - �--, �. a -� - __ � ' � . , ,��`` , ---�-�.. _.� �' • �'�• 'r r� �..t � � ,� .� �'''"� _ � �i�► �� � l� .r��i� ... � ., 1 , � ��� M �- ,� �� � . �� " �,. o� Road w , � , _ x�.. ,*�,,' � � -� � � � - � r �' _ �'�' � 1 �T 1 � .%�� � � . , , . ;�� �. r�,, �D � "�� ' � ° � ' -- � ,` , ; � , �,y� ' �.�- �{``��` %O� ����I �'•� -�`- , '- � � - . c�n w . � � , r�` s r. - � " � l ` �``_-' 1 � ' ,� �4� r. O � `` � r.� '� • -� �.� � ��� �l� G �. � � +� �' w � '� ' •? ' l. � � ,�'_i � _ : • CJ/ � � I '� � ' , � � � '� �!.";� : _;1�1 ;;�. !.�i �'� '" �' ,,,� - � ` . . -� .� � / •� . * ' v �� ,1� ! ,� � '� o (� � , ��. .�E �'��r' �t I � �„S �� . � _ � � ■� � '! • r ' �" �� �� t �� �_i� -- . • r s,.� � N C . _.. . ,� �� � �- - . 1 �"� � *.��+ �''��,� _� - .. �'��� . ., , !t�S t �,, _• ...'� _r ,��►• � , C � R� � ' � , ° �•�� .� J r' . � � 1- � �� � .t � �'...1' � � ��� � � � � -� � a� ri � j +.. - � ♦ . - - ���,�.���`', ' I _ � � � _ �l � ...�� '�_'5,,�,- �� .�� . � l J1 i � j� J�r � . {' � .� , �i � �� j , � U !g�'1 � �, �v � .. � � _ ��; * � ` ;'+� R� }� � i ; � -. � I \� ( � � ^�, - �, �• . � �. a� �.. ► �� . .�.� � �- � �� �� U C� ., ��,• � ,� a � , ` •, �"�_,� '` . � � , � J ' � �� �� ��n r���� ."e, ° ' ' ' :� ' '� t,.+r- � •� -�r. �- !P.. � ', r - .- " - �i � . � � � I' ►' 1f / _., �, . - `,� _ ; L~ '' `� � �O C� , � �h , - � �, � -+ �� .� � ,r . . '�''��-'- � _ . . � � y- . � � � . .� .. � ,� -� ��, .� - . � �. �� � � ..��-�� �- a.) . . � ,�.4 � �"►+ " , ' ...•. - .� _ � s 'r - � ,.,. . • � � ,�. '� � �# , � �• �• '� * •,"�!"y" ;,� �I, �• ¢ . •.,. .,► , � � � S � 4' '� r`��l. _ r r �'��� .• . ` � �1 . � �.� � 'r ��• � �� � y; 3 _ � � 1� � I � � �-�4+*�,` , , � � � �' .> , �„ .-�, ,. ,��. � �... �+�: ' � '� � �. � _ r� , , ,.. � . " • a .+,.; '" � `4 w ".� • ; - r�`" - ' � , '� ' -' `- ���?� '��',� ��`�` � , � _ , - � • �,`' 1 � � ` ' ^ -� '� _ , �, ' ,�� �•y� _ ,-� � f� � „` # ��i.�+:� � � 'f � '�#'��' � � +�� � � - _ - - � � � � �� _� � _ �- 1 � �.r�- � (� � � � �, �'� . -"� .�j � 'i�� �, � '_ � � �' --- � _ ' � �'- � ^_" � 3 .�,�,�'�",� .� '�''' ��� � Ili�l,l },�' � cU� - ; � "�" ,,, " ..��; �� - � '' ' � - � � �,, � ' +' ' . / �F� � i Y •� � � -•► �' , � � � . � .� ,�.� �� � �`' � �1'�� _t F �ar• � r '� « _ p+r' , � � � ,. ._ � � •� R a .� � •• � � � ��� ..a. -� ,�,,,� _ �, _�r��� � �`�, . � � °R:.. �� .:, _.� 1� ,� �+� _ � t#► � � r�� � � '' - ���'s� -�;. =, � � '�''�� �' 'lt.,,,�r- f . •.. � . . e -.-. -�'""'29 `,�-- +� _� • ( .. � • � �. . �-. '��� . _ �.�� - Hwy � .� �' _ o , �• .� .. .. � , � . _ tate .� � �O _ ,�'"�� _ � _ .+�;�;�:. w s _ , - So u rces: � � l � � � �'� �, �� ��' ' ` �' �'-'rt0 St -' � � .�3�`�.► �`�,*.� � ` y,`•?'� # -�"�� 1.Stud Area:Created b LaBella usin information � ��. � _ _ - � - � • r � Wash►ng� �''�`�w �=�: _ ..,� W � , � . ��.� v y g u, �► � .,. ! �• � - - �_+�� ' � ''` _ � ', �- ,��,�:t�, provided by the client. � � , ' � `� � ; -'r ; � � ~ ' � '� � � 'g � �_. � " . �' .�� � .'�'�'�`" � ' ?,�!.�•� ' -� ��'�'�'�; �� �� 2.Basemap:Esri,Di italGloce,GeoE e,Earthstar, � �� �, ,"a'�' �-� >� . � _ �� �; � ''i �' ' ,-L ��, ,� �ry ;�, _ . � , g Y � � f. , , � ° - 1,� � , ,��,,, ! � _. _,�,.�`�"�. � �- 1 =� � �,�,� � . •�� -��"f,.�k , . . � � ��`,. . ►- _r Geographics,CNES/Airbus DS,USDA,USGS __---� • - � �' � � - � � � � '� �a ' � � � �'"�_' '�•„ ; - � ,�' �! AeroGRID,IGN,and GIS User Community,2021. N . .._ ' �! �- ..� � �' . , �..,�� , . � �,� �� � � i. , � . �+ � `Y "�. 'a'� u��` 1 ��' � 4 * � �••. ._ ! � , � i* , (1� �P!• �'� � �,8 ' /'�A� � �� -� '�, ; ���y 4. ' � ' �� � � I � '1 � •� �,, �t�� �`- � �• ' � r,,�� - �.� „ • ; ° `T ! •, � '_ • ��� ._ � . 00 `' �' . 'i • " . � ' _w� �� �+ 0 � , -, �,�+ •� � � � �' � :1 A � � � •�1. •r . - _ � ,.+ � � � w � � r � � �r1 fe� � � , � - ���"�� ���,''��� '�• •� -�� �i � 1 . T �. ♦ � ,a -. t �r (� .�� � ,� � � '~�� �'�e � N1 �-- -�► ���'r -�� ,� � � ."` : �� t-+� � ..j�.� • �' � ,,►',� � ;�; if Y#� i« �'' u � � � N i•� _ , � /� �- i � �. ,{ �,� � � ��, �,!=.f,,•��r,� :�,` � .��� � _.;� , ?,� / 'i,.,�� ►r � • + �.• � , � . . � . • . � � - � "vr � - � ... .�'�„ ` i�i.� ,� �� �- - .� N .._ . ,. .�- 4 � '�� � L�� +l.�� �r j � �� � �.� �r1 �,�.+„ / � �.,� �- r ��, � , � � Q ' -- � ,.�• - L: ° � ! . . ~ ti', ��' �s . .1 . �. N = ,. � .� . � , . �: r � . �[ Tree Survey Map � � � i � �� . . �, � , . � i► - ,. .,1 p � 4 ,��.,' y � ,� � � r - a. . , " ��1�.� ��' .� `k, � � ' � ' . "k � o �_ s � _� I ��r �� � �•' - t �'R��r '�' � .�,r. � �+�'�T�E��Q r r ���� .♦ : • ► _ . ' - � . � � �. 1 � , f i � 1 1 � � � �l . • , .� R � �•tz��� ,t �, • � . „ •� ( / -� � ,�� _ - - � ,� . � . . � - .�� , ..� � includes 4 treesl � ; ti'_ _ , � ` • �---�__ � . ':.� • , L -,�'` \ / �, � , � . � ti * a � - ' � _ r +,� � �e� � . ' -r, ' - , ir:� I (� ► _ �► W. � �'- i � 's-. , -. , � � � .1�� F.w� �. � • C P' �-•,� � �� �,; � � �� .�; � , ' • � i ` a • . _�_� .� t Char1e'- :�•� - � S � "� e � � . � 1 � 5 ,�� , r� _- - � J � � �� �r " • . ' � '�' , '�` a�y�"'' � �., --� . . `w i �.�• � �l � � � � .+' , ' - � � . � }'I .� �_ --�� � , ,w,' �� •�1d �= F I G U R E 1 p� � 7 �' . � � ' („� , r�_� � - ' - '��' `'� C� -��"�-` � � � - � .� �� �R •�}„ � . II �. s'`' . �(` '""_ �� � I Q- � .-� -.- � . ��'�, -' � `" � ' N � .. - � {� � .. � • . - � � ;�. - �� � �� '- �.�'�. ` � I ,� I ,,� �.,, . . � �, � _ , � o . . . , u� October 24, 2024 .�"� . �, ,4 �i •- , fi pn �� ' ��1 y , �� �� �_ . , �=��'� � • I • '�r _ • �r • ,� � i � -»�' �# ,� � !�'� ,� . . � .. . -,-�� _ :�� -� � �f � - '� � � j' � ' , ��.. 7' �, .; � � � ' � -- - �. LaBella Project No:2230803 � . - _ � • _ . cey �'•.� - � x - Date:October 2024 m Notes: f �''�_ ' `'�- _ - � _� . �' r � ` S ���. , . , , � 1.Tree Surve conducted b LaBella on October 14& � � ��'�`�' �' � � t + '� �"� � � � , �, y y .� , o +� • � -�� ,� �" '* "� ~ • � �� 15,2024. � � ,� � '� _ _. `� � �r ' � � N � � •. +� , r _ � � � � � . tA .� ,a -"�'► ��r +� � , � J -'� t � O : J ' ; �� � '!' � � �i . � • 2 � , . � �, � � �i `-' .rr.� u� �► ' � � «�r� � L . � � � � � '� � � r� . +� _ ,.; -.�,..�� �, �� � � _ _ � , � � � � David Moh r �� ' ``�'� � � �� �« � � � � ` putlook Ave � ' �`� r _� � � , � ``�. � ' � _�► _�, _ '� � � '� � � � � ' ' , . � ��` � �..� �, :��► �"°� .�" .',� � - � �� ,� �, t - Tree Su rvey • ��5� � � � � ~ •� � � � i ; - ��'S R`��' . R , _ a � _ �� � � . � s � i rs.'��� ��: � � �� � . * �� � � � '� .� � .. �, � � �� �, 1 ; � j � �w� �� �/-� ■ ! �'�'� � ., � - � � � :'�'"` -• � � 239 Wash i n to n Ave , ,� "'* ► • , ' � � - ,� � �. g � � �l � ' ���- ` � � "� Sarato a S rin s. NY � � .� g p g v. . . � � �a�Ii�'�u_�...��► � � s - �#- � a +�• �� � ' � ' - ��� �� �� � • • - �--�- -- ' ,--�l� . _ .-�• . �i- � �r � � _.. _ --��-- 7 -xti � - . 1 �. h �e �� - , �' . ! '-�• 1 � � �,_ � � - _ -- .��ti----rt----��----�� { � � �� ���� --�--7� --�- �� � -�---�� ( � i ,� �/ � � . -- � ---- � � � •. . � . �• -----,��~� j, U U U U . �# , � _ � _ \--� U �'-`' .���. ---�-_���~�J � U � � � � -- • � - � , ----� C� U U � � ' � � - � -�---�,.----�----�� � � U U� U U , � , -�-i � � , J ��j J �J �J �t J ��j �. � � , � �J - �J �J cJ�--@�� � �-� (���c-, �� -�J (J �` � �, � � � ; U �� U UU U a � �� . o •,� . � _ �J �-��J c� c� • •� ��� �� � � � 9 0 50 100 Feet � • ��. �(�cJ �J -_ �J �J �Jc��`�-�(J�J cJ J l� � ��J � �� � I I I P: . , � �J ��J - �J cJ � �� cJ ���,. N � � - _ 1 i nc h=100 feet r , c� � - `�. cJ - �J cJ < <J � �J �,J_ �J� �� �Jc� ��^cJ cJ � �L''� ' � r . �� ��,� :�, � �� , �J �J <<�J c� � cJ �� `J (��J c-��J�-��� {� �� � , � �� '�p � -- U-_ `> � U �� « �r/� � � Z � ����� � �� Le end c� ���_ `�= �� �J `� �J �J �^� ��� ,� g J _ � � � `�' `J � �J �J� `J �J �v�J �J`J �-`J �� �� `��� ����- '�� OStudy Area � cJ _�J <<� �J�`� _ cJ�-� cJ `)�J - _ cJ U �^ � �� .�.,�+-. �J - ��J E-a cJ ��- �J U �J -- � c� __ „-�s - �, � t+.r� Phase 1 Limit of Disturbance '. � �J ����J _ <<J �� '� �J c i�j �- c�j �� cJ c�j�-��) <<� �� �J - r. i � � � cJ ��t�-� �� J U�� ����J - � �U � � `"� t �[.'" ��� - �- � _- _-- �1 _ U - - - � J - -� - � , �_:� �• �� � �-���� �`� �� J�J��`��J��.�� �� _<<� �-�' �`� �J�JJ � �`��J <<� �J�J �-� ��� J , — ti . a se 2 I rYl It O I St U r a n ce � `� � � � � � ��� � �, -� Retained Areas 2024 � � � � � � ; � - � � � -�� �� � � z �-'�- � c� - _-cJ -c J �J _ _ �� _ �`� �J � � 4� ���,�i � _ J �- J c�J �JcJ �`, _ ��j �� � cJ ��J �� � , H �� - �J�J � _,- ���> ��.,�' i w `) _ cJ _c��`) cJ c� - kJ �' �`> ti� �J U`"��,� c;� `� Tr@@S _U' � � � � � � Q � �J �J J��cJ��J �J)�- �J cJ �J' . .� , i�`� _ -1 ���iJ � �� � �n����_y;� w # � �4�� t� V�� m � � ( � ,�J ��-i) ' . _ , �.. �J � py���� ��:�� � � � � � C �) �, � \ / c (/�\ � �� U U - '��� �������s.a rn r�r`�-� - ��� �1i� �' O /Q 11 L O \��11 �j � U � ��f�r � � - - +� C) U � �-- " �J -(� * �+i 1�,� '�,�� � . • , l ��� � � ', - • � � o �-• ,� �J�� �� �-� �J _ �J�� ;�,�,�,,....� ��`�� � f � >_12" Significant Deciduous � � � �� .������-��- � � J ��J (�, ��J�� �' � •b � � :��� _• �"� � t�A s � _ � �� < �� � �J J , , �� 12 to 24 Coniferous � ��� �`��� � � ~ � �� �� °� ��` -� - � - � � ' � - � � � • >_24 Si nificant Coniferous � _. UU �����U U ���'� '� � �� � � �� . �- � � g � �J - _U _ �, � � � � �► ,O �J � - � • -� �� � � ti� , � � �` �� � � , � , �_ � �ti � � . �,� ��, �� Road � � �J J _c"� , . +�"�` '�� � �+ � �" -�".'��. � � � � � o r � � l��J �J�J � � .�� � �� ' � • � � a J_ � �._.. � r ■ � � '� �� � � � � � �J ��J�� � . r � ,. �-- � � ��� • � � � �1� .�`�. (J (i� U ��� (-- ^ w �( �_'�`r ,�+ � � w � � � � � � � c�n < <����<<��^ r �J � _ ,# � � � ��' � U � ' i � r � � ; � � � � � � � �. � � �:� U -i�� �_.�� � �� �. '� U U << �� � _ i � _� � � '� c� �J � t - � � o � --�`J �`J�� �``�� �, � �`� ,� - � , � ' � ' �'� �J `J � ��=--'� . � � � ' / � _ �� � '� � �M� . -_ � � Q � (J �J (J���J : � ���'�} - � � � � � � . � � �� o � � � _ � �` ; , w Sources: � , J �J � - ' ' _ 1.Study Area:Created by LaBella using information � �R `� ' + �� � �� 2r Basemapt Esr II DigitalGloce,GeoEye,Earthstar, � - . m , • � � � �� �, Geographics,CNES/Airbus DS,USDA,USGS - �. ' - � AeroGRID,IGN,and GIS User Community,2021. cv + � . �`' � , < . •� � Y � ` tti! �, ' �� �► , � t � _ ;..,"_` i, i{ ,+, � �� � ,� � � 1 � a � � � � N WeSt q�e � �� �, - � � �. ' R• ; � � -. N �- _ � . �. � . t � , � � ae ,,� � ti � ••� �� r i , ► !� ,� ,� . � + ' � y � ! �,�.� � �, `� �,,f, .• - ."".�' , �n A • '•i _�� �� . � � �'1 •..�, ; . • � � � ��•- 1� ` -•1k ' ` � �. , ,� a� �, � � -�.��.�. -,. : . ��;� . .; ..�.� 3 _ �, _ . .. � - �� �: � � , ,; j � ����, �.�, . Tree Su rvey Ma p . , '"''� . �- � � , ,�, i -+�� . 't f + . «� ' � ,/� .r c � '" `�,! - � . � ' � . • •• `• �' . � • � I� � ` j s J �_--�. � � 7. � �.T� ' • ! � �..,�-_ i ,���, . .. ���� �, . - � . �. - +�. �;. . ;�.�.. _� � _ ��-- ��=- -�� ��--;�� ` � (without 4" treesl � , � --. . _ .� �• , t i` � . • , '�''� . . \ / .� � r . . . �� _ � � "�'` Z . . � �. + .„ '+� �, ` _ • ,r � . _.,�._.. � � ���a � � . �� . � - , t t. ' �� � • � L` , � � � � r • _ • � � �fi^' �"'�`�,I �1� + •� � #� .���•�� � ,� �� •r _ ��� ` _� .�s,� ` �, _ ` �� ' � ,K. � • ��� . j, � ~ ` � ` _ `. . � � � � � , � 1..� / ��,�h ,► � ., �. • , �� •L i" ' ,�•,s, � '�s ' � •. t ' � .��- �♦ - +r ;• r 'R �_ ` �` � �.��� �� -- • �.. , � � a ytiO .r �� `� �` �1 �,� ' • ��! � � ► � � M � ` �� �M• � •� 1 , � _� •1�'t �' a . •+I����� � � � � .��� t . FI G U R E 2 m � `i• � r . . . �• � ��1► . • , � • ti �"�„ � •��, °, � � / .t� � • - . � - �s . � � .-.. ?�• ����.. , O 'r ♦ ,..� ` ' � �r'� � - ' ��� � �� ..� - * �' t ' - • ' ti -�''; `. - � � �ti� ��� `�,Z,. ��� w� � .��r e �� � ` � 'e . ,� � '� !� �� � ��f+�+ � '. t 1� , ��.���.� � - * � , � ..� � • , .. ' .�•, . , • , -�� •j� . . # December 2, 2024 � , � ' '�. . *+► �• � -• `�.,, •�j.• �_ . .. ,♦ -- '�,�-�•�►� � m 7 ' . � ♦� � ` � S ` r i.�' - ��� • ' �+ •1 � A:, y - '`,��� �� � � i^r �r � •� �.J"�'� � � t _ � � • T f� � � � �� _ _ s _ , �- �.��pr r f _�• * ' :- . � _ � �► �� LaBella Project No:2230803 � � ' Date:October 2024 op �. ___._ .. , � �_ . . , � m f'� .-rt � Notes: `'�►�-t : � F � - * ' � ; � �� � 1.Tree Survey conducted by LaBella on October 14& . � � • t � �'�,� �� � � a� 'y '� � 1! � •�- "�� �� 15,2024. . , � '� ,� . . , , +�T + �+�,,�i�,_ ' � ' ,�►� � � � � r � .+ ! • * � ' � � � � � , ,� • + � 1 a� �rl. � � � � � . � .f ►�. ' -�,�4 �;` � ' � � . +� _ � �,� . ,. .,..,. . � � a �, �� ,, ,, �:, :,�, ,� -� "�. . ...,.� . � � - . � ! � � � � � � � �- i . � _- - -.�- � � , . � ,. o � rr� - . '' � �!. . � � - • + s David Moh r .:,,� �� � � � � . } � . __ �. . _. �. _ . - . � � ,� ;� � �t,,,� ..r.� v � � �,�„ -��"' � �,� ; � �� _ ` � "r; •�r!1 N � � , , -.- , � . ' � � - _ � , 1 � _ ~ -�'. •� � , � , � . � .. � � .� �_ ,, • � , ., � _ � �.� Tree SurveV . . . 7 w, � , i' i I� i ♦ / � � � � � � � , � I � � � �� � + "� �� • • � �� �' ��� �� � � � I {. s � �i 1I � � i�. -- . ' � y �. . • ..I[- . + � J . `y.��_ i� .., , r � � �" � 'w rr�. � ��.:,,,���� � � � � r � �� ' . 1� �. � , � � � , _ _ _.. . � � �-�% � ; ; ' � . � 239 Wash i n gto n Ave � '�'`� . � � '� . � � - . �• � � � , • _ �• .•. . . � � � .i� - � ��. • .�, � � . Sarato a S rin s. NY � s a � �.��:,,�. � ;�� � � ' ' , � .._,� g p g ,�� � "'`��' i,�.��. � , � � �' � t� � •_� _ . « . � i �' ��� �� ; L l�� +� � ,� '�_� � � � • i � w, J _ •!��' ' _ - - �' � � � . 1 ' M � � i� � � ..- • � � �'� z `��� - �`y -. , � • f� � � � � ` _ � - ■ ■i ■ �L_ ■_ li ■ ■i ■ ■i � ■i ■ ■i � ■i ■ ��� � .,f• ■� �� - • . �___ ■ �L-�_. W � Y . � � �/ . O � � . �' � ��'� � � r� ' r'-1 = O � O O I � 1 r• , `� � � O � O � t�� � • � � ' -�`- �� "� 0 � � � �� � � �� '� - � 0 50 100 Feet �� �`''"'• � _ � �- � ���� �� � � . O � .�� - '1 " e �- ' , _ � � � x � � w �.� ; (� O � � �` ,�� �� . � -� 1 i nc h=100 feet � O C-?''�! � •��..m f y�-•�,4.�'� , �r � , ,�,�� � 1 � � � _� � � � � —� , '�'�: � 0 �� � � � _ M,, � � '� � �. . ; � � � O � s. . , ��-�• _ . +r� � ; , �� Legend C'� � O O � N �_ O . �0 � � i �"'�'��� � � �I �� � ' �`� � � -• ' OStudy Area � O � . . . � �_ �� �a . Q � � � � � � � � � Phase 1 Limit of Disturbance � o � � c� � • 4 � • Phase 2 Limit of Disturbance � o � � .�-�� - _ � � � � • � o00 � � z �''`, _ � � � � � ' �„ �, Retained Areas 2024 � . �i� . .� w � • w � � O � O� �` +�r � ❑ Trees To Be Protected � O O � � � w � � � � --�� � � ` � � � � � Trees To Be Cut m � O _ . � _ �.. � � � � O � � � , w � � ,� �'��`,;��7� � � '"�.� ���« Trees � � OJ � ��, � w � . �_ - . �----�---� . � _ '�Ir �` �r ' , � >_12" Significant Deciduous � 0 ' � w � , � � � . � 00 � �- �.�' , � �. � � � ` � -��� ��'� � � 12 to <24 Coniferous � � . . . _ ,� �_ . � O '�� •-" � � � � _..., _ � >_24" Si nificant Coniferous � , � � � +�- -� .� . � t g � � � '� � � » . 1" � ' . �� j �� � ,��__ . • . . . � — � � , . .-*�� � , �' � , . �� � �, � � � � � - � � , � � , � o �. o ., � �� � � _ � � { � � �' � • • � �� O f?f.:.. O - �.. 1 � � �� � , - ,�, � �� � , , i �_ � ' � � �.� � �i # .> , .�, .� ,�. , � ` � w , . .�• -- t�i�,i:��#� .�� ± • r'"� i c/!� i�� - �'� �� � . � � t�A � ' � F , I r /' � � _ .�+�.a �� � � "�'' � ` � �• +� � � ; �� � � � rt.���.-- � r , � ••• „. �� � "�_� � � � � _ - � � ' � � ' — -�'�'-- O � _ � � � � � ; o � �r �r c �' (: � �r��� � �r t � � � �' � � • �* > � E� � a � � � . o � � '� � . ,. + , � ,� Sou rces: � ' '•�*- � s� � ' - ' �,_ � � �._� 1.Study Area:Created by LaBella using information - . . u ` � �� �`� �� �� �' ' provided by the client. `� 2.Basemap:Esri,DigitalGloce,GeoEye,Earthstar, � Geographics,CNES/Airbus DS,USDA,USGS m ' ' - N . M � + ��-� ��♦_ � f ����� �, �� AeroGRID,IGN,and GIS User Community,2021. c� �. . ._,F-�#�� � �s �'�► �"� `�'� , . - � ,��, o�o - * � . j � ' ��� �� � , `� ,,,�► •. "� � �, _ � � '��•�'� � 4 �, �, � � �" � �.' {,,,,� '•� ' �. � !�, - t �"�` � .� � `"M l� � r� �- • 4 �i�-- y� 4 , �''� � �, r f ---� �t. .�� �•= • , �` , � . � r N •� + �• • __ � �� 1�• '�. a. �'.'� ��j '�`•,�'�` � � * , . �. � , .�/•` ' ,Is� � r � � � �.� ��.t�� •.� �, - � +.► 'r—� � � • � � � « � �,� � � +� ' _ *` � �1 � � p i � +� � � T '' ��ti ' �j "'� .�/� • • ��, � ` � . . . � , ��, s . � ; ; ;..-.- - � �y � �,�- r� ��; � �i --� . *- � -- .�� �,�� -sj'r�_,-�� .�.- *� �r. . . �� Sign ifica nt Tree . ,� . . � _, . • . ,* �_� , . "�`j , �..�.� 1 � '! � ' , # `. '''` F � � p •�� � �. �i.I��. I 1 � �� • • `, y � � s �� r . �� � �� � ■ � . ,� _�� . � -�� , ,� �.�� ��- . �., . ,;� ., �...�. . _ � .�� , r . �, ... , � � _ ~-� . . � � Locations � -�,�•.�t ..- _�' l ,� ,�� •� �� • � ., •i�"�� .� � , _. ., � _ � - . , - , ► ,�, �• � �+ -« � � � - - � .� � � � ,`.Q �.r � � . - •+..�_ ,, . , �,- ,�. - � `� � . , . � •O t i �� .' � � �� I' . � �' " • • � � .. ♦ � � � � � � � �,' 1� � /•••�� y .� � , � , i �f � � � � �� `• a ,�f- �� • �� � � � � �� �� t � � �� o ' • � � � j ` _ !►�s'�'�-?r.� ;. � � __� � .'-�.�+ . . '� i . � -�,.. . ,, ,� .-��`. .r.,.�1, � � � J �. ��``, �1'.� '� . - � • r.' .1 _ � �''�'��►� �" ��• •. �•� ' I� '� , ` - a t + �r• ,�,'`� �� � �'r� •� •� r �4 � � � � i � � � � � t� F I G U R E 3 m 7}� ! : �•�. � • y '� s� e� � �, •�� �►�- � 1► , +`�, � • � i '� � � � . � O .�� '!� -� .�. � v , �. � � � � + . �'''"� j.• . �„� , . . � � �, ,� 1 :,� ..fiK..� ��,� � _ � �:�. -� ��.� �' . '- �• � ����� , '' . - , 1 {- � �, �• December 2 2024 s r !�A � •� � _ • � . . �� ti' � • • • ' 7_ •. � � r �y � . � m . �r �� �' , � a_ �� � � t w � ; � � � �� � �t� . a ~ _I����r,�r�j �1•►. .'_ _�i��, �,/'� � �� � i �:�s~ ~ s� ' � ' � � ♦ , +,,� � `�+ � �� � � � � � � {� � - �� � i -� - �" LaBella Pro�ect No:2230803 � � � � � � Date:October 2024 m � w • �► ' m Notes: R ' � �, i►- _� � � � 1.Tree Survey conducted by LaBella on October 14& " � �� 15,2024. _ - + a.� - . - = � � � � � � � ♦ J � � � ' ` L �� � � � ' � � . � -� David Mohr �' ` - • ' �„�■�- � � } � � ' i � � Tree Su rvey . � � � � , � � � � 239 Washington Ave . � , � • , , 1 •r� Saratoga Springs. NY �� ;, . � _. � . �.,� � - � . � � - _ - - � ..... � � . . . .�_—r__■- -�--■- -'---r�— r — � T � u � �j - _.� ! � � � rLl � � s � O � ' � , � � � O O � � '� � � � � � '� 0 25 50 Feet � � O � ,� : .. � O i i i �' � � 1 i nc h=50 feet �' � � � � � . s � � , � o � o � � � � � � � � L n e e d � �► �" g �: O � � �!� �� O � • ,,,, � � � !�' OStudy Area � O � � � �, �,�.- �� Phase 1 Limit of Disturbance .3 � _ �, . . _ O � O �'. �-°� � � � � Phase 2 Limit of Disturbance i � : . �- �r,: �� � z O g = - - • . Retained Areas 2024 w O �.� �. . - � �` w O , l �. � '` � } Trees To Be Protected � � � �� �� � _ �i' �'�"� ► �t � m O � ��� � � " � Trees To Be Cut C Y " � — � C O O w � �� � s -� ,�, _ � Trees U % �� * , � r • � � � y � >_12" Significant Deciduous � {� � � � � `�� � 12 to <24 Coniferous � � � � � f � . >_24" Si nificant Coniferous � � • g � o � � � o � � � � � ; � o ��,� , � �' o � � � � � .i o LL � �'` O � U�; � . �s� � ��,; ` � � � r � � � � o o � �� � o � � . , � � � � , - � ° � o � � � � _ _ � i � � � � _ � � —. _ a,.�,:-''f� � � � � _ _� � � � � � Sou rces: +i� � � �m , � �� � 1.Study Area:Created by LaBella using information n �O provided by the client. � ■■�■r��■�■■a o■r■■■■■�■■�■�■■■�■■�■■■■■�■■�■■■■■�■■�■■ ■■ ■■ ■i��r■r��O■■.r■fi iilr�t�r r r r li➢�r r■r��.r...�. ...■. ..� � � � 2.Basemap:Esri,Digita l G loce,Geo Eye,Eart hstar, rn _ -�� � a � Geographics,CNES/Airbus DS,USDA,USGS N - � � ., AeroGRID,IGN,and GIS User Community,2021. ' - � c� � � - �►� � o • � � o � "� __ �� i - - � c� + � + N � � i % � � � � �� . . � � - � - '�`� �� � ` � �' Si n ifica nt Tree � � - - g � �- � � �, ' � - Locations � � � � . �o � � - � �. �--� Q � � � - � . � FIGURE 3A m � � � o � �; - +�,� . � -., . • � ' { �r T� �; ` - ��-� � � T� g �.: � . Decem ber 2, 2024 m � � � ; ,� 1 �� �' � � LaBella Project No:2230803 a Date:October 2024