HomeMy WebLinkAbout20230992 140 Grand Demo & Construction Presentation Window Damage6. Window Failures and Misalignment
The evaluation of the property at 140 Grand Ave has revealed significant issues with the
replacement vinyl windows that compromise both the aesthetic and structural integrity of the
building. This detailed analysis focuses on the specific failures and misalignments identified:
Style Inconsistency:The replacement vinyl windows are not vertically aligned and do not
reflect the Greek Revival style of the building, detracting from its historical aesthetic. This
inconsistency is a concern for preserving the architectural integrity and heritage of the property.
Installation Flaws:The windows exhibit multiple installation flaws that compromise their
functionality and the building's structural integrity. These flaws include:
●Visible Water Damage:Indications of water infiltration around the windows suggest that
the installation does not provide a sufficient barrier against moisture, leading to potential
damage to surrounding materials.
●Compromised Window Framing:The framing around the windows lacks essential
structural components, such as headers, jacks, kings, and cripples. The absence of
these critical elements undermines the stability and load-bearing capacity of the framing
around the windows and the walls in general.
●Improper Bearing of Point Loads:Particularly on the first-floor windows, there is an
improper bearing of point loads on the window frames. This improper load distribution
can lead to structural weaknesses and increases the risk of damage under stress.
The window-related issues at 140 Grand Ave, including the aesthetic discrepancies from its
Greek Revival style, compromised framing, visible water damage, and improper load
distribution, highlight severe structural and aesthetic flaws. These problems underscore the
impracticality of restoring the windows to a state that both respects the historical integrity of the
building and ensures its structural safety. Given the extent of the damage and the significant
concerns raised, these issues further support the case for the building's demolition. Addressing
these window concerns is crucial, not to attempt preservation under these conditions, but to
make way for new development that can safely and respectfully utilize the site.