Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
20230393 Slate Roof Replacement NOD
i`����"� 5, Tamie Ehin er, Chair �`` � CITY OF $ARATOGA SPRINGS Rob DuBoff, liice Chair . ; � �� �� � Chris Bennett `" ..;:;',-.. A ; '1_ DESIGN REVIEW BOARD Leslie DiCarlo r r ' � ��� Jeff Gritsavage � � Tad Roemer � City Hall -474 Broadway Ellen Sheehan _ �` .� . Saratoga Springs, New York I 2866 Karen Cavocca,Alrernare ��`��rF��Aj�U ��1� Te1:518-587-3550x.2517 www.saratoga-s p ri ngs.o rg NOTICE OF DECISION In the matter of the application #20230393 Slate Roof Replacement 39 5t" Avenue Saratoga Springs, New York I 2866 involving Historic Review of a slate roof replacement with EcoStar synthetic slate within the Urban Residential-I District, tax parcel #I 66.62-I-I 6 within the City of Saratoga Springs. In accordance with 6 NYCRR Part 617, the Design Review Board classifies this request as a SEQR: 0 Type II action — exempt from further SEQR review And, in accordance with the objectives, standards and guidelines contained in the Unified Development Ordinance Article 240-I 3.9 Historic Review Applicability and Approval Standards, the Design Review Board issues the following decision on August 2, 2023: 0 Deny for the following reasons: The proposed material is not an in-kind replacement The synthetic material is not historically a�propriate The monolithic color of the EcoStar material Record of vote: motion to approve made by T. Roemer, seconded by R. DuBoff: passed 7-0 In fa�or: T. Ehinger, R. DuBoff, C. Bennett,J. Gritsavage, T. Roemer, E. Sheehan, K. Ca�otta Absent: L. DiCarlo As a result of this decision,the applicant: 0 may not proceed with the project as proposed Please contact the Building Department to verify permit requirements. / � September I, 2023 Chair Received by Accounts cc: Building Department Accounts Dept. Applicant/Agent Page I of I fFOR o��icE usEl **HAIVDWI�ITTE�J APPLICATIC�NS WILL NC3T BE ACCEPTEQ�`� ,;�`�;����,-�� �-����- ����� ITY F A[�AT A P I�.I N ��+pplication#} • � : � ,. � � '� � ��i � .�.��J � �� ��� � � � ��, �. C3ESI�fi� �EVI�W CC�MMISSI��f .�"� ,• ��` �-_ =- -„ -- , �r:f�� �,�1 •�' CITY HALL-4�4 BR�AaWAY ��ate rec��v�d} � � 'Y� '�`�'r#`��r�`,� � SARATt]UA SPR�I�C�S NEW Y(J�RK 128+5�-2�95 a°�r�__.�,I��:,.�'�.N � �������, �- ���`�' TEL: 518-587-355�Xz533 o�,���� www.sara�oga-sprr`r��s.or� �Projec�Title} APP`�.I�ATI�3N F�R� ARC H IT�CTL�RAL I H ISTC�RIG �►EVI EIN 5taf#Re�iew APPLICAI�T�'S� C3WI�JER�S�} (If,not a pfr��nt� AI�Q�NEY��GE�T ���.,� Julia Van Hall �4ddress�'� �th A�enue Sarataga Spri�gs �Y 1�8�� Phone 51� �323403 1 1 I Email ��I����abel a�aol.cvrr� [dentify primary conta�t persvn: ❑■ Appli�ant ❑■ C]wner~ � AttvrneylAgent �An appli�ant m�ust b�the prapert}r vwner, lessee, vr�ne witl� an vpt�on to I�ease vr purchase th� property in c�uestion. Applicant's interest in prer�ises: Q� �Dwner � Lessee � Under vptivn tv lea��vr purchas� PRC]PER�Y"INF�RMATIC7N Pro e A�ddresslLocatian: 39 �th A��r�ue Saratoga Springs, hJY 1�8�� Ta�c Parc�l #: . - - P �'Y �for example: 1�55 52—4—37} aate Ac uired b �wner: M�y� ���� q Y �Current Zoning Distri�t: Prc�perty us�: ❑ Residential 0 frlon-��sid��rtiallmixed-us� �"ype af�e�iew: ❑ �4►rthitecturaN ��] Histflr�c � Extensionlmvdificativn �+�f current apprv�al} Surrimary d�scription vf propas�� actio�n: We had a�ery bad �eak�ver�he winter, repaired it. We hawe another lea�k and wvuld like to r�-r�o�. Look alike slate ar�d c�pper par� standing s for me�al secti�n. "rrery simi[ar ta the Armory 1 military mus�eum dawnt�awn ac�ass from firehaus�„ Has a previc�us application �een filed with the DRC�or this praperty? L�1 No ❑ Y�s—date�s}? -►APP. Na.�s}�' Re�ised Q�1�D21 ��� _ � ■ ' �� r -,� ���� ■ � � 'I �� � r nl. ■ � � ■ � � �� Tr__ � � ■ � - � ■ � ■� � � � �� - - I ' �� � . _ � � � � i , � � - I i�- � ��� �� � � � E ���� � � _- ■ � - �'-�� � e _ _ �, s � � � , � � � 1' - - � �� � �� � � �� '' � ��� ' r � � �. � � � � - � - - � - r��;. � � �� f � � ■ � ■ � _ ii� � - � _ �� � - � ��_ � � — , �7■ � 7r _ E., � � �� - � � ��■�� _ � ■ ��'' r,. L�,■ ��� ��� u � , _� — — — � � _ ','� _ � �� — � �' � � . ] a � �� � " ���. �, - � � - - - ; - � � ,I � � �■ - � � �� i ��` � ��� I��� . �;iF � � � ��� �� � � I � I� ri � � � � � �r ,: � - �� � � � �i- i�i � ' � �- � J a�� � �' � ��� �Iti ���� . _— � �'� '� ��ll Li�_ . ' � � � � � - _ _ � R r �� � � � � �� � , . ' � -� - _ - _ _ ��_ _ - - �� _ � :�,"'�'��� � � _- �. � _ �- ■ _- _ � � � � �� �.� � � � - - n � , o � C.,� .i � `� � � � � �J _ � �� ��_ _. �� - uu � � � - � _ � �� � - _ � �, -- -- � _ _�- � �� � � _ �.� � � � P : �� - - � - . _�� . _ - �� _ � _ - � � - __ ��. _ � �, � - � � - � .. �� �, _� j �� � � �, � ��� �� � � � _ �'� �` i�i �� w n� rn �_ I_�1 i � _ � - r _ �� � i� L � - _ = 11 ��� � P � � r � � . � � �, � � � f -� _ — � — �_. _ V.� I�� _ ��I �� �� ■ � � � _ � � � � � ■� � �- ■ � ��I.__ I� _ _ � ! _ � �i', l _u � I � �� r�Il �-fl ❑ -�i �� -- �� � - i - _ �e� � - „ ' t - �_ � u � � _ � s i � � � � � _ ��: - __ _� _ �� � � � � � ■ I -I i� a �� � � � � � � -[i ui � ' � � _. - L� . �� �� �� � - � - ` ~ , _`■ �■ � ., � � `_ � __ - , r � � I � , ■�- ■�` -� • � �_ � i -i - � �- _ � - �-c � � �'r ,� _ ' , - � � � _ A -_ i• . _ - - � ■ - � � ii �- � ��� i _ _ - �' � u ■�� �, � _ �� � i �� - � � i, � ■a 6 �P�gii �'_ - -�� �_�_ S I,1 � �� � � �II � ___ �,� �. � �,� ' _ � I'�� �� � _�� ■ � �._ � �' �,� ■ �,_,�_ 1�� t_ 'Q� ��� _ � � {,. ■ `i � � .c 1� �- - � �� i E � �. � u i� �� J � II� _ ' _i e L 7 �■ _ � � � �'�� r - ' �� - ,,����-� _' — _ _ ^� ,I� �- � - _, - _ - � � . . � � �� �'w°■ -� �I�� � '� ■�■ � � �'� �' � � � � � � , � ����' � � F � � � � � � � � � ���� � ��-_ � _ , _ - J� � ■ _c-, - .. � - - � - _ ' ¶ C ' �-�� �� � � -�� -� ■� � � � ` - � � r —_ � � � �■� � - � � �_ � � `��rl r� .- � . � � � .,�,� � � � � , � ! '" / ' !i ! • �t Wh� �h�ose �coStar? Prote�tion �3v�rvievv • Innovators in synthetic raofing sinc��g�3 • Miami Dade prc�longed and acG�l��ated�rveathe�ing�4,�0o h�aur� � �read�h af slate and s�a�e praduct affering • Jab l�t control produces u�iform roof tile�v��thering • 1Vlad�e wit�i up to 80%r�cycle�d polymer&rubber�nat tires� • Miami Dade Wind TAS1oa&TA�1���1��3A#17 12�7 1�} • Designed with up to�i"he�d��p far installation i�tegrity • U�listed Class C or A fire resistance��[JL�go� • Easy application keeps installatic�n costs dawn • UL�lass 4�high�st ratin�}hail impa�t resistance(�CJL 2�15� � �'roven products praviding superior prot��tion agains�fire, • ISa gaa1:2���Quality Mana�ement St,�ndards ic�e,snow,wind,rain and hail • �o-Year.1Viaterial Warrant� • Manufacture�d in the USA • ��-�ear Transferable Labo�r�nd Material Vl�arranty available f _ _ ..,,,- �,T " ,.�`{� , �ti§�� ' � • - - - _ � - er� '� C��, e�r'e �rn�rr��w '������- EeoStar LLC is the leadin manufacturer�of sustainable stee slc� e raafin . � , ��-� � p- p ,� _ products.A family own�d and o�erated company,EcoStar has been producing high ��.�-� � �'� � quality synthetic roaf tiles l�nger than any other company in the synthetic r�of tile �Y �„�P_� r - 4 '� ���_� ,.�:~`�.� ��,� �.- : industry and obtain�ed full ownership of th�brand in 2010.F'or more th�n 2�years, ��=-�a_ �:�: _ ', �``�- � �� . � EcoStar has b+een dedicated to protecting precio��natural resources by offering our ,-- _ �� �r ,-�. �����.�` . ` ry. '�. ' �`k discerning custom�rs produCts made with recycled polyme�and rubber. ,�; ._ �,� ,� .. �. f ^�_:�� ��� f' � ikf�, �. � ��+4��5.'.� ���� 1 r +. d �� � ;r�lj. i . T F yf � +� .iv-r, � t �; ; � �7 r y � ��:'If'Fr -�. � � � .�4,. ' ' . �°; 1 '^ - " . �'s g ".. '{"Ry;`.y a r', � �_ ,r:. r � ; � f �� s`�. ��--�-�' ,,,.. � � �a s� :� / I � � � }��' ;��e } } 1 ar i A��yy F, a � r i� �����r��r� �''�p—',y�- y : i � � �'� { '.t 5 ''p � ..�}�"�J�'!'� -f,. .. � ,`4� �'� Y,�� r� ; . '" `rt!<a�'�r f� � E �,��a . �,. ..i �'i.� } � ��,,' �f r 1�'" ;� � �� � ; � : � ,� ,� , � . � . ���, , ��� .i p W: 1 S'� � 4 i' p J�J�+`<< f :", / .�� �k' �� � � ''y �t� '! f � ��1�. � e '1 - �,i�! y p�� :5 ��`p: r ' X J,�3t'�'i '.-� {y.;. ��ua °'a � r; � �r r f�+ ° �� , f` �f �� � ��j' ,,r�j� �)(�r"°; r' s , _. ;.� - ����' + ! rf'�' .� -.re� ��r�.i �.,, ��L. r.�. ,.k ���� 2 J� �..�' E i} '� r S� . .. 4 �'. �'�r ' ,�� r� ,\_ 4 � �� �i�� �� � �,��. + �i12;�f ,�.;`�f;,?� -,.�:' , ,4 ��,,¢ �,�, �' f'' � �`�t. ro�l;;�,�'��� � �� � � �r�,` ''��.�� �����t i�� � i+"$' il'ti�y,��� ,fq� ��-: , � � }� , A ' ; � ��r �a ��� f � d' •+� f}� �7� +f r�� ;"�P w}E�.. ��A�� �.� �•r f� '� r�f'I ef�' '!���. r �'' � ' a � i � + � F x�. �i . � s � ]'�,. .TS ��y, 1� { ' y �p� ; ,; �� a r �r. d � - �+�r �� P Ma esfic SZa�e�'radi�-zana�and � �� � ���; � � � : � , , . � �, '�+ �� ���,. �`'�:'�� Chisel Poin�in 1Vlidr�igh��rc�� �F � �� � � � � ����F,��,�,�' �' � ■■■ 9 f 3� ,�r+� �` r e• e {r � +F� r�r,{� �; _J �R���L.�-!! � JT T7 77 .I� d ��I'.�' �X� ��` r 1 k� -�� ��. � x yI'%�,����� .�� �' Seneca Sha�Ce(�,g arzd Y2 � ` { i l� r ,r,.ra•r l'�+f r�#71r�,� ��' j ���}y °f`�� � �I� k`a. `��. ,�a�F+A�+r°�+��- �3•r �� �i�'es��n C`hes�r�ut Brawrt # � � �,,� } � ' ,�;, ,r '� ,f 41r� �'; � ... 1 ['° , .r� �!fy°I.���-.'y� �f!f�r � !� �a � ; ��_� �� � �t i�y�k ,� �,` � �' � � ; a �a +�t }: t � •��. };, � � � � � ;, � � ��'' �: � :� � ,� ,;� �,� � , r . ; � r � ,„��o�l' �r � d r�� � � ��- ,� € �.( '�. ' r,p J �„� r A� f b� Y � �l �f i � �u� ��`3{N� F ��.�t�` �a+1'�i. f f � �� f..�l���(� � �]. � f��� F .�� !�^_�d,r } r. ,�:. I .a",�r'�f 1(y';jr: r h J t�f_�f �' �. ��.� `++�'�.' (; � 8 . � y,�� � x 1 x � FX i r� f � ����"�/� �x J� �'� •.d�d'r�" f r�.¢ 'f������- r s. r��� �ajes�zc�S�a�-e�andam-Width �,�'�," ,�:�� „ ,� ,� �'��� �� B�end(6 ,g an�d x2 �iles)in ,} .��ac�C _... _ , , vr� - _ ��"`i ' - - — _ -;, � . -- . - - - - . _ — � -�r ���` }, � ` ti .t ' _ ��L - --�.�� �. � , � " _'— - - — __/ � . �_- -— � � '�, � i ti �. ', �, '; ,_...�/` _ __ � .� � � ��. ,. . , -. � � -� �, r� �— -- � "'t"'�,"- .,�,�_ � ..�'�� ^� :x �'t �� > � -4 �__ ` /1"- _-� .�' -- �-- - � ._ _- � - � t ; � :- - . _ ,J T - _. _ , _ _ . ��� _ ,�' L � r���� �4 �` r �� `— �, � .�� 1 � � '�. �,� `1 � � _ � • —�-- —;� � 'j -- — ..._ _�_ �': --� � •�, � '� �'� '-` '� ` . - � � -� � _ ' � �'. , y` � � '*�'`�� , . � ` ,` •'•1 1 ` - '-- - —_ '_ �`_ ' -�_ .� _� � � _ � � � `. � ',` � � , /�1 � ! � �` • t` � �. ` -_� --f.��J�� �i ~ - � `��_ �\�. i ♦ _; � 1 ,•, � � \ _ �r �- E: �� _ �l _ 9 �''. \ T :. � �.,.,,�. J � _ _,� � i •� �'• � ,� �� � . .___ � - _ 1 '�, � - �. � �� ,��— �- � .� ,� ��� ��-� . � '{ � ''.` "" -� / '�` � I . 1 � . � -- : '� -_� � 1 �` � �-� - � � �` � ��� � �' ' � '��. ` ".. _.� . �r � y� � _��• 'a _-� ���`-._ � � 1 .r �_�� . _- ,i� � ` . � � `k„ � i�.������ -- � �' �� _ "� _ ��� ��, ` � _ ^���.� .. � � � � � .r -r�' � � � ` '���• JJ . I �� �• ^' � � � - �r� _- '� . .1 ��� - + ,1" e/� � � � . . �.� ?_ �,�' � � �_ _� ! V� � ��� � �� �� wo� � r , `� .. ,+�r _-� _ '_.; _ ��,r 7r- � �� � '•�, � � ,•' `�� � ^-�` a" t �i}.... ,.. p•,,,_.._...r . 'a „�� . _ �,1!�4. �= e��ea��.r�°'"'y . �a i�::lf'.�..,: �'��-�f-�,- . .` ,, __;� _ I�ll ' II� I�llw I I�;� �ii; '�j � ��� °I � ,.,,� ���� I���� � _ -.., . .���- . � �� i � II �� __ � �� I ,,� � �� ,. � � i � � � ` i . � � ���� � � � = — ��� ,. — ��� � � _l:� _ 12"Traditinnal Tiea�er Tail Chisel Paint Beveled Ed�;e F"x 1�" �"x 19" 12"x 1�" 12"x 18" 12"x 18" 1�"x 18" 12"x 18" �152�����x 483 mm} (2Z9 rnrn x 4�3�nr�n} (305 nnxn x 483 mm} (305 n3rn x 457 mm} {3(]5 mm x 457 mm) (305 mrn x 45�mm} (305 mm x 457 mm) , �� � . . � � �, �. --�- :� � r-: y - , - -. ,�.., .... r f°" �'�+�*.. � .. .�'�= . ,�. '- �'�a_ �' � '�.� r`• � �r ��� .� -. .._ +Yln;G� �`�� -e4w� _. . _� �!$P�]i..9.-�..-,- . . . 9 Rr. �41�rN=--0� �,� ��P.�. I�1� '�� II� �l l I l l� ,�i; '. � I �� � _ ---,-- ��� Y � ._=�..y ���� ����� ���� ����� �_ _ � � f� � I 1�� I �:�.��. � . -��i�� "�T -,. - t � � � ��, � � � � d � � I � � � ' � ' I � ! ' _ �� J ,. � � . ..� . �. ..�.. ..1.� �. a �:_�__� .��,s�.r{-�� -� _ . _. _ _ .�,_ _f� � .�s 6"x 19" 9"x 19" 12"x 19" 10""I"raditianal 1 Z"Tira�itianal 10"Traditianal ]3ea��er Tail Chisel Point Seveled Edg� (152 mi�l x (229 mm x �(305 rr�m x 4f33 mm) 10"x 18" 12"x 1 S" I 0"x l 8" 12"x 1 S" 12"x 18" 12"x 1 f�'> 483 mm} 483 mm} (25�x 457 mm} (3p5�xirn x 457 xr�xi�) �(25�k x 4S7 nram) �305 rnm x�57 mm) (3D5 mm x 457 mm} (3[]5 mm x 451 mm) (CU2onir�2 7'ili�rP�rc�r�e) _�• �� � .� I �. � `� I � � 'I --- ""— ,�... -�. . R'`x �.�... �,�r . "�` ��:,:� �I I °��.,.� y- ..wr . . K.,���,; .�Lt,�-� w:w. � Y, *r�� �� v I�� i� �I� I�,I � � I�� �is � �� �i I�� i� �I� I�,I I �� ���i� � �i� `�� �:_ .=�} _ ��_ � ,�, �— � ���t ���� ��:��� �s�� � �, �all �� � �� ��I� �:�� �s�� � � ��; =�I1N .I ,;"� � ,� � ���I � , �V�. I , � � I r � f'`� - 8^'xl:Y_! 1� A','S�L'�e'r �,� ;�.� , a 1� � , ;�.� � � � �=.... r_ ...��_.-_ a���:_ _��r� ,. o ,� � � ,;, ,. �� W.. � _.. ... ;, A I . � �a � �;! � .� A I � �� � � � I � , � h� i � P � � � ' � i " � � I � � � � � t � � N� ; s� � � � �� � M � �� I � r . � � �� . � I � c _ � I� I _� i _ _ � I� � J ,.� 9 ��,�z�>, �„x 2a" iz'°x zo„ ��,x 20" ,,,���a�• i2:��zc��� - - (152 rr�m x (229 mm x (30S rnm x {152 mm x (22�1 mm x �3{}5 m�m x 5Q#�n1m} 12"x 22" 14"x 22» 508 rnm) 508 mm} 508 mm) Sf7�rnm} SU8 n�rn) (3f]5 nim x S59 mm} (3S6 irsm x S59 rilm} � � � � '�" �� ,o, �'_ # _��-� � � � �'ti �� F i �_.+l�r' ► • x'xt'7s:LA", A��- � -� � r.� • { � � -�'�y1� �� . -_ . .. r-3+� � � . . Y,�� r `,��`.... . ��� _ � � ��r . -t��-s: � I ._ �.��I � � � lyll ,`� �I'I� �lll I I �'�I. � Veii � �ei - { �... • .. ,_. . . ;s � �I � �� �� + I 1 � � � � ��I. i' 1 ,_.�,_ . , _.�. 1 � � � I I �� � � � � � . � ��, ,, � , � ; , � � , � ,. _ �. � ; � � � � � � _ _ , a � , � ii� i � � , , b"x 18" �i»x 1 S" � � , ,�. _— � _-�, � �� --. ; ' . �_� .,- , (152 mm�457man) (152 mm x��7mm} - � � 9"x 18" 9„x 1�" 7»x 22„ 8.'x ZZ„ 9"a 22" 1Q"x 22" �❑"��Z„ (178 mm x �203 snm x (229 mm x �254 mm x 459 mm} �- (�29 mm x 457 inm) (223 rnm x 457 mm} 55J mm} 559 tnrn} 559 mm) (254 inm x 559 m�n) 12"x 18" I 2"x 1$" 1 U"x 22" (305 mrn x 457 mm} [3Q5 mni x 457 mm} {2S4 mn3 x 559 mxx�} 1�"x 22" � (3fl5�nm x 55�mm) 14"x�2" �Availa�le in Majestic and Empire � � �356 min x��9 rnrn} 42 Edgewood Dri�� Holland,NY 14080 � 8�9.21Y.;Y�� ��vww.ecostarllc.com �2c�22 I�y EcoStar,I,LL.�cnSt�i•is a trae�etz��rl�nf EeoStar,LLC.P/N bc�6o22