Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20230392 Significance NOD :���i������p`�� Tamie Ehinger, Chair f+ ��' } CITY OF SARATOGA SPRI NGS Rob DuBoff Vice Chair i,�'�•. .'.M�� P� ' � _ + �. �: */ . �:,, `���` � '�. Chris Bennett � _����� � -� �f- DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION �eslie DiCarlo ,: :��� � �� ='�' � , • eff Gritsava e � � g �-., ---�,, '� .� ��� ,�� ,� , � Tad Roemer -_� ,. �� �:,�' ��, .; .�; City Hal I -474 Broadway Ellen Sheehan t f. ' ' �����"���'�� Sarato a S rin s, New York I 2866 Karen Cavotta,Alternate g P g ��`���� -, - �°��'�' Tel:5 I8-587-3550 x.25 I 7 ����,���-� www.saratoga-spri ngs.org NOTICE OF DECISION In the matter of the application #20230392 78 Church - Determination of Significance 78 Church Street Saratoga Springs, New York I 2866 involving the determination of Architectural/Historic significance of an existing commercial structure within the Neighborhood Center/T-5 District., tax parcel # I 65.5 I-I-38, within the City of Saratoga Springs. Consistent with Section I 3 of the City's Unified Development Ordinance, the Design Review Board determines on July I 9, 2023 that the structure noted: C� Do not have Architectural and/or historical significance contributing to the historic fabric and resources of the City of Saratoga Springs. Record of vote: motion to approve made by R. DuBoff, seconded by J. Gritsavage: passed 5-0 In favor: R. DuBoff, C. Bennett,J. Gritsavage, E. Sheehan, K. Cavotta Absent: T. Ehinger, L. DiCarlo, T. Roemer Au�ust 25, 2023 Chair Received by Accounts cc: Building Department Accounts Dept. Applicant/Agent Page I of I _ � � _- � f� � � o 0 �a � � N � 0 II c O ry O I I I g iO � I I� I I �= j p = II � I I � ��m II 1 1 }o V � II I I � � ��� � ❑ �a �o� � i i �� + z� �� �� � ii i i ° a�� �� � ���� � '�S J O �,I�I �� �j � �s^i� O� � �' I I�?_ � +J y I I 's'a3 o p �� fl`I` 1 � � I I � Q `.�_-- `_ I �w �� ❑ I I I I`~��r�'�"5*�e� _--_--,�'--_�_� ln q Y I I � � \'�. '` -='�z O� �� �� I I �: �n---en�a''~~��"�_,---.'�`�-__ �w (!10 ��I� ��'� I I �� „ `--_�_ aax3�naoes. ¢� �� �} � � � 1 1 '„�a.�� o �"'�_____�-.�___ ai. te V I -^= � � �2�<ti g� ��` -_- ��y '^�� �'� I I �$a I I � � n. .�'"`�.*+�A ' �� '� __-- - �o �r, a Z �I��. d �3 � I I ��`�-�m`\�\1\ �� NlYMC31YM.~y"�-�`+x�.� �" - __ .�� - �"��bJ U� � � I I , qmaf �,� -_-. -_C �z 4fl1 �� w �� I I ~� ~`---_� _ ¢O !IJ �� � ly Y � I� `'-_ 'f.�-_'�} w< � 1 F 3 �TM��~0h�`'��+�,v.�,��� �'er�lk3 `' �-LJ-_-_� r� �1 QQ O I I'�-_ _ _1 I " I I- ��- - � �„'--n �ldo9._�'�trcyo i8^n S l �-��--� �� �� �V � `and.z�` I I ��`�� # �tvada�Ha�a°u" ���; 1� _ _ _ `�`- a 6 �� Q I I � 1ti y`_�-`- ��� �Q II I I �._ �.f � � ��n� ^� m�:3 1 1 �-���'� z > � ���g I I _ $; ~���; �lyl r� � p�� �� F O Q � U Qi � ! 1 a -� �� � � �u�i� ��'� �,�� a�ai]] c'z � I I ans����\ .�g Kn�nun ov�w+'�o� w ^ t►J I�' �U N �� i i �.�p-_- _ � � �y� � �'"'�`'"`�M-+ ��� E-' a m l I! I ��/ �'--�_ _ ���5 $z s �^�����nr I I "'�/� ~~�~ `1 ��` � 1�� / � �a`�--_��:��1 �� I I i� �� �Q�a�� ., m �> � I ��� m � � � �� M� a +ro'�y�newarn n aa,u a V7 N I I � '"'°� �, `"i M I I ��f .00'05 �*MYM3a �� a � z O i�� � \ s d�3u�nm „ 'g � ; W CS r- � I I ��� o * ry �� +M ^ �, LLJ �1� �� I I �/� �8 "oo y 'K..>6.aL.9F5 lL �/ Z ro I I i�' �°a��s � �` � � ' l � i I /i _ �-- -. , f �M � � '�'1 7 N� /� `� �, + -,_�, `s'ro,�� i o � �1[ry 4,vy i i ��' ' �ry r� " �'� r� � w r1 z 4< � i ii ���'� � �� �� ��\=.so' J�$� � ¢ f�ri¢J �� � ' i � F � '��a � Z I I i�/� m Ir 1 f� � �� w n 1 � z ��f�f �I � � � ���� �'•� �•�+ 1 yr� � ��jj u�i� I I i�� �f �� f � �LL �" � I I �ri�` I' � + '!r a � �� 3�s I ��� �� f �� � rrv � o � i i �'� -_ � _ � ��< + i� � (�✓ �� i i s� �`� i �aw � z� "�1 °° � �_ � I I h�// � ��� f � 9� � . M I I e� ��i ti�, p`�¢ + f 0h o � � I � ��� i� �-� _ + u� I � �� �q i��� � � I- � r o� F= J 1 m �i ,. . ��+ ! ^ ao I I a i� �r, - �^ �� � i am �a I Y I f/ uti W %' i � � k yo � �y� /�� � �_J� I Wa + 4, .:x °p � � I I �} /�i J � _ � �w'�2 � IS o¢ wo g gp� �!i� �2=� � 1 lt �� i f�� W� W� � ��� /�� � '� + " = 1 $`da � � i O � i.i o" = 4 �� � � r� 4� 3� 1 I � 1�/f I �^ �w c.i�' i ryi 4 � �, f C #.60� Iw ` �F WJ � f _ � � �'.^.� Q J W � � �J `` + a J ��I Q�� .`f�'�' + q � � 3� �[L � � � � ¢U I I � o�W g \� � i w`W m I I g w q a'� � ' f �� i i oz° N ��~�� +� � i� a a N SI I `� �^q�y !tv�h�� , I � Ca ry ° S n ��� 1 - � w � i i �, g�� °_� ��"���� f r `s o 0o g < S � � a om 3i gxsa / r� N 6 z o oy� � 6 iw�n3nra�o�oa3 ^ ,---- .---- +^ •.' !' I „ o i z a�� I I � s�[cc� M�,fo,14�.4Zs � /f �� � s ��z I 4 W I I �� �pp'ODl � �I $ w S ' ' 4 i i _ i , s � � � i:3rv�.+va��a3 n � � r I I 1 � d j � �/ I i � � I I � � �I � I I� � w _ ��J//l c� � kA � ,� �w {�. � � � �� ��n � � ,_i,w .a 9� i I °w �� V I+r I \ I o V�. � � I�I� Q � 4 �+ O �b � �`� I I m I� p� � I O� p � I J, I� � 1 W Q y ; X � I � I ❑j �m � I I I � I o a �a �l qa � I I 'seo . - � n I I -^..� d O � �� �r � � �, � � ! �;�:�� � �, �a`� n 1 I I I n�����: Q I �o a z�� z l{ .., �x3^3naa 8'a= ��� I I! �A:zxxx� s i qT� �86'SF axn"lT�ave 1 '��W3 �� �\� I �&=--zyz § � I 'a �o 3,.96.BZ.9FN . wryxtrl�y 1 � �\ �p� m Y g � � � ry axn aa3o xoa 2 ~�:\ ,� i i � ¢ i �. w aav � � ti` ��\\� � � � p Q � . �•��p A\ I I �' a ^,q, �'.r~\L�I�\ .�-�_ . I "S �-�'6� J�'�y�} ,�F,� I � o �i _ �� � Iv� 3un,�a.aa33a � 0 •`� 3 � o .� i e� .�i i i m �� o w w 6� - •�`4 I I � -IX y � ,.ay ,1 0 $� - J� � �x_ Fl I �� m � � � _ +n � ' ' N � os ;a�� a�� ;o , � � , �g� � ' ' � �� � -- i � � �__ ,���as y� � y a � M.<O.6a.s£g ry� +n n+ �h I I � �5 I :,� "" rv M« a � o � I'„,I ,�� �� ., „ ... �r�ia�ineoi I I r� f��.. �F n n � 3!+n icoa__ �� o3w�ruv 3araoron3 I '�+ r',� x,z'cx ". _ � L----------- . ., �-s�-ss.�s�^-s �� i i� u�+ ___ ____ ___________ ____� ___-_ � *� � . z.$ O � I I` � � .['[6 I ry*Y9U O 6 0 �� �' i 1� /�a�77b .a'°.,-`� n� i i�aR � � ���� i � � WIb�+B �S � ���� Q �a J i ��-ao G �d a � �Y i rf-`� � a�� � �wa8 � ` � � 1 r � �U ��< -` �"o !� .., f J� i i m�� �, }� �u�� _ �� w � - � l V � i z a< �.�, °�o� C- � �� �� w,_ ,.r� q 4oa4 �' l � � � �o� ; � � � { ' � � j � � � I I axn ia�ura aa�a '�'`R' '�'cJ �I 1 f I y %;� L � I 1 � � F n � �� �� �� ��; � '�' i � g 1,'� � _ i i � �, % � L � ; �' � � '�n �i �i �� p o ,� � �i y � 1h g � �° i i �� � = o � ` f � � i i � � _u� �b _ �i 3 �f � i i i � � o } � �• � � a �� " i i � w � � M I � s w �i �i � A1 + y� iQ � Y 6 �z J �iJ I � � �. .�9ii {a� _ ` a l I � S ,a-se o mr _ � � I �azs --------------------arvn�oa--------- � Y.i.� - � I 1 U � e�rac eczs. a�rzc« caxc F��=yw-- �f� -----------------+_ �:, �� I I ,str�6s ! . a ^��� i � � I 3..so.ocaaN i� � n f i ¢ � i I v ¢ _ +� ��w +W � I � ,I 1 ��z M� N� ��� og 1'W T��� ���n� m �� » +'I i II �d�a .�_______�___ .��____.���. �S.___�,...__f _ g� ������ „ �•`���i j� :�f !� 1 1 „ ., ° M I �"�az � m1 ! I I 6� I �� - �' � �� �� � ! g�W � � <� =` � 1 n I �a n m �33Na�.nn nnw�n f � F �� � 1 1 � i\_/� I "' I �ir�3�3av�qois m 1 I +I � i c o +^ I I � d �wg ���'a � If II s.���nram� 6-n .9l'Y9 3,£0.6£.4LN �- _'� �m zm � �� � � � c n °�''� .' "� a� II �� �I cc�i� oz N � �� �m �� �u �u S � LLw'� r°w �� owc� _ z _ _ I I � I o� �£� '¢w a � �o ozz �� �o �q Qo I I � 1 I wa v a<n+ ao -mW �s '�'oz #x av� II � I Y �e� o=w r�� ¢� ~z �� � a �w aw I I � � ow� Qp n V �,,, moa x.c moF au ❑u � �i p'� �I I� o�o �¢""i� �„ �o ��� x� ��� ¢� wz �I� __'. I I ¢ I I g'�?� � � � a7�a go o �� oa zw� �� ow� y¢ �a I� ;z23�� 1 1 �} zk q �no u U I I �' Q� a� w`wz z� €'�o ino �o I I ��zz'c I I � °° � Q � z~ - � I I i� � � �"' w�i� j� ��� ou4i ?vai s�ss---�'TF-s�s tr I I � u�'� �a �o z 3� . 3�o g� �� p � w w CA � Foz �w � o - 4z �z II� I I I � z � m � w Jqri �oLL aN o N�� ao LL� 3, `w i.i � w N tis I I � � ,�5 `n T Q �- w x � � 4 o Q o ��o ��o zo ao I I � I�I #�$ w x � q (7 U � m w ��z ow ��n.� ou ru I I I I Z ¢ d � q w � } .c c�.¢ Nzp '6"'� o oinN �� oa �I I� 1 � � � � Z Wy , Z ' U � W aw � Y�ac�i z z�'= co �o I I � � � o � q� g? C3 �� a a'-'Q �o�aao qx � ozr � zz �I' � U d. � � � � .�r�' N _ a � y�w o �w�e� �¢ a¢ ti Z i�-. "a � w o w � raw � .3`z aa: �a � I I n' V�S g� tn I a O cfl n�,n \o o q r c�r- O q c� w��i s a o ¢ ¢w � o rc .x O p c��W 9N �O I 1�I d r� J � .. .. ���S�6s W r�;�¢o� � .�i1� �aoz �o� m z"� �`�a �< I I£�,� I � W� ���� � � � 0 Q=o N�Z ¢i...a.����� �o �«W Q�Jo �Fa p O�p � ��� mz� ❑�'�3 w w Z O z 3 a `"d �,j�¢. � II � I a I � err� cwi m m z oo� �o �fYgW�<7NW -� � m�5 ��� a ❑zrc w ¢ a in �•. w �i>a n'�'- ¢� U da a � i z x� o � c� � O b.o ��z v� p�n<n=�z �n o w r ¢ 1�1 H w ¢a0 8 i+i 3 a H O o O a�c� z 3 ��c rrca i � } �-� ¢ �o o w �i7 o C?w �' z�o sa r � aa ¢a F- I O z- o � o Q¢z Z I I I Q. r��� a � Y 4 m Y J CY ti J 1- 002 V-Z w o cu�n �U[n II -�`I � �o O m O:] ¢�m ��wOZ���= �'`''+��°`mc�aZ��zzz �w� I¢yo awcz � F � � oN�w ❑wW I I � l�-� z � t>o m ti �� ai-a�U p]��I � N.�W�m o�Fo`r��. -¢��� w a i o u�'i�na� �w< z o�' W `.,o �o I I � � 2� . Q �O�� Q oN��¢ w�� ���z�mr o LL<v.��. Y7�Q�i-�� i m �ow�z JaP � 4Uw lL o"' orc II � � LL vrir�ni ��n ���aal fnao ��aww.��qN�h om;`�[Kmaa ��w �y �o�o ryY a W o0 00 I I � I � [�m X � � � � z N �4'�Q r <vpin��Ofl?�c.��J�d (�J "vUi Jo� w <a�z fY or� orp I I �, �- z d � cn H v� � � � w F�?w F�x� �e¢ w wr o � oo� orn I I � ('} ��4 3 � w o����w�z� ¢a��� �cea�w� � �cs o�¢ a� c�u or.rn I I �.�. �� I Is NvsiaavN �� Z z w� � m :� � z����s U���d.,.z o�z�`"a z a�c.n�� p ... .. w II � � II tsaM z Qz zzZ�Qaaz�rro�a� �� � Z � a h a v� ❑ _ rv I�T� j � O Q p��� � � II � e � N II � II i i �� � � �9 � ��F---....'' . h. . : �� ���� 4'-� ��� �uf � �i ��__ ,,I, � ' � �� y ,,.� . } s� �� {�, I ' ' � � ��_' i i�' M 3 4. �" �! � M � � s� ,Y�F. �� �, , ,, , �,�° i�4� a . , � F � r� , �� � v�.' - � , . . m i ; � „� � �, � � � -�; . �� � , . _ � � � � L ` �� � I � ti } �a _ i" A �,� � k r s� �a�� ��. ��i. i _,�; m �� . . . . .. I . � u Y 'Ir1N�' ��� ` ,. .E e p r �,, .� ����� � o ��" � �- � `�r, ' �t�k i , • � E �p', .�� ��� � ��� I .o �� � � "'�'��� � ! -_ � . . "j ��fi� �' 'I ., �� :�� . �. .� �,�. � ; ��':� �. � � , � � ' 4) . . ].r � fe � f i,� . a �� .� . � u �a M. , '•�' �� � �� —.�'• f Y �f����.� . ��,�' �� . .– ' ry � I ' � '�� � �'�i,',1 — �• ;�E + � , I {' � ' ' ;�. �_�r � _ .�°� � � � �a •A �_ � . ;�s: k �� �� �� c .I��� m� �,_ _ � � � �' ��:. g� ..�t � ' � •� •� - (�,,,} � ��` *'�•. A�F`" � I t c,`�iJ' . � �g � °` _ �ii —.E—li_n ' _ �� '� � . . ..,.. � , �., 'p� y�.�' . 1 � �,�Sfy�i , "� lAI,'��.. �'P I 4� y�. r�E`. _ .� , .R . , < .. � �^e'S4 V�P'- +_ � k•� �_ � P ' #��_ `��"Ts� .., .,.__ _. '�- *�. ��-� � Wf. 5 �II I . ��., J�:• 2 O �.� �'�g ��. � a �• .�,•`�'..�. .. �,� ,' �:. ��,.F . � ��� � � �r ti� � ..�,: � , . i 4 . a �. f f`',. I �I ...k� �..,. � �.�� ��' ,�r.t� � ,�� ,�� '� �. . ,� ��. e . �:�` —�,..� i �'y� � � a��" � �" '�7�' ` k. a... . � ^�r ' �' '�•I � � � ,e_ � � B d � I I � i � � � � i� _ , � ,� � �� ;�•, °. ,�� '"1 s � e .� ' , � u . �p!_ u I ,,1 � � �•J _ , i �'. �. P � ' � � 1 ' .-_ . � �; ,h�I �� _ 4 �� f�" , :; ; � � I , � o ' d ,. �, h , � " _ ._ . :��. ; �I�I�� ` � i � �ill�ll u�� . P � � I �. L � � �..� � y ��j� ` v 1 9 f �d" ��a 1 �� ��y• �..� �L l .`� �Y' ;^I-M � � m� .�� �v � , � �I �' ��'� M 1 ' M , �' u I �! � d. I I . � � �� � � � � . .,` �� ,.��� �� � �I� . r � L�.: ,. I II � � _ , , .. 7 . � ���-9 � ::. ��, �91 , �� � `.1. I . E ` .�F, Q_�' „ ',Eg' �P �. � � �; � ,-a ,�, � �, _ .{ �, F Ee � L- � �� - '� 1 �� ,�. � � � m .�. �"� 4 y _.� � _ i �j ¢ �R ��, A�� i� d �f �i _u' � y ,+.. �r�r` .�.7�o I •. � �i i '�"'' _ `.`� � + ����'".! ' •.,+ . �;. , " '' ` y �, .;�"' �p i�A 4 �' � . � ��� 'I_� '.;. ,F. ° � �•��'��A,��"�� ..:. . , i o �y,� � ,. _� � ...'�� � a4.•�' � �• P�. i i . •�. r • �p r 'I �;; ; . '" s ` { � Y�����• # �� .�+ 'L���� � ". . � �",��L�li1� � - � _ 1