Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20230314 Significance NOD :���i������p`�� Tamie Ehinger, Chair f+ ��' } CITY OF SARATOGA SPRI NGS Rob DuBoff Vice Chair i,�'�•. .'.M�� P� ' � _ + �. �: */ . �:,, `���` � '�. Chris Bennett � _����� � -� �f- DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION �eslie DiCarlo ,: :��� � �� ='�' � , • eff Gritsava e � � g �-., ---�,, '� .� ��� ,�� ,� , � Tad Roemer -_� ,. �� �:,�' ��, .; .�; City Hal I -474 Broadway Ellen Sheehan t f. ' ' �����"���'�� Sarato a S rin s, New York I 2866 Karen Cavotta,Alternate g P g ��`���� -, - �°��'�' Tel:5 I8-587-3550 x.25 I 7 ����,���-� www.saratoga-spri ngs.org NOTICE OF DECISION In the matter of the application #20230314 I 67 Spring - Determination of Significance I 67 Spring Street Saratoga Springs, New York I 2866 involving the determination of Architectural/Historic significance for an existing rear porch for a single- family residence within the Urban Residential-3 District, tax parcel #166.61-3-14, within the City of Saratoga Springs. Consistent with Section I 3.9.J. "Demolition" of the City's Unified Development Ordinance, the Design Review Board determines on June 7, 2023 that the portion of the structure noted: C� Does not have Architectural and/or historical significance contributing to the historic fabric and resources of the City of Saratoga Springs. Record of vote: motion to approve made by T. Ehinger, seconded by J. Gritsavage: passed 5-0 In favor: T. Ehinger, R. DuBoff, L. DiCarlo,J. Gritsavage, E. Sheehan Recused: C. Bennett Absent: T. Roemer I u ne 23, 2023 Chair Received by Accounts cc: Building Department Accounts Dept. Applicant/Agent Page I of I fFOR o��icE usEl **HAI�DVIIRITTEN A�PPLI�ATIJNS WILL hI+DT BE ACCEPTED�`* ,;�`�;����,-�� �-����- ����� ITY F A[�AT A P I�.I N ��+ppli�atian#} • � : � ,. � � '� � ��i � .�.�� � �� ��� � � � ��, �. C3ESI�fi� �EVI�W CC�MMISSI��f .�"� ,• ��` �-_ =- -„ -- , �r:f�� �,�1 •�' CITY HALL-4�4 BR�AaWAY ��ate rec�iv�d} � � 'Y� '�`�'r#`��r�`,� � SARATt]UA SPR�I�C�S NEW Y(J�RK 128+5�-2�95 a°�r�__.�,I��:,.�'�.N � �������, �- ���`�' TEL: 518-587-355�Xz533 o�,���� www.sara�oga-sprr`r��s.or� �Projec�Title} APP`�.I�ATI�3N F�R� ARC H IT�CTL�R►�L I H ISTC�RIC �►EVI EW 5taf#Re�iew APPLICANT�'S�� C3WNER�S�} (If,not a pfr�ant� AI�QRNEY��GE�`JT ��m� aeborah Hayes Stone Applican� Fr�st Hu��ff A►rch�t�cts �4ddres� ��� Farm Rd. 41 Lor�g Alle� Sherb�rn, MA n�77D Saratc��a 5pr�ings, I�Y 128�G Phvne g��.92�.4[766 � f 518.�84.���4 l Email �ayes.debhayes c�x gr�ail.c�m r�natt a�]fharch.��m [dentify primary conta�t p�rson: ❑ Appli�a�t ❑ C]wner~ 8 AttvrneylAgent �An appli�ant m�ust be the pra�erty vrnrner� less��, or ane with an aptian tv leas�or p�ur+��ase th� prvperty in q�estiar�. Applicant's interest in prer�ises; � �Dwner � Lessee � Under vptivn to IEas�vr purcha�e PRC]PER�Y'INF�RMA�TI�N Pra e AddresslLvcativn: ��7 ��ring Str�e� Tax Parcel #: ��� �� - � - �4 P �' �for example: 165.5Z—4—37} aate Acquired b �wner: �'11U21�2 Y - �Curr�nt Zoning Distri��: Prc�p+�rty use: e Resid�nxial ❑ frlon-��sid��tia�lmixed-us� �"ype of�eview: ❑ �Arthitectural l� Histvr�c � Extensionlmodif�cativn �+�f current�pprv�val} F�em��a� of nor�-histaric r�ar po�ch and kitchen v�rin�vw. �ons�ructivn af nev►r Surrimary de�scription vf praposed actian: rear p�rch, mud rovm, and frant porch. Installativn of new windows in� kitchen, attic, an�d li�ing roam. Has a previc�us applicativr� b�en f�l�d with th� DR�fo�-this pr�perty? e No ❑ Y�s—date�s}? -►APP. Na.�s�?� Rewised Q�1�D21 T EZSL-b8S-8lS�xpj 998Zi�l�C�����-S��OT���S Dl9LbB9Bl9auoUd � 998Z1 AN`sBuutlg eBol��eg �aIIV 6uol lb �aa��s�ut.zdS L9 i l�I�'Id 2�00'I3.LS2II3'd02�d � l�I�dZd 2I00'I3 ZS2II,�'X� � �sNoisin3d � ��l�L�Q1�7�1 C1�l�L��L,� S 1�3 1 I H�a b' �z�s :31d4 ��,��� ..o-.i=,.v;i :3lH�S i i �I i i i i �I i �� i - �I i �� i �I i �� � z II O ; z �� ° i � II � I z � > I � J � � � I =I - � � � � � = I = U j Y 0 � � i � ___ - z � a a i i o � �� I��n � � �� Z - � O � � ii ; �i O z w ii � � m ii w � � li w � m � ii = � i �------ i i � z� � �I i H o ����-���. i � � � N� � � � i o� � o i i � � z� z � i � i � g o o � � i �' an ° an � I � W n I Q z � I � I s I o I I -- I O L— u�Naa I � I I I I P-i- ----�J �� �ii �� N - Q o --- ---- � I I �I I I I i �T-----11— T �� � II �I II I I II II II i I �I II II II II II II II — — �f� I �I I I II II I I I I I I II � —'�II �I II II II II II II � II �I II II II II II II II � II �I II II II II II II �I I I II I� � j II ��I II II II II II II L-----J L-----z o J L-----JI II u----z o----�----- - ---- �I IC----- - ---- -- r-----��-----o ��----- I �-----J n----- ___ - I I I �I I I � � I I I I I I I II �I II � � II II II I II �I II � � II II II I I II �I II � � II II II I =N I- II II II I I II II II I m� I I I �� r� r---J � I I I I I I I �� -Jm I \,, II jI II�',I j II II II j I sl�� v a• ---J L-----J L--- —J�'� ----�1-----ll-----��---- r-7-i --- j I I I I� � II II`. II a I I � jI II I� I �n � � z� i II - � �I I I I I I O w� II II --II 0 ��I � � I I I a I I w� -- — I I � � � I I F� � -----��-----��-----���\ � ! ,� --�r---��---�I ���, � II �I �I \ � - II II II �I � � �°o II II d� I I � j� I �� II v I � � ° II II II II I� �� j� I I �I II I� - �� I �, jll II II �I I � II �I � � --�---- �� I� I� � i"i� �� 1L I � r ii I� � ��I ii y W_ L--- Q Q EZSL-bBS-BlS'�x�� 998 Z i�l�i`��-""��{„J'"'"O��^�S bl9L b85 8l5 auoyd � 999Z1 AN's6uutlgeBaleieg RaIIV 6uol lro �aaz�s�uiadS L9t Sl�iOI.L�1��7�Q�SOd02�d � s�olzvnaz���lislx� N �sNoisin�a � ��l�l�\11��Q�l�l��L,� S 1�3 1 I H�2i t/ �z'i's :31b4 ����� ,.o,i=,.tii :31t/�S _ u � � o w z � II I � a W 0 ❑00 ❑00 � 7 N X � � ❑ ❑ � 4 ❑ z o o � � _ � o � z W � L w w a� �; � �z � zo � �� - w m z c.aj °-'ro r� c9 �- =O O�' I� J- Ov � J �- 00 UN o�m �GzN �� 00 I--I Z v� z_ U II U I' z K= �II tf~�II W z � �w v��� �; �w � � = o � . � �� I a_ zm �'_ °� �!y�c � � � J o� - o� r�_ "'r- r w�o �m �- �� r`�� ��L_-�L ��g�-�6 �ZI-�01 �II u c� - z w- Q.�t �II �II �II �JI, F� F-� w� � � � � _ _ � � �k � N N � N F � g�,� gs,e g�-o� o z �:n � Q �� � � � � =�z wWQ � � �� � ��� � U w O � w �� �z Q o�0 � z c� N 2 � � =O Sw Q �~O o ¢ a a � � K x �� � J�� U Q �� w� U �N s O �U, O N V z o= - w O� - i 1 z U z� O� x z o i_- x ��iQ x OQ z� v �`� Z W i� N N�U N Z W��I�+ I� - � -_- -� � J� J � - �-r.-..� � �;�,_-_-_- Y� _J.-� i-,' - r�r J, � �r� �� �- _ ''- � _�_ ,_ �'��- �r'�� �- ~�'-r�- - �-�� � -�!� -- = LI � - � - �'�I�-_- � l� - _- -� -J�- i i �-_-_ � :_-_ �, � I I .-_- �_ --__= o --- --_-. ❑ � -�_ -- ❑ _ __� __� ❑ ❑❑0�0 �--��;�---_ _-- �r � i 'r -J I .',1'' - �.'lr-',�-;� l� i n ��F- _ r� '-_- �-r __ � � � �� = z _ o _ ° -� � � � � ` w�� w ;� x x � � � � I o o � � ro �� � �m oro �- ov °�= oo � J- °� °- oo Q z � u-�o °a� oo °o Z u� °a' oo �o �j N ��- z- �o ,� u- u- o- �- O �ii �ii °ii 'u�u [� �° ��� wJ� N�� �J �-J J J Q� cw Nw - a_ aw aw u�w �w �� �� � � � � W� � u � g � g I �= g � g ��L-�L ..£-�6 ��I-�0 I ,.GL-.L ,���-�6 ��Z I-.0 I �' I L — N m N Q Q Q EZSL-bBS-BlS'�x�� 998 Z i�l�i`��-""��{„J'"'"O��^�S bl9L b85 8l5 auoyd � 999Z1 AN's6uutlgeBaleieg RaIIV 6uol lro \ �aaz�s�uiadS L9t Sl�iOI.L�1��7�Q�SOd02�d � s�olzvnaz���lislx� N �sNoisin�a � ��l�l�\11��Q�l�l��L,� S 1�3 1 I H�2i t/ �z'i's :31b4 ����� ,.o,i=,.tii :31t/�S U K O z �: II I F � � � ❑ � � ❑ I � I I � ❑ � � � z 0 � ❑ � � � � � �' X ❑ ❑ � ❑ ❑ z ❑ ❑ z , o o � �; � ° � w � z w w � � � o� Q � z- � �� � w - o� �- o0 W �N °� oo °o ^ r h z- � I-I `.J ��i ��� ��� c~n�� W � � �0 �- Z Q w aw u'lw �w �m o� � ^ J- �_ o a 0 — Od �— 00 U� O� p0 OO� i--�o w� J— U— O— �— � g � Q � g � O �ii �ii �u N ii x n ��G-,L ��£-�6 ,�I-�O I aJ ii aw au i�w �w f'j�� � I L P..� � � � � — � oz — N � ��,� gs-e Zi-,oi N N oz � o ° o � N oW = � Q � � � Q z� ` w v o Q �s � � z � T U z � �'�-z a Q �z U U °�_ .�r � w O � Q W z ','�,U;�. �� �K Q � � c9 C U'�c9� `cn �� zU w O zWw =�z'� Qw �c� �O u; O z a z � ��www ro �� �� m 5 ��� Qw Uz� Q� �X �z 'z � �o� oc��oa w� �w az ��o s=o �z w�m �_ _ � z w z�� ;�o=Q a� �� zo z�z Q_ - c�z oa "a -o hZs zw u�w �2 roz i�o zw� ❑ _- ❑ fi i - h �� � - -�- � - - ,t` �' ,t�',-= � �� � i i-�� ��� ��� _ J-� � ❑ I II ��, ❑ I - ��� .��I' r- r� }� ir� , --��rt_-- = 4'� � _- ,l��Ii -- v�' _ , , , _ ---- �5�-'- - - _ �'r' �� � - --_ �---� C - _ `� i --'-,i-_-_�--___ =d = �-�� q ❑ ❑ � _== o = ❑ ❑ _ _ �.��_��_ --- ��� _ �. - ����-� --����_ - _ �� � _ �r� -- �-�-�� _�-� Jr � - _��_ _ ��� � z ��N� o ��, - o >>;� ___ � , � ,� _ � : � _ ¢ � � - w _ w W x � p a z � � z � � Q o� o� � �- o� � � � z= o� ,�- oo c7 z= o� °� oo w U N O� �� O O � U N O� �� O� � z— z— �� O U_ U_ O— '_ F'"� U_ V_ O_ F-_ r II II W il N II H �II II U II N II ^ �' �� ' �' H �-' w-� � F+�' Cw Q w Ulw ��i �� Q w Q u �w —w � O-� �II �II � � � � w� � � � � a� ��G-�G ���£-�6 �g I-�O I ,��L-�L ���£-�6 ��g I-�0 I — N m N Q Q �, �,;,�h, c `� ,I. - ��'l`[• �;�q•'`�:� s� x� `I' '�.: �` y .. ';ti"- Jr- ''� �'�� � ,4 , ''� I - �, � F .. � .r S. .,t * � , � �..-, �' _ �•�'�i �r_ '�)I 4 - ��&.�!I� � F Y`�7�5 A y- 1 r, hl �� 4 p'•�.d �I I �."� �,]i I�� .. .r �: l`•' �'-•- .,�..�� - F4_�.. '� d����� f'+�'�', �� _ .-�i . � ''�. .s `.. . S. � ?� ��.�'` l'����L ��, ��r _ - +. _ - �,'' ' '" - `� . - •- - . _ . .. �, ,, , , . �..�,-�� •..-_ =�-" ..�--�.. �.,.,- ,�r_:.., �� ... j4 �... ..� ��� �`'�" �`'. , . - . , r.:. . , .,., ., ... � ,� a;� . J � b� � j � I �� 1 �� �'� � . _ .. 'h��' _ J.. _ �. 1 .".'� .+Y M�'� ,��,`"', ��. �r� .54 .��'� Y. -f.r 1 '� �'f r�ss .^' . -. '1 � ' f�� .�.#,'� � 4 I '=`�`�� �4m J`� i '� 1`�'�},,,�,��'y �. � 'c�. ` r ,�< � ' ` . •� . x , '�\ +.�. i I: i ` ^+..�_....Y..:� . :�. :' �+ �.�;' �.�` --_e .,.4,. � Y .� _� �r �'S: �E �,`.. . _ . �� . .f`l�"i I�f�'_' '� � ����• y ..,Y-+�� . I',f' ..., yv x '•R. 4- � 'S,:+ � ' •!: ' ,..'ti.�� i't�' �+,.x4'l�i Y.`� �"..�1. 'Y �'�, ���r '-�+ ' _ y:. . . . . � .., -" - _ ,... : _"_'. '. ��{� ;�- � -� �� � � � - r '"� `�`�� '�-� 'L°`��'«� � � , �:. r ��- � , . � . ... 4- ' �y" 4 ��,..,',�, ,:-��' ,} � ry... s. 'd- k�'-�,�-.,�ea.- .�' �L s '_ �. '.: . � - . �� ����:.�pJ•� _... ti�.'.. •�__ �Si+�ny.'`� 'a .�� ,� €' -�r ':�.. �. . ���, _�� . � - .�^,` '��_.- '-�i - �_ ��s��•:.:. .+ � . � �'-. �_.�'.- _ r i� J �:� . . . •'.. �'Y '�. �,'1�,�a`..4 1 =y.� h k ..4+"'d� � ,��:*." �.�_ .. - k'Y 3 �r'�. `� _ . � _ _"� ^, ..:i. _ _ : ! '.� � ���. L s „' � s - .1��'k . '� rr �� -a•'I��� qe,.. �� :}�.. � . �!4, f � y' „� ,' L �`; � �` � ,.�p � ,�5 ��� __ _ V j ..F'.� Y:`J �,�,�_ : r+�" 'c. �� - .f� t �++�- � o-�� � '. � ':_��,w _�a. a i 5,� � - .. � �' ,�,�- y,� i � r. ; � .__ � �� �. . 1`,4 � '�� I _t�� _� ��1�., 3 ._� F r' . .. y '� - ' - ��° �#t � ... � _ � �T"b'l `. � ' _ '. ..� �. . . � �� ' -- - . .. .. .. -. :." � � .. ti, , . _ .r '. ��� ' � �. - _ _ _- e 1 ���� � 4 � ��t� .. �.� . ... � . _ � .. ,� - a ¢� 4- , . 'r �� l� „ _ _� ,,� __. - � . : a � �� �� - _ . _ � . - . { . , � __ .�: . . 5 . _ J �� � .�. ,� ,... �� --- E s_ --- - � , � - . - :. . - — --- .� � �� _ . � -- . __ . - - -y,� . _. ''Y* � •�^ � .._ J ...b, �'R.4�• ..��.�.�� . . - .. � _ � .,-1I+ . ._" . �. '...... { '" i .�.�• '� • �• -. " . a i ' • � ',. ,. . '•i . � .. . .., �. • • .�JY� � i� -- Y�,.. . � , . a 1 � i � _��e . . -„ -- -- - � "{. ,t��".i . .. � A� . , -. ... � " - j�.. - � n+ }"' 1 , _ •-t . .R R � !s ..� � ���. �41M �.� �- ' . ' . _ , > ._ �` _ � f .... - p...�- _ . � . w ' ' I. ._" ' _ :. ' _"'. . ��'. . � ..� - ., . � .•-.-�•�. . -�P°A°=i--.3,. . ."' ' ' � ' _ _ � v.. ... -- ' . . � .r... ... � ...: -.. �, � .: "_" � .� ,�..� � _ _ r r_ � . � _ gr .. ,�. -. �. : -.. .• � . -��` . _ `-; r � :y.. � l � ."� �����_.��� d1,�'�. �''" � ' °'..�__ '� '�. .,� . _ _ _,�_..���... I :f � �. � ..I . - -'" . »- . i .. ��• . A \l� . {Y�..' . -�� - > . �. ..-� r .r . .. 1 ., r . . �.. . -� - _. • � . ..�. � • _� - . _ � �- .. . .� .� . � . .--_ ._� .- - � � . �� ._. _. „ - .. . �4: -- . �. . �: � � _ _ s_ �---�� ` . � r , . . _. __. � . . __, -.__ " � �° �--- -- - _`__" ' - - - _. -_. _, : : � v�_ - _ . , � . , l � . k - - - � — -- t __ _ . , u . . . , . . , ' ° _ - k - - _ ., . , . ,. � `� �� �-�. �- 1 ; I _ , , A -�__ i- ! - - a. - � _. �-- i_ �_. __- , �� �f - - i;,�,'I' , '�"�� ��^ � _� ,� �.5y:(, @.14�• �� v' i �� 'r� �, �' �i �� ����� � �`� � �'-� � ��@, �"G,q" G �i ti� - ��`f i�. !�� t ....""#`t�� 1.. ��'f� �'�� �� "�' , � �,��.y���"�„, ��.,yf ��;��'i'� �. li .=h. Y ��.�y f4tw+ ^� i ���� r w ; y��,'t,5r�i a r ,�r�� ' 6 i I � J � «�'� ����,: ��5� �C.�s��v A� g'^ ��°' q� '� t I '� - { ",.t 'a. 3_A - , r. �._ ,r� '`_ i"�S -_ — _ _ _ � �'�� _�xi'�` ���. � �'--: M�` ��.5;� • . �..aT� — ��� r: �� . i ti �,^ s �: - - M1 `�� �� - w' -��G.� � ;- i I I� .. � „� ...'-'9�1f.�.,{a � . - -�� �� - .._���`� � �- J� � � s � �` _a. Ti���� . _ - - _�. `v � ' ���c�:, -e,.-. -__ �;'•. i _ '�.L - .. �.:{�� �. - ��.. � . r�'� 5i� I1��� . '� . � -- ----�^. :..�, ..` },_ -.-.::_ _':�.. �-�-. - ` _A_ -- . �:�,��. :� - ��� - . �y _ , �: .. S� . _ K f� J. � �.` . �w•.-�.. 'T '"A.'�"'�f"Iq� _ . . _. . TT"'�_= s � _, , , , "�`�' V,:� �,.':� . '.`',�f'_7. rnr - . - �;. j4 ''�3.��`, ,. ,. r _. _ :•i �. -� rt�, •- - . . ` '_�. ' :M..-�. ` , .,_'�, ..�' -.,'�/�i',�:�:: -_i�,- �" `.�... .�-�.. c ' � .�- --*.��� -_,.. r�x:,�'��-�-=- �� '�,�. � . .,9' ,�, .ri_ �`�.� Frant �South} El�vation �_. ��� ft_-,-�:f`='_- - :� -� - , � �:,:�-�: .i- �__� __-.�� / . ,` � � ,` `� , ��._ � �,r � , I¢'1��F Jr � �P I ��`+ �r - � � ��l '�W� �` }�� _ f. ..F .� ��. _ �r _ . ��.�rr q� i �s'���� �� ` f �'S' ,r� - ` ��_ ��� y� :. r{, '� � r'.r#���.���.�` _ s ' ��� '�k; I��'�� . Y � ti� � �1 f.��.'a`�'�'..�� �. .r"4��"�{.N. ''}� ��. ��f�-. -_ 'ti4 ".�� Y�''{7 LY _1�� -�� �, �� � �,;Y k ^!ti � .j� ���(� . - .'�_! --``�. �K. I.�_� _ '` . _ - _ I._�, b'� '{�a� `�iya� ` �y��� ` �� e'����AS. :�I..;}r� �-^� . -' -__ -"��__� ��_ � y,'+�� Y .� �f�:�6''�`` . �wA�Y.� L��� � .i�l _ --__ ___ - . . � x':�•f F� ��R�.`s ��.-.'�tc _.� •r' . --. - . .� ��, +.: _ ����, g � ---_ - - .__ . . ��Y � . 4�.�1� „ r �4; ��{� �-E. ��'.` y,' „'�f�r'f '-'_- --��_.-- _ � . _ __ 1 � - �` �� `,"r !!I '�f. _ � `- , _ � ' : = • � . , �' _ - '°I �, � _ \ ��r � �,: • ;.Il� f' ---_ -I '�- - __ ��� �, '�,� ,�.��, �p�� r`, � �� � �, ,� P -- __ ' �� M 't� n ���,a b ���I r s � �y ���� � � ���I."l�� �.r _ _ - � -- '�-� � � - � - � ,: � 7+'�`' �. - P� _ ___ ' _� � .y __. -_- '- �. . - '� r r': ti �_ a � � � ' -- ` - . ` i, � , ,,'�'''�':-� �y� - -`- - __, � -_ "�� - . , _ • � - , � • ^ — t- .'+ { 'i h..�:. � �t �� F/� - . -�_ � ' .v--� A S ' �� y I •r� _ ` � _ , . ' S I � � �r rn• r .I- .. - __ � - ��. t I � � � I `� i"T .� .� "��f���Y� F � `� j... .� � � � �y ,'.�jp � 1 .i - ��. 7€,N ..,..-.,ry _ �. ,,I� 4 • a '� - �_9 .F:'� H . x _ �,�� . _ _ - 9'-' � , "-� �€ -_� ' � •�;�'r ��; _ ._ _ - _ .. I 1 ��'FIZeC�"�' F'� ( r ,. _ L _ _ i_ ��� ! '�.p r r: "c`4.y� I�f :�. r __.��� - a� .�'Y'~� � _ __� .� �� ��\.� ...il � � s r � 1 `� � � _ ,a' -__ � y' �. ;. •�� '-- - - , r - '�i i i)� ry �`� ����1 R �' 'F.. +�j Dpyvx. _ _ - � _ I �- {::,�. � � �� r ." " -....- � I p �,� __� — _ �- r � -� i l c ~--- �5 _ . � :r r, _ �, y �II ll. �,� � - --•- �� _ � � ___ _ _ , �� - ;- � - . . � �. � - �� � �� � Y���_ ��"I � —i �_�� _:. _ - — -- -- �.M � - .; , � .� � � � �� ��:��_ � - �. - -_ � - :� -�'� °� � �� i - '�"���_ -. ;„� � _ _, ,.. ''r!��'� ._ �- �_=. �/ � . . m _�.. , .. ' � .�,�� . _-�-�� ����� ; Re�.r(North Elevation�