HomeMy WebLinkAbout20230174 Porch Expansion NOD :���i������p`�� Tamie Ehinger, Chair
f+ ��' } CITY OF SARATOGA SPRI NGS Rob DuBoff Vice Chair
i,�'�•. .'.M�� P� '
� _ + �. �: */ .
�:,, `���` � '�. Chris Bennett
� _����� � -� �f- D ES I G N REVI EW BOARD �eslie DiCarlo
,:
:���
� �� ='�' � , • eff Gritsava e
� � g
�-., ---�,, '� .� ���
,�� ,� , � Tad Roemer
-_� ,. �� �:,�' ��, .; .�; City Hal I -474 Broadway Ellen Sheehan
t f.
' ' �����"���'�� Sarato a S rin s, New York I 2866 Karen Cavotta,Alternate
g P g
��`���� -, - �°��'�' Tel:5 I8-587-3550 x.25 I 7
����,���-�
www.saratoga-spri ngs.org
NOTICE OF DECISION
In the matter of the application
#20230174
I 9 I Church St— Porch Expansion
191 Church Street
Saratoga Springs, New York I 2866
involving Architectural Review of the proposed expansion to connect two existing porches within the Office
Medical Business (OMB) District, tax parcel #I 65.50-I-64, within the City of Saratoga Springs.
In accordance with 6 NYCRR Part 617,the Design Review Board classifies this request as a SEQR:
C� Type II action —exempt from further SEQR review
And, in accordance with the objectives, standards and guidelines contained in the Unified Development Ordinance
Article 240-I 3.9 Architectural Review Applicability and Approval Standards, the Design Review Board issues the
following decision on April 19, 2023:
C� Approve with the following conditions:
Front and side stairs to be wood
Rear stairs may be a material other than wood, to be submitted for administrative approval
Note: this approval shall expire 18 months from the issuance date unless any necessary building permit has been
issued and actual worlc begun.
Record of vote: motion to approve made by L. DiCarlo, seconded by R. DuBoff: passed 6-0
In favor: T. Ehinger, R. DuBoff, C. Bennett, L. DiCarlo,J. Gritsavage, E. Sheehan
Absent: T. Roemer
As a result of this decision, the applicant:
C� may proceed with the proposed project as approved
Please contact the Building Department to verify permit requirements.
May 4, 2023
Chair Received by Accounts
cc: Building Department File
Accounts Dept.
Applicant/Agent
Page I of I
---------
----------
------------------ '7"4S'00"E - 7°45'UO"E
______________58_---___-_
--- � 102.00'
___________________________-p
�02.00'_________________________________ � I
� � �
� � � �
� � � �
� � � �
� � � �
� � � �
� � � �
� � � �
� � � �
� r-______.-_._ � � ,�_____.__.__ �
I _._..__ I I _..___-- I
� � � i �
I -z � I zl � U Z �
� °' � � �� � � z o z
� rxisTiN�cn�a.�e � �is iN��aRa.�e � W��--'
I EXISTING DWVEWAY � I EIXISTING DKIVEN/AY �� ��n
I i � I �H �J
I � I I H/-�•� �"i
I � I � C/1 I—I �•�
I I
� ' � � il � W Q � �
/ � � � ��/1
� d
_\ �
� - - � � -- - ------ � Z x� ap
� - �I r— —' � � � /J � O U a, o
i � i \ � i ��r'�
c�
�,
j � � i j � i
i i i �
i �a �
i i i I i �
i i i i
i i i i
i i i i
i � i i
i i i i
i i i i
i i i i
i ' =i i � �i
i Ni� i - Ni� �
i � �i� i � �i� ��
i � �i� i � �i� �
i =_ �i i = �i w
IANDS OF 6AGE$ASFi EYSIMPSOV � I LANDS OF GAGE£ASYILE"SIMPSON i_ � _
� rFix MaP Pnr:ce�No.�6s.so-i-6s �y � � r�N�a.a PnRc��o.�ss.so-i-6s �� I � -
I nRen=+i-i�.�sa scz.Fi. � i n�,a=+i-i 6,�sa sa.FT. I �_ -
I I U
I j � I j � �� y
I � � I � � a
I I � I I �
�I � � `-��_ I I
ml� �� I ti�� "� I
��D �� I ��� �� I
ol- ;r',I ��� oi- N I i z-e' I
I �� � I N�
� I � I I
I j � I � � NORTH
I I � I � �
� � � I � --- � � �
�- -
z - I I I �I ----- I 6 I
� ------- W -------- I�
� ____ �19._6„ I i �
� I � � o I � � � __'
� COVER�D � � � 'J j � U � --
� o; r�oKcn I I � c� Forzcr I 'Y I J tii
I . i � � I exPnNsiov j � I O
° I w
�
� � � I O�_6Z�� � � r-- � � �
J LL J-
� / _`____a��I I . j I � (/J�Q
� I,' � � '� I �
� � � � � �
� -- �' �F � � � �
I �, � � i I UY I
i �i i i I i �
� rxisi iN�inrzeE s�oRr Nouse � � E:isTi�e m�e sroRr nouse � �
� l; I � I� I
I �'� I I I i I �
� __ �i I � i_ �� I a
I � I I, �
I � I� � I � I � ��
I I
� I,� � I , I� � ��
� I j I � �W
� ; I � � I �
I � I �
�' I `-�
I / � � I � � Z�
I - I� I I --�i �
I � I �i � �
� cov-�o PORcn I � �� cove�o PORcn � �
i
I �
I � I I _I
------- I I li
� -------
`---- - I
---- o'�� -------
� -- --------
---- -----
- -
-
I
� ------ � � � � W
I � j � I � � I
I I � I � �
I I � I I �
I I
I � � I � �
I � � I � �
I I �
I � I �
� I �---- �
------------- I I
-_-------_----_-_-- _------_-----NB�_�s�,_, SP
-----"`�;ozoo°.�, i i o�- ------
----------------------
1-- ------
----! -----------1-
------�
� EXISTING SITE PLAN 2 PROPOSED SITE PLAN
SP �����_��-�� �� ,�8,�-,,_�„
.../... ��.....
I?—t
I I I��
I I I,
I I I�
I I I,
I I I�
u�I� u�
I I I li,
�
III z o z
iii�
i i i' W�'� �;
L�_L Q Q U.�
W Q � Q.,
I' �Q�v1
/ Zx� bA
��� O
����
KT�i F�, �,
i�i i i �� �
covrRro PORci, I I I I
i--i
II I
I�7 I��N �
�I��
I I�
�i. _--��_— --1�J
i
� KEMOVF E,(`POSED WOOD b1NKS
�� /
��� �/�' _ III �rrP_(37�ocarioNs)
�—
"'tMOVC L 5 fGKt WOOV COUNNS
S @ALUSTFP�FOR RFUSF �
cove�o Po�cn IIIII �
i o i I I coNP�eTe�r�Nove cover�eo
PORCH 102 �U —
KCMOVr[ND GUARD RNIL Cf MNIN w —
PORCFi_SALVAGE BALUSTEI25 F02 ~
eeuse.
�_ _
�
U =
� '
I �q.��
`o�`o"�
�--------------� .. �
. I I ..-�., ...�\..... �Q N
----- i-----------
�
r----- �
L--------------J I
� EXISTING PORCH FLOOR PLAN o
1/4,�_�����
-7y
AI.I
ti
s I -
�
�
s, --
�
U �
� �P ��--�
N
I �
Z I � I m
� �. I rv
U I
� ��
�
z
Q
W��
Q F�
U Q w
(/J�¢
zz
� �
�
a
�
a�
uP o�
� x
0
�, ;-
� ao�o��,��A��s oN �
� v �I QI
�� 10� �
�...�Y��/ � II O F�`^,
I cJ F�—I^rT�1
N-V✓GUAR�,DECK,AVD PORCH I - U w
CEI ING MHTCYIEJ TO FXISTING I r—rJ��
� � I ^
REIJSE(2)_�AI VAG�D GOI_UMN:: I O
�FW iTAIR"i:I-I 2"131I/EiT(JVF I O
/ /��
�
TREADS g LIMES ONE RISERS I
F'—I
(iYP.(3)LOCATIO�'S) I O^,
� I �[�]W^
I ^F+1
L--.---_-------___-----_—__—_----_--._.--_-------__-----_. ..-------------------J
�coNsrwc7eo s�aiRs
exisriN�PORcn new coNST�ucioN
2 PROPOSED PORCH PLAN A 1.1
,;4„=,,-a„
AI.I.
../.... ��........
1 �z �
w°�z
�� �
Q�,� on
v�Q �•�
W Q � �,,,
r�Q�v�
�
x� �
o��, o
�
� � �
ao �
�a �
�
�
\�� ,
���� s i z �
\���� I
I
�iz m \\���� j
\\����� �
�
\� U ma
------------------
��m
� ���.. �� w r���
\ ~
SIDE PORGII TO BE REMOVED - -
/ �U --
/ �a N
/3�I2 3�.'2 \�
7
O
—7y
ti
Rennov-sniN��es,F�sshiN�,e�_�NoeR�s�eNT
�N r����o�Ar�oN�ooF s�EAT�.�N�ro�E�A,� � -_
�
� EXISTING PORCH ROOF PLAN
1;4„_,,_�,� -
A1.2
���
�,I z
� �
w
J LL J�
Q F�
U Q w
(/J�¢
�CYfJAR FiNI5Y1 DRIP FDGE NNT�YIED ��
TO VALLEY FIASHIN6
F��I
:XISTING SHINGLES TO REMAIN .�J rT.
��L��1
O O
�EW FSPYIALT 51'11NGLE5 T:7 O
�ATCH FXISTING.I\STALL O�
OVE'�IC�AND WATEP.
snie�o ��
r�:2 `J W
� ^J
25:i2\ ; F�"'��
� �. �
j/ \j,�- ��� c 0 p—I
��� U Q
� _ zo
/3:I 2 3:I 2 F--1 O
/ / W�-`I
�XPO�tD�7E=L VAU-I'S N/ITFi
r.r�nr�Fiwsn�Nnrcn co�o�
l(J FLI�5h11N�UN MAIN KCJ(JF)
EXISTING ROOFING TO R:MAIN NEW RCOFING
2 PROPOSED PORCH ROOF PLAN A 1.�
A I.2 �;4„_,,_o„
zo�,z
W H v1 v�
Q,._,� bA
�1Q �•�
�Q;.�C�
Zx� bA
��� O
a�� �
�O �
�
�� -
�
w
�
i ��
U � �a �
�� \
TY11KD FLOOR ..�..
EL=I 19'-7-3i4"
b ❑ ❑ ❑
6 � SIDE POfZCl1 TO 6E REMOVED
--� -,.,
secoNo F�o� ``' �
--- �� � , z
EL=109'-9-I/4" — ���� _____ .. O
__ __— __
__ �__ ___'_.. J LLI�
Q F�
_ _ ❑ — —— —_— fn�Q
I �� � I�
N ❑ I� I
I I I I I �ro�e cownnN�-Fo�r��se
m � � z
o =______�,-=_-=--�i o
� ~
��r-sr r�ooR I I j I sn�va�e Baws�Ps Fae�use E-{
e�=oo_� ———- _______ _______ �
�� ______________ W
-- — �
KENCJVE(:i)S�1S UF bVUUD Sl�I�,S
P.ENOV[SIAf IAffIC[B[LOV✓MAIN
'02C7 �-I
� EXISTING EAST ELEVATION �
EX I �-4„=�,-o,. W
�7
�
H
�
�
�C
W
EX 1
zo�,z
W�,� �
Q�,� on
v�Q �•�
W Q � �,,,
r�Q�v�
�
x� �
o��, o
�
� � �
ao �
�a �
�
�
�� -
�
U
w
F
❑ � �� �-
� � ��
r���F�oo� � �
1=I I 9'-7-3/4'
<�� . ❑ . .. . � ❑
�
NtNA5P11ALT511iNGL�S MA7�FIED
l O tXISI IN6
SECOND�LOOR j � ` ��` �� ^(n
1=I 09'-�-I/4' � � � � � O
NEW GEDAR�ASCIA 4 ENTABL4TURE W��
MATCIIED TO F�<ISTING PROFILES a F�
- ❑ U Q w
INSfALLSALVAG DC01.MN5 ��¢
�� — — _ ❑. �..
� NrW�IJA2"J MA�H D T(�PFOFI F
E MATCRIALS OF Lxl TI'1G.USE
SALVAGED BAWST-RS AS �J
� P2ACiICABLE O
� ~
`I PS-PLOOK �
::I=1 00'_0" �j
_ �
__j=� ;=.--� __ ._. � .....,_. �
__... :' . .,_' '. --_
'__...�. , '.__c __,- ...; , -._�, . _.. __,` "- ," L_
'_ ___ _ --_ � W
NEW 2'x 2"CEDAP.IATTIC= I-./2"BW ESTONE TREA�S �
eETW,`EN EX.P'.E25 rT�
REPOINT EXISTING FIERS EXPCSED �ECO�STRUCfED STqIR.S w
8"RCN�O�AL O�SLATS AS N[CDCD LIMESTONE STONE VE�EER �y
EXISTING PORChi N-VJ CONSTRUCTION '
MHTCIIED TO F�<ISiING PIEQ.S �
� PROPOSED EAST ELEVATION �
W
A2.1 ��4,_,,-0,. Q
W
�
O
a,
O
�
a
A2.1
zo�,z
W�,� �
Q�,� on
v�Q �•�
�� W Q � �,,,
r�Q�v�
�
�\�` O U a, o
�� � ap� �
�� �� �a �
, � � vs
j� / �� \
j \\ ��
� \
� % �� \�� �
� � �
` �U
w __
F
����... .�.�� �_ -
�Q
� �
-HIRD F 00�
EL-'19'�73/4" �
b�
�
SFCOND FLOOR %�' `
b
.--_ i% f
EL=109'-9-I/4" �
�� Z
---------- �
_ �
—_--_--_— J w�
__—__
Q F�
I I ��Q
-la IU
z
---------- o
�
F�R�-F�oo= �
---- ---------
E�-�a��_o� - -- ----- �
�� i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i �___--__� --0 - - i - _ �
W
SIDt POKCH f0 13[KtMOv[U �
EHISTING COWNiN TO BE SFVHGED W
�EMOVEGJARD.�ALVAG- �T
6AI_USTE�S AS PRFlG71CAelF. �"i
WOOD SIATS TO BE�Eti10VED �
WOOD STAIfv TO BE REMOV-D O
z
� EXISTING NORTH ELEVATION L7
EX2 ��4•_,.-0„
�
N
�
�
�
W
EX2
zo�,z
W�,� �
Q�,� on
v�Q �•�
W Q � �,,,
\ zx� ap
� �
�
;�/ �� ����
\ �a �
� �
\
/ � A � vs
/ � \ �\
/ i �� �\
� i \\ ��� �
i � � �
�U -
w
� �U =
� �a N
�.
-HIRD F 00�
EL-'19'�73/4" �
-� KYNAR�INI5IIVALLCY�LtLS;IING
_ MATCHED TO EX.MAIN�OOF
� �A571�6
NEW ASFIIALT SI11N6LE5 MATGIIED _
TO IXISTI�G
SFCOND FLOOR � �—
EL=109'-9-I/4"
———_ =� Z
NEW CEDAR FASQN 6 ENTNBLATJRr �
IvIATC�IED TO CXI`iTllvG PIZC�II_ES W�jj�
INSTALS�LV/�GED GOWMNS I I
��Q
�� U
NEW GUAKD MATCHED-0 PROFILE
e MATFRJAL�OF F�.'I�ING.USE
SALVAGED BNWSTFP.S AS Zj
Piza,cricaa�e.
H-I
_ E"i
FiRs�F�oo�
e�=�oc�_o� -- �
�
- � � I I—W�
;-1/2"BWESTON�TREADS �
LIMt510Nt Sl ONt V�NttK x
MATCIIED TO EX.P ERS NEW CONSTRUCfION
��.�/
w
� PROPOSED NORTH ELEVATION �
z
A2.2 ,;4..-,._o„ �
W
�
O
a
O
�
a�
A2.2