Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20220563 209 Lake Porch Mods SPFF Letter ���r��a a ,� ���. s � � � I'reserva�i�� F��r���ti+��.. �� July 19, 2022 ti--�� ,� �c�� ��.� I?1�.F.�F k,V A T I C)�: Ms. Tamie Ehinger, Chair FC)1� YEAlt*� � � Design Review Commission -f�� City Hall ��� 474 Broadway °, Saratoga Springs,NY 12866 � � RE: 209 Lake Avenue—Exterior Modifications Board of Directors Dear Tamie: Adam Favro P�esident The Saratoga Springs Preservation Foundation reviewed the application to make exterior Michele Funiciello mOC�1�1Cat10riS at 209 Lake AVerille. Vice P�esident L�nda L.xa�ey The Craftsman style residence at 209 Lake Avenue was built in 1923 for Royal J. Dryer. The se��eta�y house retains many of the character-defining features of the style including: a loW-pitch gable �m�tr�y Ye�olaye� roof with exposed rafter tails,a full-width porch With tapered square columns,and wood shingle Treasu�e� cladding. Tiffany Blair Steven Dodds The Foundation supports the removal of the two center tapered, square wood columns to return Giovanna D'Orazio the porch to its original appearance. The Foundation recommends that the stone piers be Julia Dunn Sandra Fox repaired where possible rather than rebuilding of all the stonework. If rebuilding is absolutely James Gold necessary,every effort should be made to use the original stones. John Haller Richard King , , , , Stephen Kyne A significant character defining feature of the house is the balustrade beginning directly at Vincent LaTerra ground level and extending without a break. This is typical of several other Craftsman style Samantha Nass . �orothy Rogers-sull�s residences in the neighborhood, many of Which Were mail order kit houses (i.e. 203 Lake sne�la sperl�ng Avenue and 168 East Avenue). The Foundation strongly objects to changing the balustrade to Jason Thomas an open lattice. If ventilation is a concern,dirt immediately adjacent to the balustrade could be Maddy Zanetti replaced with loose stones and/or the lowest course of shingles could be removed to allow for James Kettlewell air to circulate. While the Foundation does not support the change to lattice, it does support eme�itus the modification to allow for water to escape to prevent future deterioration. The Foundation Staff also does not support the top rail being changed to bluestone. The top rail should remain wood Samantha Bosshart to retain as much of the balustrade's original historic appearance as possible. Executive Di�ecto� There is currently construction taking place at the garage at 209 Lake Avenue. The Foundation Nicole Babie . . . . Membe�ship&P�og�ams does not recall the Design Review Commission providing approval for the changes being made Di�e�to� to the garage. Based on photos from Google Maps, 2007, 2014, and 2022, it appears that Jacqueline Bunge exterior modifications have been made including: roof replacement;removal of exposed rafter Events&P�og�ams tails; exterior siding being changed from novelty siding to clapboard siding; alterations to the Coo�dinato� door and window fenestration; the addition of a stone base; and the installation of an interior Anne McDonough chimney. Administ�ative Assistant Patricia Herrick The Foundation appreciates the significant investment that the owners are making into their Bookk��p�� historic property. Thank you in advance for your thoughtful consideration. S inc erely, � �� � Adam N. Favro � Samantha Bosshart President Executive Director 112 Spring Street,Suite 203 cC. Sue Davis,Architect Saratoga Springs,NY 12866 John&Karen Zanetti, Owners (518)587-5030 Amanda Tucker, Senior Planner, City of Saratoga Springs www.saratogapreservation.org r� �� , ��� -�� -����,� „�y� �. �- , ,,� � �� : , . ��,.. ,� . � ��s� , a{ � Y � Y � � �. � . , � , . , . y y � q ,� � �° "� ,: �. y. a�. � * �$ � � �,. , � � . ,� ��, a a,��. . tl � - ;� r�.: �x.: �'�'"`� A���,�; � �^ . . p� �.s� �', -,. � , `�'"'°� . ��'� "�"',y�� ����,����.�.'�.. , ��, ��. � ��� �� "'� � ., �+ � � ,h.�,,. r ��;'„�r , � �� ,,��d ��� �. , ,�n�-} f, �� �'�^�•, . � �.�'�t'Y� ". : "`a�. ° � �'�." �'�"� ���.w �}�,�`,��� � � , * ��,�;� . . E� , �„ �""`"�°.�y.9 � , , . . ?a� •� ;�,�-�,, �� � •�� � °� � � , �� „ ., , _ , , . � � ,, � r, ,� i_> � � ! , s � r � s .�, . �6'� ,r- «:� KK .. � ...�,4 d�' �,� �� �f .r � rv � � , . �. � � ii ' � .' . �9 „�� I ,'K ''. . 0.. s _ � ,� . W�. . .,..�. � . } �� I5 �r, ' ' . ." � „ t.. . � � .�.$�' � �S� '� .+M '.��� �v� �` M1 ��i�� ����(��Q(f� - '." ' 'e ,�'�6„ �d� *��., �, � r., _ . , �'�`��'+� . . �� -. .. �. ,�' � :x�::. � _�.�_� _,.�ry� � � .. .., , . , �: - � � _. k n�: —_�_ ��-�-w =�� '�..,�: ��;. ., � �ti�� ��� � �,� � �-; � �� �� �� w �.,. ', . .,`, �' : �,�, . �n< <-1�, ° �`""_-_��a_� � �'�� �� � .�' ,� � � -�_�� ,.,.� �a a �; m:. �P�v��d��"� '` �*�r- �m_�--� _ �-_- �� : w�,�s M 3Y�.,�"� �,.�,`--^�-.:..�����"'- -�� _°-� '�� ��.. k �°� �+"��`. ."^"�'.,ar.._s,.�.,r,.��^-.-,.-.� �_ - � . v '�"4 aF.� _ � "6. � '■ r N . �� '-'"a:p r. I- .r�,. F r� �..w,,. -''^�-, �`iA IM^M�� ,..� Ir.. ���W�. , r���y� ! j��s/. =.�v„�-+r�-.m~t.� *� - _ _ �Y � �,___.� � ~` �� � [f -� , _� ;,.. n ,� : r� I l�F' I j"W.. �� . �_�� ^_. _. - � -'`� �~ ,�� ^�.Y�°+ ����a� ' '�i �� f -._ - m ". � . ' . ��.,.�.,�,�,�.,-.�..,� d�r�"-�•� e d -- , '� �,�*� r �-� _ 7, �., ,,�,h,.., _ ,'�'.-�,. y „-. , "' � •�..^'"-� �'�. --'-�^ �. �v' f � � �IjP}. � _, � � ' d r _ ..P d ��� � ��^'�ti� I ._ �- y.l..P- 1*r��� �;�,'., ���,. ,� � __r�""� _�_� _� - �-�`� , „ --. � -� p �' ,, � � _ � ��:m= ��� � ''�:�a.� �. �; �.�.�. , �,- ,. - _ ___., - ���. "� � � ry , �� .:m ,������. ��:- _ - M �� -��.���.�� ..,. , ���,�f,. - —�,�� -- . ��� �;� � _ ,. . ,, ,� . . ,� � . . � �. ��",�"���. �� -�.<�.„� -,° ,, ^��,;���. � '`. ,-�,��,: _ �- .«:� r- �� . _ � . �.�, 4. . ., " � �� �,��mrk"pw+ � ... ��c"�"�"'ly,,��,E,� i.�. �.. .. -.;, „w.y�,�, y � � „� ��� u � � .� ,.. �w : ,�. � q . � � . . �. � °� � �. � ��.� ����� � � �A � ss�s�„ _ � . , � � ; . ,i�,Mr4..�� � � a. , � ti ,.r, � , .: � y � � � F . , �° � . W� �~"' - ' y�. � �,k - - �..r � �, � s "��_, a�- . 4� �^: . - ',,��-� r °_ r..�w awy .�3 �.�� �' . �, � �: K :, �, i � ,�� - . ., P �� �.� _ � r,� � � � �� � � _ . _.� � 7 �� _�Y�,�_ �� � n n � ����..��� w : . ��� � .. _ � .� � . ,� T _ . ��. �T � _ _� u uu. __ � W_ _ �_ _w t n� �� �, ...�� i �. . ,; , , � .�,, � , ,.. .w , a � ; . . ; �_. , .. � � t��i���� r �. �� � ���-� � ,� �f,� , �_ �_ }t� � -�.__�. �����, � . �, �` _� �..� �.: �+V` � � � ,:. � , ,`�h'" A - A '. u �l ��,�. ...,..,.�w�, � �����,�* �. I� ` . � ,.,. , .�. • � ��,,�,� �_ , ,`� �y '�f ' ��y,� '. �: � ¢ ` :. , i. �i.' �41 49#A I � ���� LY"m�,�S e 9 .' s r, � � � r., "C+n... � � 1 ( ' � '�'M '� "� ��� � .�.� I � . -a' j� , qy " '" ' ��e ��� n{`��. w ,� o '� ` �� � - ° :� � , �tlir�� �.,�, .,�w � .... AT� ..�: L j w s �" m �.. � � � � ,d .. .,.� � l s' '0 �� � �µ oIr��..� i I'IX 1 � r f Fw , � ��� �r�� ° � �p �� ` � , � � ,,� �' � � � �1 � � � �° ;� � � ,� .„ . '3�"sa � . ' � � � ��" °°� � � 1� rt ° � � � I � �i � ' d � �' �'� �� � � � � � q ���� � , � �� _ � �` ��. ,��- �� �� � .�: � � � ,�� ^,,: � ;� �;�d � � � � "�—. � ���.,�{,< , , µ . ,� , ,� � � �� �� � „' �� ,,..��„ �_� ,� .�,� � 2 `�s� �r i � � : , � ^�:,�»�, ���' ��� � . , � �'� �� �r«� -#�t '�.��� d! � � � p � � � �ah�-,,.v'�' ,,�„�" ., a�� � �� w .i � �. � '� �,,,�yL� ,':d! =: ���°'�' ��. +��.��y „'"�� � � � > � � � 1� ,,, �- � ��,�' 3 ' �x.i-t � �y, .'�4 ` � �M�. �' � .,. � ��r.�," .�� .��� ��� �,��''��aS° `.�.� '"'"'"�..,m az��*� �� �� '.-�"4v �w��yra p����� P �. � � "= . � � ,�,. ,� �, , ,�, �,°��a F �:� � _.. �.w �. ._. �., .. . ; , ���w ,�, �' �, .� F�.. . .i.� ^�,� .:: �+ar�.a�°"'�.�„pe' e�°k' . .. y�'�-'�:*�����ai :y,';' A , .�. �F.,,�:���. ��`.� 168 East Avenue, Saratoga Springs,NY built in 1924. ,. ,.�--.,�, ��, � ,� �� �.�, »�" ,� �-*" � { � °� . �, t�.F � '�'+�, �.. � ._�. �, • � . �..,# . , � � _ �e' � �, . .,. , , ,�, . � �� � � r � . � „� F 9 �, �tl�."' . �' . 4 . � . .� q^4.5."��.. � .� � . �# �- �'' ��� ��. �� � � �a y� ��F d^ �m' '2'y�" S ��` �• " ��' � � i' F�w .� �.�� � I�V��yW , �''Y�. Y tl.F v �.��� ��.:����� �a� 6��,�'���,�. �� .� „� � �� � R �. �I b,F���4 i• � `;� .�,. � �' .,� . � ti , , . „a .. . �. F . , �� � 1�' . x. '" �w'" ti.�P'sa�� '` x , � � .,. . 4 ,,. e �'t . + " " . y(�y,y . . ..... � A�.. .�" � a� . . �.,, . . 4� x� � � . �s-. �.. � .r . + 1 ' _ Y:�.ry ' '+�� _ � �•, �F � �, -. , m R� � �� - � i �° ` � � ,� " ., a �' ,, , �+�-,w� � iµ �,_ ! ,-.� ..�'° �": � „� ����� � � �. r .. � . , , � . �,� . �� . � ' �' _:�� ., a � �r . :��"�i h9. . � , � � . � _- . � . . � W. � . . � s � � � _�. "' -�°� x ' � '� � . - � ,� -�c. ~" ` � � ,• : _ , �a „.�, ,�r � � ,. , �,s '^p u, F« � �.��.. µ�. ,w S� Rql�'!G;o� b. +� „"J4w�,�"�X��9�1"'. w.f'�n w., � b 'P�wp, yu M��a-e' � .. „A.t .. W . tl�„: . . . � M. , ,. .�' �„ q . . n �y )i` �'' N n r.e��'.R.�n; pF�,;i .Y.��. '" :_.. .. ' � �*�,��..� 1� .y d • Si. q�` . �A . .__. . � n . �. 7ek ._ �4 �':+.: ,l '�.,r�, -" � � . - �� _.,mr. „�y��t..., '��"�1 t l�.7ry.,�"�"���V e ,� ,� �.'. .,, � �. �' �'.�;' u 11 � a , �._ �.�. e. ��. ».M�;°`�k" � .t'ir000r... ,�;,,:.. ,� __� _ �R^ �^A ... .. ...� '��"� � _ r„ � P. I�.. . , „„a 1�i�.���'. . . �� �� �: < �, ,� . � e« " z;.... ""��,,��,� " a . � � .i ��. ._ .,. __. ,�,..,, .�. +� � � � . � � � �,. , �' ... � ��� . ��� � . •U `, � , �. 4`t I� �, I, ,. • �" ° „"�► " u � :���� u�� ��� ��t W � � � . . �m>� � �,, ; �H !� ; , �� � ` , ., �, � . � � � � c . -:� �; � . � , rc � C "_..;: '"` . .,, .'; ,� �.._ . ....' „ : � . . ,au. ...,..��. .� �w . . ' .': . .... . .. � �. .�—�[ �.., �w i ;°' . . „ w.. � " ��_ '..:.., M:�,� �� .. f� � i �.-. '4. W �p � . � � ���uX � 'a}=� ,_. _ .y. �, � �.; x._y . .�� .Y.. ..... 1 y...� "�— . - v, . �., .,. 6_ _.. ._ ,�� , *� _�, y 4� ��w.-,s � �6 ��w«`"� , �_ ,« , , � '. . � ,� a�... : � �.. �� ...w�.r���-. � ��I r -� 1��� .� �� �, . ' `�. � � . a .� , _, � � - .�.�"' .. � , � • � .�,.. N, � .._ z . . a � 4� �+a.:. Ar. `�` �� �,��,�V : . �. . �o�d� � ' �, .. � � �, � q'��� � :c', � �` n . + � w���� �� ���, � �r.' p�� w, e� � � �-�- � � �W �A ."'k �" ,q Y Y c,�y, � � .t�. f . w � � d . . I�. ^ 'ha. 'v 1� �-. + � �li f°� � _:µ.,,a ��i j `�` -�,, , , � �,�" � . . 1" . 4 . . '�� �� . : .°' � , �}Y�'!�� � `�` � � �'�' �"^`�" M� �, , M u ,�g _ .�.J6 �r , .,, �"�"�' ����ti�"�� �'�"�� f r� . ��%, ,�►M„ 't�,,, �. '' � "�w�p�'�'�� "' r o . , - ��i-d;a�*;, �' ,-.A �� ""��.e��" „�:x� ����y�b� �`` p��� '�°�, *� f w� " �'�^��n�y,M1 , �� �� } , ; , �� � S� �� � �IY�I��� M� � a d { � � Y � ��16� .W �F�������i ....„�i.. I � M� 4� wa r i . „ �" i � � � „��� ` jd � p�a��� "�u'„�° �"I��t"��+� . � �- . _ , ,� '. �, : :;� p�ry, ,�, r 1 �. �'� ... �' .KM ��' '.: i.. . � u' .. �. a�... �i� h Ip'.a�V� ' *',����� W, � .�^"..r 203 Lake Avenue, Saratoga Springs,NY built in 1922. � �;;: m:������,� � y��.����::ww.. . ��,�� � � � , � �� � ����� b� -�.,m ,�. �� � m �, �� � ��,� � � � - ,� �� � � ���� � ' � . � � a �� � i � �� # , ��� s,� � � � �,, ;;— . Y.�,y , w �'�r�� � �„„„ � , � �' � �f' "' ��' .m�. �.. � � . , � ,� ��, , " , ,����ti4 �.- �°��- i �-.,,�,.,��.... r „ , �,y� :,� � r,� , ....,»� �, ��'� �'�� °fl;�, i o , - "��'�a� � ...� � �u ,. � � . ��� ., �� �_ x . �� „ � rww�I� �� ��I�i�w�\� ° � K � ���. P. ; � � �� , " ,� a ., �.��.�,�_��,�;�-��M .._ � �.. ., � ,, rr,„�„�^�. � �.;�„ -,.:.��. ,.,.. . . �v,""_'�rr�a ,_. �� � .. ..,.._._ , . � ,�- �,a� ��I � �� � ��� , , �� � � �.. �,m� �., ���r-° � , . .w ri � , . �� „.� � .��w, ,��9v� .. �;;. � .,y A,- �t:.�„ � �� � , �, ^ .°� � �� ��� e . " ` � ,ra�� ...� � �� �nMW� . . � + - a� a_' .^ +�"�^�'+!, ���„� � .� eui�'i. l , �' � � m�. � ��� ��'��1 i' � � � � p, y �yy� '. �i _:. �Nl�p:jg � si�. i . a+�v .�,+ m���pa;mo. '�^ a.,wV, �+1�� ' ., + � �„ . .. „q . .. m�mF^4' MF.�.rr� .;Ibb� � ^�'A�WJu�� �.var„�.m��. ., ':�� ... . ,:.' . ,° �ne xal���m��m�n "�aWY�iw}� � ,� �. .,.��� ,. ,�� ..N� � I �'h+� � �"N',,,.�" wu..�.an,r� �r� . ' �,��„ . „ ` �Ww� �., t �, � .. .'�w�ypmt+'�d� .�wm� �'^ . N .�._ `�ai� �a..��w �� y�`� " - -, � , ,�ypwwc� "�+ r k� ��,. �`� ""Yq ' �+ � � '^�y ��„�r . , � w,. ' "°" "` tw �pu "^J �,�» � ��w.. « � ��i �r �". ���,, � � , �. � � �:. � ,� � � � � �, r au, 4� ro , N �" � � � . a � ., �. m,..� _ x. .,., ,,�, W � �-- �r . � � � � , �� - �,. � � r �. " � n s � m� � r_ . s .,•a,� �w . �1l, �+� -.,sy. . � • �'ww�.�`q�� . '� � H a„'L �„Ww���. � ,w.d MF� .. . �� .'�` .,.:� F�"'�o p 4AI�.� .... . . �, r, . �,....., ; a.n ...*s= `.,;��,u wraNlYe.�- ` ' . . .. ..3. - . � , ,:. :.:� � ' . �� .... ,� ° U .� �, ,� ^,�° �, %/ .. ,�,� � .� � . � .. _ . .Ih� � 4 . �a� � �'" _�' . ... .,a � „,�a o �"�•.�'4' , �. ,� ..., �y n . , � � , � ��Y � r 1'' .�A�' m w_ � � ��� �" ���. M I�����+� :. � ���M.a����,������� ��� .,�, �����_� �������t�r������ �.��� ������ ����� ���� , ��� ���"��i� �� �� ��9,,.1��;r'�����;���w ������;a w`_+, �� �� _ j��. �s �� � � � F � ���".�rr� �s �,� � ,.. �������,���� �t a��r ��.���a a � � .'�° �. , '" r w..�. '�„" 1 i� . �.��c ��i���` �� �r�'+i� � �� . ` � ���' m �+tt �R ;��w��b ��.?'q.L,P �.��.��:��'... :� , � � C � � � .� �, �„ � � '" �l�'�`.;�€ ;�"a ;� �i � � ��� � ��`��`��'�����^ �1��1�1��M�'�[,�+,,: �M V�t" �"�!"i��+���� �,�Cr�r '��4�.C�`� �Y 1'��� �r ti � ' � � �er c�� ��a�;r��[�. wr�aa�w �����t����� �'���r����-���' ������-���.-� t���,� �-�::.�i�.i� ' �` � � . t�: ._� m , � , . . �. �` ��r������ . �"a'u�a'� m ° �� e - °"� ` I r ` I '�, v `m`�� �."�w w �� _ .� w !.. � �"��II T I�.�. � �w��„ V R r�e q,�,.�� k���1 l .�.+ 'C���1�&��. �F��"9��y'�m,"'. 4 i w�.�� tlY u�,y���"�..'�� �.��Ik 6 4�9�.. 1N �.r���� : , � �. ,�.� y y� �.y��y� ��y� �,��,���.. ��a�,� �N���'�,,i .�.���;fL�4 1.7� 1.�'�i������SN�� ��'� 4.{�A 1.�4 4y P�A 7.*h� �.�L p��R R 1 4■�� T.���#F`�,��"�^I ��(���"'�Fb�*wY'"`YI'`� . � � .� ' � , r , r r en a���er". 4'�Nd � p ���i�*�1�'�' �.+kti��''.�"�":.°� . `„"�r�C �� ��8��'�#� Y:'�� �,,.[''N,.�B$�N�'" �'ti °�.��L� ��.��.m N�.., �F 1 �',�.:�1. '�M K�# ���I�+�� w� ;�� , 6 m r.,��F a��:,F.. .� . �. o y �6ellwlb W �R � � � n,.1 'F � ..m '� . .w x u i' G..�,; a� 1 6... Y �. ' �"�, h, .�� „. � ,.7� ." .�.� °��,.p����"�. l��.��� �������`�����`7°�� ��rX�� :�� ��"�����5�'�sk��i��r� :.��� a.���:°1 ���.�;° �;"�.. "" „ d � . ��CI � � �'"��r�������'� ���� '���a�` ��,���t�"�4' r° ,����#��;�� ���'�4 �� a��•;�����*1�. „. . ��� �'��A ���������� ��7'1�°��,°� ��4�` �'����� ��@ ��.+�' ���:�������,,. � �_ � � .� � f P ' � ,�� .��f�" { �. ,�,.����� ��:.�`� ���t:����� .���.������. �������N�9 ��_�T �����.��' �����.���1+�6� �a�� �pa:� ���=��t�� }:4�� �:��°��� �::.���� ��w�:�,�;� ����� �.,r'��� ����°,� �,�' ���r:��µ�:�'i�y:.;� u�.° }��y�� + y F y 5�,� Y1 �py y I� q + y7 �J�a��4'W �q 4�.J� if 1�5ii. y 1�'M M+Y�.��'JI IF.'�'i� ���1�,11��1k�li R �M� �F 1 k����}F 4�C�" �A k�.F�} k i. �6� .u�.�, . T r p iR * „ y ���t���.*'�.��.� ���d� a,�Y 1��.'�i� ���..�k 'f'� � h ,�,� P. �,N . ,o :i�, .�. ,,...�J —�..�� .. T ' . ��,�..�"�.�i. ��� �<'�N��� .,�R.'��,,w� � e L "'"�"�-�,_.--._�� ��,�f+�T� ,. . , i r ,, � 'a .� � s�' � ,.: ., i; +, w � � -, _ �,,.�y,. � � ' ,�, �C � +, & *a � �� ',S +j+ w t.1 � � �� � w�-- y 8 ,:k "L�,°� a * � � �" � ' �� ,q— � a;rw *w; w, s � � ��� �t.. G��i � " + ' � �� � k � ,.,� � � . f { �b �, �„ }. " � +,a� ., v+ � . � �m �, a N �"` �.�,�. 4 � �� � � R ��.�..� ��� ,�� � � " �� : ; � —�� � � n �� � w� , r� , � � . � �o ���—�.. �; �- � 6. � .� , ' y�,�`, r {" i �e� ....+a:. .•'�*�. � m � �' �� 1�; u .. , ° u . .. . Y � ip � r �A ,��.'Mf i,, w �' �� ` .r. ` ` � .... � " .,.. ,���.. , ��' r R.* .� � ... ,..!r� . � _y '"t� �"*"��YY ib. �� � w . . _ . _.. M,. � �° i _ F, _� � � ��T �' �.- ��P.4.�"� * r � � �� .�� �4 � � � �:.. �.'.. ` ' W°�{� � a �G.. ! �_ .�.,.�d ' I . M . n. ,,. � '� �� ��� �� � + � —. � �w (� � r ... a y � �ro P � y� ���� v .wy A �. " �a � � , p. ,, b�' � '�tl�, 1�'. �R 1� �1 �,� 0 �" � �nA,'",e.�..,,,��� - T �c ^le � ��. r .. . �_., µ . �`�o- . � , � , � �. ,; "�� �. a �� 'f _'`�"" � 1' " � �. � ��,t }�: ,s�.s � �. ° , P '"„� � _,:.,�,�� � �� �. �"'' "," 0�. � .� �. ,� ,�" � � 6y �.. �� �r �. * ^�` . • ,� ,a °k,y� a d y*�" y, , � r 1 . a '�' , q�t�a � 4 �,. .. . S{ * .n'w � . # � �. -� • �." � � W°W�► o."�_M',. . ,� '� .�in�'pi, a � .. � , P .. a . „„�-«.�r...... .. � p� � .� , , y"# P. . .. �...,'k ,� n .i , a .. . �.� ��,, . . , .,, , � , � ,�� I� . ' - �E ,"`, �. ��� f s �, ,. �a :A. � ,� .�� ,.4�_ .. � * .� � F I "��-_.., w � r , , w. � , . � �r ,�j c��. "�"�; � ! . . ��t'* � n „�� �,, � � . � �Y.,.. , � � e � r,� "�� � ., � � y � ,o ` ' 4 � x '� .� { �� !��'� �n.w._ � y �� .i I 1 V .� � �� �.� �..,.. � ,_��.�„���;.�, ` . ". �ry ' �'�.�`��. "���.....,en 1 ` � , . � � a „ �� �. � �� ,.�W Y g'. t i �� ' a.���'„s+ � ' . 1 � i. -,a._� � 9 � ' � ' Y '1 � � �. . ,,� , . +�,... - • . c . W. -.—,,�„��" �� . , . . �' ''�� '�' �...e"��'i,. �"� . I ' , ,� 4�'