Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20220484 68 Caroline Ext Modifications SPFF Letter • � ��r��t+��,� �rl��� I're��rva�ti�� F��r��ati+��.. �� July 19, 2022 �-���� ���-�� Ms. Tamle Ehln er Chair �-}u�:����fr,,_�..�ci� g � ����� �� ����, Design Review Commission � � City Hall ���" 474 Broadway �y� Saratoga Springs,NY 12866 ,�--� RE: 68 Caroline Street Exterior Alterations Dear Tamie: Board of Directors Adam Fa�ro The Saratoga Springs Preservation Foundation reviewed the plans for the exterior alterations at P�esident 68 Caroline Street. Michele Funiciello V��e P�es�dent The circa 1880 front gable Queen Anne is a"contributing building"to the East Side Historic Linda L.Harvey District listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Sec�etaYy Dmitriy Yermolayev The Foundation is pleased that the vinyl WindoWs located at the second floor will be replaced T�easu�e� with appropriate two-over-tWo wood windoWs. It is also pleased that the vinyl siding and the Tiffany Blair inappropriate,deteriorating plywood on the primary fa�ade will be replaced with a wood siding. Steven Dodds Giovanna D'Orazio Julia Dunn However, the owners did extensive work to the building without Design Review Commission Sandra Fox approval. The Foundation strongly recommends that the Design Review Commission require James Gold . . . . John Haller that the lnapproprlate vinyl windows at the third floor also be replaced with approprlate two- Richard King OVeP-two wood windows. Stephen Kyne Vincent LaTerra samantha Nass The Foundation also recommends that the oWners remove the inappropriate shed roof over the Dorothy Rogers-Bullis mailboxes as shoWn in a previous application by the owners. This could serve as mitigation Sheila Sperling Jason Tnomas for the extensive unauthorized work that the owner completed that significantly altered the Maddy zanett� overall historic integrity of the building. James Kettlewell eme��tus Thank you in advance for your thoughtful consideration. Staff Sincerely, Samantha Bosshart Executive Di�ecto� � � Nicole Babie ��'"�' Membe�ship c�P�og�ams . Dl�e�to� Adam N. Favro Samantha Bosshart President Executive Director Jacqueline Bunge Events c�P�og�ams Coo�dinato� Anne McDonough Cc: Helen&Case Simpson, Owner Admzn�st�at�ve Ass�sta�t Tonya Yasenchak,Engineering America, Co. Patricia Herrick Amanda Tucker,Planner, City of Saratoga Springs Bookkeepe� 112 Spring Street,Suite 203 Saratoga Springs,NY 12866 (518)587-5030 www.saratogapreservation.org „� ,� . x w..� .- ,..._. �„�� � , , , �� � � � r u k . � �, � �� C� !!' � � � k �, ky a �w, .6!' h, �,.�� �u , � �'p�'A' � b' "� ,.�� a. �,m� �� ,�.. T y ,�^r � N � ��t��,”. P � �� F, ,:�i . � ^ � ��"�"r�'y p �r'. , . .. e yri � �� �� �� k .. .. T96. .� y p ._ � .�y"'.'4 . . 1 � ay /u 0 �+�,,�. � .g i • • � � m . , w � L ^ ° M � � �; �. ' „ �.. � �q � t �,..h� . . . .0 •_ ��' -* , � � � '1� r. ' ` , .. .. , , � � . �.�, . ...� � . .: � �,� , ; � . !�" 4 a n r � ., .,,.�� ,� � ' f a�,.' �„- "� �.� � .��,:9 r�� �. .� ��'�� �� n « � .' ' � �, ��^ r � �► ,. �� - , � ,.,'.. . � �"� ' '��d' e � � p ' � ^� p 4 � w., � r � � �+�5 � . � ... � � '� � � ^ �'� ' "s" . " .. P r N', ,' ,� 4 �" � M �...._,.. , � . i� � �r . r1 � . � �. , .�,, �, � 4 � _ , , ," ��,��� �� . � .r: . f... . ... m , , ` � .. , . �. . i �' � . '�. � ,�,W ";'tr '� , y� x'° ^��a i ��,,*" ; , �' e"" , ��i �� '�� " R� R I d 1�f4� y 9 ��� 9 . ¢� � yd t', Swm�� �rr.A���f ,�,_� .,..�u,R�.'M k� �� �4�.�,� �k�� ?�� '��,��P �;��, e � d �,tl i 7 I �.��� w � tl � � � 4� �� � � , n "� 'i iY 9 ��i �T ." �� ' �„�'1F a: ��"a , � � v • W . ._ , y + ,§ '�� � . �. � � N„z� � � � ' �� � ����� �. � �� . ,� . . � � , . �. ' � I'� � m,. m �`� :���.�r�^� „+t °" ,� . �����w�+��a. � �' ���� Gil ''� '�`" �q A ���� � e� ��„�� � n � g� � �s y� ;�'�Y° e,,� ��,.� r. . � �;,'�.�^',�'*"�ac�,',;,�,, ��"' 4,�� � � :�' � 4��V ' � � . ���� "� � q1k € i^. a � m . �r��...°"+_ „a �. „ 4 � ,e. . �� 'I ,r �a �.. + ���'.. � . b � �r°k� � ��. r F :.a ,y, ' 'd � .. ��: . yr�� IN '�"'� � Aa a �� . „ :'r.� °� � � 9 7 :� "�4 � . �"�� , ,� ����'�� u���'��; � �� @� � �- �' ��" �� °�� °�'�. �� "W � � � � �. ,.e � � + � r��"'��q � ; �.. �t��� "�,��. �,+� � � � _ �� � F N�" ,6,�� r., h ; �,: . W # y.. ., ., ,,. u�.,. , q, �t y A a �„�rm R �'/"'W'6�,�' � ' � r, 6 ' �y� w'`y , , , . � g �, .- , � ��'� �i, �a'� t. " 1�,;'.x, �6�'�" . � �.A �,. , ; ��� ���� * ��� w � � � . a Y r V � � � ��4� � �"\ P P � � �� , r ..� �� + ' � ��-� m� R. �b� r k x:: y«_ � � ,��,�� �y�{ � ! �,d�,ti,w �. ` " e . � � T "� � � � � �� ,�.. ° {.�, � � ��.' , . .. "�,�Ah 7� i .. , . �$ c`. i�� � t �� � ��� � , � � . �5 - i-�##�` � s,� � ,r'�.' ''r_- b '� a�, � ��,.'� ��aj'��h"�j ��t ,�.. _ ,��.' � ' � rv T j � Y , � .v�, �'' . r � � " ' � � � �• dl'� � , , � h, �� �� � - e $ �y�( � �• '� � � ,s?��. � - �� ^ �' �' ,� � , . - , , �r' � �.�. . ■n. .k .� �..;. }� ..,q , . �`,:h 'Pf ��b.; ff I.#� ? �a � M 1 � � i.�` m� � s i F. � � k �. o � {J�s �... ._ � � � ;. re. ,... �� .' " ,Y,` '� R i �y � &,P�@+ ++�� '�� 4 � ���� i,��. ;�f�m.,.� .������,. �i�,� � t +� ,��',_ m. � P �,,t . ��^�"��,�' '���.�")F d ��' r�i� ��`�c��+� .x , �• �r +� � `r ...,� , � ' �,�p t � N ,"� � +..`— '� �' ���,,,w i��+����{��� ��'��'..�„����� ��;, -�"'; � � . � �`� � . ., � � � � �Sa ��� p �° ���' r `� y�,° y�F � � d �, � � ''�„����t����„� .a,� °" �� +,�,�r� , w o� -y,"" _, , �Y, �" r� �y� �a w� � :: �' ��' � b�J ,. r �� �� �� �� �'�� � �M .. � i�.�e 4�� y.* . ., �� ' _ � � * � "ati�W.. .l..� �)�r�� � ��� , � . �F � �, � � • �. . . ... .., : , . :. � , � . . �� . �. , .. q� , .., �,� . , g . d r . ,�s I. � ��' � . � w.., , . ., ��� �� * ��,. . • f TM��'S ° � � fl ..... � „ ., A ��W 5, �A ry '�,� f,;� . M.av�� o � Y ,��,� k I^y'.�` i-r,r��.��1N . , ' � " � m�" � � f fl•s � & � � ^� � ��� �`d °�.. _. " ' :,- �. � �� :. ���W . � , � 'Y F .�.w+ ., ,� r � .• �,d' v ,. V` �,�+�� at� ^�� ,�.F. ��� ' ;�&�x � � � � N�,� y� � 9 �',�,' w. �F�� t'`��'II�&�� �� . .� � �� ��, "� � � } � � � . Y ^i `�r,,�g�"�j°�� � ` � _ .� q�,, � . . , , d � '� �* � 4&b ��� � ���� '-" ` ����,�' }� ��' h ,,. - y. � 's�" t�� � � � , ..� � �y �"' �,.' „�� . , �� � f i���. ,� w r.0 "'.�� �.. ,� W Y ;:i.� �„ 4� . 4r " r-' � •��,�q.�` +'�� ��'�F � ''�+;�",� �" n � na� W � I 1 � �� � � . . • �,7 �, w�4 �Y �,� u ���P m ,_ ,� � �� .. . , . � �� � � '� � ° ` r �', - ' „ �G�� � � „��f_ . . . ��.� , � � ; r� �� � ,�� ��- +„� .. •� -V� 'Y.. � .�. . ' �.. ^ w+, ., 4 "� ��N ` �V' � . .�.. ; i a�'v" M �#�„ 7� .� y,� Mfi � {�. � ��� T�� y , � LL;,ij,.� r» '� ��,�� ���,°� � w . . i �� �� ��,��',� # �. '1r � � '�q= �w ..� �, -�,�.,�r��. W .'I;, � �' � � G �a �M� fi �r� d ''d�! ,P �' �. �,. .. t'��,C .��. �ae'yq:, . ,. � � � �' � f b w 1� �, }y.�� � ��� �a wi � � I • � M1 * .� ~ �N �, � ,�� �t ' . ^x�� d��� ,� , � ��'_�°' j!.� ry ;.,„A. , * �^�r��,,�'�' �`"�� �d� � '4 ��+. M �� m . .., ,...� +T�u . ''.� �, � ° � P, � � , +� � .�� ��� . � ,. . ... . , . �`�� � °� �y" � y��s& ,��. ,p° ,t� '''� x�g9 P ��,`��� .�� � � ,,.°a �N��' ����' x � R�'� �y ,��r,�'� Iv��v'��^� P"' �u a# �� � ��.'��'�y�" �"w6 y� .��1 W�'�"ti, .� . � ��`r _qr� �� v,' ,3�e'��.. . t"�e �r �.�,'�� "��qt�'4° � * ' ��'� .. '. ' f .. � � �Y�.[ � �5r`r� p°"� . � �k '""- '�', ��P'�v . r � ,. � �'�-, �^° �, & g + W?�f_ � ,� y'�°'�#.� °� p � �' � Y,� , H:^� r ;�.� �Y�=am , , �� i, -�m'k� �a'� �N •q � �4�m� � R� �' � " � � „,� .��+ �d �� � j. . , ' 5 . 1� •� ..���','Mli !'J�" � ��� ���"• ��� �. ���NIR�q ��ix,. � ' � � . ..+�� �. "�#,�4 er� ��'�� ��' w, �y 9�'n��u�rl ���1`� ~� ��a �'�,* r � r"` ' � .m �� b � .,, , ��° .i' ' �a �„� � �'�*�� �. , m. ��r•#rp � . ,.'F � y� �p�° �� � -"`��� �', �="„f��� p _ �' . 4 .� fui'n�'��� � y'�4w 1'' s' �� *� J��� 7^ �� ti ,o �.9e'; `�"^�� + � �� � ,�� y �a„ p , a „"b�i ,. � - i � �_ �w,�.+^�., ������ �'`n a ,�C ,� , �,��, r��w�' °�� ��� ti�' �� , d � ,.,. , .,�. ",�r. N�y� � '�,,,"r�,, � r�_. �i��,� ." .Wm, � '1 m ���y 1��sI� �� d��• ..�P �.�Y� �' Y.�"R 4 '1k` ' '��h F�iN i°�t.. t 1 , j �n. -{� . c�y 'Y F.. ' � �'v r ,; ,r �. ,r� �,,,�,�',.'�'�„� �" .�. �l ,b4 . .,p � < „�. � . m .I i"I .,,: ��� a � ��i �°�,��' 4�'� �,.�+���� �� a F � ,�..� .... �' „� � � � .. . .. ., „� . . .. . u ^-• ,. � � � � „ �.. -.� ..��",..�r ,h. i „, . cy „ �,: ,a ,;� y v� .� � ��'� ��'�m�"�.�'� J j, �� � . �-,�ry �..�� `.��. . '�� �..�y ��."�,��'w•��,. 4 y , ��. �. .. '°' � ..,.,�, �mw��:3u� :q'��� �"�, ����W�'���It� ,�� + �Y .��' u..� r c�K q�"'"�"t'� �m M4d��Y1 .. �., � � , � �., �_ ,� ",.. ,� �� „,�"rua.w .�f f��� �Y.. , " ,.� a�'w.Ym.�� m �* P r ���p�dl� ,., W :�.�' �.� �"« L�` �� �,.�" ' � .- � � f w� �, a �.: g�,'"'��§n'�,�,�� �,�.s 4'� . ,���,. X Ti�, �, ., �., ���`��"�;'�u ;�°f��h, ,;� ��' , .... , .P � � � + yyy �m,� ' ,� � �r � ��� ,��,� .. �� �, , ,„����,�i' � �� �. �T � µ.�* �Q.����#�� y�� ���p�� k�' .d �� �. �i.a � . ' x. �'t M�u�^t��Ma��p A"�k �„�, y�" � 4" � }V�V�," S""' p�M'��� h l. � , ,. � ' � �� �� � ��� ,� „M � I��J�,��1 � y r �� �`� q �� •d _ .�,u � � �" ` .Mu+�t��� u v "������I, q�,�ky 1'A�W ...... ��ea+RAwm"��� � ���� r�A'��. r a ar e �E M v � p��'r4 .�� �, �� �++,..rmw,��.. .W�'� �� z" "'�'"� °� .,�'L��`�. . �-�-`�- -_- n�r.�'' '� �"� + ����` , � ^��� �° ��' �►',� a'" � 1�„�,31 � . �r p ' ,,.a ^; 4 . . . r+r rr. ' ; � . xW��l .,. � rW I '. � ,J�4' a � � A�p�'��� � a'e�'r�� �"� . a+*� y e `'. * �i 2.F � ��� . ;����� '..�,�e+�•a��w.,..,.._.� '.'^8 i � ��` # ,Y.�'d� ��: �,.. � � �� . .,„ ,,�-�+.'� *'��V �� r "M•+�„"� tt... �.v. ......� ,m_� �x'. .e^ � �a,�.y o " » ,. . . _._ ,.. . . ,:�. , . , � ,¢��,. ,� I.,.. i � +� � _ ., u, �i,w . ,� "" � �4� '� w ,;"��1 s ti . „ M s�.�. M (, o0 *. � � � .... .,,,vYM!n :y� ..',.r,.. s'x"� ,' ,c .. � ", ' � �r.�.�...,b �:�.+WwTa'`" k��'� � ' � m,s.Gw.� ��� ,��'4 , ^ �g� �l.�.iw.�'' ��,. � � �k �W ��` reri�5i w":rr� s,«Xm M��.���,.aw � ` �� r �., i � �e x°�"�£"A.�xadP�,Nr�''�,}� . .�l . . �"hetire . � n . '"x " � a,�, "^,�f^ �� � :,��o � µn w�MI S� �� ; � �., ��,�.,���� ��y�, �<<.... �..,�,,.�.. � � "�e,� `'A� �"� ��' '��� ,��.5�'P.. b u.� �w � �+� "� °�'� � � � ' t� � ! ,� 'Qm�,ow �� ,�.� .ro, �� . .. �r r., ,., ,. . q�: $ ��X ,.4. �`�.�, . r 4 �, � `' �� . �. o- j � ` _ �-. _ E ��s �� � < „� v� �y � �. ��, y � � � �� � ��� � �, � � �� u r�` � � �'��� ` . u. . ry �� �� �i�, . ' u' . . 5 .'.;� G ' � y ���1 �' � ��,i ti.',.. ,.��„ 'f ,ns �y$ . . v�� .:' � a � � �� ��Y �'" 7� ���°°'R , � M Y tl M ���_,'.�� . :s .. � Y, �W �� ��� �°� � � � t . �d ✓r� � �,"P� �_ ��I^ F.. �,., W',� I �--n,��r�� ��+Y� � � ''�� ,�v �:` Y Y m e I o 6 a ���� � �w � ��,f �"nm ' x U „yN � $��� � {� `� ��qI � { �� +, i � � 'x (r.�.I.,a�. i�Y�� & U.l6H.�� .. "I�M yw�, �' � � .� . W � � y � 4�xd. 1+� � �^�$�W � � � v , ,� � � . . W � � . +. . a � F t, 4 _"._._._ 'y, _. � A y� ! �' � * i(f �°i i� � . . 9I � I�p fu ' . , . �., Y -M, 'C � y�l '. r yu . . � 9� �'������� '�W, ��� � d.. N.,��� . . . . � � � . �' ., � i .,� � k i fl^ w 4,p v w, �� k; . . . �'pt � Yc'.a �w�p r, �"�� ..,� � ..� . „ :8's'r �� "'y�'� ,� j � ., � �� � �., , F� �pF .:....�..� " � � �� �. � . ., . � , , . �, n �F, ^, � � �, �„ ,, ° �^ �, �, r' �° � ' r�� '"'� �� � � � . � � , � , �� - m . � , � � ia � . ,., �� ' � . `,ti, y��, ,j�i. ,ef��"r r,C.i , ,. � ��, �,�}��4 �i � . . � d � I�I� °�� - � � � � `' . , ^� , s�,r f .: , .X ;� a�a. "�, i H . , ..I. ,.� . �Y'.a R �r �s ..� �Yt _ m , , r�"'°".'�'° ° {,< j �. � "��°;� , � � � ' - � �� w.,,�, �� � . �.d �u'� . , � ,� "" t'r!+ d r"! . .�. .�� , ,� m ws�.� .. . � � r x i �, � - �� ��. �. � ����� I , . � •�� � . � . ��. � � � � �,. • � f , . � j� , , � f � � � x p J� :. �. �r�4 � � " � f �,. ' ry� � n P �. � � � d P� ' ; , � ��,nn.,�...m.���,.,..__.....�..„m.�,.,r,�+rP ' �� �d � � +MR � x.r� - �, � �S r � - ,� . , . �._....� y�� � � . �. - � � , m ��� �I.1�. . , '"wM'�,., �.�r �"-'Fa � n �r u � . � ",�,.° ry�w" "� �, � a� ° y � � a '' �' ���',�'`���`� �`�� + �,,+���,,.�,.,�;"..� _� � � � �'��� „� „N .�� �� / d��' �� � ' � +�U h !�,'° `'o-,a i �,.o-,' i � � � .. � a � ,�1" �ar�k� a u, "' f , , tl� I F .rN C\ !��'�N � � ��, � -�� b �. . .. F ,� a � t . � t ,�h t; '� � ' ����a,�'& � 'S�(� n� ry'� „ti �,. n * , � � � `' � � � �i �y� m p � ��. . y�� .� ,� [.i �' ���.. .����o..i� ,����7) �afi��... ����& �o� � �:�, �� ; 9 �� ��.��� � ��� r , .�Y: �� f. � — . �� i16� �� �6 r. � "� a u �a .� � -' �r .,,. � * J 9�� ��� �� Tw^�,��"'A°� � , ' �� t „ � v �+ r �� �+ a ra `� � �� � �� ' � ���,�A� m ,�h � ,� � �.�' d" �V .�.�,,. � � �, � �� , . ., � ��'�� d 4�w..���� �'� �. � e. � � � E .. � � . �"s•`. � � i `" ��, ���"��� �� p� k��o����I , M� . p � � ��'�� �� �F�..� i i � � � 4 I� �. �@� �� � � � t ¢ ' � � � � y�, ,�,;� � a �u" � '� �7 �. >.� �,. I '� ,y'� ; ; � . ��,��k�' 4 Y�i � � ".�I � 'D .t _,�b�,.-� ��^� � � k . , �� i�P''s,�4b s.� 4�@. �4 � - ����� � q � � � � a �,��� ���. .� � € ` ��� ��A� ��"�y, � �� �� ;� � �(p `�� �.%,`� .B� �'� ' r a` �Ciirp��y �f,, ,'".'„�A �°�s+ �`�''�v. � �� �� � & s 0 y Y f � � �µ � ��� f Y� � � + „ fi: ��� ��"° � «� " ,, � w�' � f � � � � . � � �� s,� M � � �� .� �� u. � , �y; �,� �'�"�a b ''�'` �� y � �� � �ar ��� ��,. � I"'�� � . �.� � � � � .d. � �, �'k' �,r"� � . � � �,n � �� i i ; ��� ' X� `�� � �� I, � � V � � � %�, �' � � ,' $ � d i ����, � � � i � n�`.�, "�. � i '���`� t �' � �,.�, �" ���i��,'II�IfIi������,tNr��IIrIIjIII��III i�I � �}��r�+ � , ���Y° � �� r � � � � � � �'�� `� I�II���,ri�tilll il,�Y III �i ��y i�" i1 w '� � � �t ny�, :6�:'. • .i � .° Q , � . e � � ",.�@', �r �p �'�. , y��, 4 p�� 1 � i �� j � � �� �"�' rW 1° �MMy � x. ��� '�Il �I� ,� . , , �, , , —.. . a � , �� ,� ., � , , ,n , ��.,�� �, , : � �������� � � � , � �