HomeMy WebLinkAbout20200735 Excelsior Ave. Apartments Labella fifth review letter �� ivj�+�'�v`'i:,a�'� M�.�� ��i`�i".,�°w.r�':����r..r.
��,
�une 23, 2022
M r. M ichael B. Veitch
Business Manager
City of Saratoga Springs
474 BroadWay Saratoga Springs, NeW York 12866
RE: City Designated Engineer Services for Site Plan application and SWPPP Revievci - 5t"
Submittal
Excelsior Avenue Apartments
Excelsior Avenue., City of Saratoga Springs, Saratoga County, NeW York
City Project No. PB#2o2o0735, 20200736
ProjeCt No. 2221175.02
Dear M ichael:
LaBella Associates have completed our revievci of the follovciing materials received:
• Comment Response Letter, prepared by The LA Group dated May 4t", 2021.
� Stormvciater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP> prepared by the LA group, dated
October 14t", 202 and revised April 13t", 2022.
• Site Dravciings entitled "Excelsior Park Apartments", dated October 14t" 202o and
revised April 13t", 2022, prepared by The LA Group unless noted otherWise, consisting
of the folloWing 15 sheets:
o Cover Sheet
o S-1 Survey prepared by Thompson Fleming, Land Surveyors, P.C, dated
September 16, 2020.
o L-Z.o Site Preparation, Erosion &Sediment Control Plan
o L-2.o Site Layout& Materials Plan
o L-3.o Site Grading Plan
o L-3.1 Site Drainage Plan
o L-3.2 Site Accessibility Plan
o L-4.o Site Utilities Plan
o L-5.o Site Landscape & Lighting Plan
o L-6.o Site Details
o L-6.1 Site Details
o L-6.2 Site Details
o L-6.3 Site Uti lity Detai ls
o L-6.4 Site Uti lity Detai ls
o L-6.5 Site Uti lity Detai ls
Note that there vciere no SEQR Materials received vciith the application materials.
� �riti�h�m�eri�car� Bl�� L��h�rr�, f������� p ����}���-����
Y"� 'ro'ti %r"w,�.t.i Jv"'.�r��.�i`-.r'^w��+�P Y u�
Excelsior Avenue Apartments—PB#20200735,20200736-5t"Submittal Review
June 23,2022
Page 3 of 4
Follovciing are our observations / comments. Comments follovci the original numbering in
our March 21, 2022 letter. Comments that have been satisfactorily addressed are not
repeated; nevci comments / clarifications are presented in bold.
Site Plans:
1. Please provide a signed and sealed copy of the boundary, topographic and utility
s u rvey.
The applicant has responded that they vciill provide the signed and sealed copy
upon final site plan approval.
2. Please shovci the limits of the existing easements on all sheets. It appears that vciork
including erosion control measures, paving, proposed catch basins, and grading,
may be proposed on Lot 4, ovcined by Excelsior Park, vcihich is outside of the existing
cross-lot and parking easement. Please identify any additional easements that may
be required to accommodate this vciork.
The limits of existing construction easements do not encompass erosion control
measures�inlet protection� on Lot 4. Please expand the easement limits to
include all required vciork areas.
3. Please provide a signed and sealed copy of the Subdivision Map.
The applicant has responded that they vciill provide an updated subdivision map
upon final site plan approval.
SWPPP:
13. The final SWPPP should:
a. Be signed by a responsible corporate officer, general partner, proprietor,
principal executive officer, ranking elected official, or duly authorized
representative; and
b. Include a signed copy of the Notice of Intent.
The applicant has responded that they vciill provide the signed copy of the SWPP
and Notice of Intent upon final site plan approval.
2
Excelsior Avenue Apartments—PB#20200735,20200736-5t"Submittal Review
June 23,2022
Page 3 of 4
We believe that all of our technical comments have been satisfactorily addressed, and the
remaining comments in this letter can be addressed by a final submission to the city.
If you have any comments, questions, or need additional information, please do not hesitate
to contact this office at 518-273-0055�
Respectfully submitted,
LaBella Associates
,
.
Jennifer Nechamen, PE
Senior Civil Engineer
3