HomeMy WebLinkAbout20210315 Ingram Garage Addition NOD 0 GA
N`fi Tamie Ehinger, Chair
CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS Chris Bennett
{. 5
Karen Cavotta
i DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION Leslie DiCarlo
�a • Rob DuBoff
, ���
Tad Roemer
City Hall -474 Broadway
,.> Ellen Sheehan
rn Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 Jeff Gritsavage,Alternate
Tel:518-587-3550 x.2517
www.saratoga-springs.org
NOTICE OF DECISION
In the matter of the application
#20210315
Ingram Garage Addition
207 Nelson Avenue
Saratoga Springs, New York 12866
involving Historic Review of an attached garage addition to an existing single-family residence in the Urban
Residential - 3 District,tax parcel #166.61-1-I I, within the City of Saratoga Springs.
In accordance with 6 NYCRR Part 617,the Design Review Commission classifies this request as a SEQR:
E Type II action — exempt from further SEQR review
And, in accordance with the objectives, standards and guidelines contained in the City Zoning Ordinance Article
240-7.4 Historic Review, the Design Review Commission issues the following decision on July 21, 2021:
❑ Approve as submitted or shown on the attached plans
E Approve with the following conditions:
Applicants to use vegetative screening to reduce the mass of the concrete driveway.
Note: this approval shall expire 18 months from the issuance date unless any necessary building permit has been
issued and actual work begun.
Record of vote: motion to approve made by E. Sheehan, seconded by T. Roemer: passed 4-2
In favor: C. Bennett, K. Cavotta, T. Roemer, E. Sheehan
Opposed: T. Ehinger, R. DuBoff
Absent: L. DiCarlo
As a result of this decision, the applicant:
E may proceed with the proposed project as approved
Please contact the Building Department to verify permit requirements.
July 28, 2021
Chair Received by Accounts
cc: Building Department File
Accounts Dept.
Applicant/Agent
Page I of I
,.
,
,
,
i
4 j ,
. , H
'', 1 1 '•
l' -----,
---
-4,...s. .,-..
-f:-.
i
, , i'
,,, ,' •H , 1 H " iiiii,,2
',/,'. +.' '', ,' '- - ''r -- -
t
' /./.1 '; -7 . '
-ii, s.C..
„,..,,-
. -------,- ' t. `k .I.'''',.:, '1.
,,
,/ 1 ,, il'....',':'
, ,, , , , , 1„,,,.. -4-----, cr,< .
1 -_..
v,, L
.,
.: ',..,;,-..
.-- .„''''' -------------..., .-7...-,1
- nil.
.
•
' ;' : 'p111 •
.„ ,
- ‘ 11=" --
ttsv ,
-'
1
''t' LiNii f
azs,. k,:- t,,--- ,,,,-"r-', ,,----------,:,..'iints• -. , .,___ . f, ''' t',...;'1 ..'f'
_ , -1,,: ,`, ',.+ , /
---- ,4,1.1,' ,. '' 1 ' ''' .•*
,----- ,'--1,,1 . - -- ---1 1 '
--- --
-- '',, ----------- '1,1!.7.•;','," .,,,-'',.,,.:-::::,,, . ,• , ,,r,,,,',.:.,,P,..zR --,:f..':"I
f:',';',"::"`,'.;r,„,_' ,._ 5c,;,4
1 - , 11: -.'::,,,,•,•,',.i.:.!.,`,4,-",S,!„,',...',.',.',;'','''',','',,,,','';',,rill?,'r!',... ..4 ,- i i ' —•
'. 9k' '':'''' --A:::°:1,•-•,- ''''';'".,,,,,','''''''''''''' ,::;;,.1,,',,:""i *.1
":••••',7..;,',44-42",''.'I-7n4',767.'71!... A ';&?-nII
,,,'..,fi,,'•:.;/,.,-,-,c-:,,..7,,,,,,;:;o:,,,r-iiii,,,,,;,..',II-i.'k,' II --/'/1----
.
4 ..:,''-',1'•••',.
1.,
" ilil'• ----- ,Illailliiii*Wagr-77,11''!'!.i .M. .,...:4!1/: ',--- , : ‘:1 f 1 ',,,,N -. . '
,,.1
,_4,,z,,,,,
."/ I ift, :7,-,Iff;.- -i: ''.. ' j'Y',..°-..,,,,•,1I'1-1!,1 4:-..,gV.i"7- '...."----77,1 ..-' ';',..',..„,,,,,,, ,,i,i,'"-,:t1 J,,,,,I '6,;„'s
, '..,,,,7 1 i ILI
c•,,,i-',:',,'--;•-7A ,,::,..,.„#]2...,--,1,111 .-:,---,. ;1 - ,1 • ..,,,,„,i`;1.,,,7
, ''s-'-''L;:l'i.'cli'' ''' ' " ....,_'
,,,i.,/ :'', 11U-11:1 77,7:--,,,, ,,.,., ,'..1,„,:i. ., :--.-7------
'' ' . i, ' :_._1_,,...' .)11:'':,f!'::-,ji; -41.1.i:I 1 1 1 ':' ,,,',i . I l_li, ''''''''',,,;:.7,., : r,''''• ,,,,,,,,x -
I. 1/ • ,.1 .1:,, ._-_,..1.,::_e i:ri'li,',1-' ',`.--Ni.-.& ---
,,,,_
';if/ l'.. ,,..p.A!::.,-.----- -: ,:, l -.., :_.__
/
' ' f7---,---r-z7-',7,--::IIIIg. ,-.,.."2,;;; Z,/,f, i_-, •: '.,:::,, (3':,; ,1_,A W N. , . i
`,,, '•, ' ! ,:,9 'J I ' i'' f 'i„.;.,1'1"',"':, :,-Z.-'".'" ...
'-`,,. ',. 1 11 i i 1 i H :'- ' '0't,'111.:'.. .4-=-..:,..,--- --:::•it- 11,' '11111,-."! H H • ' ' '
' '' '11' '' 'r i'1- 1, • '''',1.1.1i,;,' -1,77777----77-# r', '',:r!,',,,,. • 1 ' ' .
.' ''1,,P0 '
,- 7 ,,,_,--' i : •-----z. ------L. 1 1,--,-----
,
1 I 4':. ', :. .„ -i ., . . ;.4, k
,:,,,--,:,,,,„,,,„..,,,,:,,,i..,:r .,1„ ,,,,: 0--..,.„7„.1 '. ';.,,, ..q
•
„.,,, ----- . --- ,:t H ',, '6 -.,,,..„:„. „.,,,,,,..„v„.„,„..":„.,,,--„i4..,,,.‘,3„..I. • .,.:
_ rx.,,,H.P,„',•:,.,, s,..„, F... , 1 .i :.1 . „ L::;::[iiiiiiioikooxtoi„I.'. •
' -,.,'';l'''• •'• \1 '
'", 1".J':, :''''-';‘• 1.---' •L,-Li ,„ ' . •
•.• 14 1
•
,
.'',;'. : • 7; 4--------.. ,'• , a
• t,. s ,,, , -1.!---------------- ii,---.!),-,, , ir • Elt
;, .:,-,_'.---7:,,,,, _.:.,_,_, ''' it L„
, .011------, . , , ,,\-,..,,„
.
, •- _ , /, , -7,t
i-11Hi UT L. I- i '... all'ILI- '14,''''''.. _
-
.
. • .--,°.,..,
1 -
, '' - ' , • 1 , -
1 '•
I '
.
:.1.---
li •
. '''' t'. I ;
- ; __1:. •
.. . ; ! . , ' ,,
.! ' - -; 1 - ;
, i 1-. .0 . I '
•
; ', 1--.P,,,L.. ' l'1 •
,
;;i____ _ _ — 7--
,i'$'77,4.1p-j, ' 4
----gr?,1', 4- ----_-- -
,
,..,. ,,,,,,
•
•
.
..
1,-'T-- 1 •
---”.e4
.
I , ,
. . .
-..
.. . .
., ..
.: , , ,,..„,.•- - - .,
Y
,
}f
1 .
' - , i. , -,
i
. - ,, ,,,
, .
. ti 111 -.A a-01A
, i.„4,01..ifv... lia.e:,;"--rd.:11-i:...,/,.a2L ,,... ,
., , }
,.,... I . ,
a . „
, ,
i Iloilv,„201 ,,,,,,,,,.0„3.,,„,,i,I. . j, , 1 .
, _ prik: . i
1 ,
_ . ,,,,101,,is.,,,,,,id '-il-';i71 - i ,_
/1./ / . .
wii f
d .,.. _ - .
, 1 1 1.4 .
i 1 • ' „ ,,P m,,, • iyit_______.; _____y_
_W
., .. /1
i I
[ ''',7:t2t/'',.,,4-VA2_____.relkl---V-2-d.---":1-1, - - HP"' ,
a ,1
L..„:;,..:.:*-1.5.tV,M.,1441221
_ — „,,„ ...,,,k ,,. . ,
_ .„,
Iti---1 : .. ,.,,.,,d ... _____..,..„,_ , ,i, $1LLT1t , ..
!I
„;
n
i
, 1. ti.-,,-,::1
-:',--,:,',.:::,7.7gi.,:ov.,-,-,,„-,—.:::_..,X;a2V,,,,6; 7.-Th-----4-V
'4; 1,...
f
i ':*:':.' i
.3
i .' ' 1 1 • IA'- -2,-,-'''''':.: 4,T101.1, '.” '''''jt .„.„..,. :, ,
xa n i S ,Vii{ , Cr". .7.1-;G'_3 'mssa, b
r 7wt'' d ./^.#
i .,. ` . _ aw. ',',''
Ey
g
G fifi _
. _Hi; . ,i_..., ,,,
„........ .._.........,:,
,_,
,..„
... ,
_ .,
, ,
r},S s,?�f ,... ,,,..„4„,.,,,
,.. � !° ..,y I .: r T'�.tM'aL or
' I .i'l ,,,,,,'1
f
7l j
,
.:,.. H'r,.!,:,..- '1_,,, _,,,1:1.__T, ' .
,„,,,,,,-,,,,.. 1 :,,,,,, ,,',..‘ ,—...4.!-. 'I'll .
•
..._.e, '. 1 5 } I ',
1 ,,i;::'.;::._ _
i 1 , •Y
Sq �J� ,r r 1 ` ,
VI! 1
r g� r
k.! .-1.7-7,=7"—_,'.;..lifiti. ,. , ..__. t. A
}
r - `
...__. _._...___....___�._._.___w__.W_._ ....__.. :.� ...__ ._�...__. .
a k1 1
ii
i f
j
i
o
,
, i
: ,,-,-T—..7.-, 1 Emu_ i t
t
€
4 3, i ( li i .ii :
• i T y 3 �1 3 - I r
ii IF
! t
{ ' I iS •
f _
�f j Q'�
r • ,' iA E F } ,1 •.• ,! Y
• 1'f E ' fi 3 tT
01 s , . i'li' i t • I l``i • � t i
' L. •
Ni\1, ii, 1' i ' i I t• '• ,}} r ' • gp
p i f (; { E•i h f !'
4 ,
,..' ,: ': '4 i t , .', i ' t,1,,,.: , , ... ''il.1''., ''. .-,---.1-,--4, —,r-,
3 'ft, ` ¢ E E i 'i _r. ,tk ,gip, :‘,..i'
, , '''' .'','1,' •rd', '''., I I; ''';', ' ;`,:',.' , ' - '''..' '. ' - I ,,, -:,;,,,,I „__,01,„1 ,,
, 1. .,i y g a[�i 1
1:'T , i 1 4'. '4) 1 ' ')1'),:, .f..:'.: , ' 1,' ,...---h. i. ‘) :. a., , ..4,---,,,,,' - ,Fi ,,,:,...,1,, ,' —
,
H
( 3's '
1, ,
A jE '1,
p
9. ,,,,,--,0.,,
.,,
t''' . ' i I ,'-'"'-';'10,1,),
6 r. } _.,,,,.may
, G ,i
3
9 •-!."1-- ' 'il.''. . , Ill-ki
' '°'''',.',.1?-,,
r r
I
.-.±-J-1,--4-----, '''''.•H',.\'„,i, . ,
{
� i"
k
_ t,� ,
-- ; , , , i, 1 ,Eat
11 o i ' t, # 1 1 i � i , o 9 ,4
i � ; € 4tp { 1 ' 1 ', • ' t 1,1,. 1'
pp)) f i r
i' '' ' ' ' ' . I , ' , i , i 'i .lj 1 ;, , .. : -..''''
r d
,'„,, iii,' ',.'i ' '', i. '1, '. H i 1 II '..,'1 'I.'i'. 1 ___.. ,
I.
'i i.i., , , ,,, , 4 , i ., , mi
, ,
' „
_ . .,, . .: ,, 1 i ,,: ,..., ,. , ,
,
,,,,! , : . , ,, „ ... , . ,, , ...,.._ ..._ ..„, :_„.
.. ,
„,
, ,
_ ,,,. . 2,•
. .._......, i',,qui:,,:,,,': ,, , ',,,,r-_,,..,„:_._:,..,, ,„, : ,
, . . ,
-,,,,,, , ,
,..:,....._.„..,_... ,., .,
;,...---.....=,-,:,, , ,
,,- --,. ,,, , ,i.
9 li' i ..' a i
Vj,..
k
�i
f
- 4; i C
i
r.
i
' V '
_,,.2,., ._,
-k''',
i
3n
: '-',,,-!'171..,5:,
:, 4, ,,
, ,...,,,,,,,
t i „,
, ,
.., . ,c,. ..
,, ----, ,:
, , .
, .. . , ..,-. .--•,- ,
. , ., . , --..,„ i ,„
„,,,N m.,,,,, ,,.
•
. •_, ,,, i ,_„. , . *, ,
,,
±-1. lc',
, .t.,,,L.',..,.- 4. .'' . F4 ,L,
,.„.„..,„ .
.,. „ -17E..
1
i
t 4 y t l Y{+ `"Ti—z'rf:} a.. ,a.stunx�e,<,...,:.-,ua�...-m.. :0,,,!., ' :60 .
• . r
At
rr t t�Y€�3�� r i ri f• , '"""""'.k` 1�ttt - V �r � ': ��� �b
:
: ,1:'-,',•:. ',,,ii u Al t aiiiimm, , i -,-,,,..,j,. . , mum„ Tm., •
I
•pi
ni)tgg ,,ii„,,,,,,
max. ,,J.' 1,41'.,,\�l
, I I,. .,,k,,,i4-i .:j, i ,, i i I 1 '.1.HP,Hol. ; l'i
,Iil'..;..,.,di.,..c,, , . , t! , , , , .A1,,,,,,,,,), , '41 ni,.,,,,,, i.i., '..-51:--,L ,.
3 s
1:1(,,31i.,.•`;4'. /.' li i i. . '''• 1 t `,', . ;', ',”, ' i'','," ,1: iv 11. ' '' ' " —
ik/// :••• ; 7----7-.'. ''.,1,,.' 'i '. '''4! (.i. '
0 ^ ..'6t kk L
111TTT���
, y
A / Yi• 1 .,' alag ..1 •.i•r-'"f,,,c.,'„, 'T.--- .--' : 1. 1 ! *,i, ,
, / / ,,i's'! ..a.lp
1....111.:�E�l,•5i1j
r
E
i
Y ',--:---' '' ---- t ; , ,, i
6 41,'''' `� _. i „,,,,,q, ,,,,
q t p v
d �
Y
'''''','4' ''' \ , ,11=I ' '1.4 , '4 44 4.,,
',"',,\ .' ; f nal,, .,, ,,...,,
, a:,
bi: 4 1 r'
. i
; x l 4E9 n 4'' ,' +.
Y`� r:� as � ..,,i , •
ti{� _ � 11 — !g j� � :
i '1 11 ',1 1;'1).1,,
,-, :I ,
r , i ,,i I' ; I ' 1 i'' - ' t
1
, A
. . ..,.,. 'i !)'' '"' ,.' , 'I.'' '''/', ' ,. tt.i ,
W I.
:
° I
{ 1 w i ' i - ,,,,,,,,,,, r{ •.
71 to
;.-, / , , - , -- _ -- ','•0 .
AFF �,
ii 1 't —11 , ,i ,
, 1// sY 1... 16 ` a `P R a
i
r ,,,i'1
\ \.. — 'jl il iiil - ' '' '' lli i 0 41
\ ,,. ' , 'i 1! ; i ',,,,, i i 1 ',. •', ;,.. , ,
, —4- ,
, , 1 1' i • '', i '- ', '
. , VI ., ii ,, 1, i ' 1_ ,, i . „
\•1. .1 —__,.. , _..._,......2 ' ..
•
N
,
\i,
i +c .. ' lir SO' lam* [ �' "
'1 F'
r . ,...- ......,_
0
7 . : V 1 ' gal ''''', V.? ,,,,Lo:,
am - tb, r,,2...i)I" , , , (t. ri. .....
4.,,,===!b N.10,,,, 1- .
• /le; 1-- - . ., 'L'''''" ',,,),,,,_,,,tr. ,,.,,11 40.
II jj '3\s,........„. H
P .
..
1i M . -
t.' i [ 1 _ _ —
:—
7
c......4....r_„....._ { \\L„...._...
.R 1
'i,
_ a
,
'J f ,,
ir--- c ,,,,, _
",1—
, , ,
1 .7:1- Li
'' \....._,.....„./,': ' ' ... :.. ' '', i'lr,''•-•-=_:::1___r , '.,,,
,... 7 cc., __
r ,� --+sem' a9„,,,,„.,,,,,,.;,. 1�
(„...____Lic........_„....._/,
,. ---.---------
F w,
.,...
i , , ,,,--..,-E, ,
1 r , \
{o \\.,,,,- ter+ar R ” 1;,.
,/..,,,,,..„ ., ,
___,,,,_„„
, iwirl,,,„.11,,,
f:, V
. :4
.,,,AlAkli.- -- .
�'
.., ,, „,,.,,,, ,
i , , , , _ ,,,,,,,.
' i , . . . i -6. -, .
'M=TO :'1/4 I
'\\,___—) - i il ,' ,'. i);. '7,7— ' '
1 '
L4 ' :,
I I
• ig"al El."I' ',,;'-•' ' - . -:.,,.. _.'-:,,, ,f .,, ,
Om.' iie'l.IN • _ t,7:ill* _.i litt. 014 ..„
s I ,,„,,,. , . , .. Illtk,,, „,
• \.\ '1, , 1 V'''' 1 ri' '.1 .1 : , ,,,, ,
'\
ilt...'-'''''' ' 1-- ''''1.,..,-. Ilk-- .__ - . '_ . -. :„, ‘r.
-ok;. 11 wisimis-4 ( ;',,,,4,,, J.,....i.,,,„„.:::,.,_:, ,.,..
_ i, , , ' ,,,, . - ,.. , ,
- mm 4%,,L',) ..,,, . - '
„ ,, 1 „ , • ,..,,..2.....r.„,...:: 0 ,,, ..,.,,...„:.:16:,. , __
I I f j I' . ---- ': ' • %'.:.'
\\ \11111 , 1 r le, . L_L_____- _,, -, .--. .
111111111 :
iii.,
imN, -1-1;t:F �ti .�
7/-f-A-\ J./7 _ , .', . . mu
717""T:':,:..'.
_i . �.. r 1� AAA , . ,,
a r ' _ e7 ., � r L' r I 1•-,_....4. -, illi 1'e_ • .
P
, 1 ,., ________ .re' ' '' ''11. 1 "''. 4 .
q i, r' ,.. i. ,....._.
if
'- c:. ..4"-;ite 1 ' Cill....7'''''- - '.=.--'":" .:4. ' ' ---..44. ,
i ,,,,, (
it( r ---::q .u.,..C.7 4- .
r- .. ,--.... .ooy o .
--1-.r_—_-_.,,--.1<- f',..''''''..-4.1!' '''''' -I' :;7:' ,!- __, ;
'' ''''t'Z''''''- '. . ." ICAg'' - ,1.7
4' , --j lit' r -- ,'. .c ,,,,h,,,,a- — ,, --.(‘-:;_.
, ,
- ‘,.... , - , - - -,-.-0„,, ,,. i '':
k , ,-. —
. -, ."----e„ . y
- L"-- ,,./-1 .—. 'r-,,,,,, ..\,,,: .
L. , ,,, _. _ .,,,,.1 < ../.
.„.,...._. .• .
(---------- -....._,. , _,_, ,
. i_ 2 '
. .
fr.7,.(_ -_ 7...i.‘., i,--L.,_...„, e.---._:,......-...."71- ..,,,r jr.” „ . ._ .,
' .-'''A:d ..
\\\\ ,-- -
---,,..\\
\'"r� r_ •. `ter
C :—..-444-7-7-7 , \e..... , *: .,
,,E..\:01,
4 ' '�� _ F /.''.;
'� rte. '
r_____jc___.
'''' I i . ',_.., --aLit)--'Sr,--8,. *44) ' _
--:::' '
tr '
c4----/-:_
. __________ ,,, .,_
r_::,vs,,,......----76.,
,,, "I. : i , 1 t,j 41'
////\1\____/ ,.,..„ ,
, ' .
,, ( '...4
,
tti ,
iCilirli11.141'
Ch1
O n u DAV U0SION
,„
O =
W
<t. _1 _
SNIVVL i Be=N3 JNOIS
\ -- • ishS
,
>lVM]aIS ]NOIS M66 g5`5'Zo6zS /_ _ ____ _ _ , ,
0 0
— 7/
/ ,
/
o
,
U Q Z / W
Z W O O /
O> U --- -- -- / Q�J
C_.)f2 LJ_CC
w /
CI O l
W m '
C
29'-0 3/4" L- - _ _A___11_ I I Tr)
z
O
(.._.) , \p
W
,
(!)
1 \,
r
I \
= L__I tri \
l_i-!
o � z
w l T -- � O o Q
w- j
-.‹.-1
1cQ
m01I 11 \
°�O 0-0-. -- s- ----
-7 0 n ° ,
Z
qW O j
ni-,, ._ 0
,_____ , , Ow 1
11.1) ,
- 00 w � al
ctw 1
Q,1 I Q m o� Q \
,".V 1 ��
Qi ,
�! Q q
up. of
. ..:., Qb
-,-b
U, o
IN
. �hp
I OP
o
,k
(I)I I -C7) ) 1
W w71-
°
N CL
O f N
CJS Z~ II
C.)O
I ~o fl
1
I U
11 m
w
1I
w
1 CC
I 1
-C°N) _I
`,1-
.' w `0.P9 3 g5`soo 6JN o 1
— --)) 0
-- .- a
,f_), . •_._0_._._._.
0-0-0 0 0 0 °--.° x x x r
1
III
a) N
-C3 r-I
n L
a)
o c
c -a
•_ L__
. .. u) Ca 0
- '— 0
a) L _a >
_a
L ,,n 4Ea L..
a) a) o
u) L E o
EL) a) a) U
o_= U
o U L -1E1
-6
a) n 4) �--- a) - a)
V) -a _a C - C=
n o 4- a) Co a) •-
L L _. > Ca
a) o co •— c� o_
n >
- -0 a) 0- -5 a)
= o > a) 0-0 s0
'4=,
a) L- o 0
u) - COo L
T) L L a) o L
Co a)
° — o
L u) CO >1 0
a) C o (J) a 0
COr0 C13 CI 0 c 0 •
E -ca3
'2 p as = ,- ,r%
C 0 U sai Ll)
0 0 § C �,(I) D
•C a) 0 -En _a cil> c
-0) Cv ILm 4) Con
L,— co
o > coco >, CT l—
.L
.. CU ...c „(1)
-3 C� a) o U
o 0 L U) tl)
Coa) � IDo �
(73
C) > u) ii= L 0-)
-- co LI 0 n
CZ ,� 1- CD L o 0 00
— 0
,7_ co cm
C� o �CO 4 c , -0 0) -a)
•03
Go • •
.c_
n ,_ a) ci.6 ._ c
p -0 &,c3 0 2
LD 2 5 ci,12 o 0 0
-co ca. sa) F= . . pr' a)
>, P 0 u2 " 0
Cp _a c Co
fi c < 0_ 8 E .ic .
c To CU L 'i
. .
coo . La RI
irc 0 . cn
— ,� ._ o
CN CU
or..
o U) oE 0) . . N O
CD
GO .. . .
a) (7) 73 E c = E13. 8 c ›,
2co
TDT:).(1) 48 .—
._ Cn EIL. , cf-)0 0 0 u_ . .0 .-,7
Si— CI) L L_ L L L L d
a) o was'
2 . .2 .2 0 0 .2 0 '.
�, �,._ L5 L5 Ct) C5 L L L CT)
E u)
CO Ca) cu : x x x x x x 0 z
°' w w w w w w .?
W
o .C . . . . . . .
't o-
0