Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
20190069 Artisanal Interpretation Application
CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS 44 ',. a ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS G VI-9 Ho L J - 474 6 ro-a-oknta-y j v ` Sara ga' New-Yo-rk/12866 , .` Tel: 518—587-3550 j 518—580-9480 CiftPOA O INSTRUCTIONS APPEAL TO THE ZONING BOARD FOR AN INTERPRETATION, USE VARIANCE,AREA VARIANCE AND/OR VARIANCE EXTENSION APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS I. ELIGIBILITY:To apply for relief from the City's Zoning Ordinance, an applicant must be the property owner(s) or lessee, or have an option to lease or purchase the property in question. The Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) shall not accept any application for appeal that includes a parcel which has a written violation from the Zoning and Building Inspector that is not the subject of the application. 2. COMPLETE SUBMISSIONS:Applicants are encouraged to work with City staff to ensure a complete application.The ZBA will only consider properly completed applications that contain I original and I digital version of the following: ❑ Completed application pages I and 8, the pages relating to the requested relief(p. 2 for interpretation or extension, pp. 3-5 for use variance, pp. 6-7 for area variance), and any additional supporting materials/documentation. **HANDWRITTEN APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED** ❑ Completed SEQR Environmental Assessment Form —short or long form as required by action. http://www.dec.ny.gov/docs/permits_ej_operations_pdf/seafpartone.pdf ❑ Detailed "to scale" drawings of the proposed project—folded and no larger than 24"x 36". Identify all existing and proposed structures, lot boundaries and dimensions, and the relationship of structures to the lot dimensions. Also, include any natural or manmade features that might affect your property (e.g., drains, ponds, easements, etc.). ❑ Photographs showing the site and subject of your appeal, and its relationship to adjacent properties. 3. APPLICATION FEE (NON-REFUNDABLE): Make checks payable to the "Commissioner of Finance". Fees are cumulative and required for each request below. ❑ Interpretation $500 ❑ Use variance $1,000 ❑ Area variance - Residential use/property $200 - Non-residential use/property$600 ❑ Extensions $150 Check City's website (www.saratoga-springs.org) for application meeting dates. Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD APPEAL APPLICATION INSTRUCTIONS PAGE 2 PUBLIC HEARING ADVERTISEMENT The Zoning Board of Appeals is required to hold a public hearing on each submitted application within ninety(90) days from when it is determined to be properly complete by City staff. City staff will prepare a legal notice for the public hearing and arrange to have the public hearing announcement printed in The Saratogian legal notices at least 5 days before the hearing. Applicants must pay The Saratogian for the legal ad and present proof of payment to the ZBA prior to the public hearing. If proof of payment is not presented prior to the hearing, the hearing will be cancelled. PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION Applicants are required to mail a copy of the public hearing legal notice to all property owners within the following distances from the boundaries of the land in question: Type of variance Distance for property owner notification Use variance 250 feet Area variance & Interpretation 100 feet This notice must be sent at least 7 days but not more than 20 days before the date of the public hearing. City staff will email a copy of the"property owner notification letter"to the applicant.The applicant must then send the notification letter to the nearby property owners.Applicants may not include any other materials in this mailing. The mailing must be certified by the U.S. Post Office. Prior to the public hearing, applicants must present the Post Office "certificates of mailing" to the ZBA. If"certificates of mailing" are not presented prior to the hearing, the hearing will be cancelled. Revised 01/2019 q [FOR OFFICE USE] ` CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS _ (Application#) G�vhy • 'ate L 474 f3 ' 77So-Ta/S y N Jnr Yo-rk/1-z 8 66 . `', Tth 518-587-3550 518-580-9480 (Date received) 'PoRATED APPLICATION FOR: APPEAL TO THE ZONING BOARD FOR AN INTERPRETATION, USE VARIANCE,AREA VARIANCE AND/OR VARIANCE EXTENSION APPLICANT(S)* OWNER(S) (If not applicant) ATTORNEY/AGENT Quinn Borchardt Brewing, LLC Van Hall Holdings, LLC Meyer, Fuller &Stockwell, PLLC Name dba Artisanal Brew Works Address 41 Geyser Road 41 Geyser Road 1557 State Route 9 Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Saratoga Springs,NY 12866 Lake George, NY 12845 5183064344 5186682199 Phone / / / Email artisanalbrewworks@gmail.com rcvanhall@gmail.com mfuller@meyerfuller.com *An applicant must be the property owner, lessee, or one with an option to lease or purchase the property in question. Applicant's interest in the premises: 0 Owner IZ Lessee 0 Under option to lease or purchase PROPERTY INFORMATION 41 Geyser Road 178 1 33 I. Property Address/Location: Tax Parcel No.: - - (for example: 165.52—4—37) 2012 IND-G 2. Date acquired by current owner: 3.Zoning District when purchased: Brewery, brewery sales, brewer IND-G 4. Present use of property: events 5. Current Zoning District: 6. Has a previous ZBA application/appeal been filed for this property? ❑Yes (when? UNKNOWN For what? IZ No 7. Is property located within (check all that apply)?: 0 Historic District 0 Architectural Review District 0 500' of a State Park, city boundary, or county/state highway? 8. Brief description of proposed action: The action is an appeal of a letter dated November 26, 2018, copy attached hereto, as set forth in appellate papers provided herewith. 9. Is there a written violation for this parcel that is not the subject of this application? 0 Yes 12i No 10. Has the work, use or occupancy to which this appeal relates already begun? E Yes No . Identify the type of appeal you are requesting (check all that apply): INTERPRETATION (p. 2) 0 VARIANCE EXTENSION (p. 2) 0 USE VARIANCE (pp. 3-6) 0 AREA VARIANCE(pp. 6-7) Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS APPLICATION FORM PAGE 2 FEES:Make checks payable to the"Commissioner of Finance". Fees are cumulative and required for each request below. IZ Interpretation $ 500 ❑ Use variance $1,000 ❑Area variance -Residential use/property: $ 200 -Non-residential use/property: $ 600 ❑ Extensions: $ 150 INTERPRETATION—PLEASE ANSWER THE FOLLOWING(add additional information as necessary): I. Identify the section(s) of the Zoning Ordinance for which you are seeking an interpretation: Please see attached appellate papers. Section(s) 2. How do you request that this section be interpreted? Please see attached appellate papers. 3. If interpretation is denied, do you wish to request alternative zoning relief? EYes ENo 4. If the answer to#3 is "yes,"what alternative relief do you request?❑ Use Variance 0 Area Variance EXTENSION OF A VARIANCE—PLEASE ANSWER THE FOLLOWING(add additional information as necessary): NA I. Date original variance was granted: 2. Type of variance granted? 0 Use 0 Area 3. Date original variance expired: NA 5. Explain why the extension is necessary.Why wasn't the original timeframe sufficient? NA When requesting an extension of time for an existing variance,the applicant must prove that the circumstances upon which the original variance was granted have not changed. Specifically demonstrate that there have been no significant changes on the site, in the neighborhood, or within the circumstances upon which the original variance was granted: NA Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS APPLICATION FORM PAGE 3 USE VARIANCE—PLEASE ANSWER THE FOLLOWING(add additional information as necessary): A use variance is requested to permit the following: NA For the Zoning Board to grant a request for a use variance, an applicant must prove that the zoning regulations create an unnecessary hardship in relation to that property. In seeking a use variance,New York State law requires an applicant to prove all four of the following "tests". . That the applicant cannot realize a reasonable financial return on initial investment for any currently permitted use on the property. "Dollars¢s" proof must be submitted as evidence.The property in question cannot yield a reasonable return for the following reasons: NA A. Submit the following financial evidence relating to this property(attach additional evidence as needed): NA NA I) Date of purchase: Purchase amount: $ 2) Indicate dates and costs of any improvements made to property after purchase: Date Improvement Cost NA NA NA NA NA 3)Annual maintenance expenses:$ 4)Annual taxes: $ NA 5)Annual income generated from property:$ NA NA NA 6) City assessed value: $ Equalization rate: Estimated Market Value: $ NA NA NA 7)Appraised Value: $ Appraiser: Date: NA Appraisal Assumptions: Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS APPLICATION FORM PAGE 4 NA B. Has property been listed for sale with ❑Yes If"yes",for how long? the Multiple Listing Service(MLS)? C❑No NA NA I)Original listing date(s): Original listing price:$ If listing price was reduced, describe when and to what extent: NA 2) Has the property been advertised in the newspapers or other publications? ❑Yes ❑No If yes, describe frequency and name of publications: NA 3) Has the property had a"For Sale" sign posted on it? IYes ❑No If yes, list dates when sign was posted: NA 4) How many times has the property been shown and with what results? NA 2. That the financial hardship relating to this property is unique and does not apply to a substantial portion of the neighborhood. Difficulties shared with numerous other properties in the same neighborhood or district would not satisfy this requirement. This previously identified financial hardship is unique for the following reasons: NA Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS APPLICATION FORM PAGE S 3. That the variance, if granted, will not alter the essential character of the neighborhood. Changes that will alter the character of a neighborhood or district would be at odds with the purpose of the Zoning Ordinance. The requested variance will not alter the character of the neighborhood for the following reasons: NA 4. That the alleged hardship has not been self-created.An applicant(whether the property owner or one acting on behalf of the property owner)cannot claim "unnecessary hardship" if that hardship was created by the applicant, or if the applicant acquired the property knowing(or was in a position to know)the conditions for which the applicant is seeking relief.The hardship has not been self-created for the following reasons: NA Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS APPLICATION FORM PAGE 6 AREA VARIANCE—PLEASE ANSWER THE FOLLOWING(add additional information as necessary): NA The applicant requests relief from the following Zoning Ordinance article(s) Dimensional Requirements From To NA Other: To grant an area variance,the ZBA must balance the benefits to the applicant and the health,safety,and welfare of the neighborhood and community,taking into consideration the following: . Whether the benefit sought by the applicant can be achieved by other feasible means. Identify what alternatives to the variance have been explored (alternative designs, attempts to purchase land, etc.)and why they are not feasible. NA 2. Whether granting the variance will produce an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties. Granting the variance will not create a detriment to nearby properties or an undesirable change in the neighborhood character for the following reasons: NA Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS APPLICATION FORM PAGE 7 3. Whether the variance is substantial. The requested variance is not substantial for the following reasons: NA 4. Whether the variance will have adverse physical or environmental effects on neighborhood or district. The requested variance will not have an adverse physical or environmental effect on the neighborhood or district for the following reasons: NA 5. Whether the alleged difficulty was self-created(although this does not necessarily preclude the granting of an area variance). Explain whether the alleged difficulty was or was not self-created: NA Revised 01/2019 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS ApPL^C4ncN/O^M PAGE DISCLOSURE Does any City officer,employee, or family member thereof have a financial interest(as defined by General Municipal Law Section 809)in this applicationNo jaYes If^yes^.aon^oemencdisclosing the name,residence and nature and extenof this interesmust be filed with this application. APPLICANT CERTIFICATION the property owner(s),or purchaser(s)/lessee(s) under contract, of the land in question, hereby request an appearance before the Zoning Board of Appeals. By the signature(s) attached her^to, I/we certify that the information provided within this application and accompanying documentation is, to the best of my/our knowledge,true and accurate, I/we further understand that intentionally providing false or misleading information is grounds for immediate denial of this application. Furthermore, I/we hereby authorize the members of the Zoning Board of Appeals and designated City staff to enter the property associated with this application for purposes of conducting any necessary site inspections relating to this appeal. N^ +-o"u- Date: V2-42.4c1 Date: [ �C�/ (applicant � �» n��u ) /1— � If applicant is not the currently the owner of the prop.-rty,the curr;nt owner must also sign. ' . . -APP Owner Signature ' Date: /'�/ ^7� �� / �Nm�r , Owner Signature _____ Date: ZONING AND BUILDING INSPECTOR DENIAL OF APPLICATION FOR LAND USE AND/OR BUILDING APPLICANT: TAX PARCEL NO.: - - PROPERTY ADDRESS: ZONING DISTRICT: This applicant has applied to use the identified property within the City of Saratoga Springs for the following: This application is hereby denied upon the grounds that such use of the property would violate the City Zoning Ordinance article(s) .As such,the following relief would be required to proceed: ❑ Extension of existing variance 0 Interpretation ❑ Use Variance to permit the following: ❑Area Variance seeking the following relief: Dimensional Requirements From To Other: Note: ❑Advisory Opinion required from Saratoga County Planning Board ZONING AND BUILDING INSPECTOR DATE Revised 01/2019 MEYER, FULLER & STOCKWELL timi LAKE GEORGE RLLO ATTORNEYS AT LAW TITLE AGENCY January 24, 2019 City of Saratoga Springs, Zoning Board of Appeals City Hall 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Re: Appeal by Quinn Borchardt Brewing, LLC d/b/a Artisanal Brew Works Property at 41 Geyser Road, Saratoga Springs, NY Dear City of Saratoga Springs Zoning Board of Appeals: Our firm is counsel to Quinn Borchardt Brewing, LLC d/b/a Artisanal Brew Works (hereinafter "Artisanal Brew Works"), a tenant at property located at 41 Geyser Road, Saratoga Springs, NY, identified for tax map purposes as tax map parcel 178-1-33 (hereinafter the "Property"). For the reasons set forth in this letter, as attachment to appellate papers filed this day, Artisanal Brew Works hereby takes appeal (hereinafter this "Appeal")pursuant to the City of Saratoga Springs Zoning Ordinance (hereinafter the "Zoning Ordinance") from the determination of Patrick Cogan, Assistant Building Inspector, Zoning Officer, dated November 26, 2018 (the "Determination"), a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A, pages 2 & 3. Filed herewith is the requisite application materials. Artisanal Brew Works files this Appeal with reservation of all rights and claims, and without waiving any causes of action, claims or damages. APPEAL Artisanal Brew Works appeals from so much of the above Determination that states: 1. "The tasting room does not have approval under City Zoning....as an eating and drinking establishment." See Exhibit A, page 2; 2. "...no food preparation or sale of prepared food for consumption on the premises is permitted." See Exhibit A, page 2; 1557 STATE PT 9, LAKE GEORGE, NY 12845 Phone: 518-668-219 9 www, & er fu/i icor Page 12 3. "...Retail is not a permitted use in the IND-G zoning district, nor is an Eating and Drinking Establishment." See Exhibit A, page 3; and 4. "No outdoor activity such as food vending, recreational activities, or special events associated with the brewery are permitted on the property". See Exhibit A, page 3. 5. Artisanal Brew Works reserves the right to supplement this Appeal of the Determination through the course of this Appeal, and in particular, upon receipt of the satisfaction of the FOIL request pending before the City's FOIL officer, discussed below. We also reserve the right to supplement exhibits based on the review of files, correspondence, and FOIL responses that we may receive. ARGUMENT The preparation and serving of limited food items and retail sales are consistent with the use of a "bottling plant"as broadly interpreted by the administrative official charged with the enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance and given the ambiguity contained therein. The City's "administrative official charged with the enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance", believed to be the author of the Determination, Patrick Cogan as "Zoning Officer", as well as prior City staff, have already determined that there are ancillary uses associated with a"Bottling Plant"under the City's Zoning Ordinance. Indeed, that was the very basis for the location of not only a brewery, but also a distillery, at the Property. For example: a. See Exhibit A, page 9, which is a"Building Permit" dated 12/12/2016, under "Comments/Conditions: TENANT SPACE INCLUDING BREWERY, TASTING ROOM(BAR), LAB, OFFICE AND COLD ROOM", Emphasis added; b. See Exhibit A, page 10 under"Comments/Conditions: BREWERY AND BAR FIXTURES"; Emphasis added; c. See Exhibit A, page 33, copied below, which acknowledges ancillary uses such as Cabaret License activities: From:Richard Tiersch<r hard.tiersch sa rat ia-springs OrQ> Tue,Oct 16,2018 10!50 AM Subject:Fwd:Artisanal Brew To:Stefanie Richards<steianie.rEchardsm Sarat - spnitfa. > te-Fa nie, The building department has no issues at this time regarding the Cabaret License for Artisanal Brew Works located at 41 Geyser Rd as long as "the seating remains the same as last year and there is a clear path of travel maintained to all exits at ALL times". Artisanal Brew Works would also need to operate under the guidelines as described by Brad Sire below, Sincerel x Rich Tiersch And at page 34: 1557 STATE IST, 9, LAKE GEORGE, NY 12845 Phone: 518-6 1 GI 9 www, & er fu/i rc orry Page 3 `fXI IILJI 1 rlk 1 ►►LJL Re: Artisanal Brew cabaret license We understand that the cabaret activities are an ancillary activity related to the brewing and tasting room activities permitted under the KY State Farm Brewers license with the caveat that: 2. this remains an ancillary activity and does not become a primary activity 2. the cabaret activities are conducted wholly within the Artisanal tasting room portion of the building - no outdoor cabaret activities are permitted 3. the total number of seats permitted in the tasting room cannot exceed 50 regardless of any singular or combination of uses. Thank you, Bradley d. See Exhibit A, page 45, copied below, which acknowledges ancillary uses such as Eating and Drinking License activities: From:John Barney john.barney a saratoga-springs.org> Wed,Sep 27,2017 04:39 PM Subject:Re:Artisanal Brew Works To:Carrie Spencer carrie.spencer saratoga-springs.org Carrie, The Building Dept has no issues at this time regarding the Eating and Drinking License for Artisanal Brew Works(41 Geyser Rd). Sincerely, John Barney Zoning and Building Technician With all of the foregoing, none of which, we note, was ever appealed by anyone, the City of Saratoga Springs has acknowledged that there are ancillary uses outside of the definitions contained in the City's Zoning Ordinance definition of"Bottling Plant". A"Bottling Plant", though used in the City's Zoning Ordinance at"Table 2: Use Schedule", and §6.2.6 "Off-Street Parking Schedule", is actually not a defined use anywhere in the City's Zoning Ordinance. This creates an amigbuity in the City's Zoning Ordinance. It is hornbook New York Law, that Zoning restrictions are in derogation of the common law and, as such, must be strictly construed against the municipality which enacted and seeks to enforce them, and that any ambiguity in the language employed must be resolved in favor of the property owner. Spilka III v. Town of Inlet, 8 A.D.2d 812, 814 (3rd Dept. 2004); Bonded Concrete Inc. V. ZBA of the Town of Saugerties, 268 A.D.2d at 774, supra; Matter of Allen v. Adami, 39 N.Y.2d 275, 277 (1976); Matter of Uciechowski, 221 A.D.2d at 868, supra; McKinney's Cons. Laws of N.Y., Book 1, Statutes, §311, at 473-474. Here, the City staff has previously determined that ancillary uses to what has been described as a "Bottling Plant", include: a"Brewery", "Tap Room", "Tasting Room(BAR)", "Eating and Drinking License"uses, "Lab", "Office", "Cold Room", "Bar", "Cabaret License"uses. Notably, a"Cabaret" is not defined in the City's Zoning Ordinance. Neither are a"Cold Room", "Bar", "Brewery", "Tasting Room" or"Tap Room". Interestingly, a "Laboratory" is a defined use, but not discussed in the "IND-G" zone. All of these descriptions clearly point to the finding by staff that"Bottling Plant" is an extremely broad term, one wide open to interpretation by the Zoning Officer. Such wide interpretation is in and of itself ambiguous. 1557 STATE IRT 9, LAKE GEORGE, NY 12845 Phone: 518-668-219 9 www,meyerfull6,rcorn Page 14 In addition, the new decision not to allow "Retail" sales defies logic. On the one hand, the Determination allows a tasting room, which of course permits the sale of"tastings" including pints of beer, to patrons, which of course is in and of itself, a retail transaction. However, the Determination then inexplicably states that"Retail is not a permitted use". Would this include the sale of cans of craft beer to patrons? That too is incidental to the "Tap Room" or"Tasting Room", and clearly incidental to the "Bar". Such "Retail" sales are not the predominant use of the Property, but are clearly incidental to the "Bottling Plant" again, based on the prior determinations of the City officials. The City has licensed Artisanal Brew Works for Cabaret, Eating and Drinking, as well as "Brewery", "Tap Room", "Tasting Room(BAR)", "Eating and Drinking License"uses, "Lab", "Office", "Cold Room", "Bar", "Cabaret License"uses. Those uses are inherent in the business of Artisanal Brew Works, and most definitely required for this business to succeed. The owners have invested upwards of$500,000 and more in this business at this location, and now, the City seeks to reverse its prior determinations that gave rise to the detrimental reliance by Artisanal Brew Works for the brewery at this location. Given what the City through the Determination, as well as prior licenses, clearly identifies as an ambiguous "Bottling Plant"usage in the IND-G zone, that ambiguity is, by law, to be broadly interpreted in favor of Artisanal Brew Works, and against the City. There is no basis for prohibiting incidental sales such as pints, cans/4-packs of beer, or for that matter Artisanal Brew Works hats, glasses, shirts, etc. In addition, there is no prohibition against"eating and drinking" or"food preparation", which too are incidental to the broad uses already allowed with a "Bottling Plant." Lastly, there is no relation whatsoever to uses that may be regulated under the NYS Uniform Code, and the Zoning Ordinance. The NYS Uniform Code is a creature of New York State regulation, not the City's Zoning Ordinance, which flows from the General City Law, and the Municipal Home Rule Law of the State of New York. Thus, any reference by the Zoning Officer, who may very well also be the "Building Inspector"under the NYS Uniform Code, to regulations of the NYS Uniform Code have no relevance to a zoning determination. It is apparent that the Zoning Officer's determination was influenced by some pressure to change the business of Artisanal Brew Works. We are quite confident that this change, particularly given the ambiguity in the definition of a"Bottling Plant", results in an regulatory taking of Artisanal Brew Works vested property rights. Artisanal Brew Works never would have located in this specific Property if it wasn't for the incidental uses associated with the brewery, a/k/a "Bottling Plant." Indeed, at its inception, we note that there was also a distillery - "Upstate Distillery" - owned by one of the principals of the landlord that was also located at the Property, but which business has subsequently closed and moved elsewhere. This use, too, had incidental uses such as "retail" sales of bottles of spirits including bourbon, vodka, etc. The City took no steps to end that use, but has no for inexplicable reasons targeted Artisanal Brew Works. As noted previously, we reserve the right to supplement this argument and appeal based on information discovered subsequent to the filing of this Appeal, and other information that we deem fit. 1557 STATE IRT 9, LAKE GEORGE, NY 12845 Phone: 518-668-219 9 www,meyerfull6Prcorn I ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 1 Zimbra patrick,cogan@saratoga-springs,,Org 41 Geyser Rd. = Artisanal Brew Works From >, Patrick Cogan <patrick.cogan@saratoga-springs.org> Wed, Aug 15, 2018 12:00 PM Subject : 41 Geyser Rd. - Artisanal Brew Works To :Aaron Dyer <aadyer@ssfdny.org> Cc : Lisa Shields <Iisa.shields@saratoga-springs-org> Capt. Dyer, I will be meeting with the proprietors of Artisanal Brew Works this afternoon Section If 303-1.2 of the 2015 IBC. Under that section, a small assembly space of less than 50 persons may be classified as part of the surrounding occupancy. The -.0 L.L- /Nr,% v -%m- nrii in P -r % 1 7r) M Please let me know if you want to discuss. Thanks, Patrick Cogan Assistant Building Inspector City of Saratoga Springs (518) 587-3550 x2491 8!15/20181 12:00 PTVT 1 of 1 November 26, 2018 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL City of Saratoga Springs BUILDING DEPARTMENT CITY HALL 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Telephone (518)587-3550 Ext. 2511 www.saratoga-springs.org Artisanal Brew works Kurt Borchardt and Colin Quinn. 41 Geyser Road Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Kurt and Colin, EXHIBIT A PAGE 2 DUANE MILLER Assistant Building Inspector Extension 2512 PATRICK COGAN Assistant Building Inspector Extension 2491 MICHAEL CARLSON Assistant Building Inspector Extension 2541 JOHN BARNEY Assistant Building & Construction Inspector Extension 2521 RICHARD TIERSH Assistant Building & Construction Inspector Extension 2563 This letter is a follow up to several discussions that we have had with you in recent months with regard to the operation of your business, Artisanal Brew works, at 41 Geyser Road. The property is located in a General Industrial (IND -G) district which permits bottling plants with site plan review by the Planning Board. It had previously been determined that site plan review was not required for your use as a brewery within the existing warehouse building. Upon that determination a building permit was issued on December 12, 2016 for "Tenant space includingbrewer tasting room (bar), lab, office and cold room". A subsequent Certificate of Ys g occupancy was issued on August 15, 2018 with the condition "occupancy of tasting room limited to p Y � g 49 persons". The tasting room is only allowed as a "small assembly" space, accessory to the main p y (F-2 p Yesuse of a brewer occu anc designation). The tasting room does not have approval under City g Zoning or the NYS Uniform Code as an eating and drinking establishment. It 1s understood that Artisanal Brew works holds a NYS Liquor Authority Farm Brewery license to beer and sell the same on the remises. Therefore, an eating and drinking license from the brew b p Acco p q ants De artment is not required. for operation of the tasting room. Additi onally, no food re aration or sale of mepared food for consumption on the remises is ermitted. You may, however, seek a. cabaret license from the Accounts Department for entertainment inside the building. to the table on the next page, which includes the relevant section of the Use Schedule for Please refer p g zoning district IND -G. Specifically, please note that Retail is not a permitted use in the IND -G zoning district, nor is an Eating and Drinking Establishment. No outdoor activity such as food vending, recreational activities, or special events associated with the brewery are permitted on the property. ANY OTHER USE IN THIS ZONING DISTRICT REQUIRES AN APPLICATION TO THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS AND/OR THE PLANNING BOARD. I hope this helps to clarify what is permitted. The staff of the Accounts Department, the Planning Department, or the Building Department would be happy to review with you any ideas for future events 1 fundraisers 1 activities before they are scheduled. Further, for assistance with an application to the Land Use Boards, please contact Bradley Birge. Since Patrick Cogan Assistant Building Inspector, Zoning Officer Cc: Ryen Van Hall, 41 Geyser Road Lisa Shields, Deputy Mayor Maire Masterson, Deputy Commissioner of Accounts John Daley, Deputy Commissioner of Public Safety Jack Donnelly, Code Administrator, DPS Bradley Birge, Office of Planning and Economic Development Pj ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 3 CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS ZONING ORDINANCE TABLE 2: USE, SCHEDULE Z0N1Ns D'15TMC;T PFANC PAL.PrrR[SIT ED USES AND'STRUCTURM USES PERMITS WTH ,[SES.PERMIT ED NTH SITE PLAN APPRGVAL SPEC" USR PERMIT AND SrFE PLAm APP-RavAL. pIERVIT ED ACCESSORY USES AND STRUCTURES Industrial Light None Bakery ftolesala� potifing Plan, Vehicle Fueling StatiGns, MaIntenanc erStorage Facilities, (IND-L) Light ManufactudRg, Machine Shop f ietar Vehicle Repair Establishment, Cie€deer StorageiDlisplay, Empbyee Recreafional Heavy Equipment Storage, Sales & Selvage and Serail Pressing Facilities, Daycare Center ktaint6ance, Warehouse, Tracking fix. Freight Terminal., Crishibulicrrr Plants �. �el�ala Esiablishrxtenls, Antennas � Satellite Dishes, lar/HeatingiVen ilaticrdUtilfty Administrative Offices, Laboratory, Equipment TVIRa dio Station &. Rec:eli&WBroadcast, Utility Establishments [ndustrial General Norte Sarre as IND-L, plass: Outdoor Stcrage0spia Sage as IND-'l_ (IND-G) heavy Manrfacwring Salvage and Scrap Pro sir , [Mustri l Extra ten Cone Concrete IMix Plant, Asphaft Mix Plana, Outdoor S€crageMlsplay Same as IND-L , plus_ ExlracWn Equipment QNDN X) EAraetion of sand, Stene or Gravel Amended by City Council Resolution 041211.015 Specifically, please note that Retail is not a permitted use in the IND -G zoning district, nor is an Eating and Drinking Establishment. No outdoor activity such as food vending, recreational activities, or special events associated with the brewery are permitted on the property. ANY OTHER USE IN THIS ZONING DISTRICT REQUIRES AN APPLICATION TO THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS AND/OR THE PLANNING BOARD. I hope this helps to clarify what is permitted. The staff of the Accounts Department, the Planning Department, or the Building Department would be happy to review with you any ideas for future events 1 fundraisers 1 activities before they are scheduled. Further, for assistance with an application to the Land Use Boards, please contact Bradley Birge. Since Patrick Cogan Assistant Building Inspector, Zoning Officer Cc: Ryen Van Hall, 41 Geyser Road Lisa Shields, Deputy Mayor Maire Masterson, Deputy Commissioner of Accounts John Daley, Deputy Commissioner of Public Safety Jack Donnelly, Code Administrator, DPS Bradley Birge, Office of Planning and Economic Development Pj ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL, EXHIBIT A PAGE 4 O ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 5 g Y 0 r CD r.L MMd M o �UQ o [� CD cn cn.. ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 5 a r rt 0 Uq cn °q V a ,t g Y 0 a r rt 0 Uq cn °q V a ,t Not • mow's cv foil ■ r 00 w w ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL �> 0 n CD CD �oo ►x N O O n COIN 00 O W � O r r n � d CD CD a 0 00 n 0 Pid z 0 0 Ind0 n n C:ro z n ARTISANAL BREW.--.-WO-RKS APPEAL . ...... ... - - ---------- ... .... ---- -- EXHIBIT A PAGE 8 IV l`. >461 „. . ,, ` CL m 7 a r°C.D.*. ,- 4, Ak --Ito CAD Cm H. 0 C° - to �. 0 VI C - r° =. v •'�'� CA:., � E CD : a- ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL --------------- ........... ..--.-..-..-._-.-----.--._--._..--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- EX1ff1'B]T_A7_PAG_E'_� 1 - l I I I j 1 i f�{G PERMITBI.TILDII�T, TO CONSTRUCT � I • j k A MAJALT-STRUCTURAL-COMMj €� Permit Number: 20161320 I I Date: December 12, 2016 I Permission is herebyranted to the below owner or contractor for construction in accordance to application 20160958 together with plans and specifications hereto filed and approved and in compliance with the provisions of the Codes of City of Saratoga Sprigs, New York. I I I i Permit Issue Date: 12/1212016 Permit Expiration Date: 12/12/2018 I I' I I ! I 1 I LOCATION PERMIT CLASSIFICATION Sect/Block/Lot: 178.4-33 Permit Type: B BUILDING j Street: 41 GEYSER RD Work Type: 12 MAJ ALT -STRUCTURAL -COMM j Zoning District: INDG GENERAL INDUSTRIAL Prop Usage: COMM Occupy Class: F-2 Const. Class: III i I k I ; E OWNER CONTRACTOR VAN HALL HOLDINGS LLC ARTISANAL BREW WORDS ' 41 GEYSER RD 41 GEYSER ROAD SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY 12866 SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY 12866 518-409-2539 515-260.0361 1 j j APPLICANT I j ARTISANAL BREW WORKS I 41 GEYSER ROAD SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY 12866 I 518-260-0361 j j I ! Total Value of Work: 1000 I ' Total Square Feet: 3383 I Application Date: 11/17/2016 Permit Issued By: SS Permit Fee: 1.020.75 i I I Scope of Work: F-2 OCCUPANCY WITH A-2 ACCESSORY USE ' I I ' Comments/Conditions: ING BREWERY TASTING ROOM BAR , LAB, OFFICE AND COLD ROOM. TENANT SPACE INCLUDING � ) , I I j I I � I I i , I i I I I I 1 1 ' zni Building Inspector E I _j l_..------.-------�--------------------..-----------------------------.------------•---------.-----------.--------•------------------•-----------------_------------------------'--------------------------------------------_.-_- -- ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL _-----------_-----------_--------------_--------------------_--_-----------------------_--------_----------------.---_-------_-------.---------------.-----------_ - EXH-rB'[T'-A'-PA 0 i i E CPLUMBINGI ti ! PERMIT - COMMERCIAL PLUMBING i Permit Number: 20161319 I PAT i ! k ' b ranted to the below owner or contractor for construction in accordance to application Permission is hereby g i ether with ions and ecifications hereto filed and approved and in compliance with the together g p p provisions of the Codes of City of Saratoga Springs, Never York. i ! i 't Issue Date: 1211212U1� Perms l ! Permit Expiration Date: 12/12/2015 k l I 1 LOCATION I i PERMIT CLASSIFICATIQN i i Sect/Block/Lot: 178.-1-33 Permit Type: P PLUMBING Street: 41 GEYSER RD Work Type: 1703 PLUMBING - COMMERCIAL � Zoning District: INDG GENERAL INDUSTRIAL i OWNER CONTRACTOR i VAN HALL HOLDINGS LLC ON CALL PLUMBING 41 GEYSER RD 99 WALWORTH STREET SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY 12866 SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY 12866-2296 I ` 518-409-2539 i 584-2300 APPLICANT ARTISANAL BREW WORDS 41 GEYSER ROAD SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY 12866 518-260-0361 i i Application Date: 11/17/2416 I Comments/Conditions: i BREWERY AND BAR FIXTURES f I ! I i I 1 ! ! E i ! ! ! I f I i----------------------------------------------------•---- .------ Permit Issued By: S S Permit Fee: 146.00 Zomn Building Inspector co ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 11. �1Qc) ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL C:VuiQiT o oAGE 12 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 13 1 .FLOOR PLAN ARTISANAL BREW WORKS BREWERY OVERLOOK SCALE *1=14-011 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 14 251-611 0 D W 0 tiyxZo =�� O O q 17, Sr-,� Per 04L,tpfjA�- O O O O O ,no 421-311 0 0 /T*N 0 � 0 0 0 0 0 0 � 0 FLOOR PLAN ARTISANAL BREW WORKS TASTING ROOM SCALE. tI-"'=l'-O" ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL BUILDING PERMIT SUBMISSION CHECKLIST ALTERATIONS COMMERCIAL BUILDING p PROJECT SITE ADDRESS Ll [ �' (7-4�> — CHECKLIST PREPARED BY: &F CwN-10-- - — ZONING DISTRICT PREPARER'S PHONE No.: EXHIBIT A PAGE 15 ALL ITEMS BELOW MUST BE CHECKED EITHER "YES", 66NOY$l "NIA", or "PBA" (pending board approval - only where applicable). A separate checklist, must accompany each application for a building permit. All items checked "YES 11 shall accompany the application form at the time of submission to the building department. Until the application is deemed complete it may be rejected by the building department and returned to the applicant. Acceptance of a permit submission as complete does not imply or guarantee that a permit will be issued. N IA�j YES NO�4•V PB :>. 1. Building permit form completed and with required signatures from the property owner and applicant. 7i. Permit fee to be determined at plan review 3. Energy code compliance report, bearing the seal and signature of the N.Y.S. licensed professional engineer or registered architect. Specify compliance path: 4. Enerqycode .ins ectionchecklist. 5. Septic system permit application form completed and with signatures from the _prqperty owner and the contractor. 6. Site plan.approyal from Planning Board..., 7. S ecial ermit approval from Plannin Board. S. Architectural review approval from: Planning, Board P Design Review Commission p 9. Historic review approval from Design Review Commission, 10. Zoning Board of Appeals approval - 11. One complete set of building plans, each sheet bearing the seal and signature of the N.Y.S. licensed professional engineer or registered architect. The set shall include, but not be limited to the following drawings: (a) structural plans; (b) floor plans — all levels; (c) cross-sections; (d) details; (e) elevations; (f) schedules; (g) HVAC; (h) electrical; (i) plumbing, 0) codes specifications; (k) fire protection systems; (1) complete code summary 12. In accordance with section 1704 of the Building Code of New York State, a statement of special inspections shall be prepared by the registered design professional, to include: a complete list of materials and work requiring special inspections; the inspections to be performed; and a list of the individuals, approved agencies or firms intended to be retained for conducting_ such inspections. 13. Other: AV 'Is 6j".) I r. Tl - ' r W "MU, BMI'SSION '*`(N t q 7 z -F - D v Im ALI - 141wllil 0E PP Te E, -VST % fm -'t 5,4 U i. -'REVIE tA. RE 7� r. j 7 REVISED 6-13-12 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL APPLICATION FOR BUILDING PERMIT E -- Nei ORAIEV' For Office Use Get Permit No. c 413o-)-0 Date Applied ljo Issue/deny date 1t I Permit Type — check line that applies: Residential - New Addition ik1teration Commercial — New Addition Alteration Change of Occupancy ApplicationFee Fee Balance. CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS BUILDING DEPARTMENT City Hall- 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Telephone (518)587-3550 Ext, 2511 Fax (518)580-9480 � Job Site EXHIBIT A PAGE 16 File # DH Application# -_::40j(-o09.5a Zoning Informatio Zoning District TIN P;1 Sect-Blk-Lot 1-76& Lot Width Lot Area No. of Bedrooms 1s, Floor Area No. of Stories 2nd Floor Area Bldg. Height Basement Area % Yard Dimensions for Princi - al Building Front Rear Left Right Accessory Building — Distance To Principal Building Left lot line Rear lot line Right lot line Fee X115 -t- 25 Owner Rr!�2Applicant /�i Z��t.� Pr'ur► Address Address 7 Phone Phone Fax F Email Email,&/p CID # # 1 � 8 3% Design ;i Contractor *Wcv DesignProfessional 1424711 (04 1&4 / Pet Address Address IL/ AJ Y Phone Phone- 5eo' 4ES ' � � r`� `� � Fax Fax Email Email, CID # CID # # -7 2qa7-j ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 18 ADDRESS/LOCATION SPECIFICATIONS & MATERI( ALS -CHART GENERAL SIZE MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS OTHER -FOOTINGS psi DRAIN going to: -SLAB psi -FOUNDATION WALL psi WATERPROOFING VENT -COLUMNS/PIERS Z_i v7e psi -GIRDERS/BEAMS -EXTERIOR WALL STUD O.C. -INTERIOR WALL STUD O.C. -FLOOR JOIST, 15 FLOOR O.C. -FLOOR JOIST, 2nFLOOR O.C. -CEILING JOIST O.C. -ROOF RAFTER O.C. -COLLAR TIES O.C. -RIDGE BEAM -FLOOR SHEATHING -WALL SHEATHING -ROOF SHEATHING UNDERLAYMENT INSULATION SIZE MATERIAL VAPOR BARRIER R -FACTOR -FOUNDATION - OUTSIDE -FOUNDATION - INSIDE -UNDER SLAB -EXTERIOR WALLS -CEILING/ROOF FINISH WORK SIZE MATERIAL UNDERLAY OTHER EXTERIOR WALLS INTERIOR WALLS FLOOR CEILING ROOF MISCELLANEOUS SIZE MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS OTHER ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL ADDRESS/LOCATION - EXHIBIT A PAGE 19 HEATIN SYSTEMS PLUMBING — #UNITS & VENT SIZE TYPE FUEL SINKS Zf,AVORATORIES VENT—MATERIAL SIZE TOILET TUB /SHOWER e f1TATE SEWER TYPE CITY PRI `� - - - DESCRIBE (DRAW O7TPLAN)// WATER SUPPLY CITY PRIVATE CHIMNEY AND/OR FIREPLACE: RLr1L FLUE SIZE GARAGE TYPE : ATTAC ED -DETACHED UNDER NO. CARS GARAGE/DWELLING SEPARATION: DOOR TYPE . FIRE RATING MATERIALS: HR. FIRE RAT PORCH: FOOTING FOUNDATION PLEASE PROVIDE A BREIF DESCRIPTION OF WHAT THE SCOPE OF WORK IS TO BE DONE: W �in f �- , ,� -- I-all ee41)n 4 n.ce� d , wd,/��ve o�ote� A M ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 20 ADDRESS/LOC.ATION �6e LOCATE MAIN BLDG, ACCESSORY BLDGS, AND ANY ADDITIONS, GIVING ALL PERTINENT YARD DIMENSIONS REAR LOT LINE ft. LEFT LOT LINE ft. LEFT Yr= ft. REAR YARD ft. * ACCESSORY BUILDING DISTANCE SEPARATION LEFT YARD ft. RIGHT YARD ft. 10 FRONT YrlltD ft. RIGHT YARD � - ft. -� I FRONT LOT SLIME RIGHT LOT LINE ft. - ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL ,.•� �v .�+ vy�r �r � �=9�.3��w` '�tf3i.r"=�' #� �G�;[: ">�i'l:r. s�''i3?�F�`i�;?'r'E:�':�'d3�!• - -, ;��,;. r�:. �.zxh, � "" ,.;3�- ,�• '� �,. c�y A.%1r" � '"rs ' C � �� . ce ...J:.Y g , ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 22. N -AKEN ENGUNIa. HA LLP .0 .. ......... .. ------ December 9,,, 2016 Stephen Shaw 474 Broadway Saratoga Spnwngs,.NY 12866 Re,-, Artisanal Brew Works Special Inspection Report HE.Project No, 251330 Stephen, Haanen Engineering, LLP (HE) completed a v1sual OSpecial Inspection# of the steel Installation at the: Affisal Brew Works on 41 Geyser Road In Saratoga Springs, NY on December 8, 20164 The steel construeffon was Visually accessible at all locations Oasting room floor reinforcing and cantHevered stair) and was constructed as per plans and specifications developed by Hoorn Eng berm June 1, 2016. If questions arise i0th the above information, please contact me at (618) 793-7444 ex.tension 19, Very truly yours, HMNEN ENGINEERING LLP Daniel A, De Nero* R Er PrIncipat. Ab A 01241 AS, 254 Bay Road, Queensburyr NY 12804 Tel: 518,7934444 f aws S18493-7061 Email,,*,'hjh@hjhllc.com ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 23 �Q �w CD—O'o o z J J p W ry cn r Q W {A � z �J J ....� U) M� u C C a c F c L C L L C ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 24 2 0-0 Q 0 l C) Z0 �CL C) Lu 0 W 0m CLi LL Q J p Z Z Q ry r Q r w r J r 00 J J ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 26. OHAANEN ENGINEERING, LLQ" December 9, 2016 Stephen Shaw 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Re: Artisanal Brew Works Special Inspection Report HE Project No. 251330 Ste-.phe..n, Haanen Engineering, LLP (HE) completed a visual "Special Inspection" of the steel installation at the Artisanal Brew Works on 41 Geyser Road in Saratoga Springs, NY on December 8, 2016. The steel construction was visually accessible at all locations (tasting room floor reinforcing and cantilevered stair) and was constructed as per plans and specifications developed by Haanen Engineering June 1, 2016. If questions arise with the above information, please contact me at (518) 793-7444 extension 19. Very truly yours, HAANEN ENGINEERING, LLP Daniel A. De Nero, P. E. Principal 254 Bay Road, Queensbury, NY 12804 Tel: 518-793-7444 Fax: 518-793-7061 Email: hjh@hjhllc.com CD In z 3 CD C� C --N) C:) C37 CC) C7 0 (D( m0 a c CD. C C7 U] CD �C C7 C0 10 •1, I& is C� C0• 0 0 Cr w 0 —. 0 CD CD 0 C Z) • Q:D us 0 C Q 0 CSD M 0 C3 0 CD CD 0 2) -0 CD C C. CD Cr �] h r+ 0 0 i) CD 0 m 0 CD �" 3 0 CD CD0 0 CD CD —. CD fl) 0 a cr�C Q :D -'ICD � (n- 3 0w 0 {( 3 Cm? = ch ch • {p 0 0 =T 0+11 0 �] o CD > 0 CD �. cn 0 3 W � C: CD CD {n E3 CD a) %' CD 3 0 cr CD CD 0 r-+.•-+% - 3 0 CD , D7 fJ _'• j CD CD C7 - -•� zr 3 0 CD 3 CD 0 CD c =r CD F 0 0 CD CL(n W CD CD U) 0 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL FXH I RIT A PACE 27 LW --A" 0 n CD 90 0 4 3 CD CD 0 _ CD 0 CD C- -0 CD 3 CD 0 m r-+ 0 77, CD > CD CD W CD CD c' 3 CD V] CD = — CD C7 [� 0 � � 0 Z5 CD 0 C) zr Zr CD CD 0 3 CD 0 0 CD CI? � fl) � r+ � 0- 0 �. > CD --I tn• U) P-+- 0 -+0 0 i� r--F- 0 U) CD ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 28 ° o 0 �F. 'n L Q �' � (a 3 0w°�; a Cf7 fn _0 D O != 8 �, �, Fn. Ca > a (n < Co v � a CD 0 CC CD W ° cin_ © �, ' ,rt NCD (. .--� =rc � . o - M zs _ �+ sv O o ' cin _�' @ 3� crCD r. ED c 00 ------------------ -00 0 C) x' ° f° 0 4w e Q -0 ro n C m CD cn � W A CD.70 m CD CL o :3�+ ca rvn� i Q C7 2. CL* 0 [f? N til Cl) (C) a 0 � :3� 0 CD� � n r--�- C) MNN, E 1 -#- CD --+.ro 0 o' -.. iU m a : ( D z C:0- ci sc ro Q � (SFS — — :' 5 iT � Q o — (D �" i CJ C) U] p] � � ¢F] � d o T ' 1 �] LC] � iD D 0 CD > zi3 0 3 IV 3 n U)(D ill 63 D 0 6 C 3 co ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL I, EXHIBIT A PAGE 29" - Mal III sc�lmm � CD V-41 —10 3 m 00 h CD � (D CD 0 a- . (nCa _0 cn 0- cn3.-- 0< �-cn 0 CD CD MC oo 1< 0. a ~ - 0. ` l 0 -a -� ("] cn CD � M 0 CD C NO a■ C: CL c CD 0 � 3 0 m 00 �S 7r' cn :. LSD 0 +•� a S. 0 :3 n w CD -0 CD C+ 0 CD r.. r � 0 W Cv < 0 (n 0, > CD (n -0 CL 0 0 L. civ CL ---.- o CD W CD �- CL 90. N �.. �. 0 CSD --s(n�o X CCD o • cn 0w 0 En r -i - o a o �. • CD ^. 0 mo w �. o -% � o o - o �, o CL -1 � - C C) ,� r m+L m CD 0 -r ` CD CD CD �C: CD W 3 0 CD La)CD �' 0 .�CD CDQ Cn C �. � CD Svvi CD CDo 0 � r �- 0 �' (n 0 w"31 3 0 \V n cn .. c: CD 2> Z3 CD + • 0 _ � . CD L/ / CD ter. rr 3.� C: 5o °cO --- CD 0 crCD > cn (D 0 -. --% =3 0CD CD zT cn w cn. 0 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 30� ------------------------------------------------ © > v C 00 M .� 0 a 0' o' C N X N :01❑ o c v ° oID � Q.a5rn � Cl) COD -0 a =r❑ :n o N, CL W • m❑ m n `a �`� o 2 arN m D_a=• Cr o c�n C. -a ❑ < ° rn CD o N N rn v v ID � � CD c N v = �• sm v c cv Cr �' �- CL n :3 =)7 CL CD m CD � v ------------------------------------------------ © > v C 00 M .9-00 = 0 a 0' !c C N X g :C In 0) C77 U1 I=D 0 �y (0 • _A Z CD [D C. 2. a1 �} C c rr h �- 00 m Uf SD '— C a=0 w CD N (D r -F 'LTi S20 �i [�➢ A7 CD 7 m w a CA � � �t m � �' r-i•� CD c- o N' 0. �— s r►r m @ � Q a cn rn :3 CD �sD En ra m m Clio) r- 0 0 z m 0 m z 0 mn a 0 0 m z r-� 0 m IkRTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL 4m t �opt �,�Z �F EXHIBIT A PAGE 31. ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 32. �►FFIDAVIT Date 11/21/16 County: Saratoga Purpose: Bu.iiding Permit CoLIN M. QUINN came and appeared before me, the undersigned Notary, who is a resident of SaratogaCounty, State of New York, and makes this his/her statement and ty, General Affidavitp upon oath and affirmation of belief and personal knowledge that the following matters facts and thins set forth are true and correct to the best of his/her fo g g knowledge: The installation of the Aq uatherm piping installed at 41 Geyser Rd. in Saratoga Springs New York was done in accordance with all of the manufacturers specifications. DATED thisp I �day of &)CWIZA42z,e , 20� Signature of Affiant SWORN to subscribed before me, this 151 day l VnUC11n 20 )C-- r DYLAN C DEVERY My commission Expires: Notary Public, State of New York No. 01 DE6345609 Qualified in Saratoga County Commission Expires July 25, 20 --'?D ._ 10/1612018 Zimbra Fwd: Artisanal Brew. ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL Zim rd EXHIBIT A PAGE 33 richard.tiersch(gisaratoga-springs.org From : Richard Tiers-ch<richard.tiersch@saratpga-springs.org> Tui, Oct 16, 2018 10:5Q Aft subject Ford : Artisanal Brew 7'0 : Stefanie Richards <stefanierichard$@saratog&W springs.arg> Stefanie, The buildingdepartment has no issues at this time regarding the cabaret License for Artisanal Brew Works located at 41 Geyser Rd as long as "the seating remains the same as last year and there is a clear path of travel maintained to all exits at ALL tames". Artisanal Brew Works would also need 0 operate under the guidelines as described by Brad Birge below¢ t p Sincerely, Rich Tiersch Richard Tiersch Assistant Building & Construction Inspector City of Saratoga Springs y 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 518-587-3550 3550 ext . 2563 confidentiality/privilege Notice: This e-mail communication and any -files transmitted with it contain privileged and con�fidentLal information from the City � Springs of Saratoga ran s and are .intended solely for the use of the individual(s) or entity to which it has been addressedo if you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution or taking any other action with respect to the contents of tha.s message is strictly prohibited. if you have received, this e-mail in error, please delete it and notify the sender by return e-mail. Thank you -For your cooperation. - - _ - Forwarded Message " _ .�.Wo" From: "Bradley Birge" <bbirge Saratoga-springs.orp To: "Stefanie Richards" <stefan� e ¢ r*.cha rds@sa ratoga - springs . org> • "Richard Tiersch" <richard,tiersch saratoga-springs.orgy, 'Donna Buckley" <donna . buckley@saratoga - springs . org>, "Skip Sc,irocco" <skl . scirocco sarato a"s rin - s . org>, ' Mcarilyn L Rivers, cPcU ARNP AIC" p � g p g , <maril.yn . rivers@saratoga - springs ,vorg>, "Raelynn Smith" <rael nn.smith Sara toga- springs . erg>, "$usan Barden" <susan . barden@saratoga �- y. org a � s rin s"Patrick Cogan" <pat,rick. cogan saratoga- springs . org> p g Sent, Tuesday, October 16, 2018 9:32:10 AM Subject: Re: Artisanal drew https://m.saratoga-springs.org/h/printmessage?id= 2504&tz=Ameri�1� ca/New York 10/16/2018 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL im ra FXHIF IT A--PAGF 35 message is strictly prohibited, If you have received th:.s e please delete it and notify the sender by return email. Thank you for your cooperation* https:/lm.saratoga-sp6ngs.org/h/printmessage?id=2564&tz=America/Neter York 313 0 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 36 CITY OF sAR&TOGA SPRINGS RECEIVED 36 LICENSE 112018 New Application or Renewal Application (etre% one) , 31 , APF U NTS DEPARTMENT ()Xiiginal date of a Hicationn Current Expiration Bann ,and ifrinkiu Cal ar Lo (# of rooms j Sidewalk of k1k - .M%rJS - L Name of Buses ar-.e LJ 1A I Businem Physical Address 3. Businm Mei Address a-11 . --- czovl +t, Bum=s Web Address 92 A. S. Bushm$ phone � aFaxNumber Emergency dell ] itoue 6. Applicant's Nme , , 11 J 7''. Applimmes Home Ad& • 8. Applicant F plicant's Date of Birth 9. Busim s ow4cr. Email`reayuvr Phonegoo Emai : +..,. Phone io. Emergency Coutwt 2_ -- u. Cwt occupation 17. Applicable Business Experience 3----ur%j5 1* 13. termer of PMPMty Properly Owner's Mm 14. Property O=W3 Address t5. Desc aes in detail, semces provided and thq uselof your prcrnisea:_ ' t6. Type of fire protection equipment: '`" Spriuld,er System? YesDliold U yes, daft last inspected andVer serviced: By who: Fira Extinguishers? Yes o many extiu&shers? if yes, date last Impeeted =&or eed: 4-- By Who: commmial Elba= isoash? Yes, NO IZ if yes, date last inspected and/or serviced: . By Who; -Fire Alaun System? Yes]ANOO +e Who: If yea, date last lnVected and/or servIced By 0khcr? 17.%irai on dam of New York State DepaaC�t of kl=lth Cmlificate gr New yo�rk State DWrtment ofAgriculture and Markets Food ExpProm g pertm it (Please include copy) 18, is kitchen equipped w& a flmc dorsal �e trap or gc+rase ince epinr`�' Yes c If ea frequency of fs "onteeMee? weeldyC]Bi-weeltly[DNfontbin Other By Who: j"rfi"i,�,� 0 ffi l9 Hoesy= business use a tester? Y NCO "Yrs, contpct the Depanrnent oo, f.P41ic Safety to obtain the required D umpster Permit). gyp, Does your t usincsa have as alarm system? Yes []No (7f)w, you w fl be reed complete the orte ii Alarm User P"U). bow man bars do you have�nciude n and skeliite}? Zl. Do you sere alcoholic bevagw? YesteNo[3 yep y Ifye.% you are required, to subudc wiitb this appUcation nit of your current Now York State Liquor Licenses. 12, if renewing, have you made auy floor plea changes aincc your last repewal? Y431 „ Ma ui jr,Leb ptepse jaciude an updated floor pia% neer applications vault supply floor pl . (pioor plait can bre as simple as a sketch or. an 11110 Mace of paper to s'bow &a Lsrut of your estmbl Went.) qty of Saratoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 6-1-2017 � ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 37 -23.3. Do You p y �J em to seems guards or hire s ecuxitY wards for your business? Yes No l es you are required to submit proof with thrg appflica on thatyorar eslablishvient is registered a a d licensed w4h the Mate of New York Department of SWO Oman Of , !"using authorizing you 1w einploy seenri fy guard& You must dso provide with this a iication ar deMi►led s"ich �` a ch aro addition sheet of papar) Of the idend yrng shirt your business will he asing ass file seder � �� ,��'��' across fire guard taniforrn, which has to indade your bosun s name, as w l as five inch leering, all capital Iegm, the �`i oss the chest of ilia grant of the shirt, qad across the shoulder blades an the hgek o ff. the shtr� This Citi be suhme#ed �� h ty' Wipe to the �° en artmt o, f Public SOW , far aRrOv ai. Your seem�y glsarrds aro repaired to wear Public �'a,�ety axPproVed .lf Wente' acadon whale employed of your estahiishment. W&hix the f; Yst f,vc (5) days of evapi4yrnent of each security gase°d, You will he required to pravide the C'itypraof of each se up* guard -Is New York State registration) 14. Describe, in detail, the fixed locations of Your security wards; The Ci of Saratoga Siwings requires: t, A Cer0cate of Insurance for Prapf of commercial genes liability insarance, including persgnal injury liability insurance, in the amount of one Ilion Dollars ($1,000,000) per occurrence and Two Million Dollars aggrepte, naming the City, of Samtoga Sptings as an additional Insured. The City shall be included. as an additional imured on said insurance for the pmm t(s) process. The City of Saratoga Springs must be Med as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway; Saratoga Springs, NY 12866. 2. proof of Now York State statatory workers` compensation and employer's liability insurance for all employees, or a waivers of same as permitted by law. 3. For si&walk cafes that serge alcoholic beverages, a. Certificate of Insurance for Liquor legal liability insurance in the amount of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) body injury and property dmage per each ocaarrence must be submitted with this application. Such insurance must contain a provision that the Cormnisszoacr of Accounts be notified if the poUcy is cancelled or if there has bei► a material change in coverage and,tor conditions. The City of Saratoga Springs must be listed as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866. The Certificate nix' the City of Saratoga Springs as Additional Insured solely for the issuax2o'fV itfsl should be addressed to the attention of: Department ofAccounts City of Sairatoga. Springs 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Attention: City C leak}s Office The Licensee acknowledges that failure to obtain such insurance on behalf of the municipality constitutes a material breach of contract and ejects Licensee to llability for damages} indemnification and all other legal remedies available to the City. The Licensee is to provide the City with a Cerdficate of Inmance naming the City as Addition. Insured � t4 the issuance of any permit. The failure to object to the contents offt Certificate ofInmrance or the absence of same slall not be deemed a waiver of any and all rights held by the municipality, The Licemee sball indemnify and save harmless the City of Saratoga Springs, its Agents and Employees (hereinafter preferred to as "City''), from and against all claims,damages, losses and expenses 'u�cludw�g, but not limited to, attorneys' fees), arising out of or resulting from the licensed activity, susW=d by any person or persons, provided that any such claim, damage, less or expense is attributable to bodily injury, ase or d 4r to in' ` de uclion of proms caused by a tortuous act or negligent act or omission of Licensee or its &ick�ness, disease, est, .iurY employees, its agents or aubcontracWres. Nothing in this lieense sW be eonstraed as granting the Cpnunissjoner al Accounts any power to confer rights upon license holders to do or p erform any act in contravention of my duly adopted zoning regulations or ordinance in erect in the City of Saratoga Springs. It shall be the respousibility of the licensee to detern mi if bis or herr activity complies with the applicablo zoning ordinwes. City of Saratoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 6-1-2017 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 38 *d this is ars 1pi ial app licafion for an eating an€t drinking, cabaret, or lodging license, you are required to submit with your applicatiOn two .� .ballvraysa doors, (2) s of detailed pious for your establishu=t. Plans mast inclWe a floor plan icaftg the location. of all rooms, windows, reception tion. areas, kitchen facilities, batbroorn facilities, exits, bar or bars, fixed stations for security guards, and all fixe, ,protection e moat, The ia� meed to show the location of your structure relakive to other parcels of land, adjacent streets, sidewalks, and p�►lic equip meat gays if your mtblishment has on-site parking facilities, ftplans moat shote' them *.f rijis is an iniliari appiictafion for a sld alk W6 license, you are rcqu fired to submit four (4) suis of detailed plans for your establishment. You must have a -valid eating sd ung license in order to obtain" a sidewalk cafe Ucwsc. For the rectuirements and specifications on the layout of sidewalk cafes see the attached copy of the Code chapter 13th -24, 136-25. Be advised there is an application fee for s hearse PS well as a licmc fee. � � is �� a ae! a c orp, being duty sworn and depose and state that no park of the subject .#' pp premises, sus provided and use o pareises has 4bIUany sbstial matter sire rn. previous Iicese was issta. If Ih& is a# ��l�ca�v� „�o� � s�a��w�1�C c�c��, � agree to be fully responsible, to correct y +damages c=sed to the sidewalk a �t of my business'. sitdewalk cod, including financially, .k dtv,4 A % agr to cagVly with all applicable. stag and local orlinances andlor law and agree to operate is business m tam compliance of those lags and ordinances. I lmderstand mfr 11censo(s) have annualrenewal date(s) and that I am solely responsible to renew mfr lipense(s) prior to the expiration date(s). HI Alit to renew my license(s) ptior to the expiration dates I agree to pay the re-appllea tion fee of $250.00 per license. Date `l — /0 /49 STATE OF"NEW YORK 68: COUNTY of SARATOGA ) Sigiiature of Applicant On the day of of D_ before me, the undersigned, o Not ry PubliclCo�ssxonu of Reeds in and for said Stat, pmonally appeared personally known to me or proved to ane On the basis ofsatisfacto3ry evidence to be the individual(s) whose zame(s) is (arc) subscribed to the wiflAn. instrument aoLd acknowledged to me that shelthe executed the same in hi�rltheir ca acity(%cs), and. that by his/ber/their signatur(s) on the i to neat, the individual(s), or h� � � persons upon behalf of which the individual(s) acbA eUMUCd the *torment. Nom Nblic[Commissioner ofDecds Fees. $ l 00.00 Bating and Winking License $150.40 CAbnret License $15.40 sidewalk r�'f�,4 TA�pplicadon $50.00 Sidewalk Caf6 Lir- .nso Lodging License: 5 rooms or less $25.00 6— 10 rooms $50.00 11-- 25 room $75.00 26 --100 roams $100.00 101 rooms or above $150,00 r,tty of Saratoga Spring Chapter 136 Li arse Appiicatioa 6-1-20 17 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 39 RATE tMMrazaIWWI CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE TIMI A'TE S... .ISSUED AS. A MATTER OF INFORMATION QNLY AND CONFERS No RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THE THIS CEPrERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVKY AMEN13y EXTEND OR A4TER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED ESC THE POLICIES IE 13ELO . THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSIURANCE DOCS NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT 0ETWEEN THE ISSUINe INSIXER(S), AUTHORIZED REPREBENTATIVE OR PRODUCER, AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. ImPaRTANT, If the ra ffifti.at c Iden �� an APP INSUU0, the p006l (I*s ri l�$ R DITIONAL. INSPIRED �r��sloI�s Qr be endcr�6da If SUBRI OQATION 15 AJVEF)r subject to the terms and cords lons of the policy, cartaill p1lo1may require 6p endorsement. A statemant an this g0roficato does not confer rlghta to aha cerdflcate holder In IIau of s Ch endomement - � HUGE N � ' I Ouse PHONE TSig iA �dlnauan O - 3123 Bay Raved Af31R�£S: P0 130.X 46aO Q I et ul�, N� 2 g �I��U� A. TO(at l of MinneeWta 9 3 Ho �rapeW QUINN $QRn'+"i ,A ADT BREWING LI �A1 � V i AR11gANAL IjrJEW WORKS a I 41GEYSER ROAD INaURIER F. SARATQGA SPRING$ NY 12- � a r REVISION UMBERRCERTE NUI1ERD :OERA I ill _ To cERT�FYTHAT THE PIES QF INSURW9 Q. TEO JBELO���I�A�IE BEES! FLIED TOtRE JN$V E� i�A�E� AS�i1E F�RTt�E I��t 1� @E�1�1� MICATEoi NDTWITHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENTt TFRM OR 0 al -HER Q�00�lrHRES F -OT To WHH THIS �A�I()�� C R'T�� ATE MAY BE ISSuE� ORC MAY PERTAIN, THE INS JRA ASF t 3 BY THE I� MES D_PgFUB�p HER51N i5 S.tlSJECT TO ALL THE TERf+�l�i EXCLUSIONS A CONDITIONS NS OF SUCH POLICIES., SR Lltl I ` HOWN MAy VE SEEN R��J�E€� BY PAIS �l�.l�'$�, .. LTR TYPE OF INSURAKE � POLICY NUMOSR ��gw��»� Islr�i�� C�MRCi�►�-GtrNP ►1..1.1A®iR.Si"�f EACH OCCURRENCE � 50OV000 CLAUMS-MME � OCCM T PfiIL SSE � ri n Y MM EXP AnY We P8M0€fa A ADV��7N66.12 0910112018 r(I �#]OD,© PERSONAL & A'CV INJURY G iE Lti�ll�'A lIES PEFi; GENERALAGGRE[�TR GFN'LA 4,pbd,000 FRO- LCA PRODUCT$-COF�F��i�A.GG S P J90T C#THEFt: N3 sIN� LlMrr,0[��io AUTOPAPPILR 1?Eq a6ddan�) WAPTO 40 DWY I144URY (For p n� A ��L � DUL ApV6273effi-12 09101/2Q18 09101/2019 00 Y INJURY (PeriW, ) AUTM OW PWFE A ACE HREC ONLY � Par acc, W AUTOS tMORMf.A �R OCCUR _ EACH €�=URRENCE EXCE35 IUAR C�4II►��1�' ME A�L�RE��'E � i CECT RETE _ IO_N HER CRKr: Cil mmusA ON A STA-�v� ER . ANP EXPLOYERV MAIR LITY Y 1 N 'I t� x'090 AKY P' OPRIET 'ARTNER WCU RVE N A 09 E '" 401 �3!'I 2�9 031161901 E.L. EACH r C l��i' ICERNE R EXCLUD03 E.L. s�As EMPLOYEE O�rE �9na , d� Ewer E.L. ©IGWe- POLICY WMIT 3 wo,poo . PTI 7N OF OPERATIONS raw A I~, r s rR,iabil AQV5273680-i2 09101018 0913'I1209 C opromvn came 2.000,000 u81nes5 pafse(lal Propq limit !;216Q0 dodwt 41e, 4409 i I � ape-RATI.QWS I LOCATHM I �OL118 (ACORD 9 94 A4ORN ��i Fl �r d , air oat I)d t �€ tt a r�q�utrndl id 611 pollqy tArms, lirnttaltons and candOW41, C Ilmts Holder Is AddiNnal Insured on a Kmary Non Conhbift y ba -5W, incl ing ���ai o� ��ah�g�,Il��, when r Uis�d �� �i R ��tra��, a�F��men� or pangt ERTiFI4 4'fE HOL�ER CANCELLATION__ Y $HOULD ANY OF THE ABOVE I�EPMRISEP POLICIES BE CANCE4WD IiEFQkRE TIJZ EXpIR ►TION DATE THER!WFt NOTICE VW LL RE 09VVEREP IN $erax ri s ACCORDANC2 Ifs 4TH THF— POUCY PR�� ION5. �!� a� . �9� � n9 474 aedwgy AuVO4 0 2PIMse�TAT ' ■ Saratoga prings N w 1983-9010 ACORP PDRPORATION, All rights reserved. ACORD 25 (2016103) T'he.APORD Pomp qt4 logo are registpredmarks 9f ACC)RO ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 40 STATE OF IN" YOB. WORKS .S' COWENSATION BOARD OF 1 T' S WORKERS,, C()MPENSATION INSURANCE COVERAGE CERTFcCAxE se street address only) Ian gal Name � Address of Insured �T �' I.b. Business Telephone lumber of Insured Guinn Borchardt Brewing LLC Art[sanai Brew Works &e. NYS Unemployment Insurance Employer c/o Colin Quinn Registratign Number of Insured 493 Labe Desolation Road Diddle Grove, NY 12850 Id. Federal Employer Identification Nuluher of Insured or Som Security Number 474970368 Work Location of Insured (Daly repired if coverage is sp9cificidlY ftited to certain locations in New fork ,state, 4a, a WrqpUP Address of the Entity eques g rroof of �. �a�e and A 3a. amo of Insu€r=ce Carrier Hartford Propel & Casualty Coverage (Entity Being Listed as the Certificate older 3b. PoUcy Number of entity listed In box '11W' City of Saratoga Springs 01WECZ12401 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs 1 1 .8b 3c� Policy effete period 31161101 , to 311 M1 9. 3d. The Proprietor, Partners or Execudve Officers are included, (Only check box if an partners/a rs Included) all excluded or certain partners/officers excluded. This catifies that the insurance eamier indicated above in box "4341 uWS tae business referenced above in u0p. la, 101 WMIN43 State "or :�' ozx .tion Law. o use this forun, New York OM must bo Usted wader Items 3A cotnper�on under the New ' .� on the + }�A`I'I AGE of a or ° coa�peusation di Insurance policy). 9(Ue Insurance Caer or its licensed agent w send tbds CertifIcate. of Insuxanee to the entity listed above as the cerfificate holder M box 2 Insurance Carrier will also notify tho above cerci cato holderwith n 10 days IF apolicy is canceled due nonpayment of pr=emign s or the coverage ' hire 30 days IF there are re�aso atter t1jan noj)paym t 0 pemiums that cancel the policy or elindnate the insured ft'orn Ott ,� FM ' e i ,� ese no�aggs may be senf y regular mail.) Otherwise, the ��r�f�ca� �'s rc� 'far aye year a�t'er Ih�.�a indicated hrswhiche Is a . ro�u h t lInsurance carrkr or its licensed e .0 ar anal ��e�al�cy �lrat�� die �ls�e� �� �e� r��c' ; ,, y Please tote. PU ou the canceration of the woar rs' -empensation policy indicated on this form, if the bless continues to be permit, Keense or contract issnpd by a cerdfleate holder the boolne" must provide that certi0eate,holder w�t� a �� named on a � � - t of Wormers' Compensation Coverage or other authored proof that the business � c���l�� ��� the �a�td�t�r� Certificate . � coverage requireluents of the New York StateWorkers' Compewation Law. Under penalty o perjury, I eerti� f that I am an authOrized representative or licensed agent of the insurance cairier referenced � above and that the unwed Inured bas the coverage ps depleted on ffiis form. Approved by: Ueda Abodeely Rdnt nam of ;au rized represcotative or licensed agent of insurance carrier) Approved by: �° =• S ember 1� 2M (side) •`'� ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 41. Title: President Telephone Number of authorized representative or licensed agent of insuran carrier: 518-723-3131 . .�kase �oje. Only insurance offers and their licensed agents are authorized to issue FOrIn 105.2. I surar�ee brokers acre ���` 4UthQriZed to issue it. www,web.state.ny,us C-105.2 (9"07) ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 42 STATE OF NEW YORK WORJCRRS� C01.4pFNATIONBOARD CERTIFICATE OF CF, O ERAE UNDER THE NYDISABILITY BENEFITS LAW. le Disabih a fts Carrier or Licensed bsurance Agent of that Carrier PART �.. To be completed .. ].b. l�u�iuess Telephone Number of Insured a. �.egal Name and ,address of insured (Use ��eet ad.dre�s onl.. �) Quim Borchardt Bmwing LLCc. SYS nernpla neat insurance Employer Registration Artisanal 73£e Works Number of Inred c/o Colin Quinn 493 Lake Desolation Road Middle Grove, NY 12850 1 d. Federal EMPIOYer 1deu.tifcatiOnNurr�ber of Insured or Social Seeuritsr Number 474970368 __ . Name and Address of the EntKy Req=ting Proof Of 3a. Name of Insurance C =Jer Coverage QRntity Being Listed as the C ertificatc Holders Standard Security Life Ins. CCS.. of NY 3b. policy Number of entity listed in box" l.a": C i of Sarato a S rigs 885344-000 gr p 474 Broadway Sarato g a. S r� 128666 3c. policy effective period: p 3/16/2018 to 3/16/2019 4. Policy covers: . eligible under the New York Disability Benefits Law • a. A11 ofe eplrg s employeesli g b. Only the faUowing class or classes of the employer's employees: Under pqpa1Vofpedury, I cert" � ate. an authorized representative or licensed agent of the insurance carrier referenced above and tha� � t t the named ins=d has NYS Disability Bi.edits inse covera. ajrqcntative 'bed. above, Date Signed Septe 18 , By �, LSignatmv of lance aaarrices authorizo2rINYS Licensed imurance Agent sof that �asurgncocarder) 5.8--X93--151 president Telephone lumber Title o u4a" ��iec a, � s form i3 sied by. the insurance garDOORTANT. if ter's authorizedre�rese� hve or s Lice Yaaurance I►g+ t of that cxteX, thfs cerWk is 15 C()i'IXXTE. a 1't (jirecay to tha eperhfiae to hold-or. 1f box 114b"is che*ed, Ibis cer#ireate hr NOT COMPLLTFq for purpages of Sectioja 220, Subd. S of #.ixe �sabiii� Bene. fits �Ga�.1t Inst be m$Ued for Co i thorn � the worki.5 ' co rpeAsatinnBoards D13 Plans A= tanc6 Unit, 29 Park Street, Albany, New York 12207. PART 2. To be completed � N' N'o rl rs� ensati n Board o� if box .644b" of Part 1 has been checked) State Of New York Workers' Comp ens n on Beard Ace arWmg to information ma tam by the NYS Workers' compensation Board, the above-named employer has complied with the NYS Disabaflty jacaef.ts jAw with respect to all of his/her employees. Date Signed B (Signarare QfNYS Workers' compensation Board Employee) Telephone Number 'ride F oss Note; only insurance carriers 11cerise d � ' ,e. ' S' is benefits s ins nee policy and eased insurance ggent� o '► ► `�i ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 43 • ' r re authorized to issue Forrx�. DB -1, 0.1. Insurance brokers are OT authorized to issue this form. those insurance eor��e s a DB -120.1(5-06) ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 44 City of Sarataga Cha ter 136 License. needed: AnnficatIOR arm user Permit (O #Me) ter Vermit Ef ..� v:rs �:r•"�tC r+y., i i�•v�::�y,•.' ;v r,-• a j.+�v.� ..... wi..r,•.ve•r��r' .. +�..�^"s'."t""".'•' �.. tY�"�„'. '3 S �rl��r.�6:►iy� �e �r. s'!d.':.�. fes• t «r...,.� .a.�- •s'•s^s�rr n.rx-•.+..-r•� ....: » .�...««. ._�•••: ..:.. sly Y.: c::: r;:•s.». r•iv�rfti►.� ~a •,.� �` :s• . u�.ts•.'.—v'�:.,-- -y» .•..p,� .�.a. s�.yii75• ty i•.' r�i•:;��-.^-$r•��1'lly�ai;:���+'i'� 1'tiF�[�k!�'Alll�i v- ,. .» ... - . ' �----r--�-r-. - -- Floor flans -of new lappjkgtjOp, oir If any chang" have boon made since Lest rememal) Agree meet for sidewalk c*s (Yg Nj N/A) (on ffie third page) Security Guard proof of employer registrgtion with. NYS OfappfieoLble) Security Guard proof of employee(s) realstration with NYS (if applicable) NYS Liquor License (if apocabie) Liquor Liability (only If 0 sldew Wk cate opplition) lag General LiabiUtyw (Na ng City of Saratoga Sprigs 474 Broadway Certificae Wider, and additionAy inswed on a primary and non-contributory basis) Workers Comp -4f no employees, must do waiver NYS Disability -4" no a pio mp must do waiver NYS Health Cerfficate Fire Inspection Fee paid (Y9 N _ el•3! •Lslc tds a*� r..• �•• ..rr ...:�fa ...•.Yj,�^R�..x::.s.' .0 ."'-""-",. •S.=L:_L�':.C�;.• y�:�i.e L• t �• �:7: »'::.'::"-:n:..::.. . ,..: e � a.i�wre u• s.:si.» ...,_.....-.....« r•. F^ �'x:• � e. `���"� � �` ��'Sk �t � .. - ,'r�sr: For assistance piem cantaco Nicholas S. L=ekus BRYCER-, LLC 4355 Weaver Pae4woy, Sub; 3'30 Warrenvill% TL 60555 Q: 6359-7301 Q 630-253-6825 License Fee: $100, 00 ,Eating and Drinking cewe 150.00 Cabaret Licer-se $15.00 Mdewalk Cafg Ap pfication $50.00 57dowalk Cafe cense Loefn ,Ucen,ve: 5 roots or less $.5=00 6 — 10 rooms x`50.00 11— 25 rooms $75,00 26 —100 rooms $100.00 101 roQms or above $150.00 city of map Springs Chapter 136 Lice Apple ioik f)-1-•2017 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL 9/28(2017 Zimbra -_-- 3 - EXHIBIT A PAGE 45 Zimbra - john.barney@saratoga-springsaorg Re: Artisanal Brew Works From : John Barney <john. barney@saratoga-springs.org > Wed, Sep 27, 2017 04:39 PM Subject: Re: Artisanal Brew Works To : Carrie spencer <Carrie.spencer@saratoga-springs.org Carrie, The Building Dept has no issues at this time regarding the Eating and Drinking License for Artisanal Brew Works (41 Geyser Rd). Sincerely, John Barney Zoning and Building Technician From: "Carrie Spencer" < ca rrie. spencer@sa ratoga--springs. org > To: "Brad Birge" <bbirge@saratoga-springs.org}, "Danielle Willard` <danielle.willard @saratoga-springs.org, "Donna Buckley" <donna.buckley@saratoga- springs.orp, "John Barney" <john. barney@saratoga-springs.org, "Kathleen Farone" kath leen.farone@saratoga-springs.org >, "Marilyn Rivers" < marilyn. rivers@saratoga- springs.org>, "Raelynn Smith" <raelynn.smith@saratoga-springs.org, "Skip Scirocco" ski p.scirocco@saratoga-springs.org > Sent: Wednesday, August 30, 2017 11:06:46 AM Subject: Artisanal Brew Works Attached is the eating &drinking and cabaret applications for Artisanal Brew Works, please advise of approval or denial. Thank you, Carrie Carrie Spencer Senior Clerk, Accounts Department Saratoga Springs City .mall 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, CITY 12866-2292 Office: 518-587-355o ext. 2546 Fax: 518-58,7-6512 tV W -S ■ in s. ag Confidentiality/Privilege Notice: This e-mail communication and any files transmitted with it contain privileged and confidential information from the City of Saratoga Springs and are intended solely for the use of the individual(s) or entity to which it has been addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, https:Hm.saratoga-springs.org/h/printmessage?id=9538&tz=America/New York 1/2 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL 9/28/2017 Zfmbra distribution, or taking any other action with respect to the contents of th'r�m�ssTs3UrIBIT APi AGE prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please delete it and notify the sender by return e-mail. Thank you for your cooperation. https:Hm.saratoga-springs.org/h/printmessage?id=9538&tz=America/New York 2/2 1. 2. 4. 5, 'JAK"A' xo W ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 47 CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS CHAPTER 136 LICENSES New Application of, ; e ,,�enewal Application (qlrch one _ �a A� Original date of H tion 31, Current Expiration 31 PP ` VtLo gin Caf Eating a ad Drj*AWn Cabare d (M of rooms ___) Sidewalk Caff Na= of Business - - Lj cf L5 M 4 1 -],-2-L%A Business Physical Address ff r Business Moiling Address Business Wcb Ad&= aEF#-!5a*114bca Business Phone 15 A'" 61331 Fax Number Emerge -au Cell Phorie 6. Applicants Name 4,0b'A LL/ -L4 - - I Applicant's Home Add - q Ica- De"68pio%- S. Applicmes Home PhobPp licmt's Date ofBirffi 9. Business Owner.. 6W on - 0---U-9kf V-) Email: 10. Emergmcy ContactEmail: k(,Jr�. L2�44 140trhone 1 5low1 M 11. C=cntOccupati(m oeegoea..., r 12. Applicable Business Experience 61 11r S� ^ CIS 13. Owner of Property Property Owner's Phone 14 Property Owner's A I rcss S44K -W -AAP- IL - 15, DescribeY in detaill, services provided and the uses of your premises: 73r,-e")kVPV 7L."e, *.r- -._ Mir 16, Type of fire proteotion equipment: sprinkler System? Yes[] No& If yes,, date last inspee 71ed and/or serviced. By Who: Fire Extinguishers? Yes. o 11many extinguishers? , 10Gw If yes,, date last Inspected 2nd/or se" ced: -Eywho -d Commercial Exhaust Hood? YesE]No if yes, da to last inspected andlor serviced; Bywho: Fire Alarm System? Yej—] Na If yes, date lost inspected and/or serviced: BY Who: Odwr? 17 Bxplrafion date of New York State Department of Health Certificate Er New York State Department ofAgriculWe and Markets Food Processing permit 16 3 0' �Ileasc include copy) is. Is Behen equipped with a fumetional grease trap or grease interceptor? YesE)q0d,--2> IL(,.e k;tcLN If -yes, frequency of laspection/3ervice? Weejdy0j3j-weekly[:]Monffi1)[] Other By who: 19. Does your business use a dumpster? Yes AI\ToL] Wyes, contact the 1►epartrxent qfPziblic Safety to obudn the required Duerr Pennio. V ---j es �No Alarm User Permit) (Ifyes, you -will be requbvd to complete the one20. Does your business hive an alann system? YV, 21, Doyou serve alcoholic beverages? Yes J21NZ31fyes, how many bars do you have (include main and satellite)? 49-1 If yes, you are required to submit with this application all of your current New York EState fquorLkenses. 22- if renewing, have you made any floor plan changes since your last renewal? Yesf— L No If please include an updated floor plan. All new applications must supply floor planL (Floor plats can be as simple as sketch on as 8x10 piece of paper to show the layout of your establishment.} City of S&atoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 6-1-2017 2 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 48 23. Da you employ security guards or hire security, guards for your business? ices No {J. fives, YOU are required to submitproof with this appiicagop th at your establishment is registered and licensed with the Slate of New York D epariment of State Division of Licensing auth orklug you 10 e'mpl'oy security ,guards. You must also provide with 111is application a detailed sketch (attoch ars additional Aeet ofpaper) of the idexrfifyrng shirt your husiness will be using as the secures guard teniform, which 1ias to include your business name, as well its five inch lettering, all capital letters, SECUPJTY across ilia chest of the front of the shirt, and across the shoulder Blades on the baek of lire shirt. This will be subinitied by the a'r'ty Clerk's Office to the Department of public Safety for approval' Your security guards are required to wear Public Safety arppra-Ved idenjificalion while employed at your esfceblxshtttertt. lrVyllin the fiTst fjve (5) days of employment o, f each security guard, yore will be required to provide the City proof of each security gu ard-Is Nine York State registration) 24. Describe, in detail, the fixed locations of your security guards: The Ci of Saratoga..Svrinu re uires: x. A Certificate of Insurance for Proof of commercial general, liability ninsurance, including personal injury liability insurance, in the amount of One Million Dollars ($1,000x000) per occurrence and Two Million Dollars ($2,0003000) aggregate, naming the City of Saratoga Springs as an additional insured. The City shall be included as an additional insured on said insurance for the permit(s) process. The City of Saratoga Springs must be listed as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway, Saratoga Springs, NY 12566. 2. Proof of New York State statutory workers' compensation and employer's liability insurance for all employees, or a waiver of same as permitted by lay. 3. For sidewalk cafes that serve alcoholic beverages, a Certificate of Insurance for liquor legal liability insurance in the amount of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) bodily injury and properly damage per each occurrence must be submitted with this application. Such insurance roust contain a provision Haat the Commissioner of Accounts be notified if the policy is cancelled or if there has been a material change in coverage audlor conditions. The City of Saratoga Springs must be listed as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway, Saratoga Springs, NY 12$66, The Certificate naming the City of Saratoga Springs as Additional Insured solely for the issuance ofpemit(s) should be addressed to the attention. of Department of Accounts City of Saratoga Springs 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Attention. City Clerk's Office The Licensee acknowledges that failure to obtain such insurance on behalf of the municipality constitutes a material breach of contract and subjects Licensee to liability for damages, indemnification and all other legal remedies available to the Clay. The Licensee is to provide the City with a Certificate of Xusurance namirng the City as Additional Insured prior to the issuance of any permit. The fat7ure to object to the contents of the Certificate of Insurance or the absence of same shall not be deemed a waiver of any and all rights held by the municipality. The Licensee shall mderma_fy and save harmless the City of Saratoga Springs, its Agents and Employees (hereinafter referred to as "City"), frons and against all claims, damages, losses and expenses (including, but not luted to, attomeys' fees), arising out of or resulting from the licensed activity, sustained by any person or persons, provided that any such claim, damages lass or expense is attribu#able to bodily injury, sickness, diseases or death, or to injury to or destruction of property caused by the tortuous act or negligent act or otnission of Licensee or its . employees, its agents or subcontractors. Nothing in. this license shall be construed as granting the Commissioner of Accounts any power to confer rights upon license holders to do or d zon'vag regulations or ordinance in. effect in the City of Saratoga Springs. It shall be the perform any act in contravention of any duly adapte responsibility ofthe licensee to determine ifbis or her activity complies with the applicable zoning ordinances. City of Saratoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 6-1-2017 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 49 *If 111ls is an inif'al application for an eating and drinldng, cabaret, or lodging license, you axe required to submit with your application two (2) sets of detailed puns for your establishment. Plans must include a floor plan iadicating the location of all roams, hallways, doors, windows, -reception areas, kitchen facilities, bathroom facilities, exits, bar or bass, &red stations for security guards, and all fire protection equipment. The plans need to show the location of your structure relative to other parcels of land, adjacent streets, sidewalks, and public wags. If your establishment has onsite parking faciities, the plans must show them. *If ihis is an initial applieation for a sidewalk cafe license, you are required to submit four (4) sets of detailed pians for your establishment. You must have a valid eating and druiUng license in ardor to obtalu a sidewalk caf6 license. For the requirements and specifications on the layout of sidewalk cafes see the attached copy of the Code chapter 136-24, 136-25. Be advised #here is an application fee for this license as well as a license fee. y I Hits is a renewal a licallon,1 ! � being duly sworn and depose and state that no part of the subject If .�F premises, services provided and uses of premises has changed in any substantial matter since my previous license was issued. Ifr this is ars application for a sidewalk cafe, I _ _--- , agree to be fully responsible, to correct any damages caused to the sidewalk as a result of my business' sidewalk cafd, including financially. r � � .i-, agree to comply with all applicable state and local ordinances and/or law and ogre a to operate this business in total compliance of those laws and ordinances. I understand my licenses) have mmual renewal date(s) and that I am solely responsible to renew my license(s) prior to the expiration date(s). If I fail to renew ray licenses prior to the expiration date(s) I agree is pay Ie, re-application fee of $250.00 per license. &Z I I .-r Date Signature of Applicant STATE OF NEW YORK � ss; COUNTY OF SARATOGA � �n the day of of 2� before rase, the undersigned, a rotary PublicConx�missioner ofDeeds in and for said State, personally appe4 personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual(s) whose names) is (are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same nx his/her/their capacity(ics), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument, the individual(s), or persons upon behalf of which the individuals) acted, executed the instrument. 640t C mom. sioncr of Deeds Fees: $100.00 Eating and Drinking License $150.00 Cabaret License $15.00 Sidewalk Cafd Application $50.00 Sidewalk Caf6 License Lodging License: 5 roams or less $25.00 6 —10 rooms $50.00 11— 25 rooms $75.00 26 --100 roams $100.00 101 rooms or above $150.00 City of Saratoga Springs Chapter 136 License AppIication 6-1-2017 . . ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL - .%,'-,tW%%f,-'.--'�'ll,r---�—.", 1:7. -f.,., —, .. . ti -l" . -.11 — � .. .. � �'.'-.-. i. . INO'L q j ".. ,.� 5-1 � � . IF %I. ''-U ~ .$% � 56, In -r - .. 5'.. .I.- . - ... .it � ,y -,jk-�. . J, m , �.m . , .,? . , " �- `: ",---, ,7!, Ag 1. . . ll.,:� — - -i .;io�qf Arill t j;jj-1 - ... I �-`-!`..., I -5011 : Ea. - I I Im S. .� , J . , .) 8, - ""' . .I?-.;.-.--- ... . - I j I SMAN't � wKs'"a"Miiii, ...... , ... I . — , -L"v I 1 � � marAffil-M . .... . ` i &Ai IF 01.1 — -- -- 'M N1v-?lJ:q!J - - ill. tif -*, . . M. . . - � Ow -.e. - T -. 11:'.1 .' _. .- ..." ;r7c . - , - 5. . ,.f-;AR:A2--- .—I" F7. /—/,�— le, . . ..: I ; ". a . - � '.. - 1: A@- � ., � f ii. �!..M - - - --- - .. , , -, - -g - IR 1 ,,,5*Ki--.;,---- -- . - "S....- - r- %, ui.% `Y -n * t - I o,';� �i - lj�n, -& , .. 4." !; . , .6 . , " - ,;A-!... , g, 4--fw1.�,.--.-Y- A . - - - - . ; . 11 . 201j, . . . .2 1-m , E.�.. ., .. ;!�, Y - RAA . : g- I . . - . . .- . - --, .. . . . Aw! 1 1,10 t). .i i,. ... - - . q � I 1A ;�J-:r-,%,J-'r� - � 1& �.�- . a , I . = I - I STP. -i L .�.L Q § .. . . K . .3� N R, . 3M.- �11 - 15, . . . .. . . Z. ;i3�.-- 0. --- I - .'. . - Wo . -.'.'-`. ... -1: , � .w 6TR ��l te;.,12',,-g. - JNT�cRie ;4 iii . , .g ZnM�- * , . . * - -1 , �. . . , - - ;"�Wn - 5- � --�:-;:---Zi�Ml � t;,J I qq;j AC�T . "3. ..�, - , " , ig , -L -, , ,.� -ii - .- M-Z- - Z -:�. D.b;:r. D. .. ,gf.W4 , n 1, 1 w . - - ..; , Azz ! . �V. .. * - - . � N .. , �L - .. - --,.k�; '-- - - - -.,&J 1. . _ , - - '...'�'�F.Z�-. P -r " ), .4 . . A | . U - - .!;!�. �*- , - I - ... m H = -; -, ;,. .. � - , -� .4. R . 2'�-J -* I .- - -.1 v -I v, Zz!-�� . i �., . `. . ' . ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 52 STATE -OF NEW YORK WORKERS' COMPENSATION ROMM A"11YT V1t1�lJi E7 ,NyMENTO.A IrOW W -V r1rX7'1MnA 1-4-P 'TX T -Up A TC ,r1vR111'1F-F11"ArF,E,u 10F N1710 -V V IS -0 V %_.A U11 %-.If Ia. Legal Name & Address of Insured (Use street address only) I 1b. Business Telephone Number of Insured Quinn Borchardt Brewing LLC Ardso nal Brew Works S1jqemp1qyXp�nt1nsqran ce E er i4p 4.1 -s �q ratbga Spri ngs;.M.Y. 3 Id. Federal Employer Identificatioja Number of Insured Work Location of Insured (On ly required if coverage is specifically or Social Security Number findled to certain locations In New York State, a Wrap -Up 474970368 Policy) Name and Address di the EnfltyRequesfingTrod df 3a'flusurailte Carrier . Name d Coverage (Entity Being Listed as the Certificate Holder) Sentinel Insurance Co. LTD City oi'Saratoga Springs Val 3-1). odic dumber of ental' listed in box "' a,", 474 Broadway OIWECZ12401 Saratoga Springs NY 12866 3e. Policy effective period A.A.-Ru 417•, 3d, The, Rroprietor, rartners or ExeMive Officers are 11 included. (Only cltmk box if all partners/officers incladed) _X all excluded or certain partners/officers excluded. s xai uei�eW e , in b ex J -a 7' M_t Warkerg t.:ib :.a :�3:�� :iters •b �inr e - -i-L � T R -th fey 'New YorkVM musfb0isted under1tem 3AL compeli-safion -under theNevYovk State Wd =5? Compensafiva Law. (To use is- ws on the INFORMATION PACE of the workers' compensation insurance policy). Tho insurance Canior or its licensed agent will send this Certificate of Insurance to the entity listed above, as the certificate holder in box "T'. the F a policy is canceled due to nonpayinent ofpremiums or The Insurance Cat -ler will also notify aBove certcafe holder -within with in 10 days I within 30 days IF there are reasons other th an nonpayment ofpremiums that cancel the p o licy or elim 1 nate the insured from the coverage indicatedon this Cerlifwate. (These notices maybe sent by regular mail.) Otherwise, this Cert ificate& -validforone year izfterthisforHI C witichAmr L Cadiz is approved by the ins uran cc carrier or Its licensed agen 4 or until fil e- P 01i Y expiration date listed in box 113c 11, rk xs ' �� n atia poliq *jjdjj!afdd-&.a, this fo-r-nij if time bushiegs- 96btinres --td.. b6. Note.- U"w flie. cameltati6ri Of 'th6, Pfease mimed ob apermit, lice,inse or contract issued by a certificate holder, the business must provide thaVeerfificate holder with a new Cerfificate of Workers' Compensation Coverage or other authorized proof that the business is complying with the mandatory. Q+.%+,n f '1'%V f& ZTSA_;.MV1 CX%319 ALUJLL1Lk11&$419,%0 Tlo XIL*.PJLL3 9L.0%rX"AXPW"PX "011 "love M•L Underpenalty of perjury, I certify that I am an i authorized representative or licensed agent of the insurance carrier referenced above and that the named insured has the coverage as depleted on this form-, e- _rjjjtmmeofautheTimdmtiWdw 4aspAegPElt pow +� #*41 August2%,:2017 Appyovedby.q. (Signature) (Dale President Telephone Number of authonized representative or licensed agent of insurance carrier: 793-3131 Please Note: Onl• imurance carders an d4h eir licensed agents are auth6 r&ed to issuer F6rrfl C- 105;2:,, ksurance brokers. are NO.T authorized to issue it. C-105F'A2 (9..;07) www.web.statemy.us ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL t t EXHIBIT A PAGE 53 STATE OF NEW YO,Rk OR.RERS' COMPS SATION B(SAID C''Tr'Ia 7'TT� X� A'TyTa' �lTi TN T RTI�'F+' +f��7� T'7? e1 rf;��'i ? TD A AXJL 1� YS 7lTCi A BIT I'i' i' BIEN FITS. T h'[�[ �..s11�.�. XX' �•Z sl SJR• Y! !F *�J��•,•� e.�l1 '�•s.� T�+•r��.s l 11xr1:/�s xxlr �'1 f.7 �xur�JJ.J x ►R t xr�ri 13.:r1 ,L Lx.+k T ► 1p"T1. To be completed by Dlsabflity Benerits Carrier or Licensed Insurance Agent of that Carrier - 1•a.; Legal Name ind•Address.of Insured( Use street address only) Ib, Rusi-ness Telephone -Number of Insured. Quinn Borchardt Brewing LLC ' s 1 c. IIS U-nemployment Insurance Employer Registration - isaanal Brew'Works Number -of Insured. 41 Geys6r Rd, Saratoga Sprmgss NY 12866 1 d. Federal. Employer Identification Number of Insured or Social. Security Number 474970368 2. Name and Address of the Entity Requesting Proof of . 3a. Name of Insurance Carder Co rer ge'(Entity Bd'ing Listed. as the Cerikficate; Mder) . Standard Security Life Ins. Co. of NY City of Saratoga Springs 3b, Policy Dumber of entity listed in box "1 a'a. 474 Broadway K85344-000 Saratoga Springs NY 12866 3c. Policy effective period: 3116i2017 t4.311-6/201 B r 4. 'Policy covers: a. E] .All of the employer's employees eligible under the New York Disability Benbf'its Law b. �j Only the following class or classes of the employer's employees: Under penalty of perj uryj certify. that I am an authorized representative or licensed agent oflhe insurance carrier referenced above and that the named insured has NYS Disability Benefits insVftce coverage -as dose 'bed above. r Date Signe d August 2,01 By- U. (Signa to re of in urance carri er's au thor zed re sentative or NYS Licensed insurance Agent of that insura ace cagier) 5�.B-�'i 93-•313�. president~ Telephone Number 518-793-3131 EWPORTAW: If box "4a" is checked, and this form is skmed by the insurance carrier's authorized representative or NYS Meetised Insurance Agent of titat carrier,, this cartiricate is COMPi.r urE. man it direcily to the ceartiftcate holder. I box "4b" is checked, this certiiicatexs NOT COMPLETE for pwToses of Section 220, Subd, 8ofthe Disability Menet~its Low. Itmustbe maBed for completion to the Workers' Compensation Roord, DB Flans Acceptance Unit, 20 Park Streat, Albany, Now 'York 12207, PART 2. To be cUrn leted b S Workers' Compensation Board (Onty if box `s4V of Part 1 has been checked) Sta to - Of N ew York Workers' Compensation Board According to information maintained by the NO'S workers' Compensation Board, the above -named. employer has complied with the NYS Disability Benof is Law with respect to all of his/her employees. Date Signed BY Signature of NYS Workers' Compensation Board Employee) Telephone NWnber Title Piicase Note: Only insurance Barriers licensed to -write �Y� disability benefits irrsurance�oii�cies and ATS licensed r`�rsurarree agents o}' those insurance carriers are authorized to issue Form DB -120..x'. Insurance brokers are NOT authorized to issue this ormp DB -120.1 (5-06) S, ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 541 State of New York. department of Health RMIT Food Service Establishment TWs is to certify that QUINN BORCHARDT BREG5 LLi the •oper-40x of ARTISANAL* BREW WORKS '9t 41 GEYSER ROAD �F•1. •• =5 :�z ter+: S••..._ 7 - Located iti=die crn Of SA =;, -T;' '. GS,4 � SARATOGA County is ante uis s t " , cart sa . t meat Vn. .0 pliance with the provisions le ancl ppift k, of �--'1 �• _. 1L, -z, ^y s : . . s�• fPY. }'= +ice .i � .� •Lr� Il'F ��`,.a� - � .,{L}.r • �-' � a �•"' 4� i �`�.. r f ■ f7��.: :: +' �;�; •;,.r. ..y L,t;� }fir :•� _ (1) This permit 1s granted subq' 41�r t6. ai � �J all a-pT ab��' �t$t�� ���a�, �a N,�uniexp al Lames, (y'j � •_3y a� • -�=.1 ti`•a. �» �..,y. : ti ::• 4.�� a �, wi.itLi.f- �]� • • : { •:.' 3 • w� s: •r ,Y�r'."117 • i �wV Ki7.�[1 ''31. wLLtLiR..ff--Lti kl, .LF17A;_ f _�._ • �,''..1. • ....„ s �..:t •, t,3 •y k r,•� i {• :F:1'p - ti i.. =141 - .:`'_ •'�e,�/; �;'_l�ie ii.. _.s3r'�ih, "� �!'•: �ge *-**Menu 1intecte foate.:� v_s ri',.han 6'ae rn must approved h this ee.w?i: r .;tip,`_': ' i : �• - s.� '•.'3ywy I'I 3_ s;, ._} ��.Ly�:' iii'.1i, :,a r.�:-Z4 � •'1, .i5• S��{ •: • -• •• • •�•J Vii. ( !f: Ji�'.•.'S: y. jr � �•� � �T ��µ �<si ti•M a i:L:� �'• •� � •. =•s. �:r ,_. •at ' 't4ia �s��� _ 3t�: •• �-•� s:a' �y-•',•• '•y s7 7.=•._•.: f� j :-i' '-'"•: _ :;�.F;'j_r , to �'*:ci..-ate. -'Lr•_. r i . -:. •V ' ... -: •.�.-�«r. .r. n1'••`1-rf.+.a" • "''•' i': ?;�:•.�i� ,rL .err :f l i�. yf _•r �r f,A f• T.` '• 0 � T Effective Date January 04, 2017 Permit is NON -TRANSFERABLE This perxnit expires an September 30, z0"1S,and may 6e revoke d`or suspendedfor cause. THIS PERMIT SHOULD BE POSTED CC)NSPICUQUSLY Facility Code 45-BJ12 Permit Number 45-BJ12 Operation ID 946639 DOH -1320 (5J15) {GEN -129} j �v N 0 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEA,, EXHIBIT A PAGE 5!9 N owl a z 1 cr tu rt 0 U2 si iA �r iQ V� Q u} u� n n -n vv -nLEA 0 0 0 CD Ln cu o �- 0 C � �- CD c„ {p" cu bL (PD � p CD� � Ln � I ..z �, CD (D ��0 r-to��,�n C: C)- � 9 <tooO — '-% --T o "IT � A • o -0 (DCIE 0 3 pi 03 CD�" n 0 �•--% 0 Ln I ggg n cr En n CD '70 Ln��� rnm U 0- w i!L cu 1 Y L■ ■0 Lo r.+-`- W cn LO Q o 0 in V tQ LnLn n CD C7" V-�-0_0 m M. -% W [i7 [Ln � (U ai [a 0 LO .0 "o C �CVVV� I ~ U) =3 F3 LO • r 0 LO-� rD � o La 0 Lo Ln A o CD (D v LO rt R A u 0Lo y A Lo n n C. I� 0 � �cn` 1 4l 0r 3 A r^] � = �� w cu ■ ■�{V� a, ai • � ^� 7 j �ii/ n CD T� L I� t D "�w"�s • CD CL _ V la 0n 0(D k o ii/ �j .� �. CIEEn =3 CDLn 0 9 50-0 Lo "' . k R v 'l Cy CO ZU Lo 0 0 CI- F� • Ln n V ! 'V C =}��] ~ LO (D ,,�hA) k =3 Z3""" V I Ate" ■ y O ill• 0 {' LCI LO 0 = V 70 o ' :C) ---•0 CD❑ f� (D V 0 0 4f =3 _p a ■ = W `Z7 N owl a z 1 cr tu rt 0 U2 si iA �r iQ V� Q ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPE%--LLN EXHIBIT A PAGE ') n o �] o o _0 CD D rt rD �. ["7 ❑ =3=3 �. ft V =3 L CD�wyr a ■ i ) L R �.r ■ o =` C: -� o 3Qg-0o z CD I o 0 ( S. 0 .. CUD) M'-� _0 'C w n _ EA ID o cn (D -..ho -h 0- '� �'• rD o rt C: @ C7 0 60 rD=�Lo3 _. 3 Z3A.■ CL �r ii► En 0 0 ■ V /�h� oa ■ ►J J �oc. o � --h rD 0 �• � ry �D-.0-Ln rDrfm ��Fl-�v �O0o @ CD 0 Q �LnCD �r-r '.., -J. En rD CD =r -� Lo ,07 L 0 M n M0 m o .0 r -r ` h W • M. � (D �r r-� .. r^h 0 0 0- Lo � �C: CD w c1 C E 0 0- --h -tn --� o rD C) N 0 w L i Y cn In sn UP CDINOw N CD a ARTISANAL. BREW WORKS. APPEAL, 57 . CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS CHAPTER 136 LICENSES New Applicatiom Reimewal Application (Original date of application I Mark each type of license which you are applying for: Eating and D - kil C; bo 2. Name of Business QP mi 3. Business Physical Address 4. Business Matling Address 5.Business Web Address W WvV. Lt 6. Business Phone pf q 0 61 fir'; %'ax 7. Applicant's Name _V94A01o%. S. Applicant's Home Address 9. Applicant's Home Phone ii 10. Business Owner. 5AAoO%&.e 11. Emergency Contact7., 12. Current Occupation ;tig 13. Applicable Business Experience 14. Owner of Property 15. Property Owner's Addres) 16. Describe, in detail, servigm provided and Lodging (# of rooms _) Sidewalk CaU 00 qkl I I a I e. ftsewol Emergency Cell 'Phone Type of fire protection equipment'.* Sprinkler Syswm? Yes Nq_K If yes, last inspection date By Who* Fire Extinguishers? Yes—V No Numbex IIf yes, last inspection date t) AT' By Who: A (6ion P 1 0 ��e - All,�_4 9 Commercial Exhaust Hood? Yes No If yes, last inspection date V7 By Who 9%V 40 V. Other? 0C 17. Fire Alarm System? YesXNo if yes, last inspection date A If yes, date last inspected and1or serviced is. Expiration date of New York State Eiepartment of Health Cortificato or New York State Department of Agricultum and Markets Food Processing permit (Please include copy) 19. Do you have a functional grease trap or grease interceptor? Yes No ,. If yes, last service/inspection date 20. Does your business use a dumpstcr? Yes No of 'yes, cmitact the Departme-ni ofPubUc &ffety to obtain Me required Dianpftr Permit). 21. Does your business have an alarm system? Yes *.NoKifyIes, you will be required to complete the rangyNarnt User Perniff). 204 Do you serve alcoholic beverages? Yes ) No If yes, how many bars do you have (include main and satellite)? If yes, you are requwed to submit with this application all of your current New York State Liquor Licenses. 21. Have you made any floor plan changes since your last renewd? Yes No Ify Es, please include an updated floor plan. (Floor plan can be as simple as a sketch on an 800 piece of paper to show the layout of your establishment.) City of Suatoga Springs Chapter 136 License Applica6un 10/20015 1 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL 22. Du you employ security guards or hire security guards for your business? Yes No Wyes, you are required to submitproof with this application thatyour establishment is registered and licensed Lith the State of New York Department of State Division of Licensing authorizing you to employ security guards. You must- also provide Iwiih this application a detailed sketch (altach an addition at sheet of paper) of lite iden tify rxrg shirt your business wi11 be using as lire security guard uniform, which- has to include your busitress name, as well as give tach lettering, all capital letters, SECUBIpY across the chest a� j' thefront of fire shirt, and across the shoulder blades on lire back of the shirt. This will be submilted by the City y Clerk is Office to the Department of Public Safety for approvas Your securty? guards are required to wear Public Safety approved identyl-catt on while employed at your establishment. Within th e fr'rst f iue (5) mays of employment of each security gra ard, ,you W11 be required to protide tine City proof of each security guard's New York Statereg* tra#lora 22. Describe} in detail, the fixed locations of your security guards: The Ci of Saratoga SpflnLs requires: �. A Certificate of Insurance for Proof of commercial general liability insurance, including personal injury liability insurance, in the amount of One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) per occurrence and Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) aggregate,_ naming the City of Saratoga Springs as an additional insured. The City shall be included as an additional insured on said insurance for the permit(s) : process. The City of Saratoga Springs must be listed as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway, Saratoga, Springs, NY 12866. 2. Proof of New York State statutory workers' compensation and employer's liability insurance for all employees, or a waiver of same as permitted by law. 3. For sidewalk cafes that serve alcoholic beverages, a Certificate of Insurance for liquor legal liability insurance in the amount of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) bodily injury and property damage per each occurrence must be submitted with this appkeation. Such insurance must contain a provision that the Commissioner of accounts be notif ed if the policy is cancelled or if there has been a material change in coverage and/or conditions. The City of Saratoga Springs must be listed as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866. -The 0B.A icate naming the City of Saratoga Springs as Additional Insured solely for the issuance of permit s should be addressed to the attention of: Department of Accounts City of Saratoga Springs d74 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Attention: City Clerk's Office The Licensee acknowledges that failure to obtain such insurance on behalf af the municipality constitutes a material breach of contract and subjects Licensee to liability for damages, indemnification and atl other legal remedies available to the City. The Licensee is to provide the City with a Certificate of Insurance naming the City as additional insured prior to the issuance of any permit. The failure to object to the contents of the Certificate of Insurance or the absence of same shall not be deemed a waiver of any and all rights held by the municipality. The Licensee shall indemnify and save harmless the City of Saratoga Springs, its Agents and Employees (hereinafter referred to as "'City"'), from and against all clauns, damages, losses and expenses (includin& but not limited to, attorneys" fees), arising out of or resulting from the licensed activity, sustained by any person or persons, provided that any such claim, damage, loss or expense is attributable to bodily injury, sickness, disease, or death, or to injury to or destruction of property caused by the tortuous act or negligent act or omission of Licensee or its employees, its agents or subcontractors. Nothing in this license shall be construed as granting the Commissioner of accounts any power to confer rights upon license holders to do or perform any act in contravention of any duly adopted zoning regulations or ordinance in effect in the City of Saratoga Springs. It shall be the responsibility of the licensee to determine if his or her activity complies with the applicable zoning ordinances. if this is an initial application for an eating and drinking, cabaret, or lodging license, you are required to submit with your application two (2) sets of detailed plans for your establishment, plans must include a fluor plan indicating the location of all rooms, hallways, doors, windows, reception areas, kitchen facilities, bathroom facilities, exits, bar or bars, fixed stations for security guards, and all fire protection equipment. The pians meed to show the location of your structure relative to other parcels of land, adjacent streets, sidewalks, and public ways. If your establishment has on-site parking facilities, the plans must show them. City ofSacatoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 10120/2015 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL 59 .If this is an initial application for a sidewalk cafe license, you are required to submit four (4) sets of detailed plans for your establishment. You,must have a valid eating and drinking license in order to obtain a sidewalk cafe license. For the requirements and specifications on the lay out of sidewalk cafes see the attached copy of the Code chapter 136-24, 136-25_ Be advised there is an application fee for this license as well as a license fee, If finis is a renewal application, I being duly sworn and depose and state that no part of the subject premises, services provided and arses of premises has changed in any substantial matter since my previous license was issued. ff this is an application for a sidewalk cafe, I -- - - agree to be fully responsible, to correct any damages caused to he side i result of my business' sidewalk cafe, including financially. Ii agree to comply with all applicable state and local ordinances and/or law and agree to operate this busineo in total compliance of those laws and ordinances. I understand my license(s) have annual renewal date(s) and that I am solely responsible to renew My license(s) prior to the expiration date s . rior to the expiration date(s) I agree to pay the -appli tion fee of $250.00 per license. Date Signature ofAp scant STATE OF NEW YORK ss` COUNTY OF SARATOGA � On the day of of 20_M before me} the undersigned, a Notary Public/Commissioner of Deeds in and for said State, personally appeared _ _-- �. _ personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of - --- satisfactory evidence to be the individuals) xhose name(s) is (are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument, the individual(s), or persons upon bebalfof which the individual(s) acted, executed the instrument. M 'o# ry Publi €41iis-si of Deeds Fees $100.00 Eatiag and Drinking License $150.00 Cabaret License $15.00 Sidewalk Caf6 Application $50.00 Sidewalk W6 License Lodging License: 5 rooms or less $25.00 6 --10 grooms $50,00 It — 25 roams $75.00 26 --100 rooms $100.00 1.01 rooms or above $150.00 City of Saratoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 10/2WO15 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL , EXHIBIT A PAGE 60I It r ulf 0 z 2 -1 z ICL j of 0' 0M� � J LL �� r "<r< 1� CL I.L� ZN .4 :. I . A A% ;y -T r W -4- 3L za N L -Z4 -.0 -V 4LI T LL 6z - 5t- -4 pig ;4-p 71 I tf, ALr .-A ilia 6 4 41, .3 __ fou, Iif 4k' 4 Ile gzwv AF -T MlL Ipl- ICA 40 LL-; 'P. Sa- VJW� .34: -7 74 tI A' L AA7' r Ili e, 7 A 4 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE. 62 1� BATE (MMIDDlYM) AC<?RhP CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE 11/17/2016 THIS CERTIFICATE 15 ISSUED AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES BELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUING INSURER(S), AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER, AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. IMPORTANT: If the certificate holder is an ADDITIONAL INSURED, the policy(les) must be endorsed. If SUBROGATION IS WAIVED, subject to the terms and conditions of the Polio, certain Policies may require an endorsement., A statement on this certificate does not confer rights to the certificate holder in lieu of such endorsement(s). CONTACT Valerie Childs, CISR PRODUCER NAME: Marshall & Sterling Upstater Inc. PHONE ( 518 ) 587--1342AI N014. s1E 5S'7-�34I� 125 High Rack Ave . , Suits 2 U 6A DRESS: EIL vchilds @marshall s terli.ng . com INSURERS AFFORDING COVERAGE NAIL if Saratoga Springs NY 12866 INSURER A .Philadel hia insurance Com an INSURED INSURER B :Em to erS insurance Groin vanHal.l Holdings LLC dba Upstate Distilling Cc LIC INSURER C ;Arch Insurance Grow 4IGeyser Road INSURER D,. INSURER E; Saratoga Springs NY 12866 INSURER F : CERTIFICATE K1"?JRER:16-17 Master REVISION NUMBER: THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BE10W HAVE SEEN ISSUED TO THE INSUR INDICATED. NOTWITHSTANDING ANY REOUIREMENT, TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBE EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES. LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIM INSR LTR TYPE OF INSURANCE ADDL SUER POLICY HUMBER POLICY EFF MM10 POLICY EXP MMIDQ 5Q o00 X COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIAEILITY T MED EXP (Any one parson) $ x o , o Q o PERSONAL &ADV INJURY x r 000 r 000 A ::1CLAIMS MADE � OCCUR PRODUCTS - COMP10P AGG $ 2 r 000 r 000 COMBINEDS INGLE UNIT Ea. seeldent � 11000,000 BODILY INJURY (Per person) x BODILY INJURY (Peraccident) $ PHPY,1503474 6/1/2016 6/1/2017 GEWL AGGREGATE LIMIT APPLIES PER: EACH OCCURRENCE $ AGGREG4SE POLICY 0 JECT Loc PER OTH- STATUTE ER E.L. EACH ACCIDENT $ 100 U o o OTHER: $ 100 o00 E.L. DISEASE - POLICY LIMIT S 500,000 Statutory Lkilts ;tared) AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY basis, when required by A ANIS AUTO ALLOWNE} x SCHEDULED x PBPX1503474 611/2016 6/1/2017 - AUTOS AUTOS NON -OWNED HIRED AUTOS AUTOS LIiIIIDFtF.LLA LIAR OCCUR EXCESS IJAB CLAIMS -MADE DED IRETENTIONS WORKERS COMPENSATION AND EMPLOYERS, LIABILITY YIN' ANY PROPRIETOWPARTNERIEXECUTIVE ❑ N I A E? EIG 2363353 00 6}1/2 OFFICER/MEMEIER EXCLUDED? 6/1/201'7 B (Mandatary In NH) I[yes, describe under DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS balow NYS D�sabillty 11I�BLD667440 05113/16 05/13/17 C DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS ! LOCATIONS IVMCLES {ACORD 101, Additional Remarks Schedule, may be attached IF raore space Is req Certificate bolder is adcUt±onal insured on a primary and nen contributory written contract or agreement CERTIFICATE HOLDER CANCELLATION . ED NAKED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD DOCUMENT WITH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS a HEREIN IS SUBTEST TO ALL THE TERMS, S. LIMITS EACH OCCURRENCE $ 1 r 000 r 000 DAMAGE TO RENTED 5Q o00 PREMISES Ea occurrence T MED EXP (Any one parson) $ x o , o Q o PERSONAL &ADV INJURY x r 000 r 000 GEWRAL AGGREGATE $ 2 r 400 .000 PRODUCTS - COMP10P AGG $ 2 r 000 r 000 COMBINEDS INGLE UNIT Ea. seeldent � 11000,000 BODILY INJURY (Per person) � BODILY INJURY (Peraccident) $ PROPERTY DAMAGE Per accident EACH OCCURRENCE $ AGGREG4SE PER OTH- STATUTE ER E.L. EACH ACCIDENT $ 100 U o o E.I.. DISEASE - EA EMPLOYE $ 100 o00 E.L. DISEASE - POLICY LIMIT S 500,000 Statutory Lkilts ;tared) basis, when required by SHOULD ANY OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED POLICIES BE CANCELLED BEFORE City of Saratoga Springs THE EXPIRATION DATE THEREOF, NOTICE VIlILL BE bELIVERED IN 474 Broadway ACCORDANCE WITH THE POLICY PROVISIONS. Saratoga Springsr NY 1286 AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE Jeanne Mal oy/ VCHT LD VIA, F a 1988-2014 ACORD CORPORATION. All rights reserved. ACORD 26 (2014/01) The ACORD name and logo are registered mans of ACORD INS025 (9014nl� e FSI -890 Front (Rev. 2!1111 a) ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL , EXHIBIT A PAGE 63 NEW Agriculture' AK - and Markets , NOTICE OF I 'New York State Department. of Agriculture. and Markets.. Division of Food Safety and Inspection '[ 0B Airline Dri-ve, Albany, NY 12235 . DATE COUNTY CODE - EST. NO, OWNE-R -NAME:- TRADE NAME: EST. ADDRESS: An to of your establishment was made today pursuant to provisions of the New York State. Agriculture. .aid Markets Law relating to food. A report of the Department's findings will be mailed to you within five working days. The results of the inspection show: _ "�A .The establishment in substantial compliance in that no critical deficiencies were observed �� Critical deficiencies which were corrected of time of inspection ❑ "Critical deficiencies EST. REP'S NAME (Please printf Ira TITLE EST. REP'S SIGNATURE INSPECTOR'S SIGNATURE �""`�:C). # • • PI_FASE NOTE: A critical deficiency is a sanitation or food safety condition that Heist be corrected media�el� it may result in the ass enf of civil penalties arra other action provided by law= including administrative hearing• or court action. s �r f+, Article; 28 of the New -York State Agriculture and Markets Lav require's a retail food store to post a copy of the dale and result& of its'Mosl recent sanitary inspection in a conspicuous location near each public entrance. A retail food store may comply with this requirement by posting a copy of this police of Inspection. Ifyou offer -to give any benefit, thing or money to any employee oft e Department ofAg iculturre and Markets, your conduct will be reported to your local police or sbedirs department - :It, IB cil ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEA , EXHIBIT A PAGE 34 0 (D �a Ta ( V 0 CD m rte' D D 0 Lo r CD 0 w.� Ln ov CD 0 G) Ln ■ I./ CIO W, (D _ U)�nna�v���n aj = cr w 2. �. ■D pt -n T m CD wwwr (D WK : rp) CD m n loE�f Fn' > L ,�. cl. vo o �. LR; . -0 Lo 'a oi (D rp) A � � � n :1-0 � to 3 �■�, 11 �. 9.0 m R r r6 (D l< = = �■ 1 I Ln I Ln 0 cV 0) -0 .� M. �l sa [�D �...,, 0) coo -C to O En En n fD W V rr C4 0 rt (D =La 0) Ln aj -0 cliW o cn r�r r r� �++�' "s oFD = V�■� T) cn L CD ...... .� ti Ld cin `..VLo v 0 _ Ln E o -0e''to Ln A L V _• �' (D = 0 =1 0 3 CL cu 0 Fr0 {D 0 n 0 Ln 0 • n 1 "0 f ,0 0 e—r Lo � 0 _0 (D �'�r)(D CD o 0 0 Lo cn • D tQ ■Ln Lo to0 v V Ln La QoaCD � L� � (D Ln V V Q U _-0 y C7 0 0■ o Vr Q aj 0 I 1 voo� 0 V Lo ECFS Q o :3�?�LD pea :3 V ol w @ (A ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEA , EXHIBIT A PAGE 34 0 (D �a Ta ( V 0 CD m rte' D D 0 Lo r CD 0 w.� Ln ov CD 0 G) Ln ■ I./ CIO W, (D 1� rrlwr r �. C7 (D o loE�f ww r { 1 C) t ■ E R € j€[e C) [ I --t �■ . f■ :1-0 r �■ iii k n fD 0 E L oFD = CD .� Ll Ln 0 1 "0 f ,0 0 Lo cn tQ v V La V E f F E Vr I 1 ECFS cDCL ol @ (A {! {I k { w [k! f 0 un Ch 0 F "i3 00 E r k 1� N Al ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL. EXHIBIT A PAGE 6 n=TCl(DC)C7 v w 0 0 rt "0 CCD '70 ~' CD —1 �■ r) 0 :3 ._.. CD rr rt a • :3 C ^. Cl jr �+sa w..sa Fcr. -h . �. 3 �--� r � s • CD cv I%% Ln rt CD o CD m CU -1 ' rt CD -h Z cu 3 rD�0- LO .0 r -r CD CMD (D Ln CD CD En 0. ■ o �D 3 CD rt, --h ca. � 'C �• CD C: @ n p rp CD :3 L0 3 �. 3rt aj � 0 0:3 CD Cn CD LO ..... 0� � to � ❑ Q 0- fD rD � rD C:).n -_' .� Co M Lnri- 'C F -r e --r Q0 0 Ln �} C: —n D 3 �; aj •� CD 3=r � CD �- r ." En CD CD � sv =3 CD :3 a 0 rr o � Ln, .0 C -r r -r- QJ � r) Q. CD o�a'sa:Lo S-1 � D Q D CD ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 66 CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS CHAPTER 136 LICENSES New AppliLmtion Rene -oval Application (Original date of application I - Mark each type of license which you are a plying for: / Fling and Drin:i &./Cabaret )<"Lodging_ (# of rooms Sidewalk Cafd 2. Name of Business A931S,4VAI--m &kW VJQ S 3, Business Physical Address 5EX— v—,> 4. Business Mailing Address 6f sgg= 5 Business Web Add= I 6. Business Phone Fax Number EmeTwcy Cell Phone, 7. Applicant's Name S. Applicant's Home Address Ito 4;7Pd6r1V-- S1 55 #J 9. Applicant's Home Phone Applicant's Date of Birth 10. Business Owner: KURT P>GKAW Email hone 4 11. Emergency Phone# 12. Current Occupation 13. Applicable Business Experien ce. 14. Owner of Property F --Y Property Owner's Phone is. Property Owner's Address L41 16. Dcscribe, in det4 services providt;d and the uses of your premises: Type of fire protection equipment Sprinkler System? Yes NoX If yes, last -inspection date By Who: Fire Extinguishers? Yes No Number If yes, last inspection date y who. —e-1 mry Commercial Exhaust Hood? Y. --.s— No If yes, last linspection date By Who: 16. Other? 17. Fire Alarm System? Ycsx_ No- If yes, last inspection date Eyes, date I-,vqt insp--cted and/orsurvired 1 ^111 ig, Expiration date ofNcwYcrk- Statc Dcpartincntof Health Ceitificate orN York State Department of Agriculture and Markets e.1 . M pf opyy/ Food Processing permit Se 1"t tint ig. Do you have a fimational grease trap or grease interceptor ? Yes No Y If yes, last aerviceJinspcction date: 2o. Does your business use a dampster? Yes)!C Nq.__ [If yes, contact the Deparfwnt ofPublic Safety to obtain die required Dumpster PerWt). 21. Does your business have an alarm system? Yes No _ (If yes, you will be required to complete the one time Alarm User Permit). 20. Do you serve alcoholic beverages? Yes . -No If yes, how many bars do you have (includemain and satellite) ? If yes, you are required to submit with this application au of your current New York State J,iquor Licenses. PI.W lifth E /V P1.1141 W 4 21. Have you made any floor plan changes since your last renewal? Yes No if yes e include an updated floor plan. pleas (Floor plan can be as simple as a sketch on an 8x10 piece of paper to show the layout of your establishment.) City of Saratoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 10/2012015 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 67 22. Do you employ security guards or faire security guards for your business? Yes No (Ifyes, you are required to submit with this application that your establishment is registered and ficensed vUh tyre State o New York Department of Staie .division of Licensing authorizing you to employ security guards. You must also provide iuith this application a detailed sketch (attach an ardditxonal sheet ofpape r) of the idenfifyIng shirt your business will be using res the security guard uni, form, which has to include your business name, as well as five inch led ering, all capital tetters, SECT. ITY across the chest of the front of the shirt, and across the shoulder blades on the Back of the shirt. Thr's will be submitted by the City Clerk's Office to the Department of .Public Safety for approval. Your security guards are required to wear Public Safety approved ideutafication while employed atyour establishment. >rPr din the firstfive (5) days of employinent a, f each security guard, you will die required to provide the City ,proof o, Peach security guard's New York State registration) 22. Describe, 'xn detail, , the fixed locations of your security guards: The City of SpLa og g apri ms requires 1. A Certificate of Insurance for Proof of commercial general liability insurance, includhig personal inJury liability insurance, in the amount of One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) per occurrence and Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) aggregate, naming the City of Saratoga Springs as an additional insured. The City shall be included as an additional insured on said insurance for the permit(s) process. The, City of Saratoga Springs must be listed as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866. 2. Proof of New York State statutory workers' compensation and employer's liability insurance for all employees, or a waiver of same as permitted by law. - 3. For sidewalk cafes that serve alcoholic beverages, a Certificate of Insurance for liquor legal liability insurance in the amount of five hundred thousand dollars ($504,000) bodily Miury and property damage per each occurrence must be submitted with this appheation. Such insurance must contain a provision that the Commissioner of Accounts be notified if the policy is cancelled or if there has been a material change in coverage and/or conditions_ The City of Saratoga Springs must be listed as the certificate holder with the physical address of 474 Broadway, Saratoga Springs, lY 12566. The Certificate tim n.ing the City of Saratoga Springs as Additional Insured solely for the issuance of permit(s) should be addressed to the attention of: Department of Accounts City of Saratoga Springs 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Attention: City Clerk's Office The Licensee acknowledges that failure to obtain such insurance on behalf of the municipality constitutes a material breach of contract and subjects Licensee to liability for damages, indemnification and all other legal remedies available to the City. The Licensee is to provide the City with a Certificate of Insurance naming the City as Additional Insured mor to the issuance of any permit. The failure to object to the contents ofthe Certificate of insurance or the absence of same shall not be deemed a waiver of any and all rights held by the municipality. The Licensee shall indemnify and save harmless the City of Saratoga Springs, its Agents and Employees (hereinafter referred to as "City"}, from and against all clauns, damages, losses and expenses (including, but not limited to, attomeys' fees), arising out of or resulting from the licensed activity, sustained by any person or persons, provided that any such claim, damage, loss or expense is audbutable to bodily injury, sickness, disease, or death, or to injury to or destruction of property caused by the tortuous act or negligent act or omission of Licensee or its employees, its agents or subcontractors. Nothing in this license shall be constmed as granting the Commissioner of Accounts any power to confer rights upon license holders to do or perform any act in contravention of any duly adopted zoning regulations or ordinance in effect in the City of Saratoga. Springs. It shall. be the responsibility of the licensee to determine if his or her activity complies with the applicable zoning ordinances. If this is an initial appi'icafiou for an eating and drirjlcing, cabaret, or lodging license, you are required to submit with your application two (2) sets of detailed plans for your establishment. Plans must include a floor plan indicating the location of all rooms, hallways, doors, windows, reception areas, kitchen facilities, bathroom facilities, exits, bar or bats, fixed stations for security guards, and all fire protection equipment. Than plans need to shout the location of your structure relative to other parcels of land, adjacent streets, sidewalks, and public way's. If your establishment has onsite parl€ing facilities, the plans must show them. City of Saratoga Springs Chapter 136 License Application 10/20/2015 ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL ' EXHIBIT A PAGE 69 FV? �o �v =V3 FLOOR PLAN ARTISANAL BREW WORKS BREWERY OVERLOOK SCALE: &=Jou T ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 70 '1 6-611 421-311 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FLOOR PLAN ARTISANAL BREW WORKS TASTING ROOM SCALE: i"=1'-0" ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 71 A`�R�0 CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE aATE(MMlDDIYYYYj 8/30/2016 THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES BELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUING INSURERS}, AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER, AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. IMPORTANT: if the certificate holder is an ADDITIONAL INSURED, the pollcy(ies) must be endorsed. If SUBROGATION IS WAIVED, subject to the terms and conditions of the policy, certain policies may require ars endorsement. A statement on this certificate does not corder rights to the certificate holder in lieu of such endorsement(s). THE TERMS, PRODUCER CONTACY House NAME: Hughes Insurance ,Agency # Inc . PHONN Ex!)' (515) 793-3131 FAX NO. - (510) 793-3121 -(ALQ.-. 328 Bay ItoadDRl EACH OCCURRENCE ESS: PO BOX 4630 DAMAGE TO RENTED INSURERS AFFORDING COVERAGE LAIC # Queensbury NY 12604 PREMISES Ea oCCuenre INSURERA:Tri-State .Ins Co of Minnesota 31003 INSURED MED EXP (Any one pefrio n) INSURER $ :Sentinel Insurance Co. LTB 11000 Quinn Borchardt Brewing LLC, PERSONAL $ ADI! INJURY INSURER C DBA: Artisanal Brew Works GENERAL AGGREGATE INSURER 0 41 Geyser Road PRODUCTS - OGMP�OP AGG INSURER E: Saratoga Springs MY 12$66 INSURER F: COVERAGES CERTIFICATE NUMBER. -16-17 Master REVISION NUMBER: THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD INDICATED. NOTtI<IfiTHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENT, TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT DR OTHER DOCUMENT VVITH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBED HEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS, EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES. LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIMS. ILTR TYPE OF INSURANCE INSD V POLICY NUMBER MMIDDNYYY MMiDDMUMITS X COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIABILITY EACH OCCURRENCE $ 11000,000 DAMAGE TO RENTED $ 500 01:11] A CLAIMS-W'OEFX-10CCUR OE PREMISES Ea oCCuenre F ADVIS'1330 8/31/201 8/31/2017 MED EXP (Any one pefrio n) $ 10 1000 PERSONAL $ ADI! INJURY $ i r 0 d 0 r 0 OO CEN'L AGGREGATE LIMIT APPLIES PER: GENERAL AGGREGATE $ 2 r OOO t OOG PRO-[:] POLICY JECT LOC PRODUCTS - OGMP�OP AGG $ 2 r OOO , OOO OWER: AUTOMOUFLE LIABILITY Ea accident) SINGLE LIMIT $ 1, 010{l �iO4 ANY AUTO BODILY INJURY (Per person) $ A ALL OWNED SCHEDULED ADVIS7330 8/31/2016 8/31/2017 BODILY INJURY (Per accident) $ AUTOS AUTOS NON -OWNED PROPERTY DAMAGE $ HIRED AUTOS } J'�1�.,1TOS Per scaldenk UMBRELLA LIAB OCCUR EACH OCCURRENCE $ EXCESS LIAB CLAIMS -MADE AGGREGATE $ DEDRETENTION $ TWORKERS $ COMPENSA710N X IPR STATUTE ER" AND EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY YIN ANY PROPRIETOMPARTNERIEXECUTIVF E.L. EACH ACCIDENT $ 100,000 OFFICERIMEMBER EXCLUDED7 ❑ N ! A B (Mandatory in NHj OINECZ12401 3/36/2016 3/16/2017 E.L. DISEASE - EA EMPLOYE $ 10D 400 IF yes under CESG�RIPT10N OF OPERATIOMS belowE.L. -describe POLICY LIMIT DISEASE $ 81 0 [�1 C1 A Liquor Liability ADVI57330 9/31/2016 9/31/2017 each common cause 1, 004 r 0 30 aggregate limit 2 1 000 r 000 DESCRIPT10N OF 0PERATIONG I LOCA►TIDNS f VEHICLES (ACORD 101, Additional Remarka Schedule. may be atfached It more apace is requlrad) Subjeat to all policy terms, limitations and conditions: Certificate Holder ie Additional Insured on a Primary Non Contr-ibutory bagi.a F including Waiver of Subrogation, when required by written contract, agreement or permit. CERTIFICATE HOLDER City of Saratoga Springs 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 ACO RD 26 (20 14101) INS025 (201401) CANCELLATION SHOULD ANY OF THE ALONE DESCRIBED POLICIES BE CANCELLED BEFORE THE EXPIRATION DAZE THEREOF, NOTICE WILL BE DELIVERED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE POLICY PROVISIONS. AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE Lima Abodeely/KR ( 19$8-2014 ACDRD CORPORATION. All rights reserved. The ACCORD name and logo are registered marks of ACORD ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 72 s•rxrF.,-OF' NEV YORK WORKERSP COMPENSATION BOARD C.m XATg 0KE 1P RAiQE .8 W N ORRS" COMPENSATIOrq INSURANCE COVr �p- Legal Name & address of Insiared (Usestreet address on!y) I b. Business Telepb .one Number of insured ctt4i�no'o'tifia'rdf-'B'rewingLLc' Aft1sonal Brew Works I er NVS Unemployment Insurance Employer 41 de*yser Ro' , ag*s, NY 12866: d sartibga spr1h' Registration Number of Insured F dffibat n_9 ed .0"r S, 6CIAI,$, i um_bkr ec -474970369 W6tk Lo ejiti 6ft o f M � D'jtM - (0,61y roqk*ed #'�&ifiij6 �Pdcffleally 4hnIted to certain locations In Mew York State, IAO a Wrap--Upl Polio) 2. Name and A00iess of the Entity llpqiues.tlng Proof of 3a. Mine of Insurance CarrierCoverage(E', jitky Iiihig. Listed as the Certificate Holder) e*n" b too I n sui ian t e Co. LTD Cityy-df SiaiWka 8pthigs 3b.polidy y 474 Sroadwa�r 01WEC212461 NY: 12866 &!§/216 to 31 .16/2017 3d. Th!. P)raprketor, Partners or Ex"utiye-Offeers-airre included. (Qn!y. check box fri.duded) X all exdtided or-certahm'partne0s/offleeirs excluded. This certifies that the -insurance carrier indicated above -in box'""Y insures tho busine-gs referenced -above in box %,la7' for workers" cDmpensation under the Now -York State Workers' CotoLaw. (TjD *e.tbls.fbrrn, New York (NY) Must be listed under Item. 3A.- on . the 'tN061tMATJ0N- ]AdE 0610 workers'v*,o M*peq"sadon insurance V44), The . Insumnee Carrier ori -its I i . densed agent W0111 send 'thi's Cedi&96 of I'd6�rtLn6c to thd c'h0ty fls'ted dbcive as the c'trtlfldhdlaerin boy 'til" The -Imiranoo CarrIet-vill also notify the: above.-centflante holder i POIn J 0 days: Fapofiqy1'LS canceled -dite.to-wnp.aymgni-ofpi-emium.F or 1141hin 30 days IF there are reasons offigr than rip onpaymeni oftremiums •that cancel the policy �r e#r41nqtq the insuredfrom the qoveragg ... . *' . Otherwise, 6�6 * (These notices may be sent by regular mail.) Otherwise, this Cert] is valldfpr atwyear � indicaledon thli Corf$�ale. #erth rm its approved by Me insufance edrrier or Its 11censed agent, or until Ifiepallay expirallon date listed'i"n box 113c", xdd= Is Please Note: Upon the vancellotion of the wairkers":compensation -policy indicated on this form,, If the btpiuess. continues to be named on a -. permit, license -or contract i"pco by a certificate holdejr, tho.buslaeBs must provide that cordficate holder with anew 4be, Cate of Waikers" Compensaflon .Coverage or o' &'r authorized . . proof thltf the e builne as is carer I ying with thi mandatory ebivbirage iequireMenft of the' Now YokkStAte Wibikeirs' C60ifths4tibbi-Lawks Under penalty qf.parjairyt I eprft that I am an authorized representative -or licensed agoal -of the Insurniace.carnier -referenced above and thvit the named insured h s the.cqve"ge as depip .44 ipip this formA Approved by: Uilda'AbOddeffy (pijnt. dra�A: *,ZpA 4re&dnjfltjVa(iT .6. iikn& art I go lnsif6fl -a C1i Approved by; 4V Tit1t; Telephone Number of authorized representatlivr, or licensed agent of insurance carder: 518-793-3131 Pliws e Nato. Only im urah cc cat -r fers anal their licensed agents arc. a u ih ort' -we d - t6 IS'S'lle' ForM Cm 10&2. lnv ran ee b r 6 k ps ;a i v NOT authorked to issud'il. C.!105,2.(0F0.7}•. www.wcb.state.ny,.us ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 73 STATH OF NEW YORK W0kKjiA9` COMPI;-N*S&f6l� BOARID CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE -COVERAGE UNDER THE NYS-DISABILIW BE-NEWITS LAW ITART1. T6.be cow pjetod-,b Ys' abil#y Oeqe'fits Car-deror Lign,50 Insurance,Agent-of that Carrier la, Leg4l Ndme anal Address of Insured (Use street address only) 1b.B�itf6s�Telephoiid.Nutnli6rof-In'Wred- Qtfli�n 13ofeliardf-Mvvifig LLC I c. NYS U-nemployipent lTj5uranec�..Eimpi(iyer:Registr4tion A it'] sarial Br6w. Wdrks 41 CieNuinber of Tns.uj-qd Ver.Road Saratoga Springs.- NY 12866. Id. Ve'daml-Em*plo�or IdidntificaflonNiumber of -Insured or So'lial. eqUrlty Nuitnber .. 0.1 474970368 2. Name and Address of the Vnflty lkoqqqsKng Proof of 3a. Name of Inwrance Carrier iCoverap (Bntily Ming Listed as the Certfficatv Ifolder) stao&r'd Sedurity Lffi� Iris. Co. of NY City or Satatdga Springg -3b. Pblicy Nuffiber6f entity HsW in box "la": R8 474 BroadWa� 534&000 SaratopSpings. NY 12866 30. Flo] icy -e1Te09Voporiod--; d-3/16/2016 to: 3/16/20 17 4-.Palliby covers; a. All of the cmp!oyrpr'-s employees e1j'gible under the New Yolk Disability Benefits Lptw b. only thq.foj [ov4.ng.q1ass or. &L5ses of the. employer"s:employpes: Under pqnalky of perjury; I wdJ r that I ani -an authorized representative or licenst;d agent -of .the, it cat7r1er-r.pfqrenced- above and- th4t. the ppmO insprPO has. NYS Disability Benefits '!PrIoAnee .oyorage as deso I qd.qbPve- Date -81gr a used By nce�ia Hihres. Friiz6d r+6rituti V'e -or NYS 0656S'6d Atelli Dfthat insuranmcarrier) baie anih6ir Tclepbone.Number Title President IMPORTANT: If hex L142i" IscheeW,-and this fjqrmj�IgRo-.by mail .;t' dir,e 611y to thr- cerfiflioie b Oki. ITbox 4W1 Is ch&_ked- i4b qf0qcate k N 01" COMPLETE for pwpaspf Smfion 220, Sixbd.-4-of thp Dspbi Ity Heoetltstow. It nivit beWafled- f6r. 6 m0dion to ffig *6 rkere Coro gaftg bard, D0 PlAns AgcoP't4jkcq Unit,. ik $(=.% Albany, New. V6�k 12%07.. ch caro;; Okv ".C�MP'6nsation.HoArd.(Q�]y Wbox.!'Wl cit. Part I - n PART 2a To t(C.. -6 V6ted-Py-,NY-S*-W rs ' has bebWkvd State Of New York Workers' CoulpensatiorL Board Acmiding to information maintained by the NYS Workers' ConTensafton Board, the above-named employer has complied with the NYS Disability Benefits Law with respect to all of his/her employees, Date (S' isnatgte of IVY -S Workers* Cbmpensatioxi Boafd-Employ-ea) Telephone Numbe Ti ti e.- �.�S Mase.Nofe: Only--itistirance.�cat,,i-iers.liconsedio insurance policies and NY ficensed jM11ranae:4qg�nO Of Insuranccarriars are authorkedlo issue Form DB -120.1. Insurance brokers are NOT authorized to issue MOP= e DB -LJ 20.1 (5-06) ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 74. n 0 � 0 3 v � .a n CDCD CA o O o � m th Mk 0 � rt CA o O o � b � rD CD d CD CD 0 �b r+ It 0--+ 0 Rp p(rq o C CD CD r� ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT A PAGE 75 P 0 r 0 01q 90 cn 4 00 rD ao � L ARTISANAL BREW WORKS APPEAL EXHIBIT B 1 City of Saratoga Springs CITY ATTORNEYS OFFICE CITY HALL 4 474 Broadway — Room 7 Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 Telephone 518-587-3550, ext. 2516 Fax 518-587-1688 VIA EMAIL ONLY January 3, 2019 Matthew Fuller Meyer & Fuller, PLLC mfullerameverfuller. com 1557 State Route 9 Lake George, New York 12845 VINCENT J. DELEONARDIS City Attorney ANTHONY J. IZZO Assistant City Attorney TRISH BUSH Executive Assistant RE: FOIL request dated 11/30/18 with clarification on 1/3/19 — Snyder, Kiley, Toohey, Corbitt & Cox correspondence between June 1, 2017 to date. Dear Mr. Fuller, Pursuant to Public Officers Law 89(3)(a), this will acknowledge receipt of the above referenced FOIL request. Per our conversation this afternoon, I will be requesting the above correspondence that references 41 Geyser Road and/or any reference to the Zoning, Planning and State building codes dated between June 1, 2017 to date, from the Commissioners, Mayor, Code Enforcement, and the Building, Planning and Zoning departments. You may reasonably expect a response, granting or denying this request, in approximately twenty (20) business days. Very truly yours, Trish Bush, FOIL Officer