HomeMy WebLinkAbout20210315 Ingram Partial Demolition NOD `fi Tamie Ehinger, Chair
NNN
CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS Leslie Mechem,Vice Chair
{. 5
'< ries;.t
Chris Bennett
DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION Leslie DiCarlo
Rob DuBoff
i Ellen Sheehan
,;# ��,a
City Hall -474 Broadway
{ Sean Smith
Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 Steven Rowland,Alternate
/ p` Tel:518-587-3550 x.25 17 Tad Roemer,Alternate
www.saratoga-s p ri ngs.o rg
NOTICE OF DECISION
In the matter of the application
#20210315
Ingram Partial Demolition
207 Nelson Avenue
Saratoga Springs, New York 12866
involving Determination of historic/architectural significance and Historic Review of partial demolition to
an existing single-family residence in the Urban Residential - 3 District, tax parcel #166.6I-I-I I, within
the City of Saratoga Springs.
In accordance with 6 NYCRR Part 617, the Design Review Commission classified this action
(demolition) as a SEQRA Unlisted Action. The DRC reviewed the submitted SEAF Part I and evaluated
any potentially adverse environmental impact as part of this action. Based upon the information
provided and the analysis conducted, including any supporting documentation, the DRC determined that
the proposed action would not result in any significant adverse environmental impacts and issued a
SEQRA negative declaration on April 21, 2021.
Record of vote:
Record of vote: motion to approve made by T. Ehinger, seconded by L. Mechem: passed 6-1
In favor: T. Ehinger, L. DiCarlo, C. Bennett, L. Mechem, E. Sheehan, S. Smith
Opposed: R. DuBoff
Consistent with Section 7.5.1 I "Demolition" of the City's Zoning Ordinance, the Design Review
Commission determines that this property:
Does not have Architectural and/or historical significance contributing to the historic fabric and
resources of the City of Saratoga Springs.
And, in accordance with the objectives, standards and guidelines contained in the City Zoning Ordinance
Article 240-7.4 Historic Review, the Design Review Commission issues the following decision on April 7,
2021:
Approve the partial demolition as submitted or shown on the attached plans
Note: this approval shall expire 18 months from the issuance date unless any necessary building permit has been
issued and actual work begun.
Record of vote:
Record of vote: motion to approve made by T. Ehinger, seconded by L. Mechem: passed 6-1
In favor: T. Ehinger, L. DiCarlo, C. Bennett, L. Mechem, E. Sheehan, S. Smith
Opposed: R. DuBoff
Page I of 2
As a result of this decision, the applicant:
may proceed with the proposed partial demolition project as approved. New work to be reviewed
and approved by the Design Review Commission.
Please contact the Building Department to verify permit requirements.
"l- -
May 3 2021
y '
Chair Received by Accounts
cc: Building Department File
Accounts Dept.
Applicant/Agent
Page 2 of 2
. i 4( ,,,,r\--: , . . . ,!.. ---,,,, _ .„ ---______ .
fraf --
. %. loll, .„,b._., ,., . ..
I ., \ ,\L „II . if,,,,,.- . ,,
\I'
., . ;
',.. . Iii., It. -- . I
,,__„ ., ' ti, . .l
A i . Jr ,,
It
t , a
. . 2
. . k, ''..N.._,,,,h.,4",„*...- ,ip J"'
r.
ill ,
g...r.,,,f:fIRH_4osrf.,',D; gt-,i,
i .. '
'r , 1,,oetkii oft 1
a 7,
1
1
Tim,� u� I ... 4.N.40'14, g).4a.
,,►t . • II!rr�.!.
,i I a .,_._:: . .
°
• -i
_._. _ ___ . •
. ..,, ...___.__.• ,-) i
..______...„.
, . 1 , , .., .:
1 „i 11
f41+Gsil. I
1 i — -, . -.. r . -,.... . i , ..._ 7 '. J . : 81:.". ..
1 17. ';':' --1--7 i......' .--' ' - ri„, -,.,..,.. .,,,,;..:,,. , • i ,., ..,,..„,„ ,,,,,,,..._
.._„ ....4.,,,'. h,--,,,,, ,: 1, ..,..1,1-: , . 1 . . . , - II ,
1
1
Ili .1 ' 1 : ., - 1 I '; 1 — —- '..-._. • . 1 I 1 . . 1/1
I , i.., itiL,H, - ! , , . . , , ________ , ,
:. H . . , i. . , i
' i i' 11 iisiii. ____.,.._ •, ,
,itl ) • 1 i _,—_,—,,___Iwz.--.1 . HI , i ,,,-r.,..i
"' ,a i° tix
1 I -.7' * '''''trei • ,„/.1.41%1 imig•i 0 j.
, - ,, .77 i • .3 ' .
i _ . , 1 "--1- v D 11.01 1 3,1' 1
. ,
i
i _ _,,..._../" I 1 . rI ' I• -7 PI , i, , 'ri .
I
o
. 1 _ _..
k
. ,. -.
1 I . : 7 .'.: 1.. ' ' rr, I'
r I ,,i ! , l'i'-'
7•pl,K-.At2oirrir.r. 1 - i
I
I '
,,,..A i
, '—,P.'S
I
—iitErg:0-1V—A-74— : . ,47. q.,
2-1:—r5' .;I I! I
i -I� r.-� -- - •
4 —
iv , iN
i 1 --..,—,....,7
34i 'al
] r kL M
i
1\1- ri '-- .
Y
1
4
I
Project Narrative
The following document supports the application submitted to the Design Review Commission (DRC)on
March 10 regarding 207 Nelson Avenue, Saratoga Springs.
H=1:14----
.
I I
111110111111 I I 1.1
II
0 5 ‘4\,,%
1.111
I
1111 IIIT
41'` 7•ti
-
_ .
. -
— I I lam III Fi• - -
Project Overview
The house is modest in size (approx. footprint of 1)500 sq. ft.) and is !isted as a contributing building to
the East Side Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places(along with 340 other properties).
With careful consideration of available options and the feedback shared by the DRC and the Saratoga
Springs Preservation Foundation,the owners propose to:
• Maintain or repair the original, primary structure;
• Enhance the functionality of the property; and
• Conform to zoning requirements.
The owners are invested in maintaining critical features of the original, primary structure— both exterior
and interior. The application requests improvements to accommodate a family, including the addition of
one bedroom,functional kitchen and living space, and a one-car garage. It is important to the owners that
these changes retain and complement the character of the house. It is equally important to the owners
that the design balances this interest appropriately with the needs of today's lifestyle, which differ greatly
from time the house was built a common dilemma with old homes,
Home Exterior-Existing
-L,..
k .,
'.1141111
.".
1-
-....-- ----
Z=,
-- -,-- _, ----, 1
_ __-•,._.-, _
-----=
.. .,-_-.= S Er fi -1 .- -----=.- at
_---„. a. _ --
--_L= , -,--L-_ _ id_limif 1.111 — —.
li — ..-K--
- ---;.
South View South View
4.44 tj 41,'111 =
i: • :
a ir,--
piripli.1 fr, .
-
1
• • 11-, P
P
i
' d
•
..M.,
Raonfall routinely floods 50-ft o Sweertey Way.
VVinter weather severely affect drivabllity
Property Outline-Arial View Sweeney Way
The structure's proximity to Sweeney Way and the The alley floods and becomes difficult to
new parking area installed for 181 Phila Street on the traverse during rain and snowstorms.
opposite side of Sweeney Way have contributed to the
structure being hit by vehicles.
Home Exterior-Proposed
% \
.....'- ''
Lit
0000400wiL
$
Existing Residence Proposed Residence
4