Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20210224 Buenos Hill Auto Site Plan (7) Subscribe Sign In Breaking News Recommended Albany landlord tied Passsover takeout limo_ Jack's Oyster House Shop up, 'evicted' t i L1 from Iron Work and introducing tour: sleeping tenants, � r Temple Israel multicourse menus in Co Saratoga County residents fear they'll drown in development Wendy Liberatore Updated: Sep. 30, 2018 8:18 a.m. 000 From The Web Sponsored Links by Taboola If You Need to Kill Time on Your Computer,this Fantasy Game is a Must- Have. No Install. ` x.14 .¢t; r Play Now Research Ps „s� by McAfuc-'')‘"'L&.post ;&Treatments Paused by McAfee®Web Boost Psoriatic Arthritis Treatment I Search Ads This Strategy Game Can't Be Played Without Sufficient IQ Total Battle:Tactical War Game If You Like to Play,this City-Building Game is a Must-Have. No Install. Forge of Empires-Free Online Game Paused by McAfee®Web Boost Getting this Treasure is impossible! Prove us wrong Hero Wars These Cars Are So Loaded It's Hard to Believe They're So Cheap Luxury SUVs I Search Ads 3 of 38 Buy Photo Dawn Ulrich describes her 1880 cottage in Stillwater hugged by woods and bordered by a stream as her dream home. But within less than a year of moving there, she was fighting for its preservation. Ulrich joined the chorus of dozens of residents last February who pleaded with town officials to stop a plan to cut down the forest surrounding her home to make way for a development of 21 single-family homes. ADVERTISEMENT Article continues below this ad "I didn't move here to live in suburbia," she told elected officials. But the board was unmoved and the White Sulphur Springs development was unanimously approved. "It's a terrible shock," said Ulrich outside of her Luther Road home. "I love my home, it means a lot to me and to hear about the development and a boulevard that will run through here, it breaks my heart." Ulrich is not alone. She is among scores of Saratoga County residents who faithfully attend public meetings to petition elected officials to stop the encroachment of housing developments. The residents, many of whom live in towns along the Northway corridor, are arguing against the creep of subdivisions for more reasons than personal ones. They fear the pace of development is destroying farms, forests,fields, the watershed, and, ultimately, threatening the quality of life. Article cdFifrrlIT ENb1Ar this ad This is nothing new. The buildup of housing in the county has been unstoppable for years. The U.S. Census Bureau calculates that about 123,000 people lived in the county in 1970. Population rose to 153,000 in 1980, then 182,000 in 1990 and 201,000 in 2000. By 2020,the Census Bureau predicts the county will be home to 234,000 — nearly doubling its 1970 figure. That averages out to 30,000 new residents moving here every 10 years. The bureau also confirmed that the county continues to be the state's fastest-growing outside of the New York metropolitan area. This influx brings pressure for housing. Boom towns in Saratoga County Select a category Several Saratoga County communities along Route 87 have seen dramatic growth over the past decades. Use • Population the selectors on the right to view different economic ❑ Median home price indicators. Hover on the bars for more information. ❑ Housing units ❑ Assessed value Population •Then Clifton Park 23,989 •Now 23,906 Saratoga Springs 27,862 Halfmoon 11,860 23,684 11,188 Moreau 15,601 7,714 Ballston 10,446 7,221 Wilton 17,909 6,968 Malta 16,146 6,316 Stillwater 8,733 4,595 Saratoga 5,915 OK 10K 20K 30K 40K O Cathleen F. Crowley &Wendy Liberatore/Times Union Microsoft Power BI 1_6> 1/1 Are there tax benefits? While residents would argue the county has reached a tipping point,the county's elected officials, most of whom are Republican, say the county can add more homes and can do it in a way that preserves the landscape. If development slows, they say, taxes will have to go up. ADVERTISEMENT Article continues below this ad "We don't want to be at a static point," said Ed Kinowski, Stillwater town supervisor and chair of the County Board of Supervisors. "Everything is going up .... to maintain the services that people expect,we have to grow.We want Stillwater to grow steadily so we can keep taxes low or not raise them at all. If we don't have development,we'll have to raise taxes." The county's low tax rate is something that county politicians love to tout.Wilton Supervisor Art Johnson said that people are lured to the county because of the taxes. He said the low taxes need to be preserved as much as the landscape. "We don't have a town tax or a highway tax," said Johnson whose town ranked as the sixth-fastest growing in the county with a 5.2 percent rise in population in 2017. "If we don't grow,we can't keep our taxes low. It is important." Johnson said the key to balancing growth and taxes is a well-defined and continually updated comprehensive plan. The guidance from the plan should ensure "commercial growth does not encroach on residential growth" and that green space is preserved. "We slowed down because we need to take a breather," Johnson said of Wilton. "We don't want to grow too quickly because it can become a strain on our infrastructure and become more costly. It comes down to balance and listening to feedback from the public." 00:01 /00 Studies show that housing developments can cost more than they bring in.A 2006 study from the University of Georgia noted that local governments are trying to fix their fiscal woes by increasing their property tax base. "A growing body of empirical evidence shows that while commercial and industrial development can indeed improve financial well-being of a local government, residential development worsens it," states the introduction to The Fiscal Impacts of Land Uses on Local Government. "While residential development brings with it new tax (and fee) revenue it also brings demands for local government services,"the study reads. "The cost of providing these services exceeds the revenue generated by the new houses in every case studied." Another study from the School of Urban and Regional Planning of Queen's University in Ontario looked at housing in the U.S. and Canada and found that housing developments have increased congestion and pollution and raised the cost of services. It also concluded "the push without end through old orchards, farmland, forest and meadows" is "killing the golden goose"that brings people to the area in the first place. Affordability versus luxury Wilton's balanced approach will not prevent new subdivisions. Its planning board is considering a 310-unit subdivision proposal between Jones Road and Putnam Lane on a tract of 550 acres, mostly wooded. Peter Belmonte,who wants to build the mix of single-family homes and townhouses, described it as a"premier subdivision of the Capital Region." The deeper into the subdivision one goes,the bigger and more expensive the homes will be. This poses yet another problem, said Art Holmberg, chair of Sustainable Saratoga, a nonprofit that advocates for sustainable practices to protect natural resources for future generations.Wilton, like Saratoga Springs, has shifted construction to cater to the luxury buyer. "Houses that are a half million or three-quarters of a million dollars do not open up the housing market to everyone," Holmberg said. "A sustainable city includes diversity, more younger families, diversity of age and race. Saratoga is becoming a very gray city that is attracting retirees from Westchester and New Jersey." He said the city is building workforce housing on West Avenue and South Broadway. But he adds,the housing is relegated to the outskirts. "It's creating a segregated city,"he said. A study of housing in Saratoga Springs, Housing Needs: Saratoga Springs Market,has found that 72 percent of affordable housing units in Saratoga Springs is designated for seniors. This coincides with the construction of luxury housing units for seniors including The Summit at Saratoga,which is actually in Wilton, and Station Park,which is being planned near the train station on West Avenue. More Information A few of the controversies surrounding developments in Saratoga County DnIlrtnn. I\A:11:,..-. ,.i..n.., ............. i;,,-...,. ..1. rs— +.. AI I I-. II 1..- ..+.... i;,,...,. ;.-. +4... SEE MORE While no Saratoga Springs officials, including Mayor Meg Kelly,would comment on the vision for the city's development, Holmberg said that right now most of the development is concentrated in the city's center. He worries about what will happen once the main streets are saturated. "If development kept to the urban core, that's sustainable," Holmberg said. "If it goes out into the area of the Greenbelt trail,then that would not be good.We would really fight against that." With green space becoming more of a priority, some towns have turned to Saratoga PLAN, a nonprofit with a mission to preserve the rural character of the county by identifying areas to conserve and then helping towns to devise a plan to achieve that. Stillwater,where White Sulphur Springs will be built, is among the towns that have consulted with the nonprofit. So too has Ballston,which is in a legal battle with the state Department of Agriculture & Markets over a water line extension in the agricultural district. Ballston officials,who meet under a logo reading"a farm first community,"have proposed requiring farmers to carve out 2-acre lots if they want to build a home for family members working on the farm. MOST POPULAR 1 Albany landlord tied up, 'evicted' sleeping tenants, dumping them in cemetery, police say • 2. Closings of two Walgreens raise pharmacy desert concerns 3 Delivery-only Guy Fieri restaurant opens in Colonie Host of conservative radio show launches Albany mayoral run Gender reveal party explosion kills downstate New York man "Conceptually, the towns want to preserve open space,but when it comes down to zoning, a lot of towns fall short," said Maria Trabka, Saratoga PLAN's executive director. "You can't zone everything into 2-acre lots and achieve conservation goals, preserve the rural character or the viewshed." A shift in Clifton Park The outlier in all of this appears to be Clifton Park, the town that many critics of development point to when arguing against growth. Supervisor Phil Barrett said he is "looking decades into the future" and has shifted his goal away from subdivisions and is now focused on preserving open spaces. "Our job is to increase the value of Clifton Park," Barrett said. "We want to design a town to promote contiguous open space that is either town-owned or privately owned. The goal,years ago,was parks and recreation and trails.And that continues to be the initiative." Clifton Park, however, is sandwiched between a growing Ballston and Halfmoon. That increases traffic throughout Clifton Park, Barrett said,which is another item on the long list of complaints from residents who want development to slow. More for you V x « f c r la ' 011 r ter— ` Traffic is one of the main reasons Milton residents don't want a 52-unit senior housing project on Hutchins Road. "There is too much on the road," said Dorothy Christiansen who lives at 126 Hutchins Road. "It's like a speedway now because people use Hutchins Road to go between Rowland Street and Route 50.We are a small neighborhood and one of the oldest neighborhoods in Milton.We have single-family residents, some with second- generation owners. (The housing project) is too much." Halfmoon Supervisor Kevin Tollisen said commuter traffic also clogs his roads and must always be considered before committing to development. "We have made tremendous strides in making improvements to traffic in many areas of town," Tollisen said. "We need to be cognizant and make strategic plans to continue to address traffic.We continually work with DOT and developers to find ways to improve traffic." Halfmoon remains the fastest-growing of all the towns in Saratoga County with an increase of 13.5 percent in 2017,the Capital District Regional Planning Commission calculated. Tollisen said there are plans to ease traffic with a $1.8 million improvement at the intersection of Sitterly and Woodin roads that will add a new turn lane and new traffic signals. Route 146 in Clifton Park will also get some relief when a$3.82 million roundabout is installed at the intersection of Route 146A and Vischer Ferry Road. Recently, there has been push back on the rapid pace of growth in Halfmoon. In August, Town Council members John Wasielewski and Jeremy Connors opposed Betts Farm, a 201-unit development on Route 236. "It's too much,"Wasielewski said. "The amount of units and the amount of traffic it will cause;we don't have to jam every single area of open space with development." Saratoga resident John Cashin,who is battling the 32-home Cedar Bluff subdivision that will be built on a ridge overlooking Saratoga Lake, said there should be more consultation between towns when it comes to development. "From the standpoint of the county, it's uncontrolled, uncoordinated." Cashin said. "If the towns don't coordinate and don't consider the cumulative effects on our watershed, our trees, streets, it will be a disaster for recreation and tourism." Board of Supervisors Chairman Kinowski,who believes there is more room for housing developments without threatening the rural landscape, said the people will ultimately decide. "When people say enough is enough, it will stop," Kinowski said. "But that will probably mean a tax increase." Ulrich, however, doesn't believe residents have any say. "It's a sham,"Ulrich said. "You go to express an opinion,but they don't care." Sign up for breaking news alerts When critical news happens in the Capital Region, you'll be the first to know Enter your email SIGN UP By signing up,you agree to ou r Terms of Use and acknowledge that your information will be used as described in our Privacy Policy. 4) Written By Wendy Liberatore Reach Wendy on Wendy Liberatore covers communities in Saratoga County. Prior to joining the Times Union, she wrote features on the arts and dance for the Daily Gazette, Saratoga Living and the Saratogian. She also worked for magazines in Westchester County and was an education reporter with the Bronxville Review- Press and Reporter. She contributes to the Saratoga blog. She can be reached at wliberatore@timesunion.com or (518) 491-0454 or (518) 454-5445. TOP SHOPPING PICKS 1111110 - - ` / _ .1wirA,..E. 414417 ,.- Sho' 'in. Sho' 'in, The Dyson V8 Animal is S100 off right now I wore Dr.Martens'most expensive boot for a month : . .../ 1/2 • . .. .. /.......:".,./ 7. 11 e// te. Sho' 'in' Sho' 'in' This $10 bowl will keep your dog from eating way These Red Wing Sawmill boots are S189 and too fast worth every penny These Cars Are So Loaded It's Hard to Believe They're So Cheap Luxury SUVs I Search Ads I Sponsored People Born 1948-1979 On Medicare Are In For A Treat This February (Check If You Qualify) MedicarePlan I Sponsored Learn Mere Remember Sandra Bullock's Son? This Is Him Now Post Fun I Sponsored People Born 1948-1979 On Medicare Are In For A Treat (Check If You Qualify) MedicarePlan I Sponsored i Learn More Netflix Cancellations: Effective Immediately thedelite.com I Sponsored 20 Everyday Things Kate Middleton Is Not Allowed To Do Post Fun I Sponsored New York Homeowners Are Getting a Big Pay Day in March american-home-coverage I Sponsored l Learn More According To CGI, This Is What Historical Figures Really Looked Like Taco Relish I Sponsored He Was Once An Icon In The NBA, Here's Him Now Gameday News I Sponsored Best & Worst Refinance Mortgage Companies Of 2021 comparisons.org I Sponsored ( Learn More Tori Roloff Confirms Devastating Family News PensAndPatron I Sponsored After Celine Dion's Major Weight Loss, She Confirms What We Suspected All Along Total Past I Sponsored Toenail Fungus? Try This Tonight Fungus Eliminator I Sponsored ( Learn More Breakable hearts are the hot new Valentine's day gift Sheriff: Queensbury man sells fentanyl to deputies Times Union Man Who Predicted 2020 Crash Says "Now Is The Time" The Legacy Report I Sponsored Faith Hill's Daughter Is Probably The Prettiest Woman In The World Noteabley I Sponsored Trail Cam Captured What No One Was Supposed To See Trendy Matter I Sponsored Man Who Predicted 2020 Crash 45 Days Early Issues Next Major Warning The Legacy Report I Sponsored These Twins Were Named "Most Beautiful In The World," Wait Until You See Them Today Give It Love I Sponsored Will Amica trying to make up for lost time with UAlbany Times Union Capital Region coronavirus cases decline as 5 more area residents die Times Union Shut The Front Door! The 2021 Honda SUVS Astonish! 2021 Honda SUVS I Search Ads I Sponsored Doctor: Try This For A Fatty Liver (Watch) 1MD I Sponsored Put A Dishwasher Tablet In Your Shower At Night, Here's Why HealthyGem I Sponsored ABOUT Our Company Terms of Use General Standards and Practices Privacy Notice Newspaper Delivery Safety Procedures Your California Privacy Rights Advertising Jobs at the TU Interest Based Ads CONTACT Contact Us Events Calendar Blogs Obituaries Weather Online Store School Closings Puzzles Palace SERVICES Subscriber Services Mobile App Home Delivery Copyright and Reprint Become a Carrier e-Edition HE AR s T newspapers ©2021 Hearst