Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
20200583 Byrne Exterior Modifications Application (2)
�,���T"GA SA,� CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS �FOR OFFICE USE� � ✓ � � C� � `' � �" DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION �� i�',f, U � � � � � (Application#) �rt . 7 � �'� ".:h .,. ,;��;.;.. ; .'�r City Hall-474 Broadway 'N �'�- y' Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 C�R�'ORATEO �91 Tel:SIS-587-3550x.515 fax:518-580-9480 p , wwwsaratoga-springs.org --, � , , �-9 -- � � � r� .r� . , ARCHITECTURAL/ HISTORIC REVIEW APPLICATION SEP 0 3 2020 APPLICANT(S)� OWNER�S� (/fnota�p/icant� ATfORNEY/AGENT Y Name Sharon Byrne Agent: Engineering America Co Address 454 Maple St. 76 Washington St. Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Phone / � 518/587-1340� Email tonyay@nycap.rr.com Identify primary contact person: ❑Applicant ❑ Owner �Attorney/Agent '�An applicant must be the property owner, lessee, or one with an option to lease or purchase the property in question. Applicant's interest in premises: � Owner ❑ Lessee ❑ Under option to lease or purchase PROPERTY INFORMATION Property Address/Location: 203 Church St Tax Parcel #: �65 50 _ 1 _ 70 (for example:165.51—4—.�7) Current Zoning District: OMB�2 Property use: ❑ Residential � Non-residential/mixed-use Type of Review: �Architectural ❑ Historic ❑ Extension/modification (of current approval) Summary description of proposed action: —Addition of ADA ramn for bi�ilding ar.c:Pssibilit� - Replacement of existing (non-historic)door on West side of building with wood window to match existing windows - Replace tin snow slides with copper snow slides - Remove non-functional chimney - Replace existing roof with Boral composite slate roofing (Classic Slate: Grey/ Black Blend) - Removal of existing aluminum siding and repair of existing underlying wood siding &trim (painted white) Has a previous application been filed with the DRC for this property? ❑ No �Yes—date(s)? 2008 A No. s , unknown(not built out) - PP• � )� Revised O1/2019 �. APPLICATION FEE (payable to "Commissioner of Finance"): Residential Structures(principal, accessory) $50 Non-residential/mixed-use structures(principal) $500 Residential approval—extension/mod $50 Non-residential signs, awnings, accessory structures $I 25 Non-residential mixed-use sketch $150 Non-residential approval—extension/mod $I 25 Demolition $350 ��A "complete" application consists of 1 hard copy(origina� ,and I electronic co�y of application &ALL other materials as required below: New Construction /Additions � Color photographs showing site/exterior details of existing structures and adjacent properties � Site plan,drawn to scale,showing existing&proposed construction, property lines&dimensions, required&proposed setbacks&lot coverage,site features(fences,walks,trees, etc.};on no larger than 2'x3'sheet—smaller preferred if legible � Elevation drawings showing design of all sides of existing&proposed construction—label dimensions,colors, materials, lighting(fixture &lamp type,wattage),etc.-include compass bearing&scale; no larger than 2'x3'sheet—smaller permitted if legible � Floor plans for proposed structure;on sheet no larger than 2'x3'—smaller permitted if legible � Product literature,specifications and samples of proposed materials and colors Change in exterior building materials (windows, doors, roof, siding, etc.), or color(in non-residential districts only) � Color photographs showing site/exterior details of existing structures and that illustrate affected features � Elevation drawings showing all sides of existing&proposed construction—label dimensions, colors, materials, lighting(fixture&lamp type,wattage),etc. -include compass bearing&scale; no larger than 2'x3'sheet—smaller permitted if legible � Product literature,specifications and samples of proposed materials and colors Wltlllll fl"Oflt Y3t'CI 52tI�3CI(S IIl HIStOPIC DIStI"ICtS OIIIX (Front setbacks:UR-I &INST-HTR=30';UR-4=25';UR-2,UR-3&NCUD-I=10') - Installation, removal or change in material of drive-and walkways - Installation or removal of architectural, sculptural or vegetative screening over 3' in height - Installation of accessory utility structures or radio/satellite transmission/reception devices (more than 2' diameter) For any of above: ❑ Color photographs showing site/exterior details of existing structures,and of adjacent properties ❑ Site plan showing existing&proposed construction:include property lines&dimensions, required&proposed setbacks&lot coverage,site features(fences,walks,trees, etc.) street names,compass bearing&scale;no larger than 2'x3'sheet—smaller preferred if legible ❑ Product literature,specifications and samples of proposed materials and colors Signage/Awnings ❑ Color photographs showing site/exterior details of existing structures,and adjacent proper-ties ❑ Plan showing location of proposed sign/awning structure on building/premises: no larger than I I"x 17" ❑ Scaled illustration of proposed sign/awning structure and lettering(front view&profile): include all dimensions of structure;type, . dimensions and style of lettering or(ogo;description of colors, materials, mounting method and hardware ❑ Descriptions,specifications of proposed lighting including fixture&lamp type, wattage, mounting method,and location ❑ Product literature,specifications and samples of proposed materials and colors • Demolition ❑ Color photographs showing site/exterior details of existing structures,and of adjacent properties ❑ Site plan showing existing and any proposed structures-include dimensions,setbacks,street names, compass bearing,and scale ❑ Written description of reasons for demolition and,in addition: ❑ For structures of"architectural/historical significance", demonstrate"good cause"why structure cannot be preserved ❑ For structures in an architectural district that might be eligible for listing on National Register of Historic Places,or for a "contributing"structure in a National Register district(contact City staffl, provide plans for site development following demolition- include a timetable and letter of credit for project completion Telecommunication facilities ❑ Color photographs showing site/existing structures,and of adjacent properties ❑ Site plan showing existing and proposed structures: include dimensions,setbacl<s,street names,compass bearing,and scale ❑ Scaled illustration of proposed structures: include all dimensions;colors, materials, lighting, mounting details ❑ Consult Article 240-I 2.22 of the City's Zoning Ordinance and City staff to ensure compliance with requirements for visual impact assessment and existing and proposed vegetative screening Revised O1(2019 Request for extension of current approval ❑ Identify date of original DRC approval: Current expiration date: Org.App. No. ❑ Describe why this extension is necessary and whether any significant changes have occurred either on the site or in the neighborhood. SEQR Environmental Assessment Form ❑Applicants proposing the following must complete"Part I"of the SEQR Short Environmental Assessment Form(available here: http://www.dec.ny.gov/docs/permits ej operations_pdf/seafpartone.pd�: -Construction or expansion of a multi-family residential structure(4 units +) -Construction or expansion(exceeding 4,000 sq.ft.gross floor area)of a principal or accessory non-residential structure -Telecommunications facility, radio antennae,satellite dishes - Demolition Disclosure Does any City officer, employee or family member thereof have a financial interest(as defined by General Municipal Law Section 809) in this application? � No ❑Yes- (f yes, a statement disclosing the name, residence, nature, and extent of this interest must be filed with this application. Certification I/we,the property'owner(s), or purchaser(s)/lessee(s) under contract, of the land in question, hereby request an appearance before the Design Review Commission. By the signature(s) attached hereto, I/we certify that the information provided within this application and accompanying documentation is, to the best of my/our knowledge,true and accurate. I/we further understand that intentionally providing false or misleading information is grounds for immediate denial of this application. I/we hereby authorize the members of the Design Review Commission and designated City staff to enter the property associated with this application for purposes of conducting any necessary site inspections relating to this application. Furthermore, I/we agree to meet all requirements under Article VII for Historic Review or Article VIII for Architectural Review of e Zoning Code of he City of Saratoga Springs. Date: � � � (applicant sig ture) Date: (applicant signature) If applicant is not the currently the owner of the property, the current owner must also sign. Owner Signature: Date: Owner Signature: Date: Revised Ol/2019 FOR OFFICE USE ONL This application has been reviewed by the Zoning Enforcement Officer and is being forwarded to the Commission. Signature: Date: Additional Comments: Revised O1/2019 -." P�A���A SA CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS IFOR OFFICE USE� � ��r Q� � �u, DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION � -= 7, � (Application#) v ���.. : �,,, ,; ,'r City Hall-474 Broadway ', Saratoga Springs, New York 12866 �C�RPORATEO `91y Tel:518-587-3550 x.515 fax:518-560-9480 p , www.saratoga-springs.org -- � � � ' � � i . ARCHITECTURAL/ HISTORIC REVIEWAPPLICATION S�P Q 3 ZOZO APPLICANT(S)� OWNER(S� (/inotapplicant,� A�RNEY AGENT Y Name Sharon Byrne Agent: Engineering America Co Address 454 Maple St. 76 Washington St. Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 Phone / / 518/587-1340� Email tonyay@nycap.rr.com Identify primary contact person: ❑Applicant ❑ Owner �Attorney/Agent �An applicant must be the property owner, lessee,.or one with an option to lease or purchase the property in question. Applicant's interest in premises: � Owner ❑ Lessee ❑ Under aption to lease or purchase PROPERTY INFORMATION Property Address/Location: 203 Church St Tax Parcel #: �65 50 _ 1 _ 70 (for example:/65.52-4-3� Current Zoning District: OMB-2 Property use: ❑ Residential � Non-residential/mixed-use Type of Review: �Architectural � Historic ❑ Extension/modification (of current approval) Summary description of proposed action: -Addition of AI�A ramn for huilding��r�Pssibilit� - Replacement of existing (non-historic)door on West side of building with wood window to match existing windows - Replace tin snow slides with copper snow slides � ,1 � ENGINEERING AIVIERICA COMPANY 6H3O PH.518-587-1340 �� 76 WASHINGTON ST. 50-t752nt3 SARATOGA SPRINGS,NY 12866 �� -��- .. . _ � � PF�AR�a+. Painted white) _� .�. � �B��h� � � . � -�--� __ A�J � — � 1o2�°a , 2oos .....--, � - ate(s). , /� vnom �'°'""�� �° �,�"� � unknown(not built out) App. No.(s). SARATOGA �N��� For God So Lav�d the World..:. -�11ee1 �SpRNTOGh SPWNGS,NY t28 098-9571 �fiiffi� A' I NAL . t;, , �"'--�-,— ��� ��/°v�0�3 L'lf� i� S'�- .�.�._ �...�._:._� �:02L31L529�: LLOL8722ii' 6830 ENGINEERING AMERICA CO . 7 6 W A S H I N G T O N S T . S A R A T O G A S P R I N G S , N Y 1 2 8 6 6 5 1 8 / 5 8 7 - 1 3 4 0 5 1 8 / 5 8 0 - 9 7 8 3 ( F A X ) TRANSMITTALSHEET TO: FROM: Design Revie�v Con�unission Tonya Yasenchak COMPANY: DATE: City of Saratoga Springs SEI'1'EMBER 2,2020 FAX NUMBER: TOTAL NO.OF PAGES INCLUDING COVER: 1 DRC Application&$125 application fee PHON�NUMBER: S�ND�R'S R�FER�NCL NU�fBER: R�: YOUR REF�RENC�NUMBLR: Byrne—Ra.inp Addition #203 Chuich St,Saratoga Springs,NY ❑ URGENT C�P'OR RFVIEW ❑ PL�AS� COMMENT ❑PLEASE RFPLP ❑AS REQUEST�D Deai:Design Revie�v Cointnission, Engineei�ing America Co. iespectfully submits the attached DRC application foi review of proposed eYteriox modifications related to exterior updates /renovations along�vith the addition of an ADA compliant accessible ramp to the e�sting building at 203 Church St. in Saratoga Springs,NY. The need for the new ioofing materials has just been uncovered,while attempting to repair the e�sting roof. The existing open roof Yequi�-es uninediate attention. We respectfully request to be placed on the Septembei 16`'' agenda for review. We thank you for yow:time and consideration. Please contact my office with any questions or if additional info�narion is required. Thank you for yout time and cooperation. _r-— _ _�—__ �...----� Tonya Yas ak, E Enc. CONCRETE STOOP &STA/RS REMOVED . 13,-0"(+/_) NEW CONCRETE DOOR TO BE + SIDEWALK REPLACED WlTH WOOD o , 12"HANDRAIL WINDOW TO MATCH � TENSIONS OTHER WINDOWS o R� IN BAY BUMPOUT �, A2 5'-0" � a q o Qx `� `� �� LANDSCAPED °oa N AREA �� 4x4 POSTS OR 2"METAL ROUND SUPPORTS WOOD OR METAL HANOR,4/L 6'-6" >2"HANDRAIL EXTENSfONS 0 o LANDING �MP�P o _ EXISTlNG � � 1:12 PITCH � � FRONT PORCh y R2 a,_p„ '42 WOOD OR METAL HANDRAIL R1 A2 BYRNE: ADA RAMP ADDITION 203 CHURCH ST.,SARATOGA SPRINGS,NY ��O�o��� -- 1-�. C. 14A11/IP PLA1V SCALE: 3/i6"=1'0" DESIGN BY.� � ENGINEERING AMERICA CO. 76 WASHINGTON ST.,SARATOGA SPRINGS,NY 518/587-1340 NOTE: DIMENSIONS MAY VARY. CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR FIELD VERIFYING ALL MEASUREMENTS PR10R TO AND D(/RING CONSTRUCTION. NOTIFYDESIGNENGINEER IMMEDIATELY OF ANY/ALL DISCREPANGIES EXISTING FRONT PORCH COLUMN 1 1/2"ROUND ALUMINUM (REMAINS UNCNANGED) HANORAIL(COLOR: BLACK) 1 1/2"ROUND ALUMINUM EDGE GUARD(COLOR:GUARDJ � EXISTING PORCH TO E REPAfREO WITHOUT a MODIFICATION tl' N �� 5/4"T&G DECKING AND 5'-0" o' 6'-6" 2x6 WOOD DECK JOIS7 WOOD LATTICE PANEL (STAINED:BtACK) (STAINED: BLACK) SOUTH/FRONT ELEVATION (AS VIEWED FROM CHURCH S� 5/4"T8G DECKING AND 1 1/2"ROUNDALUMINUM 2x10 WOOD STRINGER HANDRAIL(COLOR: BLACK) (STAINED:BLACK) 1 1/2"ROUND ALUMINUM HANDRAIL(COLOR:BLACK) 12"HANDRAIL EXTENSION AS REQUIRED BY CODE � 1' � ' N � CONCRETE SIDEWALK o __- GRADE N PARKING LOT 16'-0" �—5'-0" CHURCH ST. 1 1/2"ROUND ALUMINUM 2x6 WOOD JOISTS WOOD LATTICE PANEL EDGE GUARD(COLOR:BLACK) (STAINED:BLACK) (STAINED.• BLACKJ WEST/LEFT ELEVATION (QSVIEG9Eb�FFZ57Gf F�6�P1TA'L"6R7�EwA�j BYRNE: ADA RAMP AD�ITION 203 CHURCH ST.,SARATOGA SPRINGS,NY PROPOSED RAMP ELEVA TIONS SCALE: 3/16"=1'0" DESIGN BY.� ENGINEERING AMERICA CO. 76 WASHINGTON ST.,SARATOGA SPRINGS,NY 518/587-1340 NOTE: DIMENSIONS MAY VARY. CONTRACTOR/S RESPONS/BLE FOR FIELD VERIFYING ALL MEASUREMENTS PRIOR TO AND DURINGCONSTRUCTION. NOT(FYDESIC,NENGINEER 1MMEDtATELY OF ANY/ALL DISCREPANCIES �"' _ AT�GA CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS Keith Kaplan, Chair ��,� S'A� Brad Gallagher, Vice Chair c5, �, f2. ZONWG BOARD OF APPEALS Cheryi Grey ±' Christopher Mills H �- _�' � Grr H,a��-474 BRoaowAY Suzanne Morris '� �� SARATOGASPRINGS,NEwYoRK 12866 Gage Simpson `� ` " ��'"' ' •Y Chris Hemstead,alternate �c�_ aH)5 I 8-587-3550 Fx)5 I 8-580-9450 .���oR� �9'��'. WNNV.SARATOGA-SPRINGS.ORG Kathieen O'Connor,aiternate ORA7E0 #20190834 IN THE MATTER OF THE APPEAL OF Sharon Byrne 454 Maple Ave Saratoga Springs NY 12866 from the deternunation of the Building Inspector involving the premises at 203 Church Street in the City of Saratoga Springs,New York being taY parcel number 165.50-1-70 on the Assessment Map of said City.. The appellant having applied for an area variance under the Zoning Ordinance of said City to permit the construction of an ADA compliant accessible ramp addition to the existing building at 203 Church Street in an OMB-2 (Office/Medical Business) District and public notice having been duly given of a hearing on said application held on the 16th day of September,2019. In consideration of the balance betwean benefit to the applicant with detriment to the health, safety and welfare of the community,I move that the following area variance for the following amount of relief TYPE OF REQUIREMENT DISTRICT DIMENSIONAL PROPOSED REUEF REQUESTED i REQUIREMENT MINIMUM YARD SETBACK-SIDE 15' 4.I' I0.9'OR 73% (WEST� MINIMUM YARD SETBACK- 30' 10.3' I 9.7'OR 66% TOTAL SIDES MINIMUM YARD SETBACK- 40' 17.0' 23.0�OR 58% FRONT(SOUTH� As per the submitted plans or lesser dimensions,be approved for the following reasons: l. The applicant has demonstrated this benefit cannot be achieved by other means feasible to the applicant. Per the applicant, a)relocation of the ramp closer to the main building to reduce the variance is difficult as it would not align with the parking area for access. Also, location closer to the main building rnay cause issues with roof drainage and snow between the building and ramp. b) Relocation of the ramp along the back of the main building would reduce the number of variances required by eliminating the required front setback variance.However,the building interior layout is configured for the main access to be from the front porch. Significant interior renovations would be required to allow for exterior access from the rear of the building. c)A Handicap lift was reviewed but not considered due to cost and lack of consistency with the architecture of the main building. A ramp may be blended better to the landscape and is not required to be covered. 2. The applicant has demonstrated that granting this variance will not create an undesirable change in neighborhood character or detriment to nearby properties. The applicant notes that a)the dense use and development coverage of the Saratoga Hospital is directly adjacent to this project site. The addition of this proposed ramp is minor in comparisan of scale to the Hospital complex. b)The ramp is designed to be consistent in scale with the existing building and buildings adjacent to the East.Furthermore,the ramp design must be approved by the City Design Review Commission for its proposed architectural character. c) The ramp location provides better circulation from the parking area to the building ta the main entry along Church Street. d)the height of the ramp rail will only be 36-42", much less than a full wall or roof covered structure. The variance will have minor visual impact. e)The ramp will be located adjacent to properly that is deeded for parking, therefore the impact on the property to the West is minimal as it directs pedestrian traffic on the project site and not on the existing adjacent lot sidewallc. 3. The Board notes these requested setback variances, at 73%, 66%,and 52%, are substantial, however the impact of the substantiality is mitigated by the following: a)The required lot width in this zoning district is 100' and the pre-existing lot is 50'. The lot width is 50' less than that required and is similar to lots to the East and South. b) The pre-existing West side setback is approximately 12' instead of the 15' required. The ramp is located 8' closer to the adjacent parldng lot than what currently exists. This is not substantial and was already out of compliance. c)The porch of the main house is located 15.2' from the front property line and was built in 1902. The proposed ramp is located 1T from the property line. The 23' variance is not deemed substantial since the existing porch is closer to the front property line and is out of compliance. d)The ramp area is proposed to be 140 sq ft; anly 1.7%of the site.The minor nature of the proposed addition is not substantial. 4. This variance will not have a significant adverse physical or environmental effect on the neighborhood or district.a) The ramp is located so to contain runoff from the roof and to contain snow between the building and the ramp. b) The ramp is located so as to encourage pedestrian traffic directly onto the project site,reducing pedestrian travel on the adjacent property sidewalk. c)The construction of the ramp is proposed to be on piers which would not require any major excavation.d)No large or significant trees are proposed to be removed for this project. e) The ramp slope drains onto the project site and not towards adjacent lots. fl The overall Principal Building coverage, including the ramp, is 21.1%; well under the 30% maximum coverage allowed. g) The permeability of the lot is 53%; well above the 30% minimum permeability required. 5. The alleged difficulty may be considered self-created insofar as the applicant desired to construct the ramp,but this is not necessarily fatal to the application Adopted by tbe following vote: AYES: 7 (K.Kaplan,C. Grey, G. Simpson,S.Morris,B. Gallagher,K.O'Connor,C.Mills) NAYES: 0 Dated: September 16,2019 _ Th;s variance_shalLexpire�.8�nonths_follo_wing_the�'iling_date_of_such_decision_unless_the_necessar_y_building_ _______ permit has been issued and actual construction begun as per 240-8.5.1. I hereby certify the above to be a full,true and correct copy of a resolution duly adopted by the Zoning Board of Appeals of the City of Saratoga Springs on the date above mentioned,five members of the Board being present. S��NATUrtE: 09/17/2019 C R DATE RECEIVED BY ACCOUNTS DEPT. Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Front elevation of Principal building as viewed facing North from Church St. -----_ --- ' �' �-� Y '„� *���----- -- � �4 f��4 �y�g'yq, Ti�'� ....._'M1F ..^ �. �p'�''^ � .••�,.. ��'a 9'^ - '"�,� �1y ,4 .4 � . � � ��?.."'"k�4n�. .p�1'IL� 'a A. ti''� ' � ' ' I '�'<."rl ° n ., � � .m.�w.� . '�+' z�. �:� � ",s�y�, � .:.y �.� ,,. . '�'�, . . � . � � �� "�I,��'�„' u ..� � �. r I'= .�"' .. �,��y � � �, .,�-"`�x � �: �- ... ....._,.� .� .. w, ���.r^°*g X k • ' , .� ,r�,._'---.+ _, �-. � �. �., .4„_ , � , y� . . �} �'�; �K — .. x", . �.� _. �, �"� ':�� �1� � td , �'�� . .,.. s ,k„ �+H��.�.� . � i � . � q ba'� r , �y��._ , „' ., : ; . ` r � �a,� .wyrc,a.� I � . '�" a: `x'rtw�".; ��H {,,�� �u.�' ~ . �.: . .� _ � y�� . � . � f .'. .. . � .... . �� . .,.._ �' "7�:��"'"�r"' "5 , . r s� 1.:. t . . a - , � _ r T. f 9fr.�`�j� 9t v ,al� {r" •4�l, �. , : _ ^: �.. ' � � �..r_. ^ .,r >. p.,. ,� . . .,� �i�•ti��: � s` � .. _ '"""'�7., ��`�� .., an�;�a• '41 S. �h�'-� : ���� �'� �"�.�. y' yX _� �..,.. . . �. , .. p� �,�. ., . � � tiT�4 �� � "� � �, ; ���. �� �I � 'r! �"' .� s µ w,r �, ti ���� ����, ��� �� �,������,`, �; , � ,�;� �, � � �. _;� , `'� "` ��..� � ;, �pi� �,a ,. �' h (. � ^� � N' :��' �n�. �° t � &� t� a �a $ j , � ��t" ,y� ��"�r,q.�-�?�^.�u�-� � �y � &�"iv°4 ��� � �/�" � �. r d'+ �� � �� �,. tt�. ar.+.s. . .. �. .. .-. ,,.-r�y.,+e.r„�-..- . �� ,�. ,. ..a:�., „ Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Left/West elevation of Principal building as viewed facing North East from Church St . .. . ��. .> ,�. ..�.��..- - �._. � � ��� � ,��,, �.r�, ..�� �,� � ,�� , , '�` -1� '�• '�; '� ., a � y� f�,. , „�, �b �, �� *� , � y�r-'�" ..,�a aC�' u �, �� � f�` � �� ��^ �. '�� �, �, �,�� � y , ��� . � a „.. .�. ., .,� r . .. ,ia,, ...,�.._ � �. � . � . �.�� u.. ' '�, « .i: a.`: �w � �'�?�% ��R�U' . ..,. �, _�,..--� • ,,� 1 6, y,.w^ ` � ' �� , �, � . .. �,r � � a � "' . y� 9... x: "M�'F ""'.`-',,,,....+""`-" . " � .. +� * : .,v. .,, r . �. ,�� ��{�• _ � .- _ YIIYYr�.__. . a,��t. ,� _ _. '"'.��ylr�� M C, . �.._..�. � ',� � q , , ��� ..._. e-e� � . � _. • � .... . . "y�^^"' . .. . ' . ` ,... �tr+.,...�„T..�� . . � .,r.. - . .� . :. � ,„- . ... .�"._- ,y.. �I � �'�:x �,,.�1� . . '1 �' �..... . _� � � ��� ''` � � ,, _ ' .. _... �M/�` i[,.�� A .. � �y,,. ' .. . .. . ,*" "µ�""y� ..- .. . �.�. rv., ... . ��µ�,�w,,,�,,.w�n•c �'�. , ..�,.K+..« . .,.. ����„�^ .� „.....-�..^'- . � ..,.�,.��....��+-� �"? ��. � w . ...�. . '.-..'^ �..,,a- 6 . ., ' . ,..�.�. .. .._.,�..'✓' _.. �., y , _ .µ� �. r--'^..R.e�-" .,�,,,,,,,,.._...... .. .;.�M a. Y+.'�, .� .,�,�„'.'y„. ,..�.- �^ '; . �.�,„-..�."..`...�� . � y S„ -- � . s -��� . 4 .. ..,�, ' .. . � ..,.. . G ....*...'""""�' :v �� p. ."." � � .. � '� ' ^ ww^�'"'.."".` l� , ....... .. _; . , o- . . .... .,: `*�. , „ � �. . ...-. �.,P-,.^_"'^""' a s.°S�+ "i �� "-`b,. . . .,.^'"""`' � . .. , .�.y. �'� � ... -...-w.e,.,..�-,..�^^" . .. �y .. � � .y . ���...:� `.� .. . . � �.. . :_ �.�_ .:e. .:. y. q �.�+ �+( ,. .. �� ,..�.. s� �.. ,.. � -�„ .. ` ._,.�.�-�_---. .�.. , � � �.. �, �, _ � _ : ` � y, '�_�..� N �.. 4 * _ _ �� -e,�rA� �,�,.� .:'.. w `. .�.._�._ �__:,.�...:. �.�y f _-.MF . � � .�r.`.,"��,u ,a'# .m_. ,�` � ; �. ..'��,"�:-. � _ ,...,..� � — y M � .. ��,,, � ,F� ��� , �, ,. A,,, � ___ _ — a, � , , �' � ��„"" ._ t . w.: . � � , �� � � � t : � , � � ��._ �_ ��r� �� � �• ��.�" � , ,�, . .,. . �'wy,� k,-.....�.�._ ro� - .. ... .... � _....-.,.�, .a I M �.�„���.� � �_ _ ^ , .� „ +;ti; � , - " .�IPAr4� • . ° � ._- � " � . „ � �,. ,. `a'� � �� i z:. � .a�� �a�'��rw��'� R t . y� - q �t� a "•a��� �»,.� �. - ��., , .� �'�,a�:`��,+" „� '+[Y �.. . � r .+ a. � n � * q�� Y^T �u � A� � 4 . . e .- ' � .� ��" M � . i" -,�e��'i �.t ' .."n. . .., `�`'r . �� .� .� �"�v. � .�,. ...� ' � Byrne—AD,4 Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Left/West elevation of Principal building as viewed facing South East from Parking lot _ ____ _ _ ��� � # � � �� �„� � ��* � ` �"��-�-� �� ��y "..� k --k ke„ -"�� � �,r _ . . � � l�:� •.�:- . . �� . ' �� sF"� �, R � 4 : W 2�.Y �;y�... u� �t � .���'�u, ���/"h � '�,g Y"t��° �� ��.� p" C,� , .. � �•# �d` "4. ' �� . . p�. � ,., � �, a .. .� . � �, .- • • f � . �� „. � �:. :., . r ,.��,,, �. , .' .. �.. . ��� ... „r,,... � ' . `� .l ` 'x.° "` .." ' - I ., . � N' ,- ,,, ... _�N° :;. �.: „� � a,` '�. . ' + y w' f a ......_, , _ .��K'.1'.� it�.W.h,��� ('1'i E.� d � «i � `'�,w{ ; •. iY . . v.� ��� { ._ ' I�t�..� { ... U . ' ��� �.rl �t$ a ...r. - • �� • � � k� �� :: � » « �Y ..fi� '� �.. I � �y � �1�7 I r� d 9 r�.,a uX "t .� 5 .. � . I S' , }A ��,� � �41 �� �i��4p.k�.i�l+��l�i1�,�1 S rw� f ' : ,. k , ` �"'' � � I � � i d+ii�i�,��4 W� U'��.��� ���� 4 = �� f ���� '�I� II II�� "�� ' � �� . pp¢ � M h.��3 I '�,I�,C��� I � r, � � f � � � Z��yp�7,+I � �I ��J� � I. y +rt ,%�'A; �� `^' ���'17� � �i�� �I y�x���'v a�I � . �� � x '' {: :,,+ ���' <Ga. . . . ,e�< k:: w r�", t� �i� ! ��_v � *.e,� ' ; ; � � �,��, _.�: *���» .� -.. ...,, . ,e �'a � . - *�r�.. -�•--'-"'-•� .,�,w'� - R .�"4' �� �.. �����"� �'.�"'���" � ���s� ,, � ,.. �� . ��4 i ` �',t.�.�'� :�'�"�Y':�"�'�+" . . .,.. , .�.,.. i �..�n��.�� ._ . � �� � � ���� h�� 4 �A �� -� �'� m�4 ,y„ �„� rw.� �.� „r�"�i'++4`�� 9` , w�e ` "N` 5"��;��t 'a,5"'� -t.'��''�Ai� ,�. ��;'b i��r � r .�......_:_._- _____ - �.�..�... '� ,� � :":`.x a".ir„�:���^�'�. �`t ��� �h.s. � --�= �. -�—` 4U+ �q ' � Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Project site and adjacent lot to West as viewed facing North from Church St. �:::':° �� F"��r' � � '��� � , �� �r�r. ' ,. � ,�� � , �' �r �:� ` - �'���•r' ; ! ``�:y ,� * ��F. ` - ��• ,�' , � x" . � � .�. , t ,. „ � . -� t�� , r� m � ��� � • �e y� � �` i A», ��y } ��"� �3.� �J' �"!� � � • 1 $ xr,. .1� . +"� ..`'i .�,F. . -, � 1 , ��� q � . ` v s�, ,�^W �.� g1 t��uS 4 . .Y �S- F . � • A^ ..' � . '��Y »�y� .,yM� .i��� '� �� . . w � y, . ��'� .a� a�� d-" � � �a.A" �.'� x� � �r�"�:+� p�" �, � ' � r 4'^� � ���x .�., wS'^ S �¢�rt�...' ... .. A� �Y°v ..Y. *6RlE'.: bi. ,.- , ._ �"' ..:�+. ��� ..� .`G,,"'�-..'G: . ., . .m'.'-�:. .,... � � .. .. _�,o-.m-"".." -' . , .. . ,Fz.. » . , �� .._�-»- . '.�� � ,a.. . ,b,. �k � '.�' �_ �,,....Pr-.-�u,F�� I � ... � . � kwK, ..�w,-. � 'M��., y, ,wb.�a_. . _ . .wxr '�..,, s+,. _. . "� f� _.m � -' � wi.w.�d,. � ' Ta-'�, �,� .. . w. n�. . -�m J �.,..,r ,� ._.. .. ,. .,g. . . . � .. �,:� '� ... , . , V - .. i . .. •.� . Y. � �'fw• . ^ , � . e� . + . . . . '� . ..p,,,6 , �. . . . . . ...'. � .. . ; .. '" - -' , p . . ^�.i a. . ::'�i.: 2'a .. ..� :1�t"."�:'��^.•.. ' ' � " !{ . � . .— y � ' .. ___ . �_ .a _ __ ._ �_. . _i— � , Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - North Elevation of Principal Structure as viewed facing South from parking lot ; --�- . �, Y �.-;,— - � a a ��� � w ,- t t�� - z�����T ��� �' r��� �'�•,4,�, � .� �' ,�+� f a,a." .. � -.tl � „*`f'� � �� A'���"*w , , ,. ,y 'n° 2T ��s� +^ �� * f'r,� fi '�"'�� „ � '�'Y"'h. +, l'' �` :�,� �" �� '��+: '�� '.�. '�'� ' �,� '�'� � �" � �'' � �. «--' b" 'S �_�.��� �'Y .g, . . � [„.a. . . � o� ..d" ,�r 4� . .� -� yt:4 '�^.� ^ � �„� �� ���n�''C�uo-...�^".°'..ww ,-. _.�... ._ .,. .. � y ',. �; �' � � y ��.1 � .;�. � � i{:: �ti �w'' q �.A z �. . . �kt �,. � � ��. �� �� � . . � y : K � k.1 x � ��. , � { �� � ��✓. .:4t'Y� �, ����n �� �:'''! � ��� � A N ��Y\ ��.�. L..,.�N s� �� � � � '�p� �'. ��r?'u� �,- � � �� va �' ^.�'�. r . � ��x���� � ����� � i ���,��5��,� 3T :�: �`�. 'u e�W��S �`��� �'�v'�"d m��:i" �je'Mn. $t` �'��� a1 '>V . �1 4 ��y�' l fy� v-iI"" �.. ' , t .. c� � �i. ��� /� .-e M �' a � ,..j `ka aki:-^� � ��`�Y ��� � ~,.�1J .�;•5t ��` � A�. .`. ��1�. � �Ft , _ � �.. ;;a� � � ? `� �t :. 1'�°} ..r �+ :s• a " e -d'�s�" ��5.�.,'""L � t � �y,, •'2�.'�'v � .p� � � e� � .:$,p", p�� p. '„�. .-�}1 ��"�� � �� +" -...:'�"Y'� �.+'` �".r i=� ,�... ,�:. .�+�. r '. ,,� try,�r;� .m -✓ . ' e., . � sl. .. � 'oR", � '^�' �c �". ..P.?�`✓'� $a. �.;; .� ' °°au'a..-,•+ �R� .� � ?.� �,,.K rR ^�'� '�M`,e�' � �iv�'�.�`�' . " � *f� � '." �"t- -p � « � "i e*y� ���z r�r�;�Y .t,;� � .f-E , Y�., , � � � . �,!,,..G '#��;�,�," � a�.^�,'� * '`', '_ �'�s�°ia��i:�='��.. �<r t�� ._�'5�.�_Js� Y �_� }_ __ ---..�3�..,_.:�_ � _ 1.�_ _� _..��._ � — � � Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Property directly adjacent to the Right/ East as viewed facing North East from Church St. �• a •t.: xa �,��. — ..y �,n'r'��—y.�,a,.-- _.x,,, ��""`�S, — _ �, .- �� c ��' �, 4�,�a r t ` . r� �'�,� t :'" �y 1�'�� ,, < ` � � , .,, �.. � � .t r ..�� . _ �:h r. ��'*� -�F+� ,r f����y "�,..� �'F°.r r " � ` ��. '"y . . L{°�r .r'� I r ,y+st'-3,�'� ..I�. ,�r � . ._ ." . ,� � .!r,. �..ri S�,^` ,��J"���''"d .,:fr�+ .. ' . . _.. °r ' �� ,,,:;c�.v' ��`" � 7�" � ��%� � '" � �� i � :�` ,3 ,+�- y, _, ,��,�,V �r ;` � ..'+'"y.���ik �,,. '�� ,. �' ^r, f" � ��� �=� '�:.,���y ��tii .t' „Rw ��,�; , t � „� ; . ,�_ ° ti� ��i,: , � . .,Y # �^,�e+�e� t4{9 � �� ' .-y.F. - :, s��.� _`'. �' � rlr.• ... - . .. �t' w• « $ .. . �� <M ;,p� ti�"-.�" , ,L� •, .._. ._.. •9�ky�N v„�++�.., f�`...y,� . • Y+` y ,4 + `� ��, `.S e F • < ' �`$ . � , ` ''3,a'� ��l0 �'i J�S�! F n , . ry' � �: � ri^ � ,tr „gR..� } �'��.7�`,,w� ^"^."�r„w .. . �,�' � � ` � � "_�` .'�' rF"� "} ,� r,� . .,x �, � �. � � �'; � ;�• � . M3 a. �q,.u�� � ,a,t ,,.,. �.i�„- �k' � w*n .. .. , ,, s . a �. a3'��L �� .�',.. ��ca� ��K„�.^?��� �n `s�;� ��-�, "� � � � �* �-, �. � i," � � �✓:.u� — . , _. . , .r f �_ , �.. ;, m" ��^ !f �,�,,. ...- .',w� ;..:,�w� ��Y .. „ ., ,.� � II �y i Q � 2.'� '�3' �a F�'���.'�,�'��P � ��+.,� �I I �. II tu{s E��o'i��� J�.�� I �r �� � r 1w � 1� '�I .._ � "�s " �� � �� � , ,. ..,. , , , � �. �� ° � £.;: .� � � � �- u��� I� i .� �. �� R. � �= a. _:� � �. � ;:—� . �� y, � �. p y�,,i P 4�y G':'�3-S., m II L .,�.. � � ¢�, � �m E ��„ � ' ,M �� ^ I� � �. . � � �a + '�l �� ..y".5 "�'' ��k 'k, �N.... � . w�w" k` Y ''1,.a# +�2♦� �,�t �l S!C.�.. � �+'� �rt.Po' �ry 0.�k A-�� �. w , ` �W v» t 'g 1��,.'°'�' • ',a� `;� `' `:a�.` �k ,� �.� d,�.n r�a��a,<.. ��,�. �, �; r& �� �`� °'� � . r� �fa�` - � �,.� �gM,, k ����� �����,����S��I�� al . .:,..k � 3 r x"�{k�a,'1' � � �..�� � ' " x"k�'� ��r� �I>a�y�t^�:W"Yw'�J,,}4��"�lr7�7��IGI��Y����I��'+1V���,' .. F .^�"r.� '�. - a�"' 7 t I ,t"'�p,� r�fw�a°¢� �il,�� �I��, ��y`�� �'1 � �s<V �°� ;,�. �mv� �t6h� ��';u . d :;�` .. !`����� ��. +,�� u�l , . � ' y ' - .. . .«. . ..R. x . •' . ..--.. ,_.. "* ' �,Yr�-r,r.. .«_. F � � _ .. . ; �_ �....r„ � ^ . � �__- a.-[�• _ �... —. '_ -— _n,.,:.a��___. . :_ - � Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Property directly adjacent to the South East as viewed facing South East across Church St. , ` ��;' � � � . —_— i ��.. ' -''�i ` :�" _�^,� y�, ,�° �:. `�.� _ �` � � n � t..,� ;x - - ,, ,.,, �, ' � �', ,� � �._.�.d b �, �. �. � .i �` ��,b$ �' y �� • i i Lk?!`";� .s, ,,,�- µ!., h� '� �', 4�ti . Yv r' ...�..� ���.; F�w� .�1 �'�+�� 7�'� { ' y��i �r �_� �-, � ,'�; :� �:�v - y..1+� +�• � M,p. . 1��i ` � ��.:��' � r� 1 � '#�."'�'Y""4.�. } }�'' � 3� �i � $ �' �F'X�' .�" �S J�� ��'' �,,,y �v � � ,-d` V�i' � .k ,�,@r . . �kF $ y s'�`::... F ,/ n . , ; r � " . . I . . � ' y�� t^ � �� +,�� ��� F."p"# � '' +�t., .�i, M �p4;;x* a` �� . � � �: � � � ����� � ��. ��,..: � �. � � � � � ,�� ��� � 7 ,, � ,„ � r�cr� ��� '�� � � � �„� ��� :r m �`,�i ,� + ,*� w ` �t.;� 5: }. f ��f . �4. M � i�2$�f��eM.u� � a: '� �`��` f*� � �,. :�� �' �j �; �,�.: ���, � ����t�� f � ��� � " ( �� � �.; . � �:.� . . �:; . . i�l.le�w�..._ '� w � ,R4 �- ���..`� �.., ' ����r '°� .s,„ a � `=�� �;� ., . ,, ." �� „,�,,,� ` � - �,,,,.�. -�` w. : .,� � _�. .. �'«w�:.. "�n �t" � � °*+e;:c.,. � 7�- ,kn-��:.c ., .. �, B`�,'`�` * � p'�.� s gwa^'^^�, ,�,,.. �,"'.� ,�eL:�^�. ',�... ''x` +c . � - ' '� ' ,,,,,,,.„. ��Y �, m , �� �� � k� �,�a� ..a.. . ;at+ ,�;p� r,. -m ` 7..-- ,... »,�a�uw� ��, � :x.� '�"" w. w. � ,.� .� �-� .� .a rr> . . __ ..y,� �.e . aa . , . ,.. .. , ., _. ��. .,r �� � �_ o ,� � � _n• .,s � . �x � _. <�.�� ._._�.__._.___�...., .. ' «��+� V.�- Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Property directly adjacent to the South as viewed facing South across Church St. t,. _ ..� . r�� �,�q � fi� � ������� ,-?h. ����'ar�'' ,�„,.�- e j;*�+ ` a >. .'pk,' .• �. rC. �' 1� F "��t� *�;�. .,ba���' +� b�.�. 4' ��.., y�.4�.,��r y �,i� �� � � .���: R r;...... ...�;.i.:- ,ae.b`o:+ ,t.,.� '�g ' we ...�' n:o'SS ��r' � .,y,��t +..�s '.. . , � r w �^. '�f �`;: �" . , i , i � s . . ' ��` ' .:, ;�`a� ��.. ���.. ..�e. � �.;� ����.,�.1 �, ._, ry_ � ;� � �� r IP�V� � � � , r � .� - . ... . '�� . „ x� r ' .� � °� '"� � �� T „y '"''„,�' 1,2�.+.'3k �S �{:` ���'"�'f� �''^a. ��� �:.t ,",�. � Y,*t r` ..y�'. .r ' . � 7�..a��. � . ,iiT �-• , ", � '.sP r���;;• ..� � g ' '• ... ..�' .. �+ �yl' i , ' $ _ > � � � � „ �..h;. _ ����� '. .. �� '�' ����5. � m � _ . , .. . , . _ _ ...�....�._.�,....�,. ._ �._._ �; � n� , , , � � , �� � . . . � � ��� � �.� � � �; :� 4 ,�-, ��- � w:�,... ���.��w�... � ��'� �.�..:rx� ���'�� � � ,��r ,,�^��' - x � � �- �::-a...— - wauw�iaaa ���� ���m�� �� . � Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Property directly adjacent to the South West as viewed facing South West across Church St. �. __ __._ __ , __ -- --___ , � :-. _ __— - _ _ _ _ ----___ ___--, ,s i''� i i + ; �, � G r � y, /'��� . � tj ..� �� �„ ;�� � �,�...,.-.»..�'""' � � �, Yt ,�,������ � ,. � . . . �' „ � �,. 'y" " ;a, " � M�.�� t "� � �.. � ,. _ , �. � �. .� �.. . s . � _ �" ,� � :;�r.a�.�,�z4�. .. ,"`� y� � y :4.,.;...�..._,r .__..-. m4.c �� � ` . L . '4"��f �` �� y �;��� � b ,:� ,� ,:��` , ,� �'��� ,4 �� ; � e ; � �", � 'a � .�. �.� �.� _�_ , � �;., ��: � � � � � �°' � � .;.,.._.,_�'i � �: k :�� ` ,=;��� �,r �" ��� �. » ��� ��w _ ��� .._ , F �,�,. :::^ ..�.__ , .t � ... (� �c' �._. _ � "�'�� X ��� ; � Y I � . _ , ; . �. x , � .tiw� � � r.. '.,.�:.^�° P ,�.,.._.�.... _ ,__...:....-.,� � _._ _ ,: � ::,,. � ._ �.,�.,.__.. � � '� ! w, I �'� � �'� �= ' .. i IVIV .R , ��: �� � �� ��,;,� , � � �ti.: � � �.- ..- � �... �� f .;- t: 7 �"�-:�k:.,� ''� b � � � , . ��,* �i �-v-'"--� F��,� ,��p���� �f►����. � - ' dL �. - , , _ � . , .—. _._____ ... wy , ,; +: � ._ � �'x" ' . . «.,� � ���, �f,� �� �. e . .��. ��' - k --- : �N. � s y� ._,. ' h .s� � � , �� µ ._. - w„ �:��^ � � �Y>iu' 4 . '�u..u;�. m � .. .... . ..:._. ' . ";*a',F:f':Y�' �,.,_._ . '. ".. " _,.�.. ..... ... . . �y ___ M�ca. .1'+MMM�r.-�"' �-� . . .. ,„,�:�,,a� ..�,� ...., , • � . . _ .., � . . �� A.._�. � • -- _. . �� ,_,. I �. .,� _ _ e ,. �, . ._ �.,: ; � . .�..—_, _ - ,„,. � f- „,,. �� � � , ., ; � -:.�� _.a w , -��,rau^,�w^:�''"' �� �� . . , �� �a .„ ;< ` • Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Property directly adjacent to the West as viewed facing West from project site parking lot � ;��; � W` � � �, �� k ��y� � �� �� l` �„� �,� � �� � . :s r�, '. �- �',� � � I� � , .. ,�, '�A` 4,-,r � � �+� . � d. -� r� ,.� , , �; .��, -n " '�°^"(-^' 1` d��'+� f � � �y �, yi`' �"��"�y, s�, da^�: �, y� ,x .� �'� �� `♦ r*¢ �`✓-, ,�wv' ��\ . . .... ..�.-... ; 'r�,a,"�. �ItJ' �" y�a... k�:r � . �. � '�'� P g�. #�' � jt J^ ��• h ��� ,$ m�� �i f,��'_cr.w��'� �:���� , , "� . yf,'� '� s s µ•�� ` AJ r Y . �? ��" r f�'4 * ..��. .` �, ^ i 7a �* �R '2C`' �• '%,� „H� � p 'aF .,,�° � '�1 ^' , 6"k �' � ��� �� 4 !` R� � ,�'j�, .�.�'M �� �„ ..N�� y � .i � {,� ',? �� �b� .� , y.:.�_ � � .�y�' •^c� '�'� � ` . pry � h,,�y! d: * �-,•NJ�_ � �� ,� ,�li �- =,I� �� i�, I ":b.� F. � I '"�� �yy1� �iAflle���$.� • "~ '�"� � � Y4�� ..�'U� 9A� �� � �, , ' ;�� -`M � f � �1 r n � �p t�. #„}y ' � G�, t�':;. ��; i '`+j � � "� � �. . •� . � :§ � � r�µ�� ,�, .,; M°{ �^ �-_M�� C,y � ♦. , ..� .,. � ' r= : ,� R ,�� . ,�, .. � � . .. `.,p�,-. . T.... .' . �a; �.y: . , a'����� ' � ;,.l�, „q�.. °'I,. �r�'� ��• •�^,`.n- �t '11.�3� {. �,. '-. ' 1.� _ �1 �'~l .l:: r h� .. . �.. .�. , . , i �'�s`M!�`_. .. ,,; ...�., _ - �� .. __ � .. - ` .. a _ _,..� " . . ., + - ._ ' ..... . . . . ., 5�'�''_, � � .: :.. . � .. �_-...+us �.... .+.+,5.w�1..- :`}:':i .... . _, ... 9�i `�ia'W�..yWL.r.Y+d:.a• .. ( .. . �rtw.�r+b'� �'�{°`t�7"`�'+"�'b" ,.,,� ,.� �xr� '��� ...r..� +��.+.— ,�....... � �..nr��� � .rc.�..,u- ... ....: .P., .' '.a °. (ww..�........,,.....�........_ ,....... .......� .,,....rruw..,.....«. " ..wuu........+..�� . ._ .. ___,.-...nN.......�., � � • Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Property directly adjacent to the West as viewed facing West from project site parking lot � "4 �_: ., . ., � � ��` ., � � � � � i ���4 �"�µ �� i ~� ,�,. � �K���r�r, j py�`�����'�,y���"Ji,�..•. {��','�a�.� �< . .. . I ✓ ,;�±,°�` '%��rF',�,', k �,i �". 1j x,;i Z ; b ���3. . � ... �� � p pyy �.. � � .i �..e • ��Y� s. r �S�,�d! ., . x q _�*^Fro {� �� r.. � �� .F�� , n �� �� F ��� � � .. b . K . �T ' . � � 9 T'� �Y �d�� £ '�1 M 1< . � ^ � k ffS. s�.a� ''�w�, " � �,y`:, „�, . A , , �s ;t' �#,, � `��-le�� � u�;,�� .N� � _ ��' , . � �� �: . ��. , �� . .� . �;+w�''�, � � ��� � --� �.. . • « , �,.� _ ':' *,'` •�. .. a.: z '� ,�a • , �, ., . �, . , e . ... r .e.- a�M� � _. _ . r . � . ., . � �., A_.. . . ''� � �,r^"',*' . , .. ; , — �r . £a , � .- ��,.� +�;� - . • � . � ,: �.� . . . , - ,. ,.. � . �- . . ,. t.'! ,fi. _;�"�. R •y+., M� `� : ,�'` . .. � ��:k . .b^- . L�+`w weM�{^' . p� T . r ,.'��l� ,� � . �'�n. . . " . _._ � .�„���-�;;:'�..�,.:.�...���,. .. r ������ :- . . _ =� ow�r'_ :..��:�.. .� � �. �.w�,„„-�,�...,,,�-y«..���. � ...w . ., , "".�,,,,,,,k...,_ ,: �-- _ __.. _ _-- _— w..�_� � � Byrne—ADA Compliant Ramp Addition #203 Church St., Saratoga Springs, NY - Existing on site garage and adjacent property to the North of project site as viewed facing North from proposed ramp � � „� ''� �`4� � � ,���� � ,.., � ► � �` �> � � � � " -�. `���� � �I � � w4 u�� i rf"'.� ,� ,.;. � M�k � ? ' .�, ...+� ( , ',. II i�� �I �. y f \'y� �f«rP'• .� 4 1.. b � �• : j "✓ � ' t. � � ���` i ,'y: �r... *o., . ��_. 4 . - -- � �.�r.. , . .. I. .:. ?v .. . .- _. �. y 'r _ .� �.;. � �-m ,., . ., . � ' .. ;.;,rt .. �t�M� _ �,r C''��"'!S �M h�,�,� ;�,� � _ `�, �� iu ;� �..... � � 5� a¢ � � . .+4 �� .. '�,� +RU� ' :�� � � . . .. _. �- . ,.,J .__.____ �a,.` .. '�i�"^ ydtr� , ���. � . ' :. � r ��ry� - . �5� � � �' , R ts-.:'.." - - . d y ��«;�'�� � ��� �.., ,,'. � ::" ,�,, „ � � ,.. , �. ��,�, � f `a�j� 4 'y �y� ��� �A�r M bF 4'"R Y w��,� �• • , ��^. � '"T=�+ H.f" �i, V . � ...x ' ¢� �� ��Y��� � . . �'�: � � 9k � . ,� „ � r;��.. ,. _ .��. .��� ,_ _ �, ` w,} � o, I � •� ' �j n�. _ � �►�,�F > +� S.Y ��+�;a^'p ^fi`.,}i..��. �`t -`se �, ,+u,` .,�,'� �u;t y�' �� �,.. �.����Y_�� • �T d . } . 203 Cl�urch St. � New roofing material South Elevation �o c�ie Maps Chimney to be Removed - ,�.. ��. , �r�,.�� ' �,.�;,�,� ��a New copper .,�.. ��, �r v �;�,J , snow slides ;: f � _ , :, _ ti� : 1� -� �' f � � �� ,;� �,A�uminu n s.�:,�,,�, t �titi,��c��, �� �<< ,`--��- � �r � ����df'`sd���� � , _ � � ,�. ; removed and .;�,� .,�.�, i �-�-f.� ti: �,r� . ' _ ����,�,� � .� � 'existing wood �`,��;�;�� �,� � �^�..=_---�_-.^ I. ��� c� Y�� �`�siding repaired � � :' New ADA ramp to - : - - � � , � . .- .�„� ; , �� �. access front �crch � '`' � �t - '� ;`,-�- .-� . � � � E � ,�, ; ;�'��`-- ��`• "` G' F" � i iE � � �� � , ., _ � �* .._ t �-'s"HS���,�.°i`��. ���• I = � ._.�.� �~ : il �s '7 ir�= t- �^� �. _ _.�, '* � �� 'C . - - �'`; '` �� ..�� r - .., �'"4�`, . , � ".� ..�.� 4 � t ::x�c iµ. "�4,�,,;yr Xn.�� t� `' rt.� " .� '� �' ,.5 .cW �,�- r .. P ` e „�.; ��, .w�.� ..�_ �.n+�S . �� ~ .. ��� � .. ,4.. ��F ' Y -.: _ ` . F- - 4 '�.r: ' -- . • ., ... 'a-.. itStttgl! I x�. � �} �`J+'..:, ' -" ,-, � � � � � M�., _:� �� � - �-` i J�_. , , �'.a �t'+�� � _ ���i s Y y� %'t��� ` � h�� � � ��� �x� �{ ��t�... ' l�il � 1 � �ItA�. I li I'�i�� I��I�Si'�ir��. _,�`�_'� ,� IC I I �i °( I - �. g � E4��ia .; �, � rY - I i `--- "" � Ili i � � � n a„ �t �b�° -,,, - . ' �� : ,. . - � x .l. 4 ��� � a ,Ai `� ^i. qr � , ,��a. 3�4'.; „ ..m � _ . � � . , � � - - a t t*. �� � ��� - - s...- . :�. r-.-,, . ,. . . � u � • i - _ -..-.. � �� ..., . � �b. � �.�� � �..�� � �� _ «�,�� p � x . - �;�,. ., . - ,._ � �. ,� � . � . ,�. : - � �, ., _: . . ,.�. r .� � ����. �..: , - � - - -- -- -- _ ___.__� v._ � Image capture:Jul 2019 n 2020 Google SaratogaSprings,NewYork Replace door with New copper roofing � coogie new wood window to match adjacent StreetView windows in bay LVJ Llll. __ _ .._ '•,.I-�-��---9N"... —. . _. ..._._. � _ � N , Chimney to be New roofing 203 Church St. removed materials �'� ��� �ps New copper snow slides to replace tin `� � - � `-.� " ` r snow slides 1 'f � '� � .,��,�`_ r z� ^� � 1 �''�' "`'"�z��,� �-a�.*� x y� 4h��= � , � � � a ',-�`,!,( x T-.'��.� '���° . �y .�. � �.�+` �r /f v� - i�. ,. . � ti � , q � � ' y .h.r � � r ��` y����y. ..n..* _' , `.,�1 k � ' � � -� 4R. � Y i� � 4t�` � i 7' � � ���'.4y;, � "".`�1 . �� �� „ , �e �, .: .,: 'f � �'� 1 � ,*,�,y d's .� .�_ - .� `i .,.Y 3 ;�f •d Y��� . 4. '.. �^ :t 1 � `,ry� -2y '.i, � h� :- � ' h� � .' � , p. :-. : �g �, �, `` •� �•a� ;�. � r `�ys � ,`� ;i `L ' __''""-�-- ' °���i�,� ' i"�� . . � � �',i� F::._-------j. _� - �, R� � ���:4 .�.. , . _.f y �.,;� >�:��„-.�,».r--... °="""'""r-^^"'�#""'.��.aS�. .._.i;, ��;. ��, �" ' d; r � ` +` � ,��. '*r < • _. . � ,�-�..c,.. ��r�.'.� .�.i �� s ,�m s - ..t�,r-^e .,,�: ' 1` . �..� : � �t��;.r �lt�. ��'3. : = , � ��. ., '_.. �'.� C . ' - - � ;: ^� �� �,.�. 4 ` .., ::. ... �Y:,.� , �.:, . �,y J. �_ A ' .` ; } I I� h � � y i S�' � �G �l '�.� � - �' + Y i };. �. � � ..' ` ,� M s ��� �,i � � ' � F� , y�,�.,,,� c�_ �� , ,r ��� �• ; �= :� - Y - - 'y; �", !y �; ��. � ; ,< -- - � ;;, - - , - � ��. . -- �'�:�;�' .='� �` , „_,. � : -- � • ; _ a _ __„ . m ;... w . , _ _ "e`�,:.,,,�"',�P_..._ x-�. � i. _.�. _, � ' . -�.._ , .��:: . _i � . _� a .. �. G� ` , . f o00 .. � ... ' � ` _ �.. . - y f. �: �__ � __. , :� � . ., ..,, �� , .;,� . . . �""�",�.. '.,.. - ..�.,._ . ,� _�� ��.`. � —�ui�r �-- � .� . � _,- .! � ��_ _-----�_. , —_. � =— ��._.Y...�..:__._�� . • __�------_. Image capture:Jul 2019 O 2020 Google Saratoga Springs,New York New ADA ramp to be installed �. Google Street View v Q r w� --_. .... .. ..... .—-`, ` Z � -< _ Y ___ _ _ . . . . p�OAp. O ':9�a. ' ?,.� .�. Chimney to be removed + :P ` � � New roofin mat��'. ' ': : � 1 (��`` , ,�: : g ,� ;� � �� �.�,v copper snow � � �, � �,� , �_� � � s entire _� � ,i c�� - � �- , ��es ; � �f .-,� .-::., � ��� "_�' ,�,�, ;� �� � - s, _ J_ y�� 7� ' �.-.+^ +"S'� ��.J - p �y��"f ,`, � _. Y"F ' �d' '�Ta, " �. --.::,- ' _ � � ` � - J t , � {^ � . � �•`ps �"` � ': � �'�� . . I �� ' � . ,�"n �. '� �e. � .. .?� � ..... ..,. �, .....+�� fi,'.y-�t� ... _.. emovea d�existing ��' ';,x� :-''- ' .,,,�`'�,,,. �,,�, _� � m�� . - �.. ..- nrood siding repairecf .� � ' , "„'��� ' i" ��a - � � ��*'•: � , . � M, , .. ��- �� � � . � �-�- � � .�., i � � tk.r-,. . . , ":} .y A....�. . . � . .. ` � �.: � - ,- ��•._..,.. ,��. y A,_ � �. ���� � a` � �� � ' � �� F� s e.�. � �.f}S `sY�a+'^mCc ..b'tv } �.: ��r- � a . � �0. �- � h' . ��"i � Lf'� � e:i� — �,'� � �"S� ; '..: t � ��.. m. . .-�., . . v + i `: w+� � �a.. ; ,���', .,yd`. y���:.,w. r.. 'n..: � �:.. Ftiy°� "..�.E i � .^ " . �.� e—�-__ -• .. .. . ..- __ .._ �. I . r . y •�� _. .. � ., �� (�ew ADA ramp in this area to access front porch . �.,.,.;, ; � � y �"}*"'.r' r��qY ' :e ��� #4 t��,q�� �'� ,• ., � � , � � : ¢ x�.^�"�i'�`,�'k.�S�a a,9,'� �.$y"'��'Aw s.t�.t'� ��Grs.,.��a '' y 7f�' �,�.�e�' ai�,`'°�`'�24.t���"aV�:r�.„� , a � �a. y '. �,�k; �r� �„�„. n Wrtl: ,q� �dfl �I[,���`r� ���`t � 1 i9 'd�"ktv :� 5 , „� N , . ;_ *, , � �-_. �..��... �� � .,. . � �,k -�.:a.� ..�� .m. • : . . . � .x � , , „ ._._ � ..-� �... . .�-t �r_�._.�,_:..i�.=__..._ .',,. .. . .-�e. . -�., �.^-€-�—...-------^.- ..-^--^ -•^.�,_^ .: Door&Storm door to be removed ` ��, `° �`'°' ' ��� '� ��" � a y� �1- '� �� ,�.,;�"" .,��' ��� and replaced with new wood � ",�,. �_.F � ��-"""'` • �•. �� �^✓indow to match existina window�> � _;' � �.� _ - �•••' i�,�'•`"+`"'"y -r``" �� ,,•s"^'` :--- ,. � _ _ , . �—" _ ,.� �n � �� a �,"'.�� . �� '� , .r�' .:<,��"'"'"i i . ,, # : .. � �; .. � t -„�""��` �,,,�t�s.�"'e� pE`A. �,��J ..;ta TS Ny,���1 '#'�V" K �� '.,y.ya � :;#�# '..: , :t� � �,,. �ar��'� '� 3� ,�.�. ,y� z �y:' x 'W -;v° ' . �}�� �'u� v'���, � t � i @ ; .. � � �' �� '^q y � �' � �,y,r.r�.�a�" ,�' ., � l � , � `".� - � y f� �. �'� �� � ��9 3^ .r:r+*�:< < R �'� l .� �,� �`�``. ���l� � �' � � � .� ,�. '�.q�,E`- .-.. ++ S Yf� ,} � I �� . 1 � �.�ti�+�Y V �M � 1'�,. � I �� • I � �u������1~ F I t � � y- � 4luminum �ic�ing F �._. �' �� � ; ��� { � r i � -emoved &existing � :.� ' � ��'� � �,,�, �I i � "'"'�'� � ��� �vood sidina reu�=���� F -t : �,�. , �,� �j ' � �� � � � � �' � .. _. _ �..,ea.,.:• -- �tl1�`r �- � $ i'� �' ,� r ; y��;,�'� �+e _. ...�. � � . . '{�' i. F ` �, I �,.:� _ ,.-�,. (���j� � ..) � - ;� , x � --�- i '-� � �_ �, ,�,� �, � � �� �� ��� ,�. � � � �'' r:',`.� �; � i + � ,, �..,�� 1 � r 4 - � � �" � � �` _ �� ` -ry �, �� ,'� �� F� a' � � '-" '`. � . �` �s— ��. ��. � �;"r� �• , _ "_ � r . . _ f �_+n.; ��� . '��"`'�-�e=.� �t�� �-�. � -- � .,s,�; '' : . ` I � - - h'�_ i-- �Y �� � �'iOYIG`8_c , �- . �� ' .� 'l''� �� ,' � � metaf raiis to be �; � -' ��' � � } � :�. , , w, � ' �� _ ",,,,�� q .: � ,_ n � �removed �- ' z � . � � � ,� _ ��' _: � „� � s .kl� �� y� y� '"�,�I -_ :�� ��' ,�r+ "� �� ` � ,�� ,�'� , � � ' � , I i ''�� i,r.n. I � `, % � - - - — — � � �''� � — - ,-�,� T� - �" :'� , �. il� -�- --- ,.m' _ w _ `^'. - - _ �y� �� . ��,e - ?r ��M �.,� x ''�".s.-a..— . '��.. �ay 203 Church Sto Legend - � .---� ,� �� � - °,� .. �," � �� �� s"_. ...;ei. ,�.,,�_�.� �Y,�� � ,���; t,+rw�� � -��M��. ' � r-r .' n ❑� ��..�a � M ,� ��� ,., �`�•�t �'�" .r[ �,�, - ,� �,"_- '-- ��.'`�tS�i�S.A�.� ��� '..w'�. � �' . -'�a '� h ` r _ m � �;.:� (• :N��•v+n . r � ' . - Y . , ❑ :; . 3 - y}` ,�,.^' .; :�. ) �` � ��� ..-*..� . � f�fi;;r '� -�""�:a V� --'ak�"� ' �, ,m�`a� .. . . �� r � *- ��, a�' e�s �. � � :�'.;�., � ��l $' y R S =-�-�,, �,;::�-- - �� � ,�„� `� r e�e.b��'`��- ' � ' t�� ~ �� ^'F�' / ��_. . r,; -'�►p� � � . .,.'�,"--. a -� �'� s. ��, c � �� w K' ,;� � �i - ... - r � �` �' . � ��,. _t� "�`� � ��' �w.. � ��. � 4� t... � ... � � $J�� ' � ` � r`� �� � ,� ��.� '� � �� � , � �i��. . � i '1� �u �. � � M � a �,,,�„.��;.(�.����F ��4�1 P��S�F R }�6'�[��E ciFTzr oF sA7R�1o"cn s�`,,�aRi�a�o, c iio��f�'�� ����,... ��Vti' 4 � �� `; , �# : ��,. e t'F4 .� � � �e�. ._ _ ktS-f-� �F�1•'r.t FF�$;:�C-i`i8�f"h�Y i�f_�!6 E� 1 � r o �,r,�..�-. � ' �Y�¢ �C YE� _���-.� ,� , .< . a? Y; ��'"`��1....�- �`T�- iA�'f�. �'� F��=a�s=£�, _� -- _ . - - ' — -�.- ... '`� _.�. .,�� �_ . _. .rv.r h f h 6t�,n.Nt � " � — .._ - ... »V "'k'y .. ' rT mG . rr . .. — ._ - „'�i�.a � - < " 9 � � � � �<�. �a, , _ ..a,x. — -�� «_ x:� � �, ,— „ � ��-� � x �` �t + '� �� ���;, � �� ��_ « i� __ � � ,���� �t, � � ', � �� _ � ��,�;� � � � . �� � � �' �L �� � �'��` �... p� z.� � ���� ��,.� �;,,,« r, . 4 l� ��- =� ���� � ,����;���� �� .; �, � s'� ��"A-'�t� .,y..�.�pnr � r �: t E. � ��._ry� � " � �� � ,�'�� r-° � §.��' � IV'� � p'nr , L �� � � .., . r, ��. �i r'�st�-:�_.ry�'��_`��-�.,��:��,.,� �t+�e."'F'.�- 4� �A� iir:d��. .�c R-'� �y � � � ....:�_,. .._ ' .,, ' v L .4 ...�+ ..d�"' � �.� �. � �'�, -. . �'iscla�:mer:TFis map was�re�areC by tho Saratoga Counry Interne�Geograph�c Inforr�a�'on System(GIS)_The nep �a ompiled usinp the most���rrent C-IS dste ava'ilable_The aenal photography(orthoim,agery)was preparetl by �heeN.V.S.Offce ofCynar Securityend Crltical InirssVucture Coordlnatlon tl�-nng tM1e year 2004-20t1-Parcel and municipal boundar.e:are denvetl lrom tax maps and do no�reprasent e lend s�rvey. .lanuary 99 9019 � ,a� , ,�� � �,'�� � P\ �`;'' i :� �� .—_ _ , �„� e � � � � � a._l � y 1 �� 1 �'.j �' ., .':��—" :�. ���* ' �� �, —�=.... ��'�- , --- _ , , --- — --r a;. �: _r.=-�� '�, _,`� ��< _ �; \ i ;: I � . �� ��_�-- >� _ � - ., .� _,Iti-�` `, �\ _'--�''���"� \ � � � ��� �'��� �.^"--""'' r^ ����+ ti+ . �// �. �� \� ` r� '��� �. �� �,tl`,�i m'r�'-� "'� y q�t, ` . �i� � Li� wl��'� � -�w ..:., r ��. ,�,,,,,,, t. � , `�.^.��'.r-,r \\ ` ,\ �-,T� `y, p �b`.l \`,��r.. . \ ��r....�` - \ ��.� �� f\�' .+.� �:. \ � �• �`�;'';- ' �m R �� i II �.�r� �f�`' �. :�)Y .� i.. / I ��`'"�;; �"" ' � � � �;,•`^� 'j \�; � �e; 4• � `..9� ;:�i � �.. 1� � �, �� �'i�. .,� ��. �! �� .. +.:.�t� ���f� � , �"M,w � e a� A B O U T B O R A L R O O I I N G Boral Roofing LLC is a subsitliary of Boral USA antl is the country's largest premium provitler of comple[e roofing and -oofing solutlons fo�architects as well as commercial and residential builtlers.Boral Rooting operates manufaciuring plan[s[hroughout the US. � A B O U T B O R A L N O R T H A M E R I C A eorel Roofing LLC is subsidiary of Boral USA antl is the country's largest prem m provitler of complete roofing and -oofing solutions for architects as well as commercial antl resitlential builders I Boral Roofing operetes manufacturing planis throughoutthe U.S. ABOUT 80RAL NORTH AMERICA Heatlquarteretl in Roswell,Georgia,Boral Norlh America is a leader in key consvuction materials and builtling products markets wi[h opera[ions across the USA,Canatla,antl Mezico.In 2011 Boral acquired Headwaters Incorporated,expanding Boral's protluc[of(ering"end manufacWring antl tlistribution foolprint across Norih America.In construciion materials,Boral has a national(ootprint�antl industry-leading position in the processing and tlistribution of fly ash-a by-product of coal combustion. In building products,Boral�manufacNres antl supplies cladding,roof tiles,windows,antl o[her Ilght building products for residen�ial and commerciah.markets nationally.Boral's manutacturetl stone veneer inclutles leading brends CulWretl Stone°'by Boral",Boral Versetta Stone",Eldoratlo Stone",Dutch puality Stone"�,antl StoneCratt Industries.Boral's light builtling protlucts portfolio incWaes Boral TruEzterior"�Sitling 8 Trim-a pioneer of the innovative poly-ash catagory of exterior building products-as'well as shutters,gable vents,�mounting blocks,and tool systems.In roofing,Boral is a leatling manufacturer of clay'and conerete roof tiles,antl also protluces composite polymer antl smne-coated metal roof[iles. � , Boral also has a 50%share of the Meritlian Brick loint venWre,a leading clay antl concrete b�ick manufacturer which was formed with Forterra erick in 2076. BoralAmerica.eom � � k ;-I ����fi��' I �� >�E ' � �.�ru'� � ,�, '� R O C�.�I�I`G P�;tt O D�J b 1''S +�t s �'��u��.,`' ,.�,�°;�� .,�� t � eonni. � y� ,:x � � �: ", :�:. �' � �.,, . 1. x. •'a ,.800.6�9•�`��3`�B"oixlRooEcom�� � v ( ...a� '', .�/�l ��.» ���� f� t t � � a �� ; _ , � .. 2. .� _�.., , . �, � ` � � ` I ��� SPIRE� �____ _ ��� � r � ��� � �,G►-�����-� � -- - -- - aBo� ' . .ar �' -wu� �, M'��p, 1 �e � y '�.? ���� k�+�� � ' y� .r g C..a �' I . . �� �� � R4 '' � �t��Y j � 4 ".� � � �z dt�a;h�� '",�;J�w u L� 3 ,� s�� N,�u�",n"�w, ��,, � � �.a�F"a�ty d�;t�.tm'�k`9'�dh s� �'^.�, `-�'is,�s . „ �^ .. . �� +. �s a.pt I p t; r � a� �r', ' ; e , , . ...'. ;3,. . p 'n 8 '� .�c *�y ( `'__ ° � t z p � v t r I ��" � � ! �' s � �� < <:. 1 y� ��;� � .. � ; � �:4 �� . . . . . -. . �4 J� ��� ,-''��`"'�¢.'w. .,�a,s�ssxt y.�r�.���i',na+��!z.wPa'--�zb �,�,�,.�� 3fb'cr:+kYw'� � �M�+�. ', ttl a� k�y. y�� .� . 1 ��'` gi' 'r � '� ��`^",,' ,� *� i"f J y�� i x ��, �` '�. " y "�'se:� t Y.: 1 -�^:' � qf .�,-:�...--y-�"` �,.s 'F`�l�"' 'y': � `,�, . a R'�3 �` ,s�,�°�,*";�`"�`"�� c :�M'�, � 7 � ' � ..,i„e" F .o- �r� x...Vw:�'i2�"8*'�xn_ ���� �" {�u �a ' ,� c I �� � t���n G�, k . �� �,.�r,�#&°��=9.�ti ��;�r,� 3^u��� .Y" Rf kV �.� ��v,':� A y � �,;� t '� �.. � �,� �' �. 1 S ... .—_... _._� .___ ..__.— ._ ;:i��ti. SKU:41 FUE1 190 Ciassic Slate- � ; � www.BoralRoof.com � � �_ � ° � ; � _ , -�� � a �, � �, - � -� i� __ _-- __ ' " � �_ _i�� _ - � - - - �---- � " _� 4 � „ - - _ — g�= 4 T� I — — _ _ — ,� i i,. � � I " i k ..:� — � � � � �� � � . , �, ��� � � �_ � \. �;\ ,'; ' `�.'' �- .;,�?�,.'�.. U -�:w:.�.. � , 4' ,�`� � ��;t�y�",'. . � .. . �,�,�,s�.a l�t�r�' � . [c� �i uzc �v o ii � �c� �� h� � ° `���r�` �'� � � � ����k �s ry� �������'a I� � ,_ . �� M. _, '�, i� .,, ,G, - . . . . .. , � �bv;a�"� _..."' ?, � — � � — — -�>_ _ - �� - r � .i ������� � . I""'p'�'`.,; ^� �' �_ `� - ,,� I — '?�P-, taaaQ.�� �"�T rr+,� ' .. � + �1 �, .. �, � x:i �,,, aFar. ,. ,� � vEaFFcrr�r.u��I:s.nhoe;_ Voii'i��tta1�I�sio!ssal �a�l�rntc�arn I,en s 7� {.5 I x4 I�,�i'..,5 k'1P f!� � — _—_-� M1� �y � �t e� � j :;:, �:: ��'� � - ;.� rn� � "�-�_, ` _- ,, . , _ � .;..; � ; , : ;. � � �x - _. �� � '� , , � - - � _a'- ._ _ . P, ��'' ; I � � I , � �' I���� � :2 :�'��`' �---c�: �o l r ������������'��I�'� x������t, � �� s''. I 131i,\nDYN'1\'F.I,i140�806) COACH.�A1n I s320('19�1 RIi['VS\li� - ` ^ 1 '��; LI L" 9 _'�,TS =: __ - L c '�� ."�.P_i.. � r _ _ i .—' � � � r"� u �� .s I �� � �� �� y .r ; � `.,i „ , — �„<<.� a �, ,.�,; _ �,..�-� � : The 1Vlerl�ts of „":�� k � � ,,.. � . , LUxURy ;:, y,, f. * .r, ��� Luxury is defr�ed czs a state ,� A° �- 4 -T " ,� �-`� '� ofg�eatconaf'o��tandeleganee. � p � ,s� .. , ,_: . ; _.� , -,, . .,The ativantages of true luxury protlucts increase over _ . r.,r . ,._ I' ` ,`- ��. �W} . y '� �Ar"� k fnT " e� �4�� ': P���m f lP��� -__. �h�,� ,'�� 4�y' I 'fll 1 ���4M 'trC � . �S ������yyFl !�.$}F� 1 � . � � � �, '�� ��� ��� �� �x .. �.. �, ,: , .�:�. ��_* �k'k'd , i � .F� 4 ! �'S��z f� . � � � _ ,. ". nt0t5ti' ..— � � ti ��.rC, 'SI.T9 T�a frm �,,.� '�...� 'X° 4�r� +� �.. ,r� � 5 . •� ,: �;�` ��� � ,� �; +Y f . ., . y. r,. ,. , . . a � �. , � h� i ^� t 1 �r. � _,.,.�� .�_ _ _;� �� , , �:.�,.r,.. ; � '' . � � , _,.. —._.. - . '"' �. ,.�,�.����.�.��,-...��� ���.. -,. .� _. .,. ..,.. --: _ .,_._�„;w. w� „ , ,.,,, , �a � � � rtd,M . ., . . . he , r��-�.. ..�q,�duet design ��, . . . . �+..� �,,.�',m�.�. � S"- � � ��� � '�*`"��`°w« �wtthoutcompromisingaesihe4c,s nd�pertormance.-� .._ —. ,: �a��� t� ��. a�^. � . .. . .-��.�Fi ��� ��:� � �. .._ .. , "� -�-s �Unsu "'skS���B-�,�1��'ic�S� c r Perfom�enCe are tFie� . �.� � — �' �`_r�umtess�`�VaI yy� ies thaC�d,�ine Wxury,�and precisety� .. �. ;`f ,.. ._, . ... � �� � M � �why tlisceming homeowners choose Inspire"Roofing � ,a�t �. ,t '' � � �"�' � f� � �Products for iheir homes.Choose nothing less than[he ��'���: �iy�,� { .' . ��. . y best for your home. pt�' s �y� ^ �. . . �. � �— �: � .. '' � �, ' 'av�;y�. . � � x;. ,� ;�... . . ' - � r;� _ 4- -��_ ��.✓��`�'�`,���` ,�r�;��`y��.`"� '? R. ^fi . ��r�'�,xi�"�.v ��k �� t����'���.*"'�„��'� '. ��,5 �. �� _, a�. � , ..5�' Y a3 � § �I'�+ �ky„� r� �,�3t`�"s�!` Y. 9R P ` �.,.� 4"�r� a�i'�i�'t ��� ��" �5��`,���r� S,.�`{t �#4�f y� �.. n r i' :� �'�a r f ��+7d�� ��,� r 7d� z*"�, �l'��,¥'n��ut`t�h.��`S���,��`'�` �� �,��.�r� �°s> ✓,����;�'�'�,� "�f�� �,���.��"Y,a r�'��y��R�`� ` f�� � �`��. ��3�+ ����N�� ��r .�t�� k �� �: < i����`�i`a.'*� ��rs`'��^��k����� 5:-.� tl ,���� �^ ;,ti � � �` ,� "� � �r��,�y���^" �:�'�����,� r, ,r 4ro�?� �;mr�N''��w+ �„w .,�, ��,»=.r.��,�` ;!�; �' i,.,�.+..;�. � _ � �rt� ,�, .. �� � � , � � ��� . �f: , _ ��� � � �� , • �' � �'� � ' � I _ ._ _— __--_ _ _ 1 �j � • ��=U�y,� ��,7��:<'� � 4 �� I � � � =S " � — � «Luxu7��is nota 7rerrsszty la 7ne, �1� � � � � bul beauliful and good Chines are.» � . � , . ., 4'� , � � '�,� 1 YALS;\'[��' ' I >� �� �I� ` ��� I �' I �� � _' { �) _ ',\ I � . . .,,.. . , � � � .,I �� �r �'� � � ��� i � �;� � r: 7 � � �1.: � � i � � r� �' :`� ----� J� ` ` ! � � � - �a �� ..�. , �, ��=� �� _:� ` �, ��� `;..��;j r' �:;�;�'_�`�." 1�.�1 � - �-�,,r,�.� - =�_ � �y.,:l"E'I; T'I���`=I'�r�:Vi J '.�� W ss, ,`, = �, - ' � -"� ' :-�. — ��� ��_ ,C� � I Ic�;�nC'e. �radTf i�n, �n �ty a�_i , n,� p o �r„io � '� -�' �� >'�,�'�� ✓ �`-- } you o choosa up to flve colors fcr a G _ �� � j,.-^ i"" I cifo��2��t�ce. -� ' �� � : Slate m�x f�c eate lo t �� __�����I�`" 9 Palette la�� ,._. �� t 'ir"'R;�..s � w� -��/' "�� � 1 �1 '_ � �� ��,� � .!` c C'I �.�. SI e - d Is I � ixes �s :� - �.(�" �-�' �i'� ua le r� � JY . nooayeedtoshuftletleshom ItF- • f I - —� "^�" `��� �y i I[.�.' p.. y:;o^t II.1 ..r,�t� bur� : �r�o st a o Cnc bu tilo or ' ��."' _1�J" _' _.. _�_,�..---". � � '�,. .. � ,.f� that e to �e atur2l I t f g I s c Slate In p Roof'ng P oducts comes acto y o�d - . � � �� ,o"�nai I ��� an�i ��dyfo�apoll a:�i.Qeat y ur...,nmz �. � ; �.hlr.ofer�g IqFt e,�.t,ow-�o�t,,.�ab����ryaod that�tsyourhorresstyle. ���,.�- .j� �u� 9e,- o �II, . ���.� ma[ensl — �c �Jcg�C�at_o.,���oeee,Jate. �� ��� I . =-�:8�; � _ �..'-�- .� ;, ; . ... � , c� _ . . -. �^ -��. .�.;r. , �{ '� � ~ � j�'. �.,�i„iwcti o.�;�ic �,�i.��'n t-,n„.�,nic � �� ���; � _ . 1 ( ^`-�- 1 y!�' —_—.___. __..._.-67� --r��",, - J� � '`�'A ��� "� �I � I I.;� �x ;F� - f� .. �� �''<?.:e.�i�"m�.Y�-� �� � w # „.,`s t��, � y.��- _ _._____ __ _ _ _ � _ . .. �� 1 ��,�� _ — , ��- �� �`�� �� � � �N � ,J �-�'I <cLuxu�y as in crzch dntntl» ..� _lJ�,,I... �.r -�.� ._ - .- -- "- -iivranr,i Ui 6na_xcnr IJ�LJ L`1_� �% G�� f I t.-d � ..Cg h�L� ,a�t ..�I,_ f� �iv �i`'�- t"'� i,.� �- - thar e t atu al slete roofing enh a�ce the natu al�colo�pallet of our - . -c�z . -�-.s.��,.� s �,_ � �_ 4������� -.�`�'- � � --�`�. � ' � �—`,_—� - ,,,. � .s ,�`�'. " e15HCItL1 I52P� 3] � 51Gt61YCCV I2260 91s1 \LISTCI Y �3�;5'Cz � \\� � . � � � I _ —�. .�Y —� �f r �� ���� .�:.-- ��E� �`'a � � � �,,; , � ir�i i� � _ ;� ���� l �� �� , . _ . _ .. .� . � ,. , , , s ; , � ; _ _ __ � � — � ' _ �` , - .. , _ � _ :.< : ' V � _ _ . ; i . �:,� �- * r ., , . — -_� -;�._, l -: �'- -�: ; , a _.� � � �� � ', ,�a:;�" �' ' •` _ ' ` ., r . . --� � =� . ,r�� _ .�a � u,. , . - — � .f , r � I �I�^ _ �I'� , o� ■■�■ ■��� j �!v■ l��i !` I<H� ��_ ,- ��tw[Tr I it a;,z` � otne I zz�a,aia) s'rzsr,ca2r nso(aoa) �� � __ � �.,- ��, �� ,:?-� ' -, � � ' � ... _ - (, �:� r--- �... �,rt � . i J } ' , , �. .�.,II �..� � _ ( i 'L t . - .r �'��. �rl � r _ _. � � �-_.� „��` , . - - ,� � .:- .. , _ �,,,- �, ` _ .H, K�� -/1�`.. '��7 �^ �!I r iI �i � .'� I( f � .� . �� � .._ .. �_. —_ I___ � .+.n_'* �. . ._��.�Y GRAPHII'E�1160('133) � [-.�':.t Citii\I,2�,SC'30j � C1IARCOAL6LACK�1180(801) .1F_UR()c.ti�-���;609� 6RICKRED��360('109) GRL'?'�ifl.aC14DL� > iJt`-'�.F'� ��. � Y " t.'yN � �a`; L I �v � I�'�-^'�" - :^"N`� �: s��. 5� �. ��g l }N ' . �!,� ,p,u x`'�" g �;-. Ft-� '"k ,�°9u, 1 ' � I � �: a,f F L,+.,w.,...s+�:+e'�w.=..•.aw•�,..�u,n..w:...I ��i ar,�}. I . ,;.{.';�;s-�, .. .•:. a . �I. ,y..., . , ._,.�3;H.: ,zsr.�.�� cn�.c , ..,. ��z._,,,o r- o._, cc== �e ,.w-a. �._. � :.�'P� x`�'�< ; ' ClassF.ltem N41FZE"" E�posure Witl�h � HeIgM "� Plece Bunde� . Square Pallet T�uck � . . . ' �. ' ClessGltem841FUE"" Sustaanabality Without Com�i�•omase � You do not have to compromise the beauty of your home to be sustainable.Inspire°'by Boial Classic Slate Roofing Products offers a wide palette of Cool Roof Colors that promote envimnmental�y � sustainable living.This is achieved by decreasing your home's carbon footprint and energy �� consumption 6y as much as 15%,as stated by the Cool Roof Rating Council and ENERGY STAR. Inspire��by Boral Classic Slate roofing producls offer innovative color technology by reFlecting the sun's - energy antl keeping your home cooler,hence reducing,the need for av conditiornng whde lowering its. carbon footprint antl�heat island effect� . . � . .. r�.<,uafn'"`+�e'�. Cless/1 I[emri411QE"•'F W101� Hel9ht W�9�V Wei9hi/Reces/QassA-tlemk4llRE""A �Witllh Len9b Expasure PrelormetlPltch ' ClassC-llemq411NE""A Nece BMtlle BUMe Qe33C-tlem#OINUE""W � " - -- " Pieces/LnerFON I linerFeet/Buntlle H'�9M/ WeighU Reces/ Pieces/ LnerFeet/ Piece Buntlle 6uMle Lin¢rFOM BunNe � fj � —_ _"__ ti.� .. .. _ . ._.. _ �� � TEST TESTINGPHtFOPMFD� PESOLTSFOP Cutl qti01 i, �4 ia P� -. 1 t. ._ .� S�' ::'7 k�y� x� •�y�`� ...:; ' � ;�- � .,.:,...,:. � ��4;.._:.. s�ar � .. � p i II�ST3M1�"ul'45: -^,,.r o oi P .. � ::w-ory �.. " , - 0. ... I �T� �'n a w �� v'�P — � � % o�, � —— —��`�`—��'� �` ���' ... oE .Ro_,o � /` . �� �h — � � . �;, � _�.. r. �� � .. ` _ i I�i Y � w ,` � r � .. . "" . �� sn � .. i.._ . � ! cs .k. � � } �� �`"� - _ . '., - � �y ���� �� w,.� � w..,,�m ea � ..=sro.a .�ti ��`��, a. : ���`�"°&`°,,': � P e,�FeaE cs z ^� .{ �7,x- k � �. �o -e - ... .. a u .o .�. 0 .. � q � � a.,, w.. . w ,...-. _. . �.—,,. � ^.y� a � � `�.;, l _ �" `� ff': 3 � �. <� k �i <<�} 5 � `�,i .aa �. =� � ax �\_ ��� . . �g<. �s�5� �" �:� S r� �., � ���� �SW� � � � � �� � �� — � � � � � �� p� � -- , �-�� — � x �- ' ' _- ,` y, . __' . �. �.o , .:,:. � �— , . , � . . -- �. ' ` _ o��� . _ � .�,r �_ . . _ ._ . .._ %13,1 Plut Pl.ar� of ,o F �__. ��� .� _. �"�"—�' '_. — . .. La n�7. n f , . �, ,a. ,n.._. J�'.NI ti J. � SH�ROti :1. I3tiR'�G w•.g _ � W . _ . _ . . . � �:- �c -_ __ __ .— ... ,.,, ,.. ... _� - . . ,,� �.ril J �.u. _� � _; � � � . 2iss aovrE mn ,� - y� .. ... � — , �.., .� . , � -... -- . . � ...„ .. + . � .,,-... .-__ .. .-...... v:.: I , . � . �. ,..;;: , , ..,. �_ _. . �... _ .. .. � . _. _.. ... . -_____ I }'r�;cr�T,� ri «n Foundation Septe�l7ber 14.2020 .---- Ms. T�mie El�i���er, Chair ��� Design Review Commission r�E�ir'� � �ll'� Cit�� Hall E�iz F s� ii�����i <� ti 474 Broadwav � Saratoga Spt•in�s. NY 1286f� » � � RE: Z03 Chw-ch Street—Exterior AltcratiQns ',� � Dear Tamie: Tlte Saratoga Sprin�s Preservation Founelation has reviewed the application ior exteri��ar alterations at 203 Chw�eh Street. -T"�he Queen Anne stylc house�r,�as �uilt cirea 191[}. Ii is a c�ntrib��ting buildin�to the West Side Historic Dist�-ict listed on the Nati�nal Re�;ister af Histoi-ic P�aces. F�oar�t of Directors �<+am�'. F�.���,��� Thc Foundation is }�leased that the owwner is removin�; the alu�ni�lt�tal sicii�l�� and wiCl Pr`�;`�`"` re���ir the existin;� histc�ric wt�od s�din�, and trim. 1t is als�pleas�c2 that the sno�r i,,�„rs c�,i� sficfes will bc rtplaced witE� c�7p��er. Tl�e F�unci�tic�tY dc�es not c�bjeet to t11e `'"`'P'�e�'a��' replacement of the doae located on the first stoi-�� c�i�the tw-�o-st�r}�l�ay c�f"the west �.��,�i�a�a�v�y-op;,�,�k fay;ade�vit}i a wof�d window. T}�e Founctlti�n als� understands ttte neeel for ADr� 5�������' accessibility. Therefore, it does not object t� the r�tt�p tl�at can be r-r;moved it7 the Dmitiiy Yc^a�nolayeti� fUt�l.lI'e lf It 15 tl0 IQi1�'E;C]1�C�SS�I'�. Trcasurer Per the Roofs Histc�ric 13istrict Desi �n Guidelines' )aimc Butler-Bintce � Carnlirtc Cardone � C;i�nftErn�t I.YOrazi� RoOfs 5tevcn C)odda 13i�ennan C}rakt � Re�71['a11C��11c71T1t�117 011�EI7a� I'OL7�1T1�I31c1teFlc��S 4l'�l�Tte�'CT"]�OSSI�?le. s���a�a F�,� . lf 1•e�lacetnent is necessary, the r-o�f�shc�uld�natcll the nri�in�] desi�n, size, ��7�,�, �ian�� r.;. i.���a�i sha�e, mater�ial ar7d texture or sl�c�uId �ve b�sed on 1listoric e��idence. s�'z'�n`t�'�Ke���"ii . The use of piastic, fiber��ass and tar and �1-avel roofing enate�-ials is alst� i)�,�¢�las Ke�n� Rfdrard Kiaig tj1SCQU►'clf�'�C� Ori 171S1(7['1C �tl(� COTITE�17Ut111� S�I'l1CT'U�'�5. Sle•pl�cn K�rte �i�'illiam McC�rthr� D��n�lhv Re��ers-Bullis C�11111I1�yS c��,d��sn�«�-� . Chimneys are a visible character-ci�fining fe�ture of a house. 11�Iar�y h���e �arn,�u�v����a, decor�ativ� fearures that s�hstanti�lly ce�t�tribute to the �vel•all design c�f the structure. Jan�cs ECetticuell . emen�,� � Existin� chirnneys s£�ould be ���aintarne�i. �ernor�ing a historic cl�i�nt�ev in go�d re�ail-is stre�n�ly�disce�ur�ged. e.e�s�r���c ti�re��a�� • ��y repairs should�r�atc�� tl�e c�ri�in�[ i1� s�ape, material, and color. Finishins� s��„af,a,��osst,at, a elzimney with c�elnent,�stucc� pa���;in� should only occur i��historically t�embcrship S �CCUI'1te. Programs piecct�r �""�`a"�"` Tf�e a�plicz�tion d�es no� provide a�ly docwnentation that the sla��e roo#'anci the chin�ey ar-e in poe�r corsdition. TE�e F��undatian respc;ctfull�-t•equesEs that tlle Llesi�n Review Commission rr.qUest documentarion as to the condition of#he slatc roof and � ... ll,l'. \f'�:[_ i.��.[.' _ . �.II'.i. \;,.II . L�� .`\i�l. �� '��.1 +1� lli:.:., chirnney prior to mak�n� any decisiorls r•e�,�a�r•din� the repl�eement of tE�e roof anc� the re�mov�l of the c-himney. P�r tFte guitPelines, the roaf st�c�t�ld be replaeed in-ktnci and tl�e use of tiber�lass roating materials is discaut�aged. Thank vau fc�r yout•consider�tie�z�. SincUz'ely, �� ! ' Adain N. Favro Sam��ntha $osshai�t Fresident Exe4utive Director Cc: Sharon �3yr-ne, llpplicant 1�oilya Yasencl�ak. Agent Bradley�3irgt. .4dininistrator of the t7fficc of'Plarining and Economic Deti��lopment 9/16/2020 ' Zimbra HI Amanda— We tried to save it& repair but the pieces were breaking as they were coming off. The pieces were too thin to replace some with the standard thickness of slate pieces now. I hay.e a letter from the Contractor, pictures as well as video about the condition of the existing roof&slate pieces. I will forward it later today or on Monday at the latest. Thanks so much. �p �°�.� �Tonya Y �� � �, � � �� sE� � ENGINEERING AMEI2ICA CO. � � � 2�20 ,.C)ucrliti%De.sign tviZ{t rntegyit,}-„ Tonya Yasenchak,PE ��'--�.,��q� 76 Washington St.,Saratoga Springs,NY 12866 � 518/587—1340 t011y�)/�Q 11yCap.rr.com ����"`��� From: Amanda Tucker<amanda.tucker@saratoga-springs.org> Sellt: Thursday, September 10, 2020 12:43 PM TO: tonyay<tonyay@nycap.rr.com> CC: bbirge<bbirge@saratoga-springs.org> Subject: 203 Church St Hi Tonya, I am filling in for Brad while he is out. The DRC had a question regarding 203 ChuYch St at the caravan last evening. They would like more information regarding the need to replace the slate roof and what alternatives were considered. Thank you, Amanda �Amanda Tucker, RA Senior Planner City Hall 474 Broadway Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 (518) 587-3550 eat. 2517 https://m.sar � � o � � � � v � � -�c ro a s m t e V U O fV N o U (� C � 3 Ul L L � fV � � � ' � m N � s+\�.. � Q � N y� Ol y � � VI 3 (d � Ul Q1 � N O C Q c�d � � �O O s a = v = = � va �� a � - � � � J U � w R V (�/I C p� � E �L � � ry V v £ � N � L � � 7 2 F C � cNE � � � 0 bC4 a� � N �' C N -O ,.v, N �.+ N aNi � O C � � � O •N � N � �n � �. �O �. c � �.'^., 7 ti � 0 L � N � � � °° Y U :�^ I- ro � °�' o 'o � N y V � V (d N V V � s N � � � � +� � L C � � � .N .0 C 7 S T � ^ T � � � � (C � � �n !� � m L � Z ,o a� � v 3 .' .' 7 � v l0 O O v' 0O u � C � 3 N '^ 0 N . � j OC z °� m c,�a o `� O •° c '° p °�' � � c �' °�,' '°' � O 3 Y � � a `�-� v o � � � +L-' � o °,�' v m � v°'i d Q � a � U a� o`v'o o �n 3 •c p v a�i N � v v U � � � 0 w t �n s v N U a3i .c N 0 °' � � 0 ' U O m � 0 '� O � V Z > v �� c� v�'i c O L L U v o L L �3 3 � � • ro � � a °L' � v v Z �, O o r� o � ,� N � L � � L E 7 N a� �a � o � ' ao.4 � 3 : v �; �, U aLi `�+ a�i V ,�° O � � v N `" � � � cLi� ,� E w �„ � �# � L oc p� � . a� o u, L OC �,�, � s x p ro W o v°_i u � N `° E " � U � � `� � a `Q C� = N � Z L � N O O � '�S ro �p p •; � O w m 'p .� �� Z � � l.) � � � �Q a � � �n U o � � m �a � cNa s � +`d-' a3i � `�° o � C �°1 O� O O V L tn w � (n � p4 1� VI 'j V _ � � � (_ � � N � Q � i � � I� O in v b4 C O cd � � d C ln CO X L �O w � C C � � � E U V O N u, °� �n � "a � .°-�° o s a"i � i °� a � � v v L E U F � O d � �0 O ~ = ai � J � �L.+ O- 3 >. oC x � a� v ' ` c a o � � °� '> U °� � s ,� � c � axi "�° � � c 3 � a�i � a� � c 'J L '� ro — � � U o � � E ,� �y � Z .� +-' y 3 y� •—`-1 t L � � 'V y � ca p- � L c .o v �3 > a� a� '^ o �N a� � m a � to \ a�.+ r t `d al v > � � O i � � a� � Q \����� J � a+ u - C � O — N > 3 � � fn d � � � +� 3 3 a� b .� a — � o ro c r � ., � uo c � � � '�... :; L y a � � a 3 a� : s ro +� � � � � _ t f r- L o c I� o ° a °' � `° `v' ° � ° � ° \�� � � ° a �=•' - Q _ v � ro = � E o s � o y� p miiQQ � � `\�\\ c� � � � L L H � � L � � \ / � �� \ � 7 � U ^ u � � U1 O b � N \ 'L '� � � � � � t (C � VI N � N d � L V � .0 � � Q N � �n Z .�_^ � � Q d U V 'Y(J l.l,��.', . 9/16/2020 Zimbra �,.,} ;.}., � ?� �, ��;��:.,r�__ � cs ��� �;, ,� ` --- � F��. 1��'�ir-, ,�,�;;.. ��.� � ,.� �3 ' y (jy�`` � 1 Hi Jen— er� r �z '�f���j �'' a��, ,�J�$a The e-mail and link below are from the roofing contractor. , � , /_ �.._., I will try to break out the pictures and video separately for ease of viewing access. ,� �Thank you. " - �Tonya Y ENGINEERING AMERICA CO. "Qr.rcrlit��Design tivitla I»tegi•it��" Tonya Yasenchak,PE 76 Washington St.,Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 518/587—1340 �C711ya�f�(=1)/C�(�.1�9".COf71 From: Tony<squaredawaycontracting@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday,September 9, 2020 8:21 AM TO: Tonya Yasenchal<<tonyay@nycap.rr.com> SUb]eCt: Re: E-mail Tonya, The link has the photos and a video. The slate roof is definitely beyond repair. For reference we just gone done rehabbing an entire slate roof for .Sharon.A month worth of work. So obviously we are willing to do that work and she is willing to pay for it. Day 1 we were working out of a lift to start patching up the roof and it was immediately apparent this roof was beyond repair.The slate are soft. Not all slate are created equal. Pennsylvania slate tends to be softer.These have allowed water in between which freeze thaw and cause the slate to fracture.These slate you could easily put a flat bar right through them. 75%of the slate need replacing,that's not to say how many this will damage surrounding. I have been a general contractor since 2009. We have specialized in roofing this entire time as well. I do roofing training sessions for JLC Live (journal of light construction) also. We have done copper and slate work in Saratoga Springs my entire career. https:[f idrv.msUs!ApBrIWUfJmy9grgfAxUUOZtHMIkjZw Tony 518-391-9974 www.squaredawaycontracti ng.com On Sep 8, zozo, at 4:10 PM,Tonya Yasenchak<t011yay_@nyCap.l"I'.00171>wrote: ENGINEERING AMCRICA CO. ��Q2lCl�lt�' �E'S1ti12 lh'llC! jFlt�Bbl']ll��� Tonya Yasenchak,PE httnc�//m.sar: 76 Washington St.,Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 9/16/2020 Zimbra k3�! i nA�`' lr1�iy �'=,':.p�`"__�,� 1 .�, � i? ��` � t d. Hi 1en— F��t� �C�' -� �� 2020 __� � To answer DRC questions about what other feasible options we have explored; '; • We have attempted to save the existing slate but it is proving difficult with much breakage & not much salvage. The pieces have deteriorated and are very thin. Much of the slate is deteriorating and, as may be seen in the video,they are susceptible to "punch thru" and not "splitting/breaking" as would be typical. The slate is also delaminating. The contractor is also concerned about repairing/replacing due to the thickness differences between the old pieces and the new. • A full new slate roof is not financially feasible. • The Owner would prefer the installation of architectural shingles as a replacement for financial reasons. However, from a design perspective, we thought that the synthetic slate would be a better aesthetic option. Thank you for your time. �Tonya Y ENGINEERING AMERICA CO. '`Orralitt-�De,ci�>tt tivith Irrtc�r�it1�" Tonya Yasenchak, PE 76 Washington St.,Saratoga Springs,NY 12866 518/587—1340 �Qi1�/a�l Cl C1�lCc��.}.rr.cc�m ..�........ . .,,,, .. . ................ �� .. _........... . ........_._. __ https://m.saratoqa-sprinqs.orq/h/printmessaqe?id=110468&tz=America/New York 2/2 ��� . �v�xt. �, ���y(�.. ' �� � ���� �� �' �'� r ..� ^"� +ct r-1".�tj? � � x• p.i+{�` . ' . : „, ,., . , . � 'i ���,'"�- ,� t�'�`7 s 'r *�Mlf �` t' �. ^ 'w.� 1�-4 � S�� i ^ .. , �c=-..� \� . d �. A� z�� �5,+� ,�>�� - s�r F�.� v. _ , \ • \ y ., _ _ , _ _ _. �s�� _ � ,n ,� � � � . , a ;� , . < _ . � , - �--_ . - _ _ _ .. ��� ` _..i..� r+ 1 y., Y r� �� _ �� _ _., .�• -.____�__ ��..�� . �, . \_ . _ —\� - _ , - �� ''� �`_ ��:y �'�' _ � _ � , � � ,'--- T-� �� ��_ �; '==-�=�_�_� _ \�� . �� `� - �._�,�.,.�� \ ^ � � .,�. -..� � �-. _ �� � � \ `, � ��_ � . . Y. , . . - .___ . - � , , , _ ., , , _ . _^\: � _�` - \ -`. \� \, `�-ti ��. .�-.. _ •�. _ �'� '.� _ ' ��, `., :;;q -, ` :�a _ - `���-� �y�--- �' � � _ ., , ' _` �. _ � _\_ _ .�--�^----�=j � . \�— ' _� `�� �-�.. � '°7,��, �� _ ~�-- \�, - ! ,� ,\ � . . ._ . � � _ , � . . � �__ ,� _ ' _ - - `' \ �3� • � . ,.. ;, � _ . . . � � r , .. . � ^.- _.. � �.�-c -.. _ \ .. .; -•\ � .. . \" � c�-� .. - '��\ _ :.� ' ... �,__, . .__ - . .\ . . y. . . . . . _ � ,�.. \ - �'i _ \. : ` .� `\' � ' \ \ _ - `�,-~ —t \\~ '\ _ �� -`� � . ` ~ ` �\ �,^�-��+ � - � `� ti;�� � • ` �' �,� � �-�— � ��� ti ��� - � ��� �`- � ,, .� �� �:� _ �� _ �� _ ", , � � .� "�` �- � _� � . � . . � . _ • ,- . _ ` . . . : ; ,. .t ,. _.. -- :.� ; t ~ _ �. . . t � ., , . . _ �-�-.--' _ ._� -.,_ . . � . _ ; , . .,�. - . ,. � • - .a , Q _ `- ,. . " � �. • ^,:�F.�.- \ `` � � „ ; ,�_ ._� .� . . -- �- - ';� �� � - . , : .� . . �c, " � �. ' " '� ., . . . . . � - �.f.� � :� ' � r �� ..\ ,,,�_;��_ • � .a-- '� � � ` - � > .-- __ - ^ ` � ` �. \ ,� �\ ` \_ ��� 4 � .. I � �` �� " � � . .. rn � .� { �j � , . . . ' � v.. �. \ � . ' ��� ..� , � . , ti .. . . .�� .�. .. ' _ - � 4�,.1`� ^ -I� . �• '� � \ 1". � � \\ �� 1.. .. `T; _ 'r ., . �. � � . syr� � . � � _ _' �1� - . � i' a....�, \- , � : � �_.��, t� ���,�,�.. • -� � _ . __ - .:,.'�- � ' �. ' :v . . - r� "�.. � .,�� .. . ). .. _.�. .. . . .�1_ . ..._'�'.�'F'..:. ._ . . ..�_._'..� " �. l '...`.,. J�t�'�,�-,�t;.r �"a„'�'s.^,�p.,^r��4:.;;;,: ^.--,� t � ^ , � � � , �tl`t � �- '�` , �` , • ' , � ,� ��� . , ��f,��',�r :' , •. - : �,��� � ,,. _ , - . �._ �� • �� � , ., � �.,� , .. o � x~� r� ' ' ' . r r � .r . �.; ` - . : �� `�� :�f r r��� � _ " �M� _ } � i . .�• _ , � _ . - _ 'c , I �;,:, �—..�.._,.._. �.M � ', � . �, - , .� ._ o � �,�,t,s , � � . _ V`-�--�-�-ri'"'!r C', � ���(§ �'.- �a. ,,Y,�,�„�;q1 � - ::���H,7 "' b.,'" � .i�- _ _ r _ :E � .. �� �' . . '.:: . ,... � �i/ �,��An� �^.'_•.y�...�.. a„aaA� •:/ r � L' � ' f'^� ! � t� S'NK;,'�� � � ��� _�� •��' � � ., � - - y � < <�--�---�-��,�.,���, �._....� - , -,�- ��, rr J ,s �r a�I ' r y� �. -5.:� ti�'�ir � �.l�.,. t � . . "S^';� . „s s ..j7 ��;',��..,,.�` �""-.w',...".+w�: �. , � t„.� m..!_ _..`. . .. . , � - .-' ,, c,. �� *c�*,�Kv .� j � .. ., ��, `l. _ � - �� . ;::.� ,. �:: .�-..�.�"_° : � � ' � ^-�.�, .. ���-..,-.�°' ��-_"""v.': , ''�`� .. p f�. _ . j `T'„'�... ""`� '(d �..,�7 •�N�� ' / ::. :� �{�(� -.�^w�—.�..._.�.__ ..� 'e-_..���. �::; " • . � }wT' ...y ��.� / ,�'I /'..c-t` iq' * .. � . "_" ._ �•'i.! .fi.n,,:" 2 ��'„�Q��ct......'." ',+,,.-t � _ . ..:' �. .. .:' :. �. , T.^. '. ' �w-k-q..,�...�.�. . ' � - ,�� * _Ti k , � ; ,_,�,� � � . _ _ ,� � • , r �, � I�� � r � - ��'�j 1�-'T".'rn..��"`^--r-,.--«.r•.�+,h�..+-�� , _ `� . - � � �t - _ � . ,� . �� -r�-�--` � - '�iN��.�� . .�,�s �w� '-�� � . _. , __, .. .�.._ 1 . - ;� ;, ..:' a ., � a � (�� y_'-°"'P'k' ^^.i; ''�or- ,_ . . ._�. � . _ { . � .s . . _ � .e.�-ti•� 7 .��f�:,�'� .���11�� � . . , ' 1 . ''=� 9 ��� � . - - _ � . i i.� � '— .' -�--�,�:.�1 -. ...' ._f�. �r '�+'nw..� �l.�"-�.�_ . . .. . . "� J � ry . ; '� .,ss �w� �i �f`�^ � T'�� � _ � �: J' af �.i� '�.�-4�s�. ���__'�.`- ,�{i� ' - "--""'C�.��'4�� - 'a_ _ ',� � , i �L _ . . . . . Y[t:✓ 1 Y . . l � . ' . !._ I I . . � i �..._.�.�,.� . ,�. � j �, `..�-�--;., _: _ .%. .� ��� � fi; , _ -�"`=_.;,;-� .� .� ¢ 3� �= t - � - � ���� � .., �� • `� - . � �� {� � �� �� ;�. .: . �"�"'�"�1" . � ��t � �:. �..� t � �rvr s y,��^���.',�.�t � . . . �• _ M d'� `� ����" . . c=�'c'�,,;} " �. - 2�•s , � �` e �-�� � r. - _ i. �`' �w' `� f ' �� ` r <'- �'- ��t. � +;.. ,�"`,. �n d h i ; .�.�:��-- - ' L.:�. .�°. �✓ ,� . - .aW v , - � . •�t°rr`""' _ l� tx�. .�Me"�� �•t.i:� + . �. � �� � ` � ::`.,, �� � ` �r '� �4. - * �• 4 :.K*� ` � �,.""`�"� � s � "` ,. _ " r.� �' � f, � _ , _�r. . . � � .�,, _ . . . $ ^. 1�' . t ' ��� �' it� ,>. <,. t w: ..r . - , ti�cc"`�'"_^s.1-r^�'y`�'�.' .� � �� . - ' . _. -�r.:� ;z� __ f I �r ,�s r�. . . ���(!�-. ` �i~ �' � �` ... , . . ` .., �Y � . .. � � 1� .. . , . , . 3 �r �.. � . ,. . -. � ,} ,-" '-` ,,._;,-1 , ; � � ,n a h � . a :� ... . .__.. . . �' � T�L � "- .....✓/ Y '{ J� �' ' �. . . /.}� . RI � �� h'�r �fi. ��n,;A, ,t - - - �.y,�,� 'rL�� _ �' . �� s �1,: -' ta YI� '?j' . � , . _. . ', ,- , ' e' t , . � .� Y.^! �} � . ,I . .. �il� .. ,�n, ; ., _ �K'�.. • . ., ;� • " �i 8 � . � � .i�- � � � � � �. �. _ ',j � .r�� � �� " ':.;1 } ��.d:�'__ . �'� ,. - � � • .�. :'�t : y�t .� .- . . . �� 'y 1. , - �..vu: ay; � 'fs..x"� .s � ., .` t .J �a J" t J �;� � r� - �T � _ . � , r, ' . � �. .. ..i .i � '- � ' , . � -._ _ � B - A �;! i � . .� �a�iM� �,�„a+ �4 , �� � �; �� ''�. �,. �. a.`�" . t•, �, ` � � ' . � :�. : ' . . =..r'. '�4,- ` �t+� � � . . �� , ., j : . �. . : .. �. . , . . r �, A�il/714f4i���aMi��� . .... .. .. ys ��`�"-� ��.�--.w^.:.+:..�++�nw+... P ' .. ;i. . ��� ,.._..+ ,��. . . �.' . ��� __.,. ......_. ,. �..,_.._ � A °" 1 �ti� yry;i r: � , �� � Y� s 1 �t� 1r" t � .6 �`B"� - .. ., . Y2 . , ... .k . '.ti �� ��v�� [r . ,� (� . ,���:��� { . •',y k a, �- �r;. ' I � ' . _ r, . :, , , , ✓..n/l .. � ..,.�::... � ��5 f� 11 '(�1 ' ,,,�,..�u �.:�L y ..�:�. �'_� �. ,!. :�r`J.... t• .�a...�.,,ac^:.. . �f�'�,. � ' . . ' �y �" jJf � I � a, ''T � " �` : � Y{`rr�-. L�'w .. .W .., ���} . � � - r5 . '� . . � ' n' ' . , i�• . �. �L ,, rl�J�._.•� 4h . �, �.. ��V _ --�,,,m„. ,�:-�r--�,-,b,.r �� �.'"„� �'. :; a; � �:i7 '�4�.r:+. ` S�l�" . ,� �� � '' �tw5�a. '� .,"s'�l ,^N �. . ';. ..... Ve M- a�°�'4�."�''�°�,_�., � �. F� 4 i '� 7C'.� Y .... -7t f �Y ^,- .`�.�.. y. - � x�. �� -«r:: �� ... ` - _ . _ , �,..,,.,�_ .� � .;. : - r�,�..,,� �: ' . . --�'�,a,o'�� ��r �'�: n�,��� - , _ � ,: � � ti. � ..�w..,,,�i.a� _ , � - _ � � .- � . • . . :. .; . _ _ \ �w _ �� \ . r� ` : �^+.,r"�„�� -� : _ . - . , , --,.- , ��-' � � , ��'\ \ , ��� _,. , � t .. r....u� _ � . _ , ., . _. � �_ ; r. "`. ' . . _, , � r�- "r�, - < _ `\ _ ` ��—�_�v � �� -�S _ . ` - _� � , � -_ \ `� �� � � �,� . a.—.,��x . '""--�_ �._ � �-' � 3 � �- _ �- � , .. ` ;��"•�,.,.;� _ - -_ _ _ ����� - �;` �. \ �\ � ,w h . _ \ _ �. _ "' �= � ,� �°�""` - — ;�,_ � _ - - ` �' �� \ .��--.,-+ .. „ :{ .�:. ' . . .-i . ..' .�� 4� . ' . \ ��1 \ — �\ t �=�'—�--.��.��__.� �__ -- �. - �� � _ �, � � � �� � � � ... �-:� > . - _ � � ,_ _'� �_._, ._ _ _ .�^��� :�. _ � ,� `` '`� , - �,�,.� -� � � ..4. \ •'\` � _ - --�-� �� -� --- �_ ,, _ - �-.�.-�, _ � , � �-�. . _ ; � .-; - `- ,;�` ~�- `� ,` �� ' �. - .... ,� . Y� � � �- , � - � - - � � - �. �� _.. : �, _ � ,� _ _ �. . ..,�N::: . . . �. - , -= .�_ , . - � - -- .�. � .�� . � _. , � ; ._ ' ` � ' f ,c. — �, _ � ' �` . .� ; •,. 3, t�'�''��� . . .� � � ?7� . . . . . '.. ! f6`.�at'�`„��,',i4 t .�� _ _ - ,' � � • � r ��7��......_/:�.. / � . ' ... . . . _ _ . . ..\ f�4 _ �. . . .. .,� �� � . �' . .� :, . . .. ,,. o. �... .� �.. :. � � � .. . '� ...� i k �� 't��rf . .'� i � . :;r �,a-�.! . 'k^ _ � ''.�� �� '� #s ../fe. �`' ' � � �� .7 / . . % k � a va„/ - _ ' . '. . . � [ . , � -� ` � �. � ��, . . � - . . � � �� .•. , i; • � ; - �..._ : . . . �. , �: . ,,� . .. .. ��� ; _ - �� ���� � S' ti ,7� . _ i � . ' � ! � , �p � . �' - � .:y �� _. , a. � , . - '� . � '» ��.. _„ �.. : , ,_, 1__�,� : C �. 7 :-,� r, . • ���yyy . .. � J ^' - .-r' `.. . .. 4^ �� xllr _ + �+.`f �I'� �N I I,•� �I��' I I�S � ' �. `` � I / .� .. � . . .. � � '`` � �7� ' .. �.. .� - s . .. '� f � 1. .,. Y_'. ",\ , y�r :�� 4•- . . �.. � y�:Y -N s , . . . .. . , ` .` , . . . . .. , '�� ;, �� .. . ,� . . . �. ,.-V . . . .:. �* � -'• .�, ..` 4. �.� . . f , c . .� ?" fi „t +...,,j � , ., t .!' �_ .�� �#'+�� � 5 x4,,���5� � �x., � ,� _.. � " _ ` � v � � � �� `` ' �` �,. � �� � ' i �. .i`•, : _ 'c. �w �`�' k '� �: , . ,� �,c,, . �. '"�. ; ,rr , �. , c,t,- 1 � , ,c � ,� ,. �-.� ' -,�, , � . . r �� 4, � 1 ' .. .. _��} � �'a .., a ��� � • ..'" �'"��� �� "�'�G� HI � ' f"""�Y�'.�� . ... ,,; . , - ' � . . , ,� _ , . . � . .. . : , �,�*, _ .. � Ft Y. .. � . . � . , . . . . .��" . .i�,y A�' �� . . ' � ..�. . � � . 5 ta � .�.'._ ��•. �41� - ��.,e�� '�,�fi ' .. . . . . . '. �J� 1 , � x i, � �.. ; , � '�ti. ..//� . ' . .,.' . .:� �,+r r� .. .. . .. . .^_;..p!'� �' " �� - . +�:t . ' �. . �.. .� . ,y ,/.' ... . �_ � y"'.` ,�� . � ��� -.� -�a „ �. . .. �� •: �i � . �r. 1 • ,.y , , _ � �� � ��� _ y�, �� � ,i �. y �� y . � ..��. ! .� . ' '1:.� '� �:�:,`}i^- � F �q 'yP'. '�'�� t 5��. �^ ,.^pX' � � _ �5i ' '��� ' ,,,.. � .,°'1 ,�"�t�� i ' n�r�, �,. � r�� ���P� ��'.r'� _ " , ��.' ,y.p ,�, 4: . . . . p., j�ja �+' • _ '„.;�} d h� ,�; ��y.. Y ��` ... �1 ""a n,r �t: '+���� � � .� ��Y;` .� yj,.,1� _1� , � . . �' .�'. af�:' � Yr . , "�{':. ' �`�`�,f. . i , ;: . 'SrG � . ' I , � ti � l r , �{, ��. , i^ . � � *�. . . . . 'ti . > , .; . .,. . k. . . . . . . w" . i f �'� .,;.e'"r � �� � � '�,,e � - .t � . q�'� � � R 'S ' � a�. . „h� .,� : i� �r� �f �' ��C y:,` , ' ,� � .a� ^ �.y .� 3 ,t `` Y� x • i�f , � , , . � a _ , �,..3 � n. , � , � � ,y � r.._ , ..�r �. � . r : ' - - v . � p_ ,a ��M ��^r,w ��': � ^'i+C£ ', fit.p' ' � �w,,,.�, , yf.}I� . �. � ,. !r� `� . _ .� ,� .� . r .� ,,,. . ' _, . ,. . . � �',b v�.�. r.�..« , h_+."k,.° r�`. �t rl-„_ �l�. , u.i.�e�i�� ..e " �' �d. i ti . . -..�'�i. .�_`:s7� ��""�..� x,:A �-�'R�''�'�"�,*'z^-'+.�......, e A� r�� _�� .:J f ~ ��r ''. � : � � ; : .. , / �� . - , 1 . • � . . �1 �, ��- /�7 ' .r' .. ' .. _. _ �f f -_ .. � J .�ti."� ,. .. ,: / ':. .... .. .�, .,. .:, . :� .„ f ._ _ �( �' r .f �' 'S, ,� . � ' �� ' µ- . � � . � t . _ • _ „ ,. �' ;, ��� � �, r - . , s: ..,. -,. . „ . r,C� ����� c . .. Y t w� ' � • f - � ' - ��-. � .,. � .�t . � . • f • ' Y� � . i Y , A°-�'�'�,�.. �'�- ---���� �„�`�',�:°�`� 1+'' ;; � q �_�����; � � :� - � -, ;.' _ t� �,�, _' ������'�� .� �'`` �ti. _ {�. �� -., � .,�:-�'� r�f�'„,�.'� �� �`� ��. - i . . �, � . � J . . 'I ,.:..j 4; y, .�:C .!'� yi' '�,: , .aa y��r .. . - . � ' '�� ;x�.. - _ .. �, . � . .- _,� , _. , Y. h� x��,T�r � � .:�� �. �` 7{�g,�{,v,�3i� ..-i, .� . �l/` 4,- '.n.'�' `�: � -- - '$�p , l,�. �:. . . p,9� ,�� _ � � _ ��.,'�Y,"�d„ryt" r`� ,�. .y.,�,.r ...� . S�' - ` � �� h.T .r(R Y l C^Rw ,4• I �. � � r '"� 1� i`, � \ '��a�� �� �'��a. ` �� , .� _ � ' ` � �.3 c Jx .. � .i .� �e�., f :.w. . ;•� . . �, ^tt`� a�7n .� . , . �� "�'i. � '�.- `L / . - 1.�� r �+'��1 f`2p ��''� ��� ` �•%.• �� �'' �., ` � f: ���.� . �� �-Y���. " ' i _ � . . ti"�.. �����',. _ � -i . ,� Yt� `\�r i�� � _ , . . . /� . ._ �, v �x�� .i�- _�1 ,. !. ��� �� '�•../ t '4 '��f ��,Y �A. .r, ,��� - . ' �� � t ���. r:. ` � _ , . x , - .. , . ,- ��,�.. .''�`���- .,�". -�' 7 ��'�/, . . .� �'�.� '- �,�C .� .:.n �. "J r/1 _. � . ' �,` ```- r i - .�%: .� `�y? � .. -.; � �.k� . `� � � i � K ' � .-�. � +�.' � �� �� a � � < ��� � ���� j.,. _ i Y a. � ... . �- �.•J -y�:t�,�t��y - /. ; r � " �•. �� , k ��,a,'��v¢} . �:s�; ��,4 ,K Krh 1� s�: . `19•.� � c . i+'� . . ���`��� ?;, �� r .: �a � ' . k 'i d- _ . . z � i.,,� ., ^«t . .: � , a�����r?� �` �.�� ,��;� ,, r: `'`""�w_ fk_ y k . +.4t . �� ` fy' 9 - '*Z : 4 - � ... �-�.. � ..rf � . 5 ." ..� , .-. .. Y ��°',`,� .�3,� - . ' .. ,(�` ' . , , �.�.. �.� . �� .�. ' _ . ", .. �. . M1 k F .� . _k .�s. ,� ' `, ��� � ,X. � - ���f i � � F` t ,�,�� � . , ,�rt.' / ,y( . _ . Ah "/-.� r . '.�''� N„ .. ' i . . t , - _ � �I '�r I t.(�'.-.. . S` / � 2 . , `` ��� . ; ' '; �:_',�al` h' �`:.. .1 . � � ! .. , t `�`- �::' 1 7� • �:� .�. ,��. . . . .. -._ . . . .t � � . �� ,��"� }r. . .-,:. . _�/��� ;� _ � �{ �, � ti � ,/ � � ' :b s �� �e t�; '�'� I� �r ,l', _ r,. � ' �{ r:�� 3 . [ y ry T� b. � li� . �� � . >.,. - I y�`, r - . .. . � ..s . � �� , w ��i ��a., � f ' _ � � - s �,y. Y. . f , .... - � t . �- '^. . � . � �' �� Fi 4 .; . . '�; �, ' � ... . � il .. ' r,'1' '1`hY.: .. !,� x r�� • i ` _�, � . . . �`{''� '� �,� � i. -��� 'r� , i � , � R x � j �� -t ' ��� , " � ' �� , � �" � � - ' °, S"•�,� ;��ym� ti� �;s .' �_,.� �, .•-� .."J,{* -. �w ��,s��, I; ��...J.� �, '. .�;�ry � � ' �r i� �, G.i ' ks ;:,,j r . . y . . . ..j` . J i. . � � S .:Y' `�f��� #�."" ��( Sr�': �l��;f q E t.i�r �4.. e 1 ' � +* . 'Yf ' � � .. ��:� �' dx� °�§� t ,r,`��q3p�' . '�� � ✓� r .��. J � _ �� ,�' � y+, w �, � r�i5�8 �^..i F.. . .n � .. ' -r-, r t .t,. r'. a � � ��;� bty, "`. . , . �`; -�� ,,r �� w� � ' ^� F z; �, �� �, ;� - . � ��'7 t r "� ' �'�,at.�� s : " . : " �. .,*�'i �. � �� ,. r`Yr 1�. � . . .. . �.t .�� � .� r .. . . �� �. twr � � ?'�r' ��/ � �3��.,'r.�.� 1 . I -� + �3 / i i � � ^� � � �.� � �� ��� ,7 � �'�.e� `�+��,� .r�, f "i �� � �' �� � 5a° ,7., •:� i 1 . �' . i 3t'+ h"` • � � �,,� ` "s �", ",,- � + s r , , � �, � ^� ,� a . ,�° ' r��f� t � !r' / "�r��` . : �A . . j �..+"'F+ ''1� • � � .+ !.� J �r ?•.� �,;�� .t �� � � ����� �� �• �, k�� i { YY n_ +"� � ;,;� �T. � r f L.�` `���'y�.�k-���,�'�Si�" �" ' y ```'w / \` i� "�+'� �;' � y� � t. " C : , � ..- . ,� �� � : � �j�� � 7, ' C � �f fJ;��- j �� '.� � „� "3i�i^ ' � . ., , � ,?y��+k - 1 ��3 ' ,: �, h...: _ �. � . . 1. � �A����} /�'� �+4 7 r C�.. } t ti , . d �.} �" � , r '.,. �^i 4: r �� f��� Y`-' �F"FWi�°p '^t. ey '" � Y ..� �2+Y,iPS� �� � �/����•� � .. /k f r? ,��{� �{ .- 'Gk q � � �^v" � ��. ..i �'Yry , yY l� ,G � f . ..! '� � �k .��d� ':� .�y a .� 1r ': � 1 1, d r,o. f �� � . +Y'�:� .3'�ti `SA y� S' �� �.w 4r � r �� µrG �, � !_'��, • �"s,.�' 1 d`� �+ y� ,�!�f � k ��f Sb� ,� �_ 1f"��A �f ^� p .�i �t��;�5��� � •-�T��/ T y� � ...1 '( �a,,. �j j^%'�#'z h� �", �1 / . i�d�� � ,� R'�'•• � ��� . . � j 1 �. \ � r�:.Pl r �r� . `t . ' ;r �� � ? � i �� . � �, �,^.�^__._ __ _ �5 � � � � � ��F� u i ( ` a .,. � _ ,4, . ...� .ty � �� � . , '� �� �t ���. _�-'—'°'=4:'c�+-:a+�,�r.:.�:.•y..1. -:-�.�. _ . :�'�-. ..�I�,. .. ,- r _ a ,f a ��,�- ` ,� . �F7 "! .«�.a._4��r ' J.., G . . 1 c�}._ t � 'e g � ���Ta�tifi � � Fs . '�� V ',� yg i t �( `z n 11* .. r�`�j q ,��;� .✓ , , _ t ` , ;'"`` _ ;�' 3 � � .� „ � �. )\'�`` . � � ��� `�� , � v ���` .B 4'.F I f Y�. "3� � k.^ . , � � � ��u.„'' �_1* - "'e I,. � �il . ;' �n phyr;b�! . � ,t �� P i�� S�:'. , �. � r\ ,Y�. ��'� — �.. ��= *� ��r ,a�s �.,^'F t�,, . . � ..., �, ; _ i ;ii � � ' . � r � . M� . � <. =:S:rJ. - S ; f ' �, .. . ... r ',f �'V�,� a''�5 J' � �`�. � �,.�. � � ��'' - �' � . ~Y "�� '�!�f� �' ��,_., _ -..�A-.` � � . / '� ` � �f �G� , _ _ 2 K �; � .9��'t�+Ir��� ' `"r'�' ...., l ' {: . _. "I.-._ _' . `. � _ _ , kfii �'{ � ��: �N.a`� tl I� � 7 � . ;'{ Y � . ,�` � �� �.�;, _ �; :f'� � � ��,f� � �� . �� ��'� � ` > .�a��" �� _.�-:.:,�,. :� - I� -.. 'z� �� ;� r � �v`� . , f. �' ...-.�.� 7 .F.� •�.. __� . ���' .: � �('��R`�. � . . � � '" �y� '� I . � . • � .,%Y tr ,��"�i � �� . � .j� . _ ., �e a ., . '� �i � � � � � �4=��" ` .�. y. . . � ��> r . . �• _.�k . ��-• � . ' ' ;t �.-�' 9 ���. 4 .I �� .. , IV ' � t � ,� . ... i � � � � �t, ,�° k . � �� �� i�.;�. . . . , .. . _ . - -. . �' ' � . ' . ' :�.� � � ��'�"' _ -- _ - - `'- , -_^, . , � _,. . � I xr � ----�, - � — _ - �.�' '� � � r fi ;+- ' .�1 ,I, 1j, I � , ` , . ' .; � ��'�: , . I r• �'iM,, ��' ��� � r�/� .:. ` f r+ - ' � �--�+'�1=�..—"^`."T�„�,�'--�i ": _� . . _ � �' _ , _ .{' �+ ' `' .Y , �t,�T_ .'_��� ��)'.... �,��.;- ;.-. j A... �+Y, .. F 1�t � �_ � , �. . � . i .�i�` . , � / .. . �f^=�- R;-0 , :;, `y� " .f � � �fy✓ ;i, �� � ."� . � ' ��'`��y ���. .� ti —�.�-.�,••i r_._��_J._._ _ � - S �l t � ' '� .J i. - � s '��w_.�_. ':"'� 1��:= �i 'Yu n:. �� ^',�"j" i Z �, ' i I �'� • i' t'� ° "�1 t �:>.�'�, �y� • - i �' . "� � , w . ,� ! ti` � ,r„• ) , w�a � �t k,.�� �. ,. , �/ ,. , . . . . �.� ....._/�"FS-�; '.f . ._.;I _16_ ) � ���� "''� � , 1` �� t o- � � ' . , �t � . . - �.�c.�_ � �".-. .�[ , � .. ,.- � ' . ' � a��` . � � i x . 4�- ,1' . . . ` ' .pj ���'. � �4,�,�.'a, ��,�'�� �r � ..� +,, i. � �r , � � ���,: .. ��� _.�. _ � ��'I �.,.� `,� I ...-�— ' �_ � ` "".� � ' � � �` � �N��; s , •, �:{� ���' .. �ti� � �_� � �� � � � � �` � � � � s� �� �� �= - � _�. ._ __ �..__� � , ..�� .-----...�;: _ .. - _ ,,�-�.�...r . �--� -�---�-. �_._..�.�(.. � � w ; . ' � . :-. � �:.......�� �� � � , .. '' ��. ;�,,� ��,.,� ,�'''� �i , 1 {.. F ��,� �� �bp__��-'�i�� �.��`'�, �r � .,,1���� , '+', k .'s,�t l�,,p+�Y �� �' � . . _. ._. ._ . ,� 4 ....._._ -.��-' i ��.. . � ,,..�. :� ,. . ... _ � ,� . � ���.�/'r . , - - � , � r � .. � __ •_._ s�„�..r' i;